I was a devout Lutheran and felt that close personal relationship with God. As a college student, I never lost faith, but I did lose interest for awhile. I began the conversion process after I graduated from college (Jan 2005), officially converted Easter 2006. Started to “feel” Catholic later on, and am only recently beginning to get back that “personal relationship” feeling that I had while in the Lutheran church.
I do feel that the Catholic church gives me more guidance (and thus, a greater sense of direction) in my non-religious life, while the Lutheran church stayed out of my non-religious life. At 16, I would have disliked this aspect of the Catholic church, but at 26 I am capable of admitting I need my faith to ground me and give me a sense of direction and purpose.