How specific does one need to be in confession?

  • Thread starter Thread starter babartos
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

babartos

Guest
I’ve been to several confessions to confess things that I’m not entirely sure are sins: unwanted sexual awareness and a physical sexual reaction that I was deeply ashamed of because of the innocence of the situation. I know that consent is necessary for sin, but it’s the awareness is such a constant problem for me that I feel compelled to confess it anyway. My question is: if these are sins, do I need to describe the shameful nature of each instance of lust? I don’t mean the distinction between a fleeting thought vs. pornography vs. masturbation. I mean, do I need to state whether a lustful thought is heterosexual, homosexual, or some other perversion? Sometimes it seems my mind can find sexuality in anything that moves, even when I try to squash the thoughts as quickly as they arise. I’ve just been confessing all of these thoughts as sexual, but I’m sort of wondering if I should be more specific in confession. Is this a failure to confess fully or should the gritty details be left unsaid?

As a follow-up question, when one has unwanted sexual thoughts even in innocent situations, how far does one go to avoid temptation? If I’ve had a sexual thought about a person that I can avoid, must I cut off that relationship? If I had one once during a sweet, relatively (as far as Hollywood goes) innocent family film, must I write off that film forever? I asked my priest about this question and he told me to pray for an increase in the four cardinal virtues and that intention played an important role.

The reason I’m worried about this is because I was a rather neurotic kid growing up. If I once touched an item with dirty hands, I couldn’t just forget about it. I had to wash my hands every time I touched it again. I actually had a separate brush to use when my hair was dirty rather than clean. In trying to avoid germs, I saw them everywhere. Since I joined the Church last year, I’ve felt like I’ve become the same way about sexual sin. Being afraid to touch my own light switch was such a restrictive, miserable way to live and I don’t want to go down that path again. I want to be able to watch uplifting films with the eyes of a child and be able to give a friend a hug without improper thoughts. I want to embrace life, not spend all my time hiding from it.
 
I’ve been to several confessions to confess things that I’m not entirely sure are sins: unwanted sexual awareness and a physical sexual reaction that I was deeply ashamed of because of the innocence of the situation. I know that consent is necessary for sin, but it’s the awareness is such a constant problem for me that I feel compelled to confess it anyway. My question is: if these are sins, do I need to describe the shameful nature of each instance of lust? I don’t mean the distinction between a fleeting thought vs. pornography vs. masturbation. I mean, do I need to state whether a lustful thought is heterosexual, homosexual, or some other perversion? Sometimes it seems my mind can find sexuality in anything that moves, even when I try to squash the thoughts as quickly as they arise. I’ve just been confessing all of these thoughts as sexual, but I’m sort of wondering if I should be more specific in confession. Is this a failure to confess fully or should the gritty details be left unsaid?

As a follow-up question, when one has unwanted sexual thoughts even in innocent situations, how far does one go to avoid temptation? If I’ve had a sexual thought about a person that I can avoid, must I cut off that relationship? If I had one once during a sweet, relatively (as far as Hollywood goes) innocent family film, must I write off that film forever? I asked my priest about this question and he told me to pray for an increase in the four cardinal virtues and that intention played an important role.

The reason I’m worried about this is because I was a rather neurotic kid growing up. If I once touched an item with dirty hands, I couldn’t just forget about it. I had to wash my hands every time I touched it again. I actually had a separate brush to use when my hair was dirty rather than clean. In trying to avoid germs, I saw them everywhere. Since I joined the Church last year, I’ve felt like I’ve become the same way about sexual sin. Being afraid to touch my own light switch was such a restrictive, miserable way to live and I don’t want to go down that path again. I want to be able to watch uplifting films with the eyes of a child and be able to give a friend a hug without improper thoughts. I want to embrace life, not spend all my time hiding from it.
You can be quite general, your Confessor will ask you questions if you need to elaborate on something (this can be useful, i confessed something thinking i was excommunicated, however after my priest went further into the details, he told me what i done wasn’t a sin and i hadn’t been excommunicated), however in general this wont happen.

Also some of the things you’ve told us (unintended thoughts or awareness) don’t seem like mortal sins, due to your lack of consent, therefore they are forgiven during the penitential rite.
 
Our sexuality is very fluid when it comes to our thoughts. While most of us are oriented towards a particular attraction our thoughts can still move into other areas. So, for example, a person who is very heterosexual in orientation may find their thoughts moving around all realms of sexuality. I think that in that case confessing the sin of impure thoughts should cover it. If it moves beyond that whereby the thoughts move into some type of peculiar behavior then that probably should be mentioned. I wouldn’t beat myself up if you have sexual thoughts outside the norm. I would bet that if everyone were honest and a poll taken we would see that this is not uncommon.

The reason that sexual sin is so easy to fall into is because of our innate desire to procreate. It takes a lot of discipline to walk the straight and narrow and with thoughts it takes a whole lot of discipline. By default we would adhere to entertaining all kinds of pleasurable thoughts but we are called to a higher standard. We realize that we do not want to objectify another human being and so we must consciously direct our thoughts otherwise.

So, you are not different than almost everyone here. Even the priests who hear your confession go through the same struggles. Imagine having to say Mass right after you just let your mind wander off in this area. You can always ask your confessor what he thinks but I highly doubt that he’s going to want a blow by blow description of your sexual thoughts. That’s my two cents… teachccd
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top