How does a polyamorous relationship between four people work?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bubba_Switzler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m not a supporter of same sex marriage, but I don’t think being gay necessarily means one is a supporter of polyamory .
Indeed. That is because gay activists want their relationship to be considered equivalent to a real marriage, but they believe polyamorists should be discriminated against (according to their own definition of “equal rights”). Why, based on the faulty reasoning of gay activists, should polyamorists’ relationships not be acceptable?
 
Indeed. That is because gay activists want their relationship to be considered equivalent to a real marriage, but they believe polyamorists should be discriminated against (according to their own definition of “equal rights”). Why, based on the faulty reasoning of gay activists, should polyamorists’ relationships not be acceptable?
No doubt some will at least pretend to be appaled by polygamy. But there are those who have aimed from the start to destroy marriage, not simply to expand it.
 
I’m not a supporter of same sex marriage, but I don’t think being gay necessarily means one is a supporter of polyamory .
Which is exactly what makes them hypocrites. If the whole world was supposed to change to accept their definition of love and their desire for marriage, what gall of them to then claim that someone else’s definitions of love and marriage aren’t valid.

But as someone else said, the goal was to destroy marriage, not expand it.
 
I think the point of the article is to normalize polyamory in anticipation of polygamy. There have been others previously along the same lines. This is the first step juding from the experience of “homosexual marriage”.

Is it too soon for us to say “I told you so?”
Next will be either polygamy or incest or both at the same time. And later it will be bestiality and legalized pedophilia (all they would have to do is change the laws for the age of consent). It’s guaranteed that polygamy will be next since:
  1. It has historical precedent. So-called “same-sex marriage” doesn’t even have this but is being made the law in many countries.
  2. Muslims practice polygamy, and Islam trumps everything else in the rules of political correctness.
  3. If so-called “same-sex marriage” is made the law, on what basis would the courts argue that it should be limited to only two homosexuals? There is a natural basis for limiting it to two with marriage between a man and a woman since every child has only two biological parents. But there is no biological basis for homosexual relationships.
 
And following right along in the pattern that worked so well, here’s what I assume is only the beginning of many studies proving how wonderful polyamory is, possibly even a little superior to monogamy:

livescience.com/27125-5-myths-about-polyamory.html
Oh yes, we cannot discriminate with those who identify (and were born) bisexual. In order for them to fully express their love, they must be allowed to be in multiple (or just in one large) “marriage/s.” To do otherwise violates the equal protection clause and is discrimination. Wah, poor me.
 
We can say it, but if people’s ears are closed there is no one to hear it.

Polygamous “marriage” can be justified using the exact same arguments as “homosexual marriage” used.
Yes, how long before you (as an employer) will be required to provide health insurance for all four of these creeps if you hire ONE of them?

How long before the day comes that one of these people dies and the other THREE apply for Social Security survivor benefits? (And sue if they are denied?)

We’ve lost track of WHY marriage has been given privileges in law in the first, place, so anything is on the table nowadays. Just appeal to emotion and put some such characters in TV shows with likable personalities…
 
How does it work?

First you start with 4 people with very low morals…
 
Next will be either polygamy or incest or both at the same time. And later it will be bestiality and legalized pedophilia (all they would have to do is change the laws for the age of consent). It’s guaranteed that polygamy will be next since:
  1. It has historical precedent. So-called “same-sex marriage” doesn’t even have this but is being made the law in many countries.
  2. Muslims practice polygamy, and Islam trumps everything else in the rules of political correctness.
  3. If so-called “same-sex marriage” is made the law, on what basis would the courts argue that it should be limited to only two homosexuals? There is a natural basis for limiting it to two with marriage between a man and a woman since every child has only two biological parents. But there is no biological basis for homosexual relationships.
Polygamy-marriage or polyamory-marriage would have to be legally accommodated in ways our legal system hasn’t really considered. I’m not sure what a standard form would even look like legally. It’s nothing like two-person marriages in that respect. So much would have to be rewritten and reconsidered in that light.

Suggestions that gay marriage means legalized pedophilia-marriage or bestiality-marriage are non sequitir. Those being illegal have to do with either the age of consent and/or the ability to give consent and also when people can enter into a legal contract. The overall historical move has been to higher ages and more restrictive definitions of consent. I just don’t see that reversing course any time soon. Animals never have been able to give consent legally in the U.S. and I don’t know how that’s going to change. Incest is in the same boat. The reality is that the adult/consensual version of it is really hard to detect or stop as it is, and the much more common adult/child form of it is no more likely to become legal than pedophilia. Where the heck is the movement going to come from for any of these to bring about “marriage” though?

Finally, you have to be careful when you say there is “no biological basis” for homosexual relationships. There most certainly is one, even if it’s disordered and wrong. The sexuality may be non-procreative, but to say there is no biological basis implicitly reduces all sexuality solely to its procreative function. Catholics don’t do that.
 
I believe the unstated premise must first be proven,

that it does, in fact, “work”. 😉
Was no fault divorce proven to work?
Was DDT proven to work? Was the marketing of the Edsel proven to work? Was polygyny proven to work? I don’t get your point, if you were making one. There is a premise that polyamory “works”. But I did not see anything to support that. I have seen data showing that polygyny does not work, as well as some data that purports to show that it does work. If you have data showing that polyamory “works”, it behooves you to share it. It would be helpful also to know the definition of “works” as used here. Does “works” means it “functions” without reference to goodness or badness, to success or failure; or does “works” mean with supreme success in bringing peace and prosperity to all, or at least to the participants?
 
Polygamy-marriage or polyamory-marriage would have to be legally accommodated in ways our legal system hasn’t really considered. I’m not sure what a standard form would even look like legally. It’s nothing like two-person marriages in that respect. So much would have to be rewritten and reconsidered in that light.

Suggestions that gay marriage means legalized pedophilia-marriage or bestiality-marriage are non sequitir. Those being illegal have to do with either the age of consent and/or the ability to give consent and also when people can enter into a legal contract. The overall historical move has been to higher ages and more restrictive definitions of consent. I just don’t see that reversing course any time soon. Animals never have been able to give consent legally in the U.S. and I don’t know how that’s going to change. Incest is in the same boat. The reality is that the adult/consensual version of it is really hard to detect or stop as it is, and the much more common adult/child form of it is no more likely to become legal than pedophilia. Where the heck is the movement going to come from for any of these to bring about “marriage” though?

Finally, you have to be careful when you say there is “no biological basis” for homosexual relationships. There most certainly is one, even if it’s disordered and wrong. The sexuality may be non-procreative, but to say there is no biological basis implicitly reduces all sexuality solely to its procreative function. Catholics don’t do that.
Catholicism doesn’t reduce sexuality to its procreative function. Rather it expands marital love into a total self giving, and not just sexually. But sexual complementarity is essential to the conjugal union, otherwise the union has not even the possibility of procreation. A marital union requires sexual complementarity. Even if procreation does not occur, the marital act is ordered toward procreation.

As to other types of unions, I expect that there will be attempts to reduce the age of consent. It will be argued, for example, that children as young as twelve can obtain birth control pills and even abortions often without parental consent. It will be argued that if they are old enough for sex, they are old enough to give consent. I don’t see pederast marriage as an immediate possibility, but it’s on the horizon. Marriage equality for all.
 
I think like any relationship, it depends on whether they share goals.

I think some of this is due to economic pressures. It’s easier to raise children and manage a household with four adults than two since it is so difficult now to raise children on one income.

I’d like to see the extended family structure come back where people live with parents and unmarried brothers and sisters who also help raise the children. What happened to that?

I see this as a move from independence back to the interdependence our society once had.
 
Polygamy-marriage or polyamory-marriage would have to be legally accommodated in ways our legal system hasn’t really considered. I’m not sure what a standard form would even look like legally. It’s nothing like two-person marriages in that respect. So much would have to be rewritten and reconsidered in that light.
Actually it wouldn’t be difficult at all to do using the standard Person A & Person B forms. It’s just a matter of removing bigamy laws and allowing people to be in multiple marriages at the same time. Then everyone can marry everyone else and we’ll all be one big happy family…or not.

I’ve never met a poly group who were anything but miserable. Jealously and hurt feelings always creep in. People just are not designed to share.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top