How do you talk to a Protestant that

  • Thread starter Thread starter scimitar60
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

scimitar60

Guest
How do you talk to a Protestant about the Church, when they are so misinformed about it that they pull just ridiculous statements out of nowhere? I see it everywhere these days.

Has anyone else found a good tactic around it? 😉
 
Its a heavy burden to get someone turned around.
All you can do is plant seeds, so that when and if they follow a journey, they’ll think back to you and how you were right.

In reality, the truth of the Catholic Church is a hidden(in protestant society) and intellectual truth.
Most wont do the heavy lifting of reading to get there or are comfortable in de-programming a protestant mindset.
 
I’m in the wilds of the Pacific NW where Catholicism is under constant attack. My husband and I decided the best thing we can do is be shining examples of Catholicism. That is: we go to Mass at every opportunity, but we don’t close ourselves off from Protestant activities in the community.

Our rule is, if at one of these activities and we are asked something directly, we respond. BUT, and this is the hard part, if Clarification of Catholic beliefs is not requested, we respect that we are at someone else’s venue and bite our tongues. We do, however bring that information back to the Catholic parents of the children that attend these functions too so that they can be properly catechized.

Try to see these attacks as opportunities for you to grow closer to the Holy Spirit in asking HIS advice in how to handle these confrontations. Remember, often it is through His urgings that the ugliness inside others is brought to the surface to have the light of Christ’s truth shone on it.

For example, just recently, I had a young woman tell me she thought Mary was invented by the Devil to come between us and Christ. Thanks to God, I was able to cite scripture and appeal to logic with her for well over an hour. It all just poured into me and came out my mouth.

I used to hate confrontation but now I love it because I know that the Helper Jesus sent is using me to reach out to others.

Pray for discernment and wisdom, and don’t feel bad about walking away. ALWAYS treat others with love, even when it is hate coming at you. The seed analogy is so true.

Get some good books on apologetics.
Learn your Church history.
Know your bible REALLY well. Usually you are dealing with people that have read the bible but, alas, thanks to the idea of self-interpretation, they have no clue what God’s Word really means. So when I say: know your bible I don’t mean memorize it, that’s good, but what’s MORE helpful is to know the context of the passages that might be used against you. Know when the book were written, their sources, what was going on at that time, *why *they were written.

Check out the early Church Fathers and especially the Didache. You’ll see that Tradition predates the Bible in the earliest Christians. It is clear that, just as Christ promised, hell has not prevailed against his Church and that Church has to be the Catholic Church.
Oh… but back to your original question. Read Proverbs. There is a lot in there about wisdom and fools. Realize that in most cases you are talking to someone who has been lead astray from birth. What you think of as simple factual correction and easy-to-follow logic; is actually Earth-shattering paradigm-shifting stuff that not only attacks the core of the listener’s foundations, but likely their parents’ and Grandparents’ beliefs, going back for who knows how many generations now. That’s asking a lot of someone in one sitting. Right?

Be kind, be gentle, be **firm **but pray the whole time you are discussing things and try not to take things personally.

May God guide you and help you in your efforts. Let Him help you find that room of “mere Christianity” that you can start from. May He help others see the sincerity and truth in your words, even if not at first. May He help you find peace when your words seem to fall on deaf ears. May He give you the fortitude and strength to stand firm under onslaughts of words and actions that are derived to keep you from doing His good work. May He open your heart and mind to hear the words of others and the discernment to recognize their source (e.g. Satan, Avarice, Malice, or just plain old Ignorance). May God protect you from the powers and principalities that would pit themselves against you.
May God bless you in all ways in your ministry of apologetics. – In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.
 
How do you talk to a Protestant about the Church, when they are so misinformed about it that they pull just ridiculous statements out of nowhere? I see it everywhere these days.

Has anyone else found a good tactic around it? 😉
Such people usually don’t want to know but are happy in their contented bigoted ignorance mouthing off an endless series of ridiculous claims and empty slogans.

But you can deter them from doing this and amake them at least start to think by saying “let’s take one thing at a time” e.g “you said that Catholics worship Mary” or whatever it is.

then make him stick to that point as you refute his claim and show what the Catholic doctrine really is and prove that it is true and refute his objections to that particular point.

If he asks anything you don;t know the answer to or you can’t come up with the Scripture/history/Early Father/ doctrinal statement on the spot, don’t be afraid to sgive a brief summary of what you think is the answer or "just “I don’t know” followed by “Ill get back to you” with a definitive answer /proof tomorrow or whenever you will see him again and make sure you do follow up and don’t just let it drop, otherwise he will say you ran away because you couldn’t answer his objection.
 
Remember…we always go to God about man, before going to man about God.

Offer prayer, sacrifice, penance, holy hours before the Blessed Sacrament, the Rosary, etc. Get others to do the same. THEN, “offer” the Church’s truths to the person in a “take it or leave it” manner (charitably, of course). Well we need to do is work in the Lord’s garden of souls. We plow, plant, weed, water, etc. It is for Him to say when the harvest is ready for any particular soul. But whenever we share Christ’s truths, grace accompany’s that truth, and when that individual will need that truth, it will be there.

Don’t get all caught up looking for harvests. Just keep working the garden. And be a good example. Live a sacramental life, in the state of grace.
 
Jesus,our Lords peace be whit You.
One hard question. And one for You. Do You need to do it? And another,why do You need to do it? And the last one,what good is there for You? If it is just because You want to be rigth I see no point in trying,if it is to “protect” Your faith,there might be something to do,and how would You do it. Well,how did Jesus do it? Use the same tactic,but before You do any of theese,read the Book by Job and 2 Tim.14 and 23.
 
I know what you mean. Some preacher, some where, gets them fired up over some personal interpretation of Scripture and then they come at you with it. Insanity is not an argument I step in front of.
 
One thing I’ve learned over the past 59 years as a Catholic, don’t argue with people over your faith.

If they ask questions, provide an answer without getting into an argument to justify your answer.

If they start to debate, just move on by saying this is what I believe. I respect your beliefs, not please respect mine.

In all, be a good example of what a Catholic is suppose to be and that is, be Christ like, showing compassion and understanding.

See their ignorance about the faith as their poverty.

Jim
 
Ask them to prove it. If they can (and I doubt they can), then disprove their “proof”. It’ll be very easy since their “proof” will be based on a lie. Then, tell them the truth that is contrary to their claims. If they can’t provide proof, then tell them the truth contrary to their claims anyway.

If they’ll listen, then they want to learn. If they won’t listen, then “shake your sandals” and just leave like Jesus commanded His disciples to do when a city would reject them.
 
I know what you mean. Some preacher, some where, gets them fired up over some personal interpretation of Scripture and then they come at you with it. Insanity is not an argument I step in front of.
QFT
 
From a former protestant I was as ignorant as they come. I believed all the lies I was told about the Church. I’m not quite sure what happened but I began reading some of my mother’s books as she was becoming Catholic and it all just made sense. It HAD to be the Holy Spirit, b/c knowing how I used to be I tried to find holes in everything of the Catholic faith and if I didn’t find any my brain made them up. So for me to accept it so easily it had to be supernatural.

When I went to my first Mass w/ my college roommate I was disgusted. I kept finding faults with everything and now that I look back I wonder where in the world that came from?

Now I am extremely frustrated with the continuing ignorance of protestants, most not their own fault. I wonder, now that I know the truth, how could it have gotten this BAD!!! How can they think that the Church was wrong for the first 1500 years? They are stubborn, like I was, and insist on believing LIES.

I want to tell everyone I love about the truth but I am not a good speaker. I read everything I can get my hands on but when it comes to trying to convince people I can’t pull any sources to mind, it goes blank. Which means to me that I’m not supposed to. If I am asked questions, however, I am able to come up with answers that really aren’t from me b/c they are pretty good lol. 😉

I’ll just be a witness as best I can. Like St. Francis says, preach the gospel always, if necessary use words (That is a paraphrase btw) 😊
 
One thing I’ve learned over the past 59 years as a Catholic, don’t argue with people over your faith.

If they ask questions, provide an answer without getting into an argument to justify your answer.

If they start to debate, just move on by saying this is what I believe. I respect your beliefs, not please respect mine.

In all, be a good example of what a Catholic is suppose to be and that is, be Christ like, showing compassion and understanding.

See their ignorance about the faith as their poverty.

Jim
Argue - no.
Debate - YES!

Our Lord, Sts Peter and Paul, and Vatican II all tell us that every single Catholic has a DUTY in CHARITY to his neighbours, to, as far as he is able, explain WHY Catholics believe and do the things we do and WHY it is the truth. For all you know, God may have led this person into a confrontation with you so that he can find the truth.

Sorry, but just saying “you’ve got your beliefs and I’ve got mine” is NOT an option for a Catholic. This is relativism - virtually saying, “one religion is as good as any other for the person who believes in it.”
 
Argue - no.
Debate - YES!

Our Lord, Sts Peter and Paul, and Vatican II all tell us that every single Catholic has a DUTY in CHARITY to his neighbours, to, as far as he is able, explain WHY Catholics believe and do the things we do and WHY it is the truth. For all you know, God may have led this person into a confrontation with you so that he can find the truth.

Sorry, but just saying “you’ve got your beliefs and I’ve got mine” is NOT an option for a Catholic. This is relativism - virtually saying, “one religion is as good as any other for the person who believes in it.”
de¡bate (d-bt)
v. de¡bat¡ed, de¡bat¡ing, de¡bates
v.intr.
  1. To consider something; deliberate.
  2. To engage in argument by discussing opposing points.
  3. To engage in a formal discussion or argument. See Synonyms at discuss.
  4. Obsolete To fight or quarrel.
Its one thing to explain your beliefs, another to debate them, which is aguing.

A person who asks a question for the purpose of debating, generally has no interest in
learning what your belief is, but rather, is out to convince you that you are wrong.

Avoid debates with such people. Just explain your beliefs and move away from confrontation.

Jim
 
. . . I tend to think some part of it is WILLFUL blindness or ignorance.

The waters are also muddied by the fact that Protestant ministers rely on contributions for their livelihood, so it PAYS not to tell the truth about Catholics but to instead get hysterical about them.

In 2010, our day and age, the truths of Catholicism should be EASY to find for Protestant ministers. But often they choose to persist in error.
 
Cross yourself, say a quick and silent prayer, turn around and walk away.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top