C
CopticChristian
Guest
Carol,My job (and my life for that matter) has kept me in contact with many mentally ill people.
I have yet to see a psychologist that does not have a psychiatrist on hand for prescription authority.
I don’t think they could function if they couldn’t prescribe their precious “Zoloft”.
It’s worse than that though. In many cases it’s not even Psychologists that are prescribing; it’s “Therapists”, people who don’t have the schooling to be able to call themselves Psychologists; or worse, the general practitioners are doping up people left and right.
When my dad died, I took my mom first to a Psychiatrist who was cruel to her; so I took her to a Therapist who put her on several meds. She acted strangely from the start and we tried to “tweak the cocktail” for 6 weeks with the willing participation of her GP. When her behavior became alarming, I took her to a Neurologist who had a fit over the prescribed meds. He went on an hour long rant against Psychologists stating that there was no way for them to have the level of understanding of the impacts of these medications let alone the intricacies of the interactions they have with all the others.
Mind you he was not in the least opposed to medication administered properly under proper supervision; he concluded that in this world both of those states are impossible to reach. I mean, just look at Michael Jackson. Even with direct, hands-on supervision, his doctors (as I understand he went through alot of them) couldn’t get things “right”.
There is no drug; there is no thing that could ever fill the void in us that is a separation from God. Sure we can numb the pain; but for me, I’d rather just fill that void with God through prayer. That is instead of applying Band-Aids to a gaping wound, I’d rather heal it.
CopticChristian, sorry to misunderstand you. Thank you for clarifying.
I have no love for the DSM IV and have mentioned somewhere William Glasser MD. He has a website somewhere. He has written “Choice Therapy” and fostered what is called “Reality Therapy”…I believe he would agree with you and you may find what he says consistent with Catholic thought, ie sin, free will…a la Aquinas…Glasser does not know that he is espousing Aquinas.
I suggest you look at CBT. This is short term therapy intended not to engage you with drugs and not intended to be long term…a forever and a day patient/client. It too is about choice and understanding that you are not your behavior.
I agree that the field of mental health has been guided by taking people out of institutions and graduating them to medications and the community model of frequent visits. Psychiatrists no longer do psychotherapy, since it has little value, and they do dispense meds. They also relegate the therapy to Social Workers and Nurses and technicians.
Psychologists administer tests and spend time listening and talking.
The problem with the mental health field unlike the practice of medicine in general is this. If you get pneumonia and you are treated…there is a SOAP method of analysis. Subjective, Objective, Analysis, Plan…in the plan the problem is often resolved and you having once had pneumonia can be cured and it is resolved.
In the mental health field once you are labeled with a DSM IV diagnosis then you may as well have the Scarlet Letter on your chest because forever and a day you are never cured and it is never resolved…it is a bad system…