How sinful is curiosity for controversy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter YehoiakhinEx232
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

YehoiakhinEx232

Guest
I was on another online forum site, and I noticed threads being closed by moderators and people saying “what the heck is happening to this place?” and I felt a sort of pleasure over it, (for some reason, I sometimes have this, perhaps morbid fondness for chaos) and made these quick peaks at these closed threads. I didn’t necessarily get too deep into these threads, but I did check to see why they were closed. How sinful is that curiosity? What is the exact word for this kind of sin, and when does it become sinful?
 
Last edited:
Nothing wrong with intellectual curiosity. Just pray for wisdom and discernment.
 
Hmm, okay, I see how that could be a possibility. But I am not sure it is.
 
It seemed akin to participating in gossip.
Vain curiosity isn’t necessarily a sin if acted on in an impulse - perhaps unwise or lacking prudence. Participating in gossip objectively would be dissected by Aquinas somewhere in the Summa, go look it up. What was the exact definition of gossip? Perhaps not necessarily backbiting or slander, perhaps just sitting and partaking with the gossipers which is normally to be avoided.
perhaps morbid fondness for chaos
That would be against charity, taking pleasure in others wrongdoing or misguidance.
 
Last edited:
I think there is sin in Schadenfreude, taking delight in the misfortunes of others. Unlike the Germans, we English-speakers don’t have an equivalent word. I read recently, (I wish I remember where - aleteia.org maybe), that when we gossip, we side with the devil by taking pleasure in the flaws, failings, and misfortunes of others. That’s a pretty powerful concept.

If you’re getting your thrill from lurking in on online spats, deliberately feeding any internal anger or bitterness by visiting these pages, or deriving amusement from people arguing, then it may be time to visit the confessional (I gave up one such page for Lent and will possibly make that a permanent habit. 🙂 )

If you’re just lurking to learn more about a controversial issue - perhaps to form an opinion or challenge the one you already have - then I can’t see where it would be sinful.
 
If the Lord has overtaken you to the extent that your will is habitually inclined to read the sublime Catholic teachings - and you choose to make a mess of it. In that sense, it could be quite serious. Negligence can be a grave matter. Consider studying the parts of prudence (Summa Theologica, II-II, q. 48-51). When one practices all these parts, only then can the Lord say he or she was prudent. When you get a firm grasp of prudence, the other virtues are easier to pursue.
 
I’m pretty sure I didn’t judge anyone’s soul, my only concern is that when I did this, I was uncharitable in two ways: first, the people involved these threads were either people I was at odds with, or closely associated with people I was at odds with. (Again, I didn’t take that deep a look at what went on, in these threads, just why they were closed.) The second uncharitable aspect of my actions was, the people in charge of that site had made some changes I didn’t like, and so I took sort of pleasure in thinking that this was somehow a consequence for their changes.

Did I sin mortally in anyway? I’m concerned because I have made two Spiritual Communions today, I haven’t had any guilty thoughts about this, by I want to make sure.
 
I woke up to this. My angel wanted to include this I guess: The Catechism says: “To live well is nothing other than to love God with all one’s heart, with all one’s soul and with all one’s efforts; from this it comes about that love is kept whole and uncorrupted (through temperance). No misfortune can disturb it (and this is fortitude). It obeys only [God] (and this is justice), and is careful in discerning things, so as not to be surprised by deceit or trickery (and this is prudence).” (CCC 1809) “Prudence disposes the practical reason to discern, in every circumstance, our true good and to choose the right means for achieving it.” (CCC 1835) "Gregory says (Moral. xxx, 18) that “unless we first tame the enemy dwelling within us, namely our gluttonous appetite, we have not even stood up to engage in the spiritual combat.” (STh II-II, q. 148, a. 1, c.) Which speaks of why does it seem that prudence should come first when Augustine and Gregory place temperance first? Both are correct because you cannot perform virtue in isolation of the others. Prudence on a natural level has the advantage over the others if grasped. But temperance has its advantage on the supernatural level. Which shows the simple-minded can be virtuous if they prompted by preaching to perform penance. Further, one cannot do the moral virtues on a supernatural level unless they have the theological virtues of faith, hope, and charity.

Its funny, I don’t know if others on the web forum can see it. I thought about the importance of temperance and there is a cake icon by the username. Today is my 39th birthday.
 
Last edited:
I noticed the cake and I am not trying to hijack the thread by taking this occasion to say to you:
Happy birthday @hymin! 🌟🌟🌟
May your life be from now on filled with happiness and the loving presence of God!
🧚🧚🧚 May you get at least 3 wishes fulfilled!
 
I treat most is-this-a-mortal-sin questions as I do people soliciting me for medical advice - talk to your priest, talk to your doctor.

I can say that my own priest explained to me that mortal sin occurs in the context of your relationship with God. Doing wrong with the intent to sully that relationship or spite God is usually tantamount to mortal sin. Off the record, I doubt that you’ve committed one, but talk to your priest.
 
Last edited:
I’m pretty sure I didn’t judge anyone’s soul, my only concern is that when I did this, I was uncharitable in two ways: first, the people involved these threads were either people I was at odds with, or closely associated with people I was at odds with. (Again, I didn’t take that deep a look at what went on, in these threads, just why they were closed.) The second uncharitable aspect of my actions was, the people in charge of that site had made some changes I didn’t like, and so I took sort of pleasure in thinking that this was somehow a consequence for their changes.
I think forums/public discourse/opinions/thoughts/idea’s/interests shared could very well follow the same like/discourse of two people sparing (Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, and of course Saint Augustine of HIppo - maybe read his Confessions.) If we’re trying to work for the advancement of the good of the other person. What God intends: Admonishing. Of course that’s a hint of humility to take it as well. Then, seeking out forums where you have to call out fallacies in a person’s argument or opinion. Or in anything/anywhere at anytime. As long as you serve justice and charity. I think you will be alright. But do we sin along the way? Of course. We’re in an imperfect world. Hence Confession. You’re not going to get reconciled on a forum board, but through the Sacramental life and ministry of the Church.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top