Thanks, everyone. And by the way, I’m a girl.
I know the whole thing about tendencies and attraction and being called to a chaste life. I’ve been here before and I know the whole “chaste or bust” deal. I guess I didn’t word my question right, but that’s okay. I get the rules, and the belief. I just don’t understand it. I can’t completely fathom the reasoning behind it. Thanks for trying to explain it.
I’ll admit - while I am chaste right now due to the fact that I don’t have a girlfriend, I don’t plan on staying that way forever. I understand that the homosexual behavior is a choice, but I do not understand why, if for all the wonderful things a person can do in their life, if they are homosexual and unchaste, they are put down so hard. If the “sin” of a homosexual act is something that you don’t personally understand as a sin, if you’re not going to just take peoples’ word for it, but you otherwise sin less than the average person… I just don’t get it. I mean, I have a strong relationship with God. I am very spiritual. I just feel like I am not being called to a life completely free of the “homosexual act”. I will find a single partner to stay with forever, and I’m not sorry to say that they will be a girl. I don’t understand how something that feels so natural could be shot down as “unnatural”. There are gay animals, for goodness’ sake. Nobody’s telling them to live a chaste life, or hurting them for not.
I just don’t get the reasoning. The concept is familiar to me and I’ve seen it repeated over and over here. Yes, the Church is fine with SSA. I know that.
Thank you. I’m trying to be as courteous as I can about this.
I think it was St. Anselm who said when speaking about the faith, that we should not seek understanding in order to believe, but believe in order to understand.
And remember the old Latin phrase, “Lex orandi, lex credendi.” “As we pray, so shall we believe.” In other words our belief follows our actions, in a sense. If we live right, we will gain real faith.
As Catholics, we aren’t required to understand absolutely everything. There are some things in our faith that are mysteries, such as the Trinity. However, we are called to give 100% religious assent to all of the Church’s teachings. That should come first and foremost.
That being said, homosexual acts are against the natural law. What is the natural law? The best way I think we can describe it is like this…
I have a car. It was made by Honda. The owners manual, also made by Honda, is in the glove box. It tells me, from the manufacturer’s standpoint, how to best operate my car. For example, it says I have to put unleaded gasoline in the tank.
But, what if I ignored the owner’s manual, and decided that I thought it would be better to put buttermilk in the tank next time I ran out of gas? What would happen? I’d be a pedestrian! Why? Because the manufacturer didn’t design my car to run on buttermilk!
We have a Manufacturer, too. (God.) God has given us an owners manual, the natural law. The summation of this natural law is the 10 Commandments. One of those is the 6th, Thou Shalt Not Commit Adultery. Oh, you say, “But I’m not looking to commit adultery!” True. But like our Constitution, the meaning is deeper than the surface words. We are all called, by the 6th Commandment to live chaste lives in relation to where we are in our lives. Sex is reserved only for those who are married. For Catholics, for those who are sacramentally married. Why? 'Cause God said so. How do we know? Because His Mystical Body, the Church, says so. Christ promised that the “gates of hell” would never “prevail” over His Church. That means it can never teach doctrinal error. He will prevent that from happening.
So, it’s not what we think, or what we want in life that counts. It’s what God thinks and what God wants that counts. It doesn’t matter if we don’t like it.
I think when we die and make it to heaven, it’ll all make much more sense. We’ll have a big, “OOOHHH! I never realized that in this way before. NOW it makes SO much more sense!”
Jesus never called us to be successful or “happy” in this world (at least not in the way folks in our culture believe what “happy” means, i.e., mere subjective satisfaction). He called us to be faithful to Him and His Church. We only have two worthy goals in this life: 1) the salvation of our soul and 2) the salvation of as many other souls as we can help out.
Here’s a good .mp3 talk on the Natural Law by Dr. Charles E. Rice:
alabamacatholicresources.com/Downloads/Natural_Law-1.mp3