I suffer from a specific type of post-traumatic stress syndrome, and I am averse to noise or distractions. I drive without the radio on, usually, even on long trips. I “mute” the TV and FF during the commercials if I’m watching program, and…it really bothers me when people are talking in church – not praying, just talking.
around here in all the parishes I know, there is talking – out loud – before Mass, after Mass, and during Mass (the ushers always seem to have some other agenda going on there in the back of the church).
Now, to be sure, look-up canons 1205 through 1210 that are usually interpreted and applied as requiring silence in Church.
But, these distract me so much to a level that I may as well not be in church. The last time I was in church, saying my rosary, a lady came into the same pew, but about 10 feet away, and she was talking out loud with a woman who was no more than 18 inches away from her. I stopped her after Mass and informed her about Canon 1210 with regard to her talking out loud in church.
I have tried unsuccessfully to get the pastor (a canon lawyer) to even bring up the subject, say, in the bulletin. I wrote the bishop, asking for a dispensation from Mass, and he wouldn’t give me a dispensation, mentioning that I needed the Eucharist. but, he said that if I didn’t attend Mass, I didn’t have to confess it.
One of the two churches in my parish has a rosary devotion on a weekday. I went a couple times, and the people are talking continuously until the leader starts the prayer. When the rosary prayers are over, the talking begins immediately. My aunt showed up one of these times, and I asked her about all the talking. She told me it was “fellowship” and so permitted, in her mind.
By the way, anybody can have PTSD, it’s not just a trauma of war, where some soldiers are afflicted with it. Anybody of any age can develop PTSD. The convicted murderess Jody Arias was said to have this problem like I have. It was during her trial that I found out it had a name, but now I can’t remember it. It’s hyper- (something) aha, “hyper vigilance” I know exactly how I developed this. Many decades ago, when I was in high school, I came home with serious homework to do. But, my mother liked to play the tv loudly, which drove me nuts when I was trying to study. She said that she wanted to be able to hear the tv anyplace in the house, so that she wouldn’t miss anything. That meant that there was no place for me to escape the noise and distraction.
It’s not “just me.” There are people talking out loud in the local adoration chapel. Canon 1210 is just a rug that a lot of people wipe their shoes on.
**Can. 1210 In a sacred place only those things are to be permitted which serve to exercise or promote worship, piety and religion. Anything out of harmony with the holiness of the place is forbidden. **