How do you know you are not mad?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dave_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Dave_B

Guest
Hi All

I was wondering how do you know that you are not mad for believing in the Catholic faith?

Lots of people in different cultures around the world and in history believe in invisible agents controlling things - different gods and goddesses, ghosts, angels, demons, aliens, etc. etc.

Many people today believe they are haunted by invisible beings and many religions teach that an invisible being made us and controls our lives.

Many of these beliefs are clearly crazy. Most people would say the earth being controlled by alien reptiles was crazy. But religions teach things which are far out too.

Mohammed was supposed to have split the moon in two and went to heaven on a winged horse. Jesus was supposed to cast demons out of people with seizures and fly to heaven on a cloud.

How do we decide what is crazy and what is sane? Are you sane?

Thanks in advance.
 
For me, there was a process of discernment, studying different faiths and identifying the truth and wisdom I was able to identify in each one. Eventually, after a long and careful process, I came to recognise that the fullness of truth was to be found in the Catholic Church. This is not simply about comprehending and teaching Scripture and Apostolic Tradition (which is hugely important, because the fullness of truth was revealed by God in Jesus), but because of the practical philosophical underpinnings which change us and affect the very way we live our lives each day.

It is this practical, efficacious approach to reality which lets me know I am not mad. The way my children behave, the way my family treat others and each other, the way others ask my help and advice when they’re in trouble, the way my opinion is sought by different sectors of my community, as a governor, as a catechist, as a leader.
 
Hi FightingFat, I think much of the same could be said aboutother religions. And I guess this would apply only if you are a convert and not born into it. Cause only a convert would go through the discernment, studying different faiths.

So my question is why believe in this particular invisble controlling agent (God of Christainty, father, son and holy ghost), and not one of the other ones - allah, buddha, kristna, hindu gods, or aliens?
 
The question, of course, could be turned on its head. When I was an atheist who was vehemently anti-religion and (especially) anti-Christian, how did I know that such things were not the result of madness? How could I tell that my opinions about ultimate reality were not rooted in insanity or, at best, in great personal flaws that led me to see distorted pictures of the world around me?

The answer is the that I read more, experienced more, grew up more, and reflected more, and came to believe that I was mistaken about many of my views. I came to see that the totality of the Catholic worldview was a paradigm that, to my own mind, amounted to being the best explanation for the evidence that I perceived.

Now, making an attempt to somehow demonstrate with extremely precise data and theory that all religious belief is the result of a genuine psychiatric condition would be quite a feat, and I admit, I don’t have 30 years to become an expert both in world religion and psychiatry to be able to do such a question justice. I would also say that I lack the intellectual gifts to be able to accomplish such a thing.

I would submit that most people have neither the time, resources, educational opportunities, or intelligence to go down such a path, and at some point, we all embark on making basic assumptions about certain things. Just as faith can be cultivated, doubt or indifference can be cultivated as well. As (then) Fr. Joseph Ratzinger once observed, the atheist can always ask the question of himself but what if it’s true? Thus both he and people of faith are equally open to opportunities of doubt or difficulty, and there is always a choice to cultivate one approach or another.

For many converts, I think, there are events or happenings or situations in their lives that make belief in the God of Christianity* an option to consider*. There are after this point many ways that they can learn more, and be open both to the evidence as well as to their own interior life.

Ultimately, however, the question of the God of Christianity and His existence is a philosophical question, and not a psychiatric one. To understand the Catholic perspective on this, is to delve into Thomism.

Here’s a free lecture series you could listen to: hebrewcatholic.net/12-introduction-to-theology-faith-seeking-understanding/

Here are twelve more: hebrewcatholic.net/studies/mystery-of-israel-church/
 
"The resurrection, then, is not a theory, but a historical reality revealed by the man Jesus Christ by means of his “Passover”, his “passage”, that has opened a “new way” between heaven and earth (cf. Heb 10:20). It is neither a myth nor a dream, it is not a vision or a utopia, it is not a fairy tale, but it is a singular and unrepeatable event: Jesus of Nazareth, son of Mary, who at dusk on Friday was taken down from the Cross and buried, has victoriously left the tomb. In fact, at dawn on the first day after the Sabbath, Peter and John found the tomb empty. Mary Magdalene and the other women encountered the risen Jesus. On the way to Emmaus the two disciples recognized him at the breaking of the bread. The Risen One appeared to the Apostles that evening in the Upper Room and then to many other disciples in Galilee. "

-Pope Benedict XVI Urbi et Orbi message 2009
 
Ultimately, however, the question of the God of Christianity and His existence is a philosophical question, and not a psychiatric one. To understand the Catholic perspective on this, is to delve into Thomism.
Hi IND, I disagree the question of religion is a psychiatric one. The issues here are mental, they are in the head. The advice given by people here is counselling but is not given that term.
 
Hi FightingFat, I think much of the same could be said aboutother religions. And I guess this would apply only if you are a convert and not born into it. Cause only a convert would go through the discernment, studying different faiths.

So my question is why believe in this particular invisble controlling agent (God of Christainty, father, son and holy ghost), and not one of the other ones - allah, buddha, kristna, hindu gods, or aliens?
I guess because I don’t see it as about “invisible controlling agents” and whether they exist or not, rather about the truth about life.

There are huge differences between Allah, Buddha, Krishna, Hinduism, and Aliens. And there are huge differences between all these and the unique doctrine of Christianity, which is fundamentally Christological.
 
I guess because I don’t see it as about “invisible controlling agents” and whether they exist or not, rather about the truth about life.
Hi Ff, but God and Jesus are invisible, they are said to control things, and are agents i.e. they take an active role in things. I put the question once as to if anyone has seen Jesus, and there are experiences but not much in the way of tangible proof. We have to rely on the evidence of others. Peter, James and the other apostles saw Jesus and claimed to have witnessed miracles. I dont know if we would believe the same today, if somone was to come up to you and claim to see invisible beings and speak on their behalf. I guess they would literally be put into care.
 
If you look at the essence of the Catholic religion and other Christian religions, it comes down to love God and love your neighbor. So, there’s nothing crazy about that.
 
How do we decide what is crazy and what is sane? Are you sane?
I don’t think Christianity or even any other religion is the only world view that questions and eschews conventional notions of sanity. History is full of great conquerors, thinkers, and inventors who dared to believe in something that defied the comforts of norm.

I for one only consider myself sane when it suits me. :whacky:
 
If you look at the essence of the Catholic religion and other Christian religions, it comes down to love God and love your neighbor. So, there’s nothing crazy about that.
I like that 👍 but its all the other stuff that go with it like the bible and the strange rituals which i dont get
 
Hi Ff, but God and Jesus are invisible, they are said to control things, and are agents i.e. they take an active role in things.
Is Jesus invisible in the Eucharist? What about the numerous Eucharistic miracles which have been scientifically proven? What about the miracles that have occurred at Lourdes? Or even as recent as the miracles which proved that Pope John Paul II was in heaven, validated by an atheist doctor who now believes in miracles, as asserted by this BBC article.
I put the question once as to if anyone has seen Jesus, and there are experiences but not much in the way of tangible proof.
Why do you believe that Julius Caesar invaded England, or the Xerxes fought 300 Spartans in Greece, or in the battle of Thermopylae, or Hannibal, or anyone for that matter? Because of the quality of the evidence. The academic reality is that there is far more academic evidence for the existence of Jesus Christ than for Xerxes or Caesar.

Surely this is the same with any historical event though isn’t it?
We have to rely on the evidence of others.
If you are going out today, you rely on the weather man to tell you whether you need to take an umbrella with you. Faith is a fundamental part of human existence and we utilise it in all our relationships everyday. It is not some foreign, unreasonable, construct.
Peter, James and the other apostles saw Jesus and claimed to have witnessed miracles. I dont know if we would believe the same today, if someone was to come up to you and claim to see invisible beings and speak on their behalf. I guess they would literally be put into care.
Peter, James, and the other Apostles knew Jesus in the flesh. They didn’t, to the best of my knowledge, claim that He spoke to them after the ascension.
 
When we speak about history, I think it is worth considering how valuable the information we have from the Biblical tradition, how factually verifiable it is, and how much depth, how many lives lived, kings reigned, saints, martyrs, theologians, professors, have assented and valued that inheritance.

King Frederick the Great once asked his physician, Zimmermann of Brugg-in-Aargau, ‘Zimmermann, can you name me a single proof for the existence of God?’

The physician replied, ‘Your majesty, the Jews.’

More on that here.

Sacred Scripture is replete with witness: “He saw and he believed” (Jn 20:8). Peter and John go to the tomb on the testimony of Mary Mag’dalene and do not simply see, but also believe—not just because of the empty tomb, but because of a powerful sense that something has decisively changed; the world is different, the future is charged with an overwhelming sense of rapture and mysterious expectation based on this apostolic experience. Later, St. Peter addressed the household of Cornelius and testified at length: there are four allusions to witness, and his conviction establishes an apostolic tradition of which we are a part: “Now I, and those with me, can witness…”; “it is to Him that all the prophets bear witness…” They witness to Jesus who went about doing good and curing all who had fallen into the power of the devil.

This is a living continuity of memory which exists within the Church and all its members are a part of.

The importance and essence of this continuity is wonderfully illustrated by such examples as a letter from Ireneaus, Bishop of Lyon in France to Florinus with whom he was a student at Smyrna in Asia Minor. In this letter, Irenaeus reminisces how he and Florinus attended lectures by Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna, who died in approximately 155 AD. Polycarp used to tell them stories about 'John, the disciple of the Lord’, whom he had known personally many years before.

Ireneaus, then, in France shortly before 200 AD was able to recall at only one remove, a man who had known Jesus intimately. When the Bishop of Lyon gathered his congregation, he was not thinking of something he had discovered (where Kipling’s Tomlinson found his God) ‘in a printed book’, but rather of what he had been told by his old teacher, whose friend had been there and knew.

This letter gives an example of the corporate memory of faith, of Apostolic Tradition handed down from generation to generation. Our knowledge about the origins of the church and about its Founder, rest on this living tradition, which had its beginnings in the actual memories of those who had witnessed the events and had personal dealings with the principle Actor in them and are deposited for safe keeping with the Church that he founded.

This witness matters because we will have our sins forgiven through His name. No matter what the mess of the horror, He has opened a way of transformation and pardon.

Think about that in terms of Sunday Mass & Eucharist. You attend with your children perhaps, and you attended as a child with your parents, who attended with their parents when they were children, and so on and back, to the Last Supper itself, an unbroken chain of corporate memory and practice. If you think about it, there is no stronger form of link with the reality of the past.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top