How is "haram", taken care of or cleansed?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Chipper
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Chipper

Guest
I may not be asking the question properly, I am trying to understand.

The word in play here is “haram”.

Here is an example of what sparks my question.

In New York, mayor Bloomberg is banning Clergy from the 9/11 memorial celebration. And He is pushing for the Mosque to be built at the same time.

The theory is that:
according to the koran if prayers of religions other than islam are offered at that spot, that spot becomes haram for building a mosque!!!

I have also heard that if a pig is buried on the site, then that site also becomes haram.

Is it true about the site becoming haram if Christian prayers are offered up that site? If this is true then how do we explain all those catholic churches being taken over and converted to mosques.

Is there a cleansing formula in place? If there is a formula then what is that formula?
 
Chipper said:
I may not be asking the question properly, I am trying to understand.

The word in play here is “haram”.

Here is an example of what sparks my question.

In New York, mayor Bloomberg is banning Clergy from the 9/11 memorial celebration. And He is pushing for the Mosque to be built at the same time.

The theory is that:
according to the koran if prayers of religions other than islam are offered at that spot, that spot becomes haram for building a mosque!!!

I have also heard that if a pig is buried on the site, then that site also becomes haram.

Is it true about the site becoming haram if Christian prayers are offered up that site? If this is true then how do we explain all those catholic churches being taken over and converted to mosques.

Is there a cleansing formula in place? If there is a formula then what is that formula?
Click to expand...
that’s not true
 
Chipper said:
I may not be asking the question properly, I am trying to understand.

The word in play here is “haram”.

Here is an example of what sparks my question.

In New York, mayor Bloomberg is banning Clergy from the 9/11 memorial celebration. And He is pushing for the Mosque to be built at the same time.

The theory is that:
according to the koran if prayers of religions other than islam are offered at that spot, that spot becomes haram for building a mosque!!!

I have also heard that if a pig is buried on the site, then that site also becomes haram.

Is it true about the site becoming haram if Christian prayers are offered up that site? If this is true then how do we explain all those catholic churches being taken over and converted to mosques.

Is there a cleansing formula in place? If there is a formula then what is that formula?
Click to expand...
There is no such teaching in Quran; people become whimsical sometimes.

Muhammad allowed Catholics/Christians to pray in the mosque built by him which is called Masjid-e-Nabwi or the “mosque of the prophet” at Medina.

Muslims can pray at any place which is not physically dirty.
 
There is no cleansing formula; there is no need of any such formula as according to Islam Muslims could pray on any piece of land which is not physically dirty.
 
ibneahmad said:
There is no cleansing formula; there is no need of any such formula as according to Islam Muslims could pray on any piece of land which is not physically dirty.
Click to expand...
Okay, so does burying a pig on the land make it “Dirty”.

What are some of the other ways that the land becomes dirty?
 
Chipper said:
Okay, so does burying a pig on the land make it “Dirty”.

What are some of the other ways that the land becomes dirty?
Click to expand...
Will the Christians hold a prayer service on a piece of land where dead cows have been buried recently? Will it be hygienic?
 
benedictus2 said:
The OP asked a few questions. To just reply “That’s not true” makes no sense.
Click to expand...
it is up to OP to provide a source for his assertion, not the responders

if it were true that prayers of another religions make a locaton unsuitable for a Moslem mosque why did they make mosques of, or build over locations, of Christian churches where they conquered, such as the Holy Sofia, not to mention Jerusalem?
 
Chipper said:
I may not be asking the question properly, I am trying to understand.

The word in play here is “haram”.

Here is an example of what sparks my question.

In New York, mayor Bloomberg is banning Clergy from the 9/11 memorial celebration. And He is pushing for the Mosque to be built at the same time.

The theory is that:
according to the koran if prayers of religions other than islam are offered at that spot, that spot becomes haram for building a mosque!!!

Thats not true

I have also heard that if a pig is buried on the site, then that site also becomes haram.
Thats not true

Is it true about the site becoming haram if Christian prayers are offered up that site? If this is true then how do we explain all those catholic churches being taken over and converted to mosques.

Its not true. May be they bought the church . But if it was me i would never buy a church … its just a bad idea . Unless they eel its a good location in the city center. I mean … i thiung its just a business decision and not really the intention of buying ‘‘churches’’.

Is there a cleansing formula in place? If there is a formula then what is that formula?

No there is no location cleansing formula
Click to expand...
Look… this is just drama made up by anti muslim self proclaimed experts. But its good you ask muslims so we can clear this up.

And frankly i dont care about building any mosque near the wtc site any way .
 
Chipper said:
Okay, so does burying a pig on the land make it “Dirty”.

What are some of the other ways that the land becomes dirty?
Click to expand...
If the land is dirty then you have to clean it. garbage collectors and stuff…I mean if you wanna make a place dirty you just throw in some garbage.
 
meedo said:
Look… this is just drama made up by anti muslim self proclaimed experts. But its good you ask muslims so we can clear this up.

And frankly i dont care about building any mosque near the wtc site any way .
Click to expand...
I agree with meedo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top