How important is personality?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BadTurkey
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BadTurkey

Guest
Let’s say guy and girl have a lot in common, but the guy thinks their personalities don’t match up that well. For the sake of argument, let’s say he’s an only child, and she’s the oldest in her family, so there may be some head-butting potential. She tends to be pretty opinionated, which he finds intimidating at times. Can this pairing work?

Completely hypothetical situation, of course.
 
If the focus of their relationship is on where potential lies for failure, that’s not a good start. If there is already a control issue, what actions are being taken to resolve them? Has he told her he feels intimidated and why? What’s the response?
 
The key word in the OP is “work.” Lots of work.

Anytime a couple comes together, they bring their personalities and backgrounds to the table. They have to learn how to WORK together, to meld their personalities and become ONE after they are married.

This is easier when personalities are compatible. It becomes more difficult when personalities are contrasting. But it is possible, and often these “mixed personality relationships” can be rich and exciting and very fulfilling for both partners.

When two people have contrasting personalities, they can each help each other bring out the best characteristics of their personalities, and suppress or eliminate the undesirable characteristics. (In other words, Christian couples can help each other become more like Jesus and “get to heaven!”)

E.g., an opinionated person can be a passionate reformer, which is good. But they can also be an obnoxious loudmouth, which is bad!

But both people must be willing to allow the other person to enter into their personality and work with them. If one or both of them shuts the other out and refuses to make any changes or concessions, then the relationship is doomed.

I’m not talking about “losing a personality”–that would be a bad thing. I’m talking about losing personalitiy traits that are not desirable or that are actually sinful, and keeping personality traits that are endearing and good.

It is often difficult to open up and allow someone else into your deepest personality. All too often, couples stay on a “surface” while they are dating, and “hide” personality traits from each other. They behave like “pals” instead of a romantic couple, and everyone, including them, thinks they are getting along great.

Then they get married, and because of the nature of marriage, they become more intimate not just sexually but in their daily lives. They open doors to “rooms” in their personality that the other partner never knew existed. Often, these rooms contain things that the other partner finds repulsive or frightening or just unpleasant.

Even then, everything can be worked out, but again, it takes a lot of WORK, and many couples are unwilling to work so hard to clean out those rooms and re-do them into pleasant rooms. Many couples split up at this point.

The best thing for a dating couple to do is open the doors and let the other person SEE their hidden rooms and decide whether or not they can live with what is inside those rooms. Start the “cleaning out” of the personality rooms BEFORE the marriage. Don’t hide from each other.

I think that Catholics and other Christians especially are more prone to “hide” before marriage as they attempt to be modest with each other. Again, I’m not talking about sex here, I’m talking about personality. Before marriage, a couple should strive for “personality intimacy”–they should practice honesty and learn as much as possible about each other. They shouldn’t date under a polite veneer of good manners and light conversation. They should duke it out verbally and learn the “secrets” that the other person is trying to hide. They should begin working together BEFORE marriage on melding the personalities. If they can’t do it, better to find out before a wedding than after.

In the case of the person who is the only child, my biggest worry is whether this person can break away totally from childhood and their parents. It is a bad thing for a woman to find herself chained to a “Mama’s Boy.” Often, women who get trapped in this situation do become “opinionated”, because they are trying desperately to make their partner grow a spine and break away. I would tell any woman who is involved with a potential Mama’s Boy to break it off–it’s very difficult and will make your life a hell on earth.
 
That’s why God invented counseling.

Seriously, counseling will help each person understand the other, and develop positive ways to deal with the other person’s behaviors that are currently upsetting.
 
I agree with what Cat said - it definitely takes work! How do I know? I’m living (successfully) in your hypothetical situation - I’m the oldest of 3 (and female), and my fiance is an only child.

We have found that, in terms of personality, we are more alike than different. The same sort of things get on our nerves and we respond similarly to stress. We are both living with his parents right now, and I’m collecting some valuable data on how his relationship with his parents has influences his personality.

A better example is that of my parents. My mother is passionate and outspoken (twin, middle birth) and my father is much more reserved and analytical (oldest of 3). They’ve been married for 27 years! Their differences compliment each other.
 
When I was younger, I believed one could “work” to overcome these types of differences and “make it work.” Even when there were truly large issues/difference, etc, I would “work” to make my relationship successful.

Then came an epiphany.

I decided that “work” in the early stages of a relationship, “differences” so substantial that they were always “there” and had to be compromised, discussed, worked-at, etc, were just dealbreakers and a waste of my time.

You know you’ve found a good fit for you, a good match, when it’s easy, not hard. When **it **works, not you. When you are together and you just “fit.” When it was this way with DH, I knew it was right.

Marriage is hard work in many, many ways. It’s work every day, even when you are 100% on the same page and get along great.

And, you don’t need to pile on all these problems at the start, or even before marriage. Even when you are a great fit, and it is easy to be together, when you agree on every aspect of religion, politics, family life, work/life balance, have all kinds of things in common, and love each other deeply-- it’s **still **work. If you don’t start from having a really deep bench strength in compatibility, values, beliefs, and personality… honestly I just think you’re asking for trouble.

So, can it work? I suppose so.

Would I spend lots of time and effort trying to make it work? Heck no.
 
Then came an epiphany.

I decided that “work” in the early stages of a relationship, “differences” so substantial that they were always “there” and had to be compromised, discussed, worked-at, etc, were just dealbreakers and a waste of my time.
.
.
.
So, can it work? I suppose so.

Would I spend lots of time and effort trying to make it work? Heck no.
I think this is fairly wise.

There are pros and cons to arranged marriages. And there are pros and cons to chosing a marriage partner for oneself. One of the pros with chosing a partner for oneself is supposed to be that one picks someone who is especially compatible. Why would one want to then pick someone who, while a wonderful human being, is simply not that compatible with oneself?

It’s an unfortunate aspect of our dating society that rejecting another person as a potential mate is seen to mean that the other person is somehow deficient. But it may simply mean that the two people are not a match. Likewise, it is rather unfortunate that someone with an “unusual” personality may find that there is never going to be an “easy” match.

Since we live in a society where both men and women are capable of taking care of themselves (even if reluctantly) it seems that deliberately picking a mate with whom one’s relationship always requires much work is just plain crazy.
 
Let’s say guy and girl have a lot in common, but the guy thinks their personalities don’t match up that well. For the sake of argument, let’s say he’s an only child, and she’s the oldest in her family, so there may be some head-butting potential. She tends to be pretty opinionated, which he finds intimidating at times. Can this pairing work?

Completely hypothetical situation, of course.
The correct answer is: “I don’t know”. You can’t guess the future of a relationship from just two little things. 😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top