How do we understand Biblical Inerrancy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Windfish
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You couldn’t be more wrong.
Unbiased people don’t make stupid, closed-minded assertions as their introduction.
Apologists like you refuse to acknowledge cold hard facts about “Jesus”. Christian apologists are known to make wildly exaggerated claims. For example, we know more about “Jesus” than Julius Caesar. That is absolute nonsense of course to any secular historian. Christian biased apologists already know what they believe and just look for confirmation of those beliefs. That’s not how you approach historical claims!
But that’s what YOU’RE DOING!!! And we know much, much more about Jesus than many readily acceptable historical figures. Are you willing to doubt Socrates’ existence? You should if you don’t think Jesus is real.
Almost nothing is known about “Jesus”.
I cited Josephus and Paul, and you still haven’t proven that the Gospels aren’t historically sound sources.
When was he born? ???Who knows.
From the Gospels and Josephus we can conclude 6 BC - 6 AD. Oh, and guess what. We know even less about the dates of many other, religious and secular, ancient characters and most people would say they certainly exist.
What did he look like? No idea.
That doesn’t even matter. You’re just making a strawman. And besides, modern science has been able to recreate what was probably Jesus’ face.
Where was he from? The “City of Nazareth” didn’t even exist at that time.
Yes, it did. That book is refuted and wrong, and they even found an ancient house from Nazareth at the time.
Did he write anything like Paul did? No.
So what?
Where is his burial site? Who knows?
That’s because he ascended into Heaven. 🙂 But either way, even if he didn’t the fact we haven’t found his tomb yet doesn’t mean he doesn’t exist.
What do secular historians (of which there were many) say about this “Jesus” during the 1st century? Complete silence. Josephus is a known interpolation. The other shorter reference is not the “Jesus” of Nazareth. “Jesus” was a very common name back then.
The longer Josephus is not an interpolation. It had been edited by Christians but still referred to the Man named Jesus. Here’s the reconstruction:
40.png
Josephus:
About this time there lived Jesus, a wise man…For he was one who performed paradoxical deeds and was the teacher of such people as accept the truth gladly. He won over many Jews [and many Greeks?]. He was called the Christ. When Pilate, upon hearing him accused by men of the highest standing among us, had condemned him to be crucified, those who had in the first place come to love him did not give up their affection for him…And the tribe of the Christians, so called after him, has still to this day not disappeared.
Prove it wrong. As for the shorter, you “forgot” it mentions James as his brother (like Matthew did) and that only radical scholars believe that “who was called the Christ” was added later.
Prior to this passage in Josephus, there is complete and utter silence. How do you explain this? Simple, the miracle working, raised from the dead “Jesus” was a constructed mythical character.
OK, you are so biased and radical. Paul and probably Mark and Matt. both came before Josephus!!! Both refer to Jesus!!!
St. Justin Martyr acknowledged the pagan similarities, why can’t you? He had an excuse to explain it away. You can’t deny the overwhelming evidence of artifacts and written documents showing the similarities.
If you’re so unbiased, I’ll just link my source and you should read it with an open mind.
There is absolutely no evidence for the authorship of the NT Gospels. None. Only fundamental Christians continue to insist that they were actual eyewitnesses. They weren’t. In fact, the overwhelming evidence is that the authors weren’t even from that immediate area. There are simply too many errors in geography and custom.
First, explain how that refutes them. Next, I never said they did.
Paul’s letters (the 7 probable authentic one) were likely written from 15-20 years after the supposed death of “Jesus”. He never claimed to have met “Jesus” in person. “Jesus” appeared to him as a vision. Ask yourself this. Why is that in Paul’s 7 authentic letters, he knows NOTHING of this “Jesus” other than his death and resurrection? He knows of no other personal details of this “Jesus”. Isn’t that very strange considering that he wrote his letters before the NT gospels?
He refers directly to the Last Supper! Culturally, it’s highly probable he would have met Jesus at the Passover!
In my my opinion, the reason for this is evident. Paul made “Jesus” up as a Jewish version of the dying-rising son of God hero of the pagan religions which were so well known in that area of the world.
In your opinion? But isn’t this based totally on scholarly, non-biased facts? And Jesus is far too different from every single one of the Pagan Myths to be based on them. And you know what else? More than half of them come AFTER Paul! One more time:
Give me your sources for your radical claims, and also give men any Christian Apologetics advocating the vice you have read.
 
I am currently studying up on this, and I encourage all of my fellow Catholics to study the area of textual criticism. There are segments in Paul’s epistles which can be dated so near to the time of Jesus! The Gospels were already quite close!
Already am, Windfish! Great points and advice! 👍
 
Unbiased people don’t make stupid, closed-minded assertions as their introduction.

Based on my own studies and research, you are very wrong with practically everything you claim.

That simply is a false statement. We know virtually nothing. Socrates may have been real or not, but he didn’t claim to be “God”. Sort of different I would say.

I cited Josephus and Paul, and you still haven’t proven that the Gospels aren’t historically sound sources.

The gospels are extremely unreliable. They are riddled with errors and contradictions. They are not history but documents meant to convert people.

That’s a range of 12 years. You just proved my point.

We know what Julius Caesar looked like as we have coins with his bust on it. He lived before “Jesus”. Why are there NO artifacts at all about the “Son of God”? The most famous man in history! Something is very suspicious here.

Wrong. Informed Christian apologists know well enough not to claim that “Nazareth” was a CITY (exact wording in the NT) in 30-33 AD. They do claim that it was but a very small hamlet with only a handful of people living in the area. Even that is wrong as that area was a known Jewish burial site. You don’t live near graves! That would be unclean. Guess who found an “ancient house” from Nazareth? Yes, that’s right…a Christian archeologist. Funny, how secular archeologists don’t find ANYTHING that jives with the claims of the NT. This so called house is completely bogus. You believe it because you want to believe it.

Jesus didn’t write anything and neither did any of the apostles since they were mythical figures. There is no good evidence for “Jesus” and his apostles. None.

There is no tomb since if “Jesus” was real and was actually crucified by the Romans, he would have been left on the cross for days. After the animals finished off the body there wouldn’t be much left over. This is how treasonous individuals were killed. It was a message by the Romans to not mess with them. Again, another example of the disconnect between what the NT says and how things actually were.

The longer Josephus is not an interpolation. It had been edited by Christians but still referred to the Man named Jesus. Here’s the reconstruction:

You are completely in error. Why is it that this passage in Josephus wasn’t quoted until the 4th century by so called Church fathers?

Prove it wrong. As for the shorter, you “forgot” it mentions James as his brother (like Matthew did) and that only radical scholars believe that “who was called the Christ” was added later.

Again, you mean “unbiased” scholars? How many times do I have to mention that “Jesus” was an extremely common name back then? “Who was called the Christ” is absolutely an insertion, without doubt. Were you aware of the fact that Barrabbas means “son of the Father”. Guess what his full name was? According to the early Greek texts, Barabbas’ full name was Jesus Barabbas.
How coincidental is that? The released prisoner is also “Jesus, son of the Father”!!! I do smell a literary construct here!

OK, you are so biased and radical. Paul and probably Mark and Matt. both came before Josephus!!! Both refer to Jesus!!!
Sorry, no-biblical sources are allowed. Give me extra-biblical. Would you 100% believe an advertising brochure from a company about the truthfulness of their product claims? Or, would it be a better confirmation to see what consumer reports has to say? There is nothing extra-biblical that is contemporary. 40-50 years later isn’t contemporary. Even there, there is nothing. 2nd century on is all hearsay.

If you’re so unbiased, I’ll just link my source and you should read it with an open mind.

First, explain how that refutes them. Next, I never said they did.

He refers directly to the Last Supper! Culturally, it’s highly probable he would have met Jesus at the Passover!

In your opinion? But isn’t this based totally on scholarly, non-biased facts? And Jesus is far too different from every single one of the Pagan Myths to be based on them. And you know what else? More than half of them come AFTER Paul! One more time:

Not true…virtually every single dying/rising son of God precedes “Jesus”. Some are many centuries older. You are not being honest here. Sorry…calling a spade a spade here.

Give me your sources for your radical claims, and also give men any Christian Apologetics advocating the vice you have read.
Here you go…

Justin Martyr - 100-165 AD
One of the first christian historians and defenders wrote:
“When we say that he, Jesus Christ, our Teacher, was produced without sexual union, was crucified and died, and rose again, and ascended into heaven WE PROFOUND NOTHING DIFFERENT from what you believe regarding the sons of {the god} Jupiter.”
In a different writing, Justin Martyr said:
“He was born of a virgin, ACCEPT THIS IN COMMON with what you believe of The god} Perseus.”
Its obvious that Justin, and other early Christians knew how similar Christianity was to the Pagan religions. However Justin had a solution. As far as he was concerned,the devil did it:
“The DEVILS…Craftily feigned that Minerva was The Daughter of Jupiter not by sexual union.”
The devil had the foresight to come before christ, and create his characteristics in the pagan world

Ridiculous of course to a 21st century mind. I rest my case.
 
Here you go…

Justin Martyr - 100-165 AD
One of the first christian historians and defenders wrote:
“When we say that he, Jesus Christ, our Teacher, was produced without sexual union, was crucified and died, and rose again, and ascended into heaven WE PROFOUND NOTHING DIFFERENT from what you believe regarding the sons of {the god} Jupiter.”
In a different writing, Justin Martyr said:
“He was born of a virgin, ACCEPT THIS IN COMMON with what you believe of [The god} Perseus.”
Its obvious that Justin, and other early Christians knew how similar Christianity was to the Pagan religions. However Justin had a solution. As far as he was concerned,the devil did it:
“The DEVILS…Craftily feigned that Minerva was The Daughter of Jupiter not by sexual union.”
The devil had the foresight to come before christ, and create his characteristics in the pagan world

Ridiculous of course to a 21st century mind. I rest my case.
Have you actually read Justin Martyr’s apologetics or are you merely quoting some isolated lines pulled out by someone else to mislead others.
This is the link to his first apology: earlychristianwritings.com/text/justinmartyr-firstapology.html

And here’s the etract from which you quoted:

CHAPTER XXI – ANALOGIES TO THE HISTORY OF CHRIST.

And when we say also that the Word, who is the first-birth of God, was produced without sexual union, and that He, Jesus Christ, our Teacher, was crucified and died, and rose again, and ascended into heaven, we propound nothing different from what you believe regarding those whom you esteem sons of Jupiter. For you know how many sons your esteemed writers ascribed to Jupiter: Mercury, the interpreting word and teacher of all; AEsculapius, who, though he was a great physician, was struck by a thunderbolt, and so ascended to heaven; and Bacchus too, after he had been torn limb from limb; and Hercules, when he had committed himself to the flames to escape his toils; and the sons of Leda, and Dioscuri; and Perseus, son of Danae; and Bellerophon, who, though sprung from mortals, rose to heaven on the horse Pegasus. For what shall I say of Ariadne, and those who, like her, have been declared to be set among the stars? And what of the emperors who die among yourselves, whom you deem worthy of deification, and in whose behalf you produce some one who swears he has seen the burning Caesar rise to heaven from the funeral pyre? And what kind of deeds are recorded of each of these reputed sons of Jupiter, it is needless to tell to those who already know. This only shall be said, that they are written for the advantage and encouragement of youthful scholars; for all reckon it an honourable thing to imitate the gods. But far be such a thought concerning the gods from every well-conditioned soul, as to believe that Jupiter himself, the governor and creator of all things, was both a parricide and the son of a parricide, and that being overcome by the love of base and shameful pleasures, he came in to Ganymede and those many women whom he had violated and that his sons did like actions. But, as we said above, wicked devils perpetrated these things. And we have learned that those only are deified who have lived near to God in holiness and virtue; and we believe that those who live wickedly and do not repent are punished in everlasting fire. As you can see, now that you see the entire chapter, none of these Roman Gods had identical histories to Jesus. Justin is merely pointing out that Roman dieties also went to heaven after they died so that it wasn’t crazy that the Christians claimed that for Jesus. And tehn Justin points out how different the morality of the Christians was in comparison to the Roman dieties. This is a much different picture than you painted
[/quote]
 
You couldn’t be more wrong.

Apologists like you refuse to acknowledge cold hard facts about “Jesus”. Christian apologists are known to make wildly exaggerated claims. For example, we know more about “Jesus” than Julius Caesar. That is absolute nonsense of course to any secular historian. Christian biased apologists already know what they believe and just look for confirmation of those beliefs. That’s not how you approach historical claims!

Almost nothing is known about “Jesus”.

When was he born? ???Who knows.
What did he look like? No idea.
Where was he from? The “City of Nazareth” didn’t even exist at that time.
Did he write anything like Paul did? No.
Where is his burial site? Who knows?
What do secular historians (of which there were many) say about this “Jesus” during the 1st century? Complete silence. Josephus is a known interpolation. The other shorter reference is not the “Jesus” of Nazareth. “Jesus” was a very common name back then.

Prior to this passage in Josephus, there is complete and utter silence. How do you explain this? Simple, the miracle working, raised from the dead “Jesus” was a constructed mythical character.

St. Justin Martyr acknowledged the pagan similarities, why can’t you? He had an excuse to explain it away. You can’t deny the overwhelming evidence of artifacts and written documents showing the similarities.

There is absolutely no evidence for the authorship of the NT Gospels. None. Only fundamental Christians continue to insist that they were actual eyewitnesses. They weren’t. In fact, the overwhelming evidence is that the authors weren’t even from that immediate area. There are simply too many errors in geography and custom.

Paul’s letters (the 7 probable authentic one) were likely written from 15-20 years after the supposed death of “Jesus”. He never claimed to have met “Jesus” in person. “Jesus” appeared to him as a vision. Ask yourself this. Why is that in Paul’s 7 authentic letters, he knows NOTHING of this “Jesus” other than his death and resurrection? He knows of no other personal details of this “Jesus”. Isn’t that very strange considering that he wrote his letters before the NT gospels?

In my my opinion, the reason for this is evident. Paul made “Jesus” up as a Jewish version of the dying-rising son of God hero of the pagan religions which were so well known in that area of the world.
:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::rotfl::rotfl: You should have your own comedy show!!!
 
Sacred Scripture is infallible on the topic of faith and morals. .
Would that be true on the question of slavery? The Bible says that slaves have to be subject to their masters. It seems like this is an erroneous teaching on the morality of slave ownership.
 
“Q” if there was a “Q” is the likely source for “Mark” the first gospel written. Matthew and Luke were written afterwards, using “Mark” as their source .

Matthew and Luke changed some things that were clearly in error in Mark. They were not original works but simply a “reworking” of Mark. Your hypothesis considers Matthew and Luke as eyewitnesses which they clearly were not. In fact, these gospels were likely written 10-20 years at least after Mark. John was likely written some 30-50 years after Mark. Mark is generally thought to have been written around 70-75 CE at the earliest, perhaps later.

“The Q Hypothesis, unless you are operating on some radical skeptic scholar’s view”

Radical scholar’s view? Perhaps you should substitute the word “unbiased” for “radical scholar”.

MARK 9:1 And he said unto them, Verily I say unto you, That there be some of them that stand here, which shall not taste of death, till they have seen the kingdom of God come with power.

Doesn’t get more clear and concise than this. “John” fixed this false prophecy by converting "“Jesus” into “God” himself.

Paul’s authentic letter’s do not say that Jesus is “God”. The “Son of God” doesn’t equate to “God” himself. There were plenty of other “Sons of God” in mythology. Paul being a diaspora Jew was very familiar with the pagan religion “sons of God”. His “Jesus” was simply a Jewish version of the same.

In my view, if there was an actual man behind the story, he was simply just another apocalyptic end times false preacher.
Wow…I don’t know where you’re getting your info, but…

You’ve stated so many blatant falsehoods that one doesn’t know where to start…or even try.
 
``You’ve stated so many blatant falsehoods that one doesn’t know where to start…or even try.

You dont know where to start since youve probably have never been exposed to biblical criticism.

Think for yourself!!! Don`t accept anything told to you. Do your own thinking.

Consider this.

Paul never once mentions ANYTHING (other than “Lord’s Supper”) about “Gospel Jesus”&never refers 2 Jesus as returning or coming again.
 
No, the joke is actually on you 🙂

No one is saying the prior pagan dying and rising sons of God are identical to Jesus.

Please get the argument right before attempting to refute.

There are many, many similarities. The claim IS NOT that they are supposed to be identical.

Read Justin Marty again for your own sake.
 
Would that be true on the question of slavery? The Bible says that slaves have to be subject to their masters. It seems like this is an erroneous teaching on the morality of slave ownership.
You need to understand the context, I think. Slavery in Jewish antiquity was an economic system, whereby a person would sell themselves to their neighbor for a period not to exceed 7 years. Both the slave and master were expected to treat each other morally in this business exchange. The way people should treat each other, with love, has not changed over time. What has changed is our view of slavery as a viable economic system - because it became obvious over time that it was not a system in which love generally prevails - just the opposite, right?. communism is similar in this regard.
 
``You’ve stated so many blatant falsehoods that one doesn’t know where to start…or even try.
you really have no idea who you are talking to on the internet. But rest assured, many of us have had very significant exposure to the kind of criticism you are bringing.
Think for yourself!!! Don`t accept anything told to you. Do your own thinking.
This is a bit naive on your part and also a bit condenscending. What makes you think that Catholics don’t use reason in coming to their conclusions? And recognize that we all learn from others. The trick is knowing whose infromation to trust.
Consider this.

Paul never once mentions ANYTHING (other than “Lord’s Supper”) about “Gospel Jesus”&never refers 2 Jesus as returning or coming again.
I’m sorry, but you haven’t read St. Paul very thoroughly. Here’s what he says in 1Corinthians 15:usccb.org/nab/bible/1corinthians/1corinthians15.htm
1 Now I am reminding you, brothers, of the gospel I preached to you, which you indeed received and in which you also stand.
2 Through it you are also being saved, if you hold fast to the word I preached to you, unless you believed in vain.
3 For I handed on to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the scriptures;
4 that he was buried; that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the scriptures;
5 that he appeared to Cephas, then to the Twelve.
6 After that, he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at once, most of whom are still living, though some have fallen asleep.
7 After that he appeared to James, then to all the apostles.
8 Last of all, as to one born abnormally, he appeared to me.
9 For I am the least of the apostles, not fit to be called an apostle, because I persecuted the church of God.
10 But by the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace to me has not been ineffective. Indeed, I have toiled harder than all of them; not I, however, but the grace of God (that is) with me.
11 Therefore, whether it be I or they, so we preach and so you believed.
12 But if Christ is preached as raised from the dead, how can some among you say there is no resurrection of the dead?
13 If there is no resurrection of the dead, then neither has Christ been raised.
14 And if Christ has not been raised, then empty (too) is our preaching; empty, too, your faith.
15 Then we are also false witnesses to God, because we testified against God that he raised Christ, whom he did not raise if in fact the dead are not raised.
16 For if the dead are not raised, neither has Christ been raised,
17 and if Christ has not been raised, your faith is vain; you are still in your sins.
18 Then those who have fallen asleep in Christ have perished.
19 If for this life only we have hoped in Christ, we are the most pitiable people of all.
20 But now Christ has been raised from the dead, the firstfruits of those who have fallen asleep.
21 For since death came through a human being, the resurrection of the dead came also through a human being.
22 For just as in Adam all die, so too in Christ shall all be brought to life,
23 but each one in proper order: Christ the firstfruits; then, at his coming, those who belong to Christ;
24 then comes the end, when he hands over the kingdom to his God and Father, when he has destroyed every sovereignty and every authority and power.
25 For he must reign until he has put all his enemies under his feet.
26 The last enemy to be destroyed is death,
27 for “he subjected everything under his feet.” But when it says that everything has been subjected, it is clear that it excludes the one who subjected everything to him.
28 When everything is subjected to him, then the Son himself will (also) be subjected to the one who subjected everything to him, so that God may be all in all.

Keep in mind also, that the reason for St. Paul’s epistles were to address concerns rising in the communities he founded. It was not his purpose (other than 1Corinthians 15) to restate the Gospel. He was focused on addressing new concerns that came up. So the criticism that Paul didn’t restate the Gospels misses the point of his writing. The 4 Gospels describe the life of Jesus but you have conveniently dismissed them. That is to your own detriment. By the way, there is very little dispute that John was written by an eyewitness - John, the son of Zebedee, who lived a very long life. Luke was most likely not an eyewitness of Christ but was a physician and a companion of Paul, as he describes in ACTS. He says he got the information from eyewitness in the first chapter of his gospel. Mark, may or may not have been there at some of the Christian events, but he certainly had MUCH access to Peter and the other Apostles. Matthew is traditionally the apostle Matthew.
 
You need to understand the context, I think. Slavery in Jewish antiquity was an economic system, whereby a person would sell themselves to their neighbor for a period not to exceed 7 years. Both the slave and master were expected to treat each other morally in this business exchange. The way people should treat each other, with love, has not changed over time. What has changed is our view of slavery as a viable economic system - because it became obvious over time that it was not a system in which love generally prevails - just the opposite, right?. communism is similar in this regard.
I think that the Bible is wrong on the morality of slavery and how to treat a slave. For example, "When a man strikes his male or female slave with a rod so hard that the slave dies under his hand, he shall be punished. If, however, the slave survives for a day or two, he is not to be punished, since the slave is his own property. " (Exodus 21:20-21 )
I would not agree that it is all right to beat a slave like that.
 
No, the joke is actually on you 🙂

No one is saying the prior pagan dying and rising sons of God are identical to Jesus.

Please get the argument right before attempting to refute.

There are many, many similarities. The claim IS NOT that they are supposed to be identical.

Read Justin Marty again for your own sake.
This is what you copied over from Justin Martyr on post 43:
Here you go…
Justin Martyr - 100-165 AD
One of the first christian historians and defenders wrote:
“When we say that he, Jesus Christ, our Teacher, was produced without sexual union, was crucified and died, and rose again, and ascended into heaven WE PROFOUND NOTHING DIFFERENT from what you believe regarding the sons of {the god} Jupiter.”
In a different writing, Justin Martyr said:
“He was born of a virgin, ACCEPT THIS IN COMMON with what you believe of [The god} Perseus.”
Its obvious that Justin, and other early Christians knew how similar Christianity was to the Pagan religions. However Justin had a solution. As far as he was concerned,the devil did it:
“The DEVILS…Craftily feigned that Minerva was The Daughter of Jupiter not by sexual union.”
The devil had the foresight to come before christ, and create his characteristics in the pagan world
So it certainly seemed like you were claiming that Christianity was copying paganism. And that certainly wasn’t what Justin Martyr was claiming, now was it?
[/quote]
 
Restating the Gospel would be impossible. Paul`s letters were written about 20-25 years BEFORE Mark.

re read my post. Paul KNOWS NOTHING OF JESUSpersonal details. He created the main theology ofJesus the Son of God`. Of this there is no doubting, Paul invested Christinaity.

You need to pay attention to what other people write.
 
Sorry…keyboard is acting up…

Should have read…Paul invented the theology of Jesus the Christ, Son of God.
 
To the previous poster…

Yes, Jesus, the Christis simply a Jewish version of the other sons of God mention by Martyr. Not identical, but with many of the same attributes.

Martyr confirms my point, not yours. Christianity was rightly rejected by orthodox Jews. They certainly recognized the theology has having pagan similarities. This would easily explain why Christianity had much more success getting Greek & Roman converts.

Do realize that Paul was a diaspora Jew. This is a significant point.
 
To Paul C.

Im sorry but you strike me as someone who doesnt do their own research.

Even Catholic sources disagree with you on your authorship claims. This is all by tradition. There is NO EVIDENCE for what you are claiming. I personally prefer evidence.

The only authors we know with some certainty are Pauls authentic letters and the John of Patmos Greece who wrote Revelation. Thats it.
 
Where was he from? The “City of Nazareth” didn’t even exist at that time.
Hello!

All four Gospel writers refer to Jesus as “of Nazareth.” Where did this complete agreement on this fact come from? You’ve already pointed out in this thread that you think that the Biblical authors were at pains to find a way to place Jesus in Bethlehem at the time of His birth because that’s where the Scriptures said the Messiah would be born. But now you’re saying that the other town associated with His youth didn’t even exist. So the evangelists relocate Jesus from a nonexistent town in order to comply with the strictures of a fabricated census… these evangelists sure are making it hard on themselves! 🙂

In the Gospel of John, Jesus’ coming from Nazareth is an obstacle to faith because it was not expected for the Messiah to come from there. Nathanael, being incredulous, asked, “Can anything good come out of Nazareth?” (John 1:46); and the Jews were confounded with Jesus’ Nazarene upbringing, wondering amongst themselves, “Is the Christ to come from Galilee? Has not the Scripture said that the Christ comes from the offspring of David, and comes from Bethlehem, the village where David was?” (John 7:41-42) The Pharisees charged their fellow Pharisee with an air of finality, “Search and see that no prophet arises from Galilee” (John 7:52).

Again, if you’re going to make things up about a person that you’re trying to promote, why make things up that go against your case? It makes a lot more sense, to my mind, to think that the evangelists are working with real historical data that didn’t always meet with the preconceived expectations for the Jewish Messiah. This reminds me of Tertullian’s saying “The Son of God was crucified …] And the Son of God died; it is by all means to be believed, because it is absurd. And He was buried, and rose again; the fact is certain, because it is impossible” (, Ch. 5On the Flesh of Christ). Yes! Jesus’ rearing in Nazareth is presented as an inconvenient fact of history that needs to be acknowledged in spite of the obstacles that it poses.

Or we might think, “Jesus-era evidence has often been invented in the past by the tradition, is possibly being invented now, and may continue to be invented at Nazareth in the future. Forewarned is forearmed!” (The Myth of Nazareth) And in holding this mindset, we can preserve our false sense of security in defaulting to skepticism no matter where the evidence leads. The “evidence” is all fabricated anyway. 🤷 🙂
No, the joke is actually on you 🙂

No one is saying the prior pagan dying and rising sons of God are identical to Jesus.

Please get the argument right before attempting to refute.

There are many, many similarities. The claim IS NOT that they are supposed to be identical.

Read Justin Marty again for your own sake.
The reason why there seems to be a great number of similarities between Jesus and the Greek myths in Justin’s presentation is because Jesus is compared with a great number of mythological figures. Justin only claims at most a few points of – in many cases vague – resemblance to Christ for any one particular Greek figure. If you prefer, you are free to see these resemblances as the work of God in planting the seeds of the Gospel, insofar as they prepare people to receive what really happened in the life of Jesus as opposed to what are the “mere marvelous tales” of the Greeks.

In Christ,
Pete
 
To Paul C.

Im sorry but you strike me as someone who doesnt do their own research.

Even Catholic sources disagree with you on your authorship claims. This is all by tradition. There is NO EVIDENCE for what you are claiming. I personally prefer evidence.

The only authors we know with some certainty are Pauls authentic letters and the John of Patmos Greece who wrote Revelation. Thats it.
What evidence do you have that Paul of Tarsus wrote 7 letters and that John of patmos wrote Revelation?
 
Restating the Gospel would be impossible. Paul`s letters were written about 20-25 years BEFORE Mark.
The gospel was an oral tradition prior to being written down.
re read my post. Paul KNOWS NOTHING OF JESUS` personal details.
How do you know this?
He created the main theology of Jesus the Son of God. Of this there is no doubting, Paul invested Christinaity.
Really. there is no doubting that Paul created the theology of Jesus the son of God. where is YOUR evidence
You need to pay attention to what other people write.
What is your intention for spending time on these pages. You obviously aren’t here to learn about the Catholic Faith. Do you think you are credible enough to persuade anyone here that Jesus is a fictional character?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top