Post them links to these documents:
Are Catholics Born Again
Assurance of Salvation
Catholics have a different way of doing it. These people believe that one size fits all and that all it takes “to become a Christian” is to pray a prayer once and ask Jesus to come into your heart and “get saved”, whereas Catholics recognize that our whole Christian life is one of ongoing and ever deepening conversion. The idea that we are “saved” at some point and can never fall away is foreign to the Word of God though they have it all “mapped” out as the “way of salvation”.
I personally have to answer that with a line from one of my personal heroe’s movies when he said, “I’m sorry y’know, I don’t buy it. It’s just a little too simple and a little too neat for me”. (Mel Gibson as Martin Riggs in “Lethal Weapon”.)
The fact is that as one honestly reads the New Testament and the whole Bible one soon discovers that Christianity is not as simplistic as our n-C cousins like to advertize it to be. Of course, they tell us that we have it all wrong, but I just shake my head and walk away because what they tell me just doesn’t match up with what the early church wrote about. (Not to mention the Word of God).
If you yank a bunch of stuff outta context then you can proof text it to allege just about anything. And that is what I see them doing and have seen them do for all the over 34 years that I was one of them before I checked it all out and discovered that they are wrong and that the Catholic Church is right. They disagree…but I don’t care because I have done my homework and found that this is the truth.
In the end, it’s not all about “witnessing” to people to “get them saved”, because the Holy Spirit is the real witness that can get to someone’s heart and Jesus is the one who has provided for our salvation. All we ever do is say yes to Our Lord in all he asks us to do. We take up our crosses daily and follow Him.
A Catholic buddy of mine told me that he feels like n-C religions are like some kind of “Christianity Lite”. I laughed at first; then realized that…I agree.
Pax vobiscum,