How should I answer this

  • Thread starter Thread starter ElizaE
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

ElizaE

Guest
I need a little help. I am away from home. I left my catechism at home and so I cannot look up what it says about my question. I got asked many questions by a room mate that I just barely met (I am a medical student doing a rotation away and am sharing a house with a few other girls). Before we even got very well acquinted, we all went for a run and she ran with me (we are both beginner so this made sense). She said that she heard I went to church that morning and asked me where I went. I said that I went to a Mass near by. She said that she became a Christian 3 years back after being a Buddhist. Then she started asking me about the church and I answered her questions pretty easily because they were fairly basic. She then said that the way she sees it is that Jesus said (here she quoted a Bible verse) that all we really need to do is love Jesus and everything else is extra. I

I know that this question has been asked before but I have little time. She is a very nice girl and we live together without much problems. It was rather hard to talk too much because we were running and out of breath. Sorry about this e-mail but I am on call and tired. Thank you for your help.
 
scborromeo.org/ccc/index/a.htm

Here’s the index to the CCC on line for ya.

Maybe a verse for you to share with your room mate:

John 14:15 If you love me, you will keep my commandments.

Since roommate sees loving Jesus as all important and obviously cherishes Scripture, this may be intriguing for her to meditate on.
 
Hi Eliza!

I remember medical school! Actually, my husband’s time there. . .keep your running up–it’s a great escape!

I have found that our Catholic understanding of salvation and Scripture is very comprehensive.

Here are some good starting Scriptures:

Acts 16:30-31. “. . .‘Men what must I do to be saved?’ Their answer was, 'Believe in the Lord Jesus and you will be saved, and all your household.” Here, Paul and Silas tell the jailer that he must believe in the Lord Jesus to be saved. . .then, two verses later, the jailer’s household was baptized.

Acts 2:37-38. “They asked Peter and the other apostles, ‘What are we to do, brothers?’ Peter answered: 'You must reform and be baptized, each one of you, in the name of Jesus Christ, that your sins may be forgiven; then you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.” Here, Peter teaches that it is not only “belief” that is necessary, but also repentance and baptism.

Matthew 10:22. “You will be hated by all on account of me. But whoever holds out till the end will escape death.” Here, in addition to belief, repentance, and baptism, Jesus teaches that persevering to the end is necessary for salvation.

Mark 8: 34-35. “He summoned the crowd with his disciples adn said to them: ‘If a man wishes to come after me, he must deny his very self, take up his cross, and follow in my steps. Whoever would preserve his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake and the gospel’s will preserve it.’” Here, Jesus teaches that accepting his cross (suffering and self denial) is necessary for salvation.

Matthew 7:21. “None of those who cry out ‘Lord, Lord’ will enter the kingdom of God but only the one who does the will of my Father in heaven.” Here, Jesus is very clear–belief, baptism, repentance, perseverence, and carrying the cross are all necessary, but also one must do the will of the Father.

John 6:54. “He who feeds on my flesh and drinks my blood has life eternal, and I will raise him up on the last day.” Here (and all of John 6 is pertinent), Jesus teaches that recieveing and eating his flesh in the Eucharist is necessary for salvation.

Matthew 25:31-46. Without quoting it all here, Jesus is very clear in this passsage that only those who perform charitable and merciful works are accepted into the kingdom. Those who neglect such works Jesus tells: “I assure you, as often as you neglected to do it to one of these least ones, you neglected to do it to me.’ These will go off to eternal punishment and the just to eternal life.”

SOOOOO. . .Saying that you have to love Jesus for salvation is absolutely correct. However, it is not the full context of Scripture. There are MANY more citations to this effect. Just in these few verses, however, we have noted that love is indeed necessary, but hardly everything. Faith in Christ is fundamental, but true faith requires action. This is the full sense of the Catholic teaching and the full message of the gospel.

Does that help you?

In a medical school context. . .One might say passing Anatomy is necessary for becoming an MD. This is true. Anatomy is fundamental and absolutely necessary, however it is not everything. You must also take Step 1 (and Step 2, I think–am I remembering correctly?) and pass it. . .along with passing all your clinicals. . .along with a multitude of other requirements. This is kind of simplistic, I know. But I think with respect to the whole of Christian theology and Scripture, it also very simplistic to say “all you have to do is love Jesus.” Loving him requires obedience and faith! A fuller perspective of Scriptures gives a very good testament for all the “requirements” of being a Christian–baptism, repentance, Eucharist, charity, mercy, and perseverence are hardly considered “extras.”

Keep running!
 
Hey Jane Francis,

Great scriptures! You pretty much nailed it for her!

🙂 CM
 
She sounds like a disciple of the modern day gospel that makes the issue happiness, rather than righteousness. The modern day gospel being preached tells people to become Christian for reasons other than to be forgiven and to avoid the wrath to come.

Tell her that God has put aside a day in which he will judge the world in righteousness. Let her know that if she were to be judged based on the ten commandments she would be guilty and receive justice. Let her know that God, not wanting to condemn sinful humanity, became a man (Jesus) and took the punishment for our sins upon himself so we can be spared. Tell her that she must repent, foresake her sins and trust in Jesus Christ in order to be saved. Don’t forget to convey the importance of being born again. Using the law to bring about the knowledge of sin and to help people understand thier need for a savior to blot out thier sin is vital to the true gospel message.
 
40.png
ElizaE:
I need a little help. …She then said that the way she sees it is that Jesus said (here she quoted a Bible verse) that all we really need to do is love Jesus and everything else is extra…
If ALL we need to do is love Jesus, then why is the Bible more then one verse long? Why did Jesus teach us and command us to do other things? “Faith without works is dead” ring a bell? (Jas 2)

Paul Hill loved Jesus. He tried to stop abortions by terminating the life of a murderer (abortionist) to save babies.

Joseph Smith loved Jesus, he founded the Mormon cult.

Jehova Witnesses claim to love Jesus?

Jon Phelps (Baptist preacher) loves Jesus, but says I’m going to hell for being Catholic? (Go to godhatesfags.com to see how he loves Jesus - beware of crude and vulgar content)

Jack Chick?

Etc…?

Need I go on?

We must have love in all we do. (See I Cor 12 & 13) But nowhere in Sacred Scripture does it say ALL we have to do is love Jesus.

Our 3 greatest gifts are Faith, Hope and Love. Faith is everything we believe and our obeideince to it. Hope is our Hope for salvation since we can loose it and have no assurance of it. Love is how we act in everything we do. Faith in Jesus stops, hope for salvation ends, love is eternal - but love for everything and not just Jesus alone.

Here is a handy and COMPLETE Bible.

Your friend may love Jesus but she needs to read more then one verse in her Bible.

By the way, I don’t just love Jesus, I love the Holy Spirit and the Father too!😉 Sometimes our Protestant brothers and sisters ignore the Trinity.

CONTEXT is what your friend needs not a verse here and there in her Bible.

A prisoner of Christ,

JMJ
 
Wow, I didn’t know that our salvation was that simple. What happened to baptism? How about the Eucharist? “Whoever eats my body and drinks my blood will have eternal life and I will raise him up on the last day.” Wasn’t it Jesus who said those very words? Did he say love me and you will be saved? How 'bout doing good deeds/works which James was talking about?

Jesus’ teachings was more than just loving HIM. I think your friend wants to simplify things too much and end up ignoring the rest of Jesus’ and the apostle’s teaching. I’ve actually heard that theology from a protestant station before.

The bible is suppose to be taken as a whole and not be broken down into pieces. You really don’t need to have the verses or chapters memorized(although that would be nice if you did). You just have to know what Jesus and the apostles thought. Ask her a question, take for example the necessity of baptism for our salvation, and put the burden on her shoulders.

P.S.
Never be shy to say I don’t know but be sure to get back to her as soon as you get the answers to her questions. In the words our late Holy Father, I say to you “BE NOT AFRAID.” You are on Jesus’ side.😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top