D
dronald
Guest
First I want to commend you for an amazing explanation, it’s very thought provoking and not one that I will dismiss easily.You don’t come across as harsh. Again, the argument for the authority of the Church is not circular. You may not find it convincing (I would disagree) but it definitely is not circular.
The shortest answer to private interpretation of the Bible is found in the Bible itself in 2 Peter 1:20 - “But know this first of all, that no prophecy of Scripture is a matter of one’s own interpretation.” We can ask, if one cannot interpret Scripture individually, then who can? The answer is the Church b/c the Church is the pillar and foundation of the truth (1 Tim 3:15). We also see Christ established a Church (Matt 16:18), a Church to which he gives authority and the power to speak in His name (Luke 10:16). When a member of the 12 dies, we see that his place is not left vacant, but is filled with another (Act 1:26) so we know the Church continues to survive past the death of the last apostle. In fact, Christ promised that His Church would stand forever (Matt 16:18).
All of this is very important because the canon of Scripture (i.e. what books make up the Bible) is entirely based on the authority of the C. Church. We know the Gospels of Judas and Thomas are not the word of God and that the Letter to the Hebrews and Revelation are because the Church was given the power by Christ to determine such things. If the Catholic Church has the power to determine what is Scriptural and what is not, how can she lack the power to interpret Scripture?
However, I must remind you that the words held within your Bible are the same as the words within mine. Therefore Protestants accept that Catholics are a part of the one true Church, but the belief remains that so are we. Pascals wager is almost enough for me to join the CC but my conscience will just not allow it. Basically, if I’m a Catholic I’m safe and if I’m a Protestant I am also safe, because Protestants believe that both are in the same Church. Catholics however reject the belief that Protestants are in the same Church.
It’s not how Catholics interprit Scripture that matters to me, its the tradition that comes after Scripture. (Edited)