How does a Protestant repent after Baptism and after being "saved"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter WhatIf
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
SPOKENWORD:
Hi Darrel,But I thought Christ already lives in you as a true believer? Are you doubting it? What are you searching for if He already is in you? :confused: God Bless
Your being much more polite then I might have been in the past if I were reading what I am writing as a protestant. To answer your question I search for the truth, Christ is the truth.

If you have doubts as to the validity of the Eucharist please feel free to visit an adoration chapel with an open heart and see for yourself. The more I study and experience the Catholic faith the more I see that this Church which has existed for thousands of years really does know what it is talking about and Christ really does abide in it.

What I have been exposed to was most unexpected and shocking in regards to my current views. In all honesty it was the last thing I ever expected to happen but it did. As I stated before I had a serious problem with what Catholics practiced on many levels. Only the lord himself could have changed my heart to make me reverse my position on these matters.

-D
 
40.png
Darrel:
Your being much more polite then I might have been in the past if I were reading what I am writing as a protestant. To answer your question I search for the truth, Christ is the truth.

If you have doubts as to the validity of the Eucharist please feel free to visit an adoration chapel with an open heart and see for yourself. The more I study and experience the Catholic faith the more I see that this Church which has existed for thousands of years really does know what it is talking about and Christ really does abide in it.

What I have been exposed to was most unexpected and shocking in regards to my current views. In all honesty it was the last thing I ever expected to happen but it did. As I stated before I had a serious problem with what Catholics practiced on many levels. Only the lord himself could have changed my heart to make me reverse my position on these matters.

-D
Hi Darrel,You really didnt answer my question but anyways praise God you have come closer through your experiences with the Eucharist.Mysteries are mysteries and very difficult to humanlly understand.I respect what you believe. Is our salvation based on the fact that we must recieve the Eucharist? If so,quote me the verses please. :confused: God Bless
 
40.png
SPOKENWORD:
Hi Darrel,You really didnt answer my question but anyways praise God you have come closer through your experiences with the Eucharist.Mysteries are mysteries and very difficult to humanlly understand.I respect what you believe. Is our salvation based on the fact that we must recieve the Eucharist? If so,quote me the verses please. :confused: God Bless
Try John Chapter 6. There are many version of the Bible. Let me know if you don’t see the emphasis on eating His Body (The Eucharist) in your Bible. I can maybe show other verses to you. This is from John.
48] I am the bread of life.
49] Your fathers ate the manna in the wilderness, and they died.
50] This is the bread which comes down from heaven, that a man may eat of it and not die.
51] I am the living bread which came down from heaven; if any one eats of this bread, he will live for ever; and the bread which I shall give for the life of the world is my flesh."
52] The Jews then disputed among themselves, saying, “How can this man give us his flesh to eat?”

53] So Jesus said to them, “Truly, truly, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood, you have no life in you;
54] he who eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day.
55] For my flesh is food indeed, and my blood is drink indeed.
56] He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him.
57] As the living Father sent me, and I live because of the Father, so he who eats me will live because of me.
58] This is the bread which came down from heaven, not such as the fathers ate and died; he who eats this bread will live for ever.”
59] This he said in the synagogue, as he taught at Caper’na-um.

To better understand the importance of these verses, you may want to compare to John Chapter 1 and Exodus Chapter 12.
John 1:28-30
28] This took place in Bethany beyond the Jordan, where John was baptizing.
29]
The next day he saw Jesus coming toward him, and said, "Behold, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!

30] This is he of whom I said, `After me comes a man who ranks before me, for he was before me.’

Exodus 12:8, 12:21 and 12:46
8] They shall eat the flesh that night, roasted; with unleavened bread and bitter herbs they shall eat it.

21] Then Moses called all the elders of Israel, and said to them, "Select lambs for yourselves according to your families, and kill the passover lamb.

46] In one house shall it be eaten; you shall not carry forth any of the flesh outside the house; and you shall not break a bone of it.

John 19:31-37
31] Since it was the day of Preparation, in order to prevent the bodies from remaining on the cross on the sabbath (for that sabbath was a high day), the Jews asked Pilate that their legs might be broken, and that they might be taken away.
32] So the soldiers came and broke the legs of the first, and of the other who had been crucified with him;
33] but when they came to Jesus and saw that he was already dead, they did not break his legs.
34] But one of the soldiers pierced his side with a spear, and at once there came out blood and water.
35] He who saw it has borne witness – his testimony is true, and he knows that he tells the truth – that you also may believe.
36] For these things took place that the scripture might be fulfilled, “Not a bone of him shall be broken.”
37] And again another scripture says, “They shall look on him whom they have pierced.” (Does this remind you of a crucifix?)

Reading 1 Corinthians also shows Pauls views on eating Body and drinking the Blood of the Lord. Matthew 26, Mark 14, Luke 22, and John 6 might be good too.

I’m sure your interpretation on some of these will be different, but I hope that you can see a connection between Jesus being the Sacrificial Lamb and the Eucharist (Body and Blood of Jesus). At least you know where we are coming from. Our beliefs are scriptural.

As Christians, we want to join together to spread the word. You are a very good strong Christian in my view. I respect your persistence in teaching people that Jesus Christ is our Savior. The world needs people like you. If the Catholic Church was as you thought it was, no Christian would belong to it, but you have misunderstood it.
 
40.png
SPOKENWORD:
Hi Darrel,You really didnt answer my question but anyways praise God you have come closer through your experiences with the Eucharist.Mysteries are mysteries and very difficult to humanlly understand.I respect what you believe. Is our salvation based on the fact that we must recieve the Eucharist? If so,quote me the verses please. :confused: God Bless
I thought you asked me what I was searching for. You also asked if I was having doubts. The answer to that is no I was not having doubts, Christ was in me when I experienced the Eucharist and increased himself in me as a result of being exposed to him in the Eucharist.

With regards to the question about salvation coming from the Eucharist. I like you believe that salvation became available to the human race at the cross when Christ died for our sins. I have never heard a Catholic deny that Christ died for our sins at Calvary.

That same Christ that died for our sins is the Eucharist. Nothing I have learned from all of these years of being protestant has been discarded or removed by my new outlook on the Eucharist. In fact it has all been reinforced and made whole.

The only change I have is a new found respect and love for Catholic Church and its teachings. In reading your posts I can honestly say it would take a miracle of God to change your mind about the Eucharist. I was the same way and as far as I’m concerned I had one given to me in the form of blinding new information and revelation with regards to the Catholic Church.

I have a great deal of respect for your faith in standing up and professing your beliefs here. I think you’re probably my kind of guy given your direct attitude.

I used to feel that Catholics were going to heaven in spite of some of there practices. Now I believe Protestants are going to heaven even if they are missing out on the full bounty that Christ offers to his children through the Church. In any case we are all brothers and sisters in Christ and we should all keep an open heart and mind towards all alternate Christian views. At the end of the day I will always know that Christ will answer anyone who calls his name.

-D
 
40.png
Darrel:
I thought you asked me what I was searching for. You also asked if I was having doubts. The answer to that is no I was not having doubts, Christ was in me when I experienced the Eucharist and increased himself in me as a result of being exposed to him in the Eucharist.

With regards to the question about salvation coming from the Eucharist. I like you believe that salvation became available to the human race at the cross when Christ died for our sins. I have never heard a Catholic deny that Christ died for our sins at Calvary.

That same Christ that died for our sins is the Eucharist. Nothing I have learned from all of these years of being protestant has been discarded or removed by my new outlook on the Eucharist. In fact it has all been reinforced and made whole.

The only change I have is a new found respect and love for Catholic Church and its teachings. In reading your posts I can honestly say it would take a miracle of God to change your mind about the Eucharist. I was the same way and as far as I’m concerned I had one given to me in the form of blinding new information and revelation with regards to the Catholic Church.

I have a great deal of respect for your faith in standing up and professing your beliefs here. I think you’re probably my kind of guy given your direct attitude.

I used to feel that Catholics were going to heaven in spite of some of there practices. Now I believe Protestants are going to heaven even if they are missing out on the full bounty that Christ offers to his children through the Church. In any case we are all brothers and sisters in Christ and we should all keep an open heart and mind towards all alternate Christian views. At the end of the day I will always know that Christ will answer anyone who calls his name.

-D
Hi Darrel,I also say Amen again I say Amen. 👍 God Bless
 
**Re: How does a Protestant repent after Baptism and after being “saved”? **

If one were to accept the antinomian OSAS theology of many Protestant Evangelicals, then this is the wrong question to ask. In OSAS soteriology, if a man is “saved”, there is NO sin that the man could commit that could possibly cause him to lose his salvation. “No sin” would certainly include the sin of being totally unrepentant for the sins that a man commits after being “saved”. OSAS soteriology renders repentance for sin as an optional behavior that is unnecessary for one’s salvation - and that is why those who believe in OSAS aren’t really concerned about the question of repentance for sin. To be sure, repentance for sin is a nice thing to do and is pleasing to God, but it is unecessary for the “saved” man to repent of his sins to enter into heaven.

It is very strange that OSAS believing Protestant Evangelicals preach that one is “saved” by accepting Jesus as their Lord and Savior, because they really only accept Jesus as their Savior. Having a relationship with Jesus as their Lord is optional if one believes in OSAS, since there is no limit at all to the rebellion and disobedience to the Lord that “saved” man can manifest in his life. The “saved” man has the assurance of salvation no matter what life he chooses to live – he is assured a place in heaven even if he chooses to live his life as a totally depraved unrepentant backslider. :rolleyes:
 
40.png
SPOKENWORD:
Hi Maggie,BUT I thought Jesus is our wonderful counsellor. :confused: God Bless
Spoken Word, I do not doubt your comment, but you are applying it in the wrong way. How can you receive face to face counselling if you are relying on a book alone.

It seems that you are being blind to the benefits that comes from that form of counselling. For example, how do you get out of your system your feelings of anger towards another person? The feelings are not sinful, but actions that stem from those feelings can be sinful. If you have no one to talk things over, then you do not adequately dismiss those feelings.

God works in mysterious ways. It is because the priest is in situ Christie that it is God who works through the priest to provide the words of solace and the counselling that might be required. I am talking from a very personal experience here and I am amazed at the fact that through a quick confession I was able to let go of something that had me feeling very angry just before Christmas.

Some people waste a lot of money going to see psychotherapists when in fact they could relieve themselves of their guilt by going to confession. God will also work through the professional therapist but not necessarily at the spiritual level, which is what is needed in order to be able to seek and give forgiveness to others.

It is God who is the Healer, and it is God who works through the doctors, psychotherapists and priests who are all involved in the ministry of healing. Some people choose a 12 step program, and sometimes that program is sufficient to help them through a crisis. However, there are times when there might be a clash of personalities and one does need to be able to discuss such matters in such a way that confidentiality is preserved. I found myself in this situation last year. Through my faith in God I was able to deal with the outcome of the situation that had arisen. Even if I did lose my temper and let fly with words of anger at two people, I know that Jesus was there at my side, ready to console me during that time of angst. During the whole of the situation I had consulted with my confessor about the matters that were bothering me. By doing that I had the confidence of being supported over what was happening to me.

Sometimes we do have to get real and recognize that we do need to go to outside sources (that is other than the Bible) for help. It is God who is the Supreme Psychologist and Wonderful Counsellor, and it is God who provides these gifts to others, through the Holy Spirit so that they can bring people to peace.

MaggieOH
 
MaggieOHQuote:
Originally Posted by SPOKENWORD
Hi Maggie,BUT I thought Jesus is our wonderful counsellor. :confused: God Bless

Spoken Word, I do not doubt your comment, but you are applying it in the wrong way. How can you receive face to face counselling if you are relying on a book alone.

It seems that you are being blind to the benefits that comes from that form of counselling. For example, how do you get out of your system your feelings of anger towards another person? The feelings are not sinful, but actions that stem from those feelings can be sinful. If you have no one to talk things over, then you do not adequately dismiss those feelings.

God works in mysterious ways. It is because the priest is in situ Christie that it is God who works through the priest to provide the words of solace and the counselling that might be required. I am talking from a very personal experience here and I am amazed at the fact that through a quick confession I was able to let go of something that had me feeling very angry just before Christmas.

Some people waste a lot of money going to see psychotherapists when in fact they could relieve themselves of their guilt by going to confession. God will also work through the professional therapist but not necessarily at the spiritual level, which is what is needed in order to be able to seek and give forgiveness to others.

It is God who is the Healer, and it is God who works through the doctors, psychotherapists and priests who are all involved in the ministry of healing. Some people choose a 12 step program, and sometimes that program is sufficient to help them through a crisis. However, there are times when there might be a clash of personalities and one does need to be able to discuss such matters in such a way that confidentiality is preserved. I found myself in this situation last year. Through my faith in God I was able to deal with the outcome of the situation that had arisen. Even if I did lose my temper and let fly with words of anger at two people, I know that Jesus was there at my side, ready to console me during that time of angst. During the whole of the situation I had consulted with my confessor about the matters that were bothering me. By doing that I had the confidence of being supported over what was happening to me.

Sometimes we do have to get real and recognize that we do need to go to outside sources (that is other than the Bible) for help. It is God who is the Supreme Psychologist and Wonderful Counsellor, and it is God who provides these gifts to others, through the Holy Spirit so that they can bring people to peace.

MaggieOH

Maggie I too can vouch for this Counselling. This has helped me in the last two times I"ve been to Confession, and even if there’s exactly not a sin to confess as such, it’s nice to chat to the priest.

Also I can tell you from my experiences that the counsellor really can’t do that much for you, in my case she was very optimistic and with a priest he is practical and can also give you lessons on the faith to help also he is very open and doesn’t judge but he knows what’s a sin and what’s not where as with a counsellor the attitude is like well it’s what everyone is doing so it must be ok type thing.

And then after confession you walk out so refreshed and happy and like things seem ten times better than they were before and it’s so wonderful to have it happen. And lets not forget that Christ sent us the Holy Spirit and with Him came the 7 sacraments, and one being Confession and the Holy Eucharist.
 
40.png
angel_crooks:
MaggieOHQuote:
Originally Posted by SPOKENWORD
Hi Maggie,BUT I thought Jesus is our wonderful counsellor. :confused: God Bless

Spoken Word, I do not doubt your comment, but you are applying it in the wrong way. How can you receive face to face counselling if you are relying on a book alone.

It seems that you are being blind to the benefits that comes from that form of counselling. For example, how do you get out of your system your feelings of anger towards another person? The feelings are not sinful, but actions that stem from those feelings can be sinful. If you have no one to talk things over, then you do not adequately dismiss those feelings.

God works in mysterious ways. It is because the priest is in situ Christie that it is God who works through the priest to provide the words of solace and the counselling that might be required. I am talking from a very personal experience here and I am amazed at the fact that through a quick confession I was able to let go of something that had me feeling very angry just before Christmas.

Some people waste a lot of money going to see psychotherapists when in fact they could relieve themselves of their guilt by going to confession. God will also work through the professional therapist but not necessarily at the spiritual level, which is what is needed in order to be able to seek and give forgiveness to others.

It is God who is the Healer, and it is God who works through the doctors, psychotherapists and priests who are all involved in the ministry of healing. Some people choose a 12 step program, and sometimes that program is sufficient to help them through a crisis. However, there are times when there might be a clash of personalities and one does need to be able to discuss such matters in such a way that confidentiality is preserved. I found myself in this situation last year. Through my faith in God I was able to deal with the outcome of the situation that had arisen. Even if I did lose my temper and let fly with words of anger at two people, I know that Jesus was there at my side, ready to console me during that time of angst. During the whole of the situation I had consulted with my confessor about the matters that were bothering me. By doing that I had the confidence of being supported over what was happening to me.

Sometimes we do have to get real and recognize that we do need to go to outside sources (that is other than the Bible) for help. It is God who is the Supreme Psychologist and Wonderful Counsellor, and it is God who provides these gifts to others, through the Holy Spirit so that they can bring people to peace.

MaggieOH

Maggie I too can vouch for this Counselling. This has helped me in the last two times I"ve been to Confession, and even if there’s exactly not a sin to confess as such, it’s nice to chat to the priest.

Also I can tell you from my experiences that the counsellor really can’t do that much for you, in my case she was very optimistic and with a priest he is practical and can also give you lessons on the faith to help also he is very open and doesn’t judge but he knows what’s a sin and what’s not where as with a counsellor the attitude is like well it’s what everyone is doing so it must be ok type thing.

And then after confession you walk out so refreshed and happy and like things seem ten times better than they were before and it’s so wonderful to have it happen. And lets not forget that Christ sent us the Holy Spirit and with Him came the 7 sacraments, and one being Confession and the Holy Eucharist.
Hi Angel,Of course God uses other people to speak to us. Now as for Me I like to approach God directly for He does speak to me when I come before Him. He is my Daddy God and He does want us to come to Him. He is my comforter. He also speaks to us through His Written Word.I think the problem with many christians is they do not LISTEN. God says be still and know that I am God. 😉 God Bless.
 
Matt16_18 said:
**Re: How does a Protestant repent after Baptism and after being “saved”? **

If one were to accept the antinomian OSAS theology of many Protestant Evangelicals, then this is the wrong question to ask.

But since very few Protestants embrace OSAS, then this is a very good question to ask.

O+
 
40.png
SPOKENWORD:
Hi Angel,Of course God uses other people to speak to us. Now as for Me I like to approach God directly for He does speak to me when I come before Him. He is my Daddy God and He does want us to come to Him. He is my comforter. He also speaks to us through His Written Word.I think the problem with many christians is they do not LISTEN. God says be still and know that I am God. 😉 God Bless.
Your right,

You mentioned earlier that the Eucharist was a mystery and that you were happy it brought me closer to God.

Are mysteries meant to be ignored or investigated? I totally agree with what you said about listening. Have you ever listened in the presence of the Eucharist?

A chapel of adoration is a nice small room that is usually quiet and a great place to pray. Why not try praying there sometime? Just go in with an open mind for a while and listen to Christ.

The thing I see repeated over and over is that non-Catholics are perfectly willing to believe A B and C then they perfectly unwilling to not investigate that which they don’t believe. (I used to do this quite often).

What do you have to loose? Surely the Lord will protect you from any false teachings. At the very least you can always say you took an open minded look and spent time with the Lord.

-D
 
40.png
Darrel:
Your right,

You mentioned earlier that the Eucharist was a mystery and that you were happy it brought me closer to God.

Are mysteries meant to be ignored or investigated? I totally agree with what you said about listening. Have you ever listened in the presence of the Eucharist?

A chapel of adoration is a nice small room that is usually quiet and a great place to pray. Why not try praying there sometime? Just go in with an open mind for a while and listen to Christ.

The thing I see repeated over and over is that non-Catholics are perfectly willing to believe A B and C then they perfectly unwilling to not investigate that which they don’t believe. (I used to do this quite often).

What do you have to loose? Surely the Lord will protect you from any false teachings. At the very least you can always say you took an open minded look and spent time with the Lord.

-D
Hi Darrel, Thank you for having a beautiful and concerning heart for me. The Eucharist is a mystery. I did leave the rcc church and that was the most difficult to let go of. I did spend time before the Blessed Sacrament and cried out to God with all my heart.Here what He told me. Why are you searching where I am not? My son do you not know that I live in you,body and soul already.I left that day with Gods peace and love in my heart. Why has God called me out? I know that answer today,but for now until He calls me back home, I will serve the Lord. God Bless
 
O.S. Luke:
But since very few Protestants embrace OSAS, then this is a very good question to ask.

O+
The Southern Baptists are the largest Protestant denomination in the USA, and the Southern Baptists confess OSAS soteriology. If one were to take all the OSAS believing Protestants in our nation as a single group, would they comprise the majority of American Protestants? I don’t know if they would, but it would not surprise me if this were true.

OSAS is a pernicious heresy that millions of Protestants cling to with all their might. OSAS is not the Gospel, it is the utter destruction of the Gospel, and many a Protestant has made a shipwreck of his faith through this heresy. 😦
 
40.png
SPOKENWORD:
Hi Darrel, Thank you for having a beautiful and concerning heart for me. The Eucharist is a mystery. I did leave the rcc church and that was the most difficult to let go of. I did spend time before the Blessed Sacrament and cried out to God with all my heart.Here what He told me. Why are you searching where I am not? My son do you not know that I live in you,body and soul already.I left that day with Gods peace and love in my heart. Why has God called me out? I know that answer today,but for now until He calls me back home, I will serve the Lord. God Bless
Interesting,

I have wondered why the Lord had waited so long before doing the exact opposite in me.

When I went before the mystery of the Eucharist I was sledge hammered by the Lord with his presence saying yes I am here and many other things regarding the Church and its validity.

I trust that the Lord will minister to both of our hearts in his own wisdom and appropriate time.

-D
 
40.png
Darrel:
Interesting,

I have wondered why the Lord had waited so long before doing the exact opposite in me.

When I went before the mystery of the Eucharist I was sledge hammered by the Lord with his presence saying yes I am here and many other things regarding the Church and its validity.

I trust that the Lord will minister to both of our hearts in his own wisdom and appropriate time.

-D
Hi Darrel, I guess God has a diffent plan for each one of us. Obidience is better than sacrafice. Let us be obidient and answer His call. Here I am Lord,do with me as you will. 😉 God Bless.
 
40.png
SPOKENWORD:
Here I am Lord (at Catholic Answers!),do with me as you will. 😉 God Bless.
I can only say He IS! And lucky you! 🙂
Your frequent presence here tells us that :
  1. Theology discussion with prot’s. bores you.
    or
  2. You are being considered by God Himself for a great favor.
    Carry on.
 
40.png
SPOKENWORD:
Hi Angel,Of course God uses other people to speak to us. Now as for Me I like to approach God directly for He does speak to me when I come before Him. He is my Daddy God and He does want us to come to Him. He is my comforter. He also speaks to us through His Written Word.I think the problem with many christians is they do not LISTEN. God says be still and know that I am God. 😉 God Bless.
This time, I agree with you. Many Christians do not LISTEN. None of us listen enough or the world’s problems would vanish, wouldn’t they?
 
40.png
Matt16_18:
The Southern Baptists are the largest Protestant denomination in the USA, and the Southern Baptists confess OSAS soteriology. If one were to take all the OSAS believing Protestants in our nation as a single group, would they comprise the majority of American Protestants? I donÍt know if they would, but it would not surprise me if this were true.

OSAS is a pernicious heresy that millions of Protestants cling to with all their might. OSAS is not the Gospel, it is the utter destruction of the Gospel, and many a Protestant has made a shipwreck of his faith through this heresy. 😦
You are correct that the Southern Baptists are the largest Protestant denomination in the USA. You are NOT correct in that all Southern Baptists confess OSAS soteriology; SB’s are at best ‘loosely’ bound by the S.B. Convention, and each church is autonomous… their views on salvation run the gamut between Calvinism and Armianism. The larger, mega-church SBC’s are more Arminian in their theology - much to the chagrin of older Southern Baptists.

I am United Methodist; it is hard for those from liturgical churches and episcopal governance to understand autonomous churches. Trust me; Southern Baptists are not of one mind about very many things.

I agree with you that OSAS is heresy, but I can assure you that OSAS is not a “majority-held” doctrine, and that its subscribers are fewer and fewer in number.

O+
 
40.png
djrakowski:
I am most certainly not left on my own as a Protestant seeking to confess my sin and turn away from it. I have an entire congregation to pray with me and provide accountability in my struggle against sin. I can ask any Christian to pray for me, as well.

Certain sins provide their own penance, as we suffer the earthly consequences of them.
You mention that you have an entire congregation to provide accountability in my struggle against sin. Could you expand on this? What is typical? It seems to me that many people try to keep their sins private or don’t openly talk about them in a repentent sort of way. Do some Protestants make their sins public or put before the congregation and “pay for it” in some way. Do they make reparation for the damage that it does to their church? I’m just wondering what is common for a Protestant. Lets say a person commits adultery. How would they repent of this sin? Privately or before their congregation or before elders?
 
40.png
WhatIf:
You mention that you have an entire congregation to provide accountability in my struggle against sin. Could you expand on this? What is typical? It seems to me that many people try to keep their sins private or don’t openly talk about them in a repentent sort of way.
Our pastor encourages us, nearly every time he preaches, that we need to confess our sins directly to the Lord and ask for strength for repentance, which is a turning away from sin and ridding yourself of the things in your life that tempt you to commit that sin. Perhaps many Protestants keep their sins to themselves out of delusion, but I know a good number of Catholics who’ve never set foot in a confessional since their first confession, and yet they go to Mass every Sunday and receive the eucharist. Neither side is any better than the other in this regard.

Confessing sins to God is hardly keeping them private. Simply because you don’t talk about them openly doesn’t make the repentance and seeking of forgiveness any less real. Indeed, Jesus is the Wonderful Counselor (Isaiah 9:6). Talking about them openly in a repentant sort of way is simply beating yourself up over things for which God has already forgiven you once you’ve turned to him with sincere humility and contrition of heart.

It is important to encourage believers to be in constant fellowship with other believers. One of the primary means of providing accountability is through small groups, in which we pray together, study the Bible and learn what it has to say about living a Christian life, confess sins to each other, and ask each other to pray for strength in resisting sin. We’re supposed to call each other out for the sinful choices we make. Obviously, you’re less likely to sin if you have someone watching you who may call you on it!
40.png
WhatIf:
Do some Protestants make their sins public or put before the congregation and “pay for it” in some way. Do they make reparation for the damage that it does to their church? I’m just wondering what is common for a Protestant. Lets say a person commits adultery. How would they repent of this sin? Privately or before their congregation or before elders?
Our sins bear their own penalty, so I don’t see the necessity of “paying for it.” When we sin, several consequences are possible:
  1. breaking fellowship with God
  2. breaking fellowship with other believers
  3. the suffering that direfctly results from the action itself
One who persists in a lifestyle of sin, knowingly and in full view of the assembly of believers, is giving evidence of a heart hardened toward God, and may not in fact be a believer.

Let me put it this way: the person who knowingly sins has already paid for it, and needn’t heap insult upon injury in the form of further paying for it with an act of penance (if he hadn’t paid for it in some way, spiritually, relationally or physically, it is hardly likely that he would seek repentance). My outward actions don’t speak to the inward condition of my heart, which could be hardened. In other words, one could easily go through the motions of public or private confession with absolutely no sincerity (which applies to all acts of piety, really). Romans 2:29 speaks to the issue of circumcision of the heart, and I think it addresses this matter rather well.

How does every sin damage the church? It may damage individuals within the church, for which we all have concern and a responsibility to hold the person accountable, but I don’t see how it damages the whole fellowship of believers.

The basic idea is this: no person can determine with absolute certainty, by evidence of penitent or other pious acts, the condition of another believer’s heart. That is between the believer and God, since He is the one who knows our hearts, thoughts, and intentions.

You also ask what is “common” for a Protestant. That’s an impossible question to answer, since there are so many views within Protestantism. In my tradition (evangelical, non-denominational Baptist), the primacy is placed on the relationship between our Lord and the believer. It is easy to trick everyday folks into believing that you’re sincere by committing pious acts, but only God knows the motivations that lead a person to those acts.

I appreciate this discussion, and the respectful manner in which you’ve conducted it, and look forward to further exchanges.

God Bless!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top