S
seeker_of_God
Guest
I have a friend who, every time he sees me, keeps trying to sway me away from Catholicism. He is a Baptist.
I find it challenging because I’m very new to the faith, and though I’m confident the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, my foundation is still weak until I learn more, which I have been working on.
We had this 30-minute conversation today, and though I thought I did decently, I had to eventually ask him not to try to sway me, as I’m confident the Church is right, but my foundation of knowledge is still a bit weak.
He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years. I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.
He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible.
His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.
I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.
He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell.
This is the first time I’ve had to defend myself, and I didn’t appreciate him trying to do this, but I’d appreciate any comments about the above, or further explanation. Also, whether I should try to avoid (which I already do) such need to defend myself, and how I can do so. I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.
There’s no chance of me falling out of faith, because honestly I think if the Catholic Church isn’t true, no other church is true, either, but I definitely believe the Bible is true, therefore I believe the Church is true. I just want to understand these things better, both for myself and if I should ever need to defend myself again.
I find it challenging because I’m very new to the faith, and though I’m confident the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, my foundation is still weak until I learn more, which I have been working on.
We had this 30-minute conversation today, and though I thought I did decently, I had to eventually ask him not to try to sway me, as I’m confident the Church is right, but my foundation of knowledge is still a bit weak.
He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years. I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.
He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible.
His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.
I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.
He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell.
This is the first time I’ve had to defend myself, and I didn’t appreciate him trying to do this, but I’d appreciate any comments about the above, or further explanation. Also, whether I should try to avoid (which I already do) such need to defend myself, and how I can do so. I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.
There’s no chance of me falling out of faith, because honestly I think if the Catholic Church isn’t true, no other church is true, either, but I definitely believe the Bible is true, therefore I believe the Church is true. I just want to understand these things better, both for myself and if I should ever need to defend myself again.