How to console someone regarding Racial Discrimination?

  • Thread starter Thread starter BenRosa
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BenRosa

Guest
Greetings:

In the past, I have always found helpful advice and guidance on these various forums. So I bring another problem for the collective wisdom to comment on. In my marriage of over twenty years, I’ve not be very effective in consoling my spouse on the issue of racial discrimination. We have a bi-racial marriage, of which, I am of the majority race. We have two beautiful teenage children whom I believe, don’t experience this issue (or may not yet be aware of it).

My wife however, is constantly affected by acts of discrimination (some overt, but mostly subtle). She will often bring these situations up in conversation, but as she correctly points out, I cannot relate to. She’s right, I can’t because I’ve not experienced what she does.

So, I ask the Catholic Answers community for any and all advice/guidance on how to console her during these times when she is looking for that (but where I cannot offer help that heals).

God’s peace…Merry Christmas!
 
Since this situation involves your wife, have you asked her how she would like you to respond when she relates to you these experiences? While I in no way want to minimize her discrimination, I’m wondering if this is more a spousal communication issue vs. tackling discrimination as a whole?

I would imagine that she wouldn’t mind hearing that you love her and that race didn’t play a part in selecting her as your spouse and doesn’t play a part in your delight that she is your wife now.
She might also want confirmation in her opinion–yes you perceived the situation correctly. There is an element of discrimination in it Yes, those people come from the stone age

I’m only imaging what her desired response from you might be as I’m thinking about situations that frustrate me and how I want my husband to respond, so this might not be so useful. Again asking her would be more useful 🙂

If I’m wrong and it isn’t about communication so much as the discrimination itself, have you thought about finding a volunteer role where you can advocate on behalf of her minority status and your children’s biracial status?
 
Is she hearing these comments from family members or those within her own race? I have heard that can be a problem for African-American men or women who marry Anglos.

😦

I would try to advise her to have a very thick skin about it, try to overlook it, pray for the individuals who seem to display bigotry, and ignore everything. Don’t pay such attention to it, in other words. Every little slight one experiences in life is not due to race, it could be that person is just a jerk to everyone, you know?

🤷
 
In my job there’s a huge problem with funding vs reverse racism. If you’re a white guy you have zero chance of getting anything. You can’t run a club, you can’t get scholorships, etc.

Racism is disgusting. However, when you hear some of the “minorities” complain you’d think they’rs open and vicious persecution of hispanics, asians and african americans. When in 90% of it is perception and attitude. And a little bit of “everyone loves raymond” syndrome…the inability to accept that anyone can dislike you just because they feel like it. Well kempt person will do far more than anyone with a chip on their sholder. There is nothing wrong with growing a thick skin. There’s modern idea that we’re supposed to be apologetically who we are. It’s not true. We need to be civilized and fake it till we make it.
 
Is she hearing these comments from family members or those within her own race?
No, within our family there is no issue (or when I’m with her). These “incidents” occur with strangers of the majority race.

Let’s not dance around this issue…racism is alive in the United States. I’m just at a loss as to how to console someone I love who continually comes into contact with it.

Thank you all for your advice and suggestions.
 
I am curious as to why you have bought into the fact that you could never understand? That doesn’t sound right. I know that if someone hurts my wife I hurt just as bad if not more. And this kind of “you wouldn’t understand” attitude is concerning. I think communication is lacking here and your wife could be using a situation to try to get something that she feels is missing from your relationship.
 
No, within our family there is no issue (or when I’m with her). These “incidents” occur with strangers of the majority race.

Let’s not dance around this issue…racism is alive in the United States. I’m just at a loss as to how to console someone I love who continually comes into contact with it.

Thank you all for your advice and suggestions.
I don’t think anyone is dancing around the subject. Yes, racsim is real. However, so is bullying. In fact adult buillying I think has been seen as more in more acceptiable these days. It’s not ok.

When I’m at church in highly liberal state, I’m treated like **** because I look like a teenager attending by myself. And I use my phone for readings. Infact, I go to Lifeteen masses for the sole reason that I hate getting bumped from my seat, stared at, etc. People have told me to just go home, that I should go be a Protestant…really mean things.

There have been more threads here about people being rude because X. People who are infertile, people who have large families, people who are sick, people who are Catholic, etc. Face it, racism isn’t the problem, it’s bullies. Part of the reason the attacks happen when you’re not with her is because she has developed mindset of victim to bullies. Just calling it racism makes it seem like it should have legal ramifacations.

Perhaps councelling and material about bullies would be helpful.
 
I’m a Black female, and I’ll agree with the previous posters that yes, racism does exist. I would surmise that your wife would get the same comments from the strangers, regardless of whether or not they were aware of your biracial marriage. Your wife needs to know that it’s not her fault/her problem how other people choose to act, and that most of the time, there’s nothing she can do to change the perceptions/behaviors/actions of others, short of explaining to them that their negative racial comments are now considered unacceptable, obsolete and quite rude.

Getting a tougher skin is likely the only way to deal with such overt comments. Does your wife have any female friends/support she can relate to? They don’t necessarily have to be from her race, and especially if she has friends from the majority race you speak of, just knowing that there are more people in the world who do not share such an ignorant point of view compared to those who do can help.
 
Merry Christmas
In my marriage of over twenty years, I’ve not be very effective in consoling my spouse on the issue of racial discrimination.
She might be frustrated over how much or how little you grasp the problem.
We have two beautiful teenage children whom I believe, don’t experience this issue (or may not yet be aware of it).
Explain. Given your description of your wife’s experiences in the neighbourhood I find rather doubtful.
My wife however, is constantly affected by acts of discrimination (some overt, but mostly subtle). She will often bring these situations up in conversation, but as she correctly points out, I cannot relate to. She’s right, I can’t because I’ve not experienced what she does.
More specifically, if she brings up a problem, how do you respond to it?

How does she respond to racism?

When you’re with her, how do you respond to racism? Do you usually recognise subtle prejudice?
So, I ask the Catholic Answers community for any and all advice/guidance on how to console her during these times when she is looking for that (but where I cannot offer help that heals).
The important questions are do you understand where she’s coming from and how does she deal with discrimination?
 
I am curious as to why you have bought into the fact that you could never understand? That doesn’t sound right. I know that if someone hurts my wife I hurt just as bad if not more. And this kind of “you wouldn’t understand” attitude is concerning. I think communication is lacking here and your wife could be using a situation to try to get something that she feels is missing from your relationship.
I’ll second this. By definition, anything that affects your wife will affect you, and understand because she lives with you, and you have a share in her problems and their solutions. How she can sit there and pretend you wouldn’t understand after being married long enough to have teenagers is beyond me.

I am married to a black woman, and for awhile now, we have gone everywhere together. It’s not just to protect her, but for me to see with my own eyes what people do when they think she’s alone. I enjoy taking people out of their comfort zones.

Remind her that you are the one who lives with her. You don’t have to be a victim to understand one.
 
Unfortunately, racism is alive and well. My black and Latino friends have the hardest time simply going to the store because people follow them. My students are also black and Latino and they have a very difficult time. My biracial students have it the hardest.

Even in white communities, there is the attitude of “marry your own kind,” “I’m not racist but so many criminals are X race/I don’t like Arabs/I’m OK with profiling,” even down to nitpicking on the President’s ethnic background (it doesn’t matter that his mom’s white, if you didn’t know him, he’d be seen as a black man, not a white or biracial man). I grew up in a mostly white community, in a liberal state, and a lot of kids were like, “I could never bring someone home if they weren’t white!” In my family, that was unheard of, as my sister and I have both dated outside of our race and my very Italian dad will say things like, “Blood is meant to be mixed!”

As for all those supposed scholarships, those don’t mean a darn if the public schools in your area are dismal (to say the least) and private school is out of the question. I work with seventh graders, over 90% black, in a failing public school. All they do is standardized testing, they still have a hard time reading books or writing in paragraphs and we still have to work on times tables. Not because they’re not bright-my kids are actually very well spoken and have a lot of potential-but because their teachers over the years have failed to teach them. As for parental involvement, their parents try to be. Same parents are also working two jobs trying to put a roof over their kids’ heads. Keeping them safe and fed is a challenge enough.

So, yes, we still do have a lot of problems. On both sides. Anyone who says that we live in harmony in the U.S. is either high or dreaming.
 
Unfortunately, racism is alive and well. My black and Latino friends have the hardest time simply going to the store because people follow them. My students are also black and Latino and they have a very difficult time. My biracial students have it the hardest.

Even in white communities, there is the attitude of “marry your own kind,” “I’m not racist but so many criminals are X race/I don’t like Arabs/I’m OK with profiling,” even down to nitpicking on the President’s ethnic background (it doesn’t matter that his mom’s white, if you didn’t know him, he’d be seen as a black man, not a white or biracial man). I grew up in a mostly white community, in a liberal state, and a lot of kids were like, “I could never bring someone home if they weren’t white!” In my family, that was unheard of, as my sister and I have both dated outside of our race and my very Italian dad will say things like, “Blood is meant to be mixed!”

As for all those supposed scholarships, those don’t mean a darn if the public schools in your area are dismal (to say the least) and private school is out of the question. I work with seventh graders, over 90% black, in a failing public school. All they do is standardized testing, they still have a hard time reading books or writing in paragraphs and we still have to work on times tables. Not because they’re not bright-my kids are actually very well spoken and have a lot of potential-but because their teachers over the years have failed to teach them. As for parental involvement, their parents try to be. Same parents are also working two jobs trying to put a roof over their kids’ heads. Keeping them safe and fed is a challenge enough.

So, yes, we still do have a lot of problems. On both sides. Anyone who says that we live in harmony in the U.S. is either high or dreaming.
I agree with this 100%. Here in South Carolina, we have pathetic schools in many areas… our educational system is abysmal, and it definitely favors those with lighter skin. Schools in predominately black areas are notorious for having less resources and crummy teachers… my mom is a teacher, and she sees the district send teachers who are not doing their jobs to the ‘black’ schools. It’s disgusting, but apparently it is next to impossible to fire a teacher even when he/she is not doing their job, so the district shuffles them to a school where they think no one will notice.
 
If you don’t think the problem is a communication issue between her and you, try actively listening to her so she can vent. Tell her you are going to pray for her, ask her to pray with you about it. Ask her if there is anything you can do specifically, like maybe she just wants you to let her vent and for you to empathize with her or maybe she wants you to talk to someone about their racist comments.

If you think there may be a communication issue though maybe you should ask her about going to some christian counseling.
 
We all experienced profiling and prejudice when we were children and teenagers. Let her know that you have experienced discrimination in the past, as a child and teenager, and that you do, in fact, know what it feels like.

Of course there is a difference between thinking, “I can’t wait to grow up,” and thinking “I wish I lived in a different neighborhood,” and you can certainly acknowledge that, but the experience at the time is very much the same - you are trying to do some kind of business, and someone either openly doesn’t trust you (and possibly calls you names), or else acts like you aren’t even in the same room - or follows you around in the hope/fear that you’re about to do something illegal. It’s annoying. It makes you feel like you don’t really belong. It makes you wish you were somebody else - which is spiritually harmful.

I think you should give her the opportunity to fully express her feelings, and to vent about these situations, without downplaying it, and without making her feel like she did anything wrong. Try to bring her to a point where she can laugh at these people and not take them too seriously, so that she can get on with her day in a peaceful frame of mind.

Another thing to do would be to role play various scenarios and see what kinds of coping strategies the two of you can come up with for her to use, especially for situations that seem to repeat themselves frequently.
 
Unfortunately, racism is alive and well. My black and Latino friends have the hardest time simply going to the store because people follow them. My students are also black and Latino and they have a very difficult time. My biracial students have it the hardest.

Even in white communities, there is the attitude of “marry your own kind,” “I’m not racist but so many criminals are X race/I don’t like Arabs/I’m OK with profiling,” even down to nitpicking on the President’s ethnic background (it doesn’t matter that his mom’s white, if you didn’t know him, he’d be seen as a black man, not a white or biracial man). I grew up in a mostly white community, in a liberal state, and a lot of kids were like, “I could never bring someone home if they weren’t white!” In my family, that was unheard of, as my sister and I have both dated outside of our race and my very Italian dad will say things like, “Blood is meant to be mixed!”

As for all those supposed scholarships, those don’t mean a darn if the public schools in your area are dismal (to say the least) and private school is out of the question. I work with seventh graders, over 90% black, in a failing public school. All they do is standardized testing, they still have a hard time reading books or writing in paragraphs and we still have to work on times tables. Not because they’re not bright-my kids are actually very well spoken and have a lot of potential-but because their teachers over the years have failed to teach them. As for parental involvement, their parents try to be. Same parents are also working two jobs trying to put a roof over their kids’ heads. Keeping them safe and fed is a challenge enough.

So, yes, we still do have a lot of problems. On both sides. Anyone who says that we live in harmony in the U.S. is either high or dreaming.
That is so very sad. Thank you for sharing that and being so honest about things.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top