How guilty?

  • Thread starter Thread starter OpenSource
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

OpenSource

Guest
If someone were to drink too much and was drunk without really realizing it or paying enough attention, and done something that he or she would normally not do which is grave matter, how guilty would the person be while under the non-intentional state of drunkenness?
 
I think all that really matters here is that God is both perfectly just and perfectly merciful. As I’ve grown in my faith over the years, I’ve come to realize that letting go of sin is about freeing your heart a bit more inch by inch to give more and more of your heart to God. Its a lifelong process. Repentence is letting go and handing yourself over to God’s mercy and thus fully accepting it. A lack of repentence is clinging to the sin.

As such, I just look at the qualifiers for a mortal and venial sin for trying merely to figure out if I should not go up to communion before I go to confession. I also look at it when prioritizing what sins to confess. When I’m in doubt, I don’t go to communion and even if I committed a grave sin but have reason to think I was lacking in total consent, I still feel the need to rush to confession ASAP not because I fear God’s wrath, but because I want the grace to avoid becoming attached to that sin. I look at it as a learning opportunity. I try not to worry myself about the technicalities. All I can do is educate my conscience, prayerfully examine it realize that when I go to confession I’m confessing it to the best of my knowledge. If I am to grow to examine my conscience any better than that, it is through the grace of God.
 
I think in such a situation one lacks, by means of drunkenness and in isolation from all other things, the capacity to give a fully informed and active assent to the acts that might otherwise be grave.

However, one is ALSO culpable for being so inebriated in the first place and getting that way WAS something to which a person actively consents. It really isn’t THAT possible to be so completely unaware of the effects that alcohol can produce that one becomes completely intemperate by accident.

Drunkenness could be thought of as placing oneself deliberately in the occasion of sin. Unless your drink was deliberately tampered with (and that really isn’t that common) you have to bear the responsibility of your actions.
 
Watch the Twighlight Zone episode “Dust”. Deals with this issue in a Sterlingesque manner.

Dex put it well, methinks. 👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top