How to defend myself on these points?

  • Thread starter Thread starter seeker_of_God
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

seeker_of_God

Guest
I have a friend who, every time he sees me, keeps trying to sway me away from Catholicism. He is a Baptist.

I find it challenging because I’m very new to the faith, and though I’m confident the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, my foundation is still weak until I learn more, which I have been working on.

We had this 30-minute conversation today, and though I thought I did decently, I had to eventually ask him not to try to sway me, as I’m confident the Church is right, but my foundation of knowledge is still a bit weak.

He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years. I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.

He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible. :confused:

His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.

I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.

He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell.

This is the first time I’ve had to defend myself, and I didn’t appreciate him trying to do this, but I’d appreciate any comments about the above, or further explanation. Also, whether I should try to avoid (which I already do) such need to defend myself, and how I can do so. I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.

There’s no chance of me falling out of faith, because honestly I think if the Catholic Church isn’t true, no other church is true, either, but I definitely believe the Bible is true, therefore I believe the Church is true. I just want to understand these things better, both for myself and if I should ever need to defend myself again.
 
I have a friend who, every time he sees me, keeps trying to sway me away from Catholicism. He is a Baptist.

I find it challenging because I’m very new to the faith, and though I’m confident the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, my foundation is still weak until I learn more, which I have been working on.

We had this 30-minute conversation today, and though I thought I did decently, I had to eventually ask him not to try to sway me, as I’m confident the Church is right, but my foundation of knowledge is still a bit weak.

He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years. I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.

He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible. :confused:

His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.

I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.

He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell.

This is the first time I’ve had to defend myself, and I didn’t appreciate him trying to do this, but I’d appreciate any comments about the above, or further explanation. Also, whether I should try to avoid (which I already do) such need to defend myself, and how I can do so. I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.

There’s no chance of me falling out of faith, because honestly I think if the Catholic Church isn’t true, no other church is true, either, but I definitely believe the Bible is true, therefore I believe the Church is true. I just want to understand these things better, both for myself and if I should ever need to defend myself again.
That’s a lot of stuff to hit at but none of it is new. I would suggest reading alot of the tracts in the Catholic Answers library. catholic.com/library/faith_tracts.asp They can answer most of these questions pretty easily. Even print some of them out to bring with you next time. A good book to have would be “The One Minute Apologist” by Dave Armstrong.
 
"He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible. :confused:

His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.

I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.

He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell."

Ok, I don’t know if I quoted you right.
I, too, was once weak when defending myself. After exploring this forum, however, I can provide these links for your defense:

Tradition:
catholic.com/library/Scripture_and_Tradition.asp

Mary:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=214212
catholic.com/library/immaculate_conception_and_assum.asp
catholic.com/thisrock/1998/9812fea2.asp
catholic.com/library/Mary_Ever_Virgin.asp
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=244369
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=276109

Papacy:
ewtn.com/library/ANSWERS/PRIMPOPE.htm
ewtn.com/faith/teachings/papab2.htm (continued from the first link)
catholic.com/library/church_papacy.asp
catholic.com/library/peter_and_the_papacy.asp

If you search on this forum, you will find all the answers you need.
Good luck!
Keep us posted, please.
 
Hi seeker of God!

About the corrupt priests, tell him that in Paul’s time, there are corrupt Christians, too. Look at these verses:

"For there are many unruly and vain
talkers and deceivers, specially they
of the circumcision:"


"Whose mouths must be stopped, who
subvert whole houses, teaching things
which they ought not, for filthy lucre’s sake.

"One of themselves, even a prophet of
their own, said, The Cretians are always
liars, evil beasts, slow bellies.

“This witness is true.** Wherefore rebuke them
sharply, that they may be sound in the faith;”**
(Titus 1:10-13, emphasis mine)

Paul is exhorting Titus to rebuke those persons who are unruly and vain talkers. Point to him these verses which is the proof that even early Christianity has these problems. In other words, corrupt priest doesn’t represent Catholicism, nor can affect the validity of the Church at all. One must fight these evils inside the Church as Paul did. Take note, if your Baptist friend reacts and says they are not Christians, then make him explain verse thirteen that says “they may be sound in the faith”. What faith is Paul talking about? Isn’t it not the Christian faith?

St James also has the same problem with the Church.

"Ye adulterers and adulteresses, know ye
not that the friendship of the world is enmity
with God? whosoever therefore** will be a friend
of the world is the enemy of God.**
(James 4:4, emphasis mine)

James was writing here to every Christian, yet he call them “adulterers and adulteresses.” There are even these problems in the early church. Don’t make your friend think that in the Catholic Church all these evil things are acceptable. Emphazise him that there is no way that evil members can take away the veracity of the Catholic Church.

The Word in John 1:1 is Christ, not the Bible. The word of God in the Bible is God’s language and instructions to us, yet the Word in John is Christ Himself, a person. That is very obvious because in the following passages after that the third person pronoun “he” (and not “it”) is used. Read Revelations 19:13 to let him understand.

A man doesn’t need to get in trouble to have a Saviour. In life, we had pre-savior’s and post-saviors. Example, you can save me from falling into a mud-pit when you see that I was walking unconsciously and seeing that I was about to fall into a mud-pit you’ll cry “Stop” and I regain my senses and see “Whoa! Thank you for saving me from the mud”. That is my savior before I got into trouble. On the other hand, you can save my by getting into the mud-pit itself, and suddenly it became a quicksand, and I am being sucked in. You can pull me from it and I’ll say “Thank you for saving me from the mud”. These are examples of Saviors in different conditions.

If your friend demanded from the Bible the proof of a “pre-savior”, cite to him the donkey of Balaam in Numbers 22, whom had saved his life. Cite also the angels that saved Lot’s life, Make him understand that God has a pre-saving and a post-saving nature, according to what the Bible says:

"But you will not go out in haste,
Nor will you go as fugitives;
For the LORD will go before you,
And the God of Israel will be your rear guard."

(ISaiah 52:12, emphasis mine)

That means, if God is before you, He can save you from the approaching dangers. And on the other hand, if he is your rear guard, he can pull you out from danger when it strikes you. That is also understandable in Psalm 91’s verses. (read that) That is the concept of Mary’s salvation. She was saved by God beforehand from the curse of original sin.

More…
 
I have a friend who, every time he sees me, keeps trying to sway me away from Catholicism. He is a Baptist.

I find it challenging because I’m very new to the faith, and though I’m confident the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, my foundation is still weak until I learn more, which I have been working on.

We had this 30-minute conversation today, and though I thought I did decently, I had to eventually ask him not to try to sway me, as I’m confident the Church is right, but my foundation of knowledge is still a bit weak.

He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years. I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.
You know, I will try to respond to some of this because I am sick of watching the election coverage.

Having corrupt priests means nothing and you’re right in what you said. As to the Church,

“…the household of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and bulwark of the truth.” 1 Timothy 3:15

Ask him how the “church of the living God” can be the pillar of truth if protestants can’t agree on such central things as salvation (for example Baptists think “once saved, always saved” while Methodists, Wesleyans, Nazarenes, etc do not).
He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible. :confused:
You’re not the one confused. 😃 The Word became flesh not paper. He is making a common mistake to assume “The Word” means the written word. Ask him why Scripture itself says to follow tradition.

“So then, brethren, stand firm and hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth or by letter.” 2 Thessalonians 2:15
His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.
Check out socrates58.blogspot.com/2007/03/all-have-sinned-mary.html which can give you a little ammunition for the “sinfull” Mary.
I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.
He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell.
I would tell him that what his Aunt told him was a misunderstanding of Catholic teaching. Break out your Catechism and actually have him read this straight from the horse’s mouth,
  • In fact, “in this one and only Church of God from its very beginnings there arose certain rifts, which the Apostle strongly censures as damnable. But in subsequent centuries much more serious dissensions appeared and large communities became separated from full communion with the Catholic Church—for which, often enough, men of both sides were to blame.” The ruptures that wound the unity of Christ’s Body—here we must distinguish heresy, apostasy, and schism—do not occur without human sin:
Where there are sins, there are also divisions, schisms, heresies, and disputes. Where there is virtue, however, there also are harmony and unity, from which arise the one heart and one soul of all believers.

"However, one cannot charge with the sin of the separation those who at present are born into these communities [that resulted from such separation] and in them are brought up in the faith of Christ, and the Catholic Church accepts them with respect and affection as brothers . . . . All who have been justified by faith in Baptism are incorporated into Christ; they therefore have a right to be called Christians, and with good reason are accepted as brothers in the Lord by the children of the Catholic Church. (Catechism, sects. 817-18)*
This is the first time I’ve had to defend myself, and I didn’t appreciate him trying to do this, but I’d appreciate any comments about the above, or further explanation. Also, whether I should try to avoid (which I already do) such need to defend myself, and how I can do so. I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.
There’s no chance of me falling out of faith, because honestly I think if the Catholic Church isn’t true, no other church is true, either, but I definitely believe the Bible is true, therefore I believe the Church is true. I just want to understand these things better, both for myself and if I should ever need to defend myself again.
It sounds like you did pretty good for your first time. I would try to memorize a few Scripture verses to explain the most common objections or just print out a few tracts and stick them in your Bible. If you are ever asked a question you don’t know the answer to, admit it and tell them you will get back to them (and make sure you get back to them). And sometimes people are just so stuck in their religious groove that they will not listen to a reasonable explaination, so you may have to just agree to disagree.
 
Baptist are not so historical, though sometimes they may use history to attack the Church (and even more vague history to prove that their church is real by using a “trail” of heretical groups that they can use as stepping stones to the time of Christ). That’s why they don’t accept and listen when it comes to who authorized the canonization of the Bible. Who compiled it? They don’t want to hear these arguments. They just wanted to believe the Bible as it has been.

Believing in the Bible alone entails many criticisms. One, if they believe the Bible that they had now, they must also believe the institution that first compiled it. This is important for since 1945 there had been some discoveries of old ancient papyri in Nag Hammadi in Egypt. It is the gospel of St. Thomas. This gospel was declared heretical by the Vatican, but if you look at it from it new teachings can be taken, including the teaching that there is no such thing as an institutionalized church (like the catholic Church), but a church inside souls, a personal relationship with God. That teaching is what Baptist’s adhere. But why do Baptists never accept it? Furthermore, the recent Gospel of Judas is more clearer and can be understood in the context of our original Bible. Judas’ role in that gospel is salvific, the instrument that enable to lead Jesus to the cross. With all these manuscripts, why still many stick to their own Bible? If they can believe a mere book, they can believe others especially those with ancient origins. Do they really believe the Bible, or do they trust more the institution that really tested its authenticity and soundness?

more…
 
“How to defend myself on these points?”

The best thing to do is…
  • Continue to learn your faith.
  • Pray for your friend.
  • Take this as an opportunity for growth in your faith.
You are going to face many challenges in your journey, the only thing you have control over is how you react.So with that in mind…
  • Control your breathing.
  • Remain calm.
  • Speak slow.
  • Use a pleasant tone.
  • Try to control you emotions.
  • Focus on those subjects you know, one at a time.
  • Explain that you will find out “why” and get back to him when you know the answer.
Other then that? Pray for yourself and read Scripture. Where I work when I was learning there were many who attacked our faith. It was hard to deal with. I tried to avoid those who were less then respectful but it was like God wanted me to get angry enough to care enough to find out all the “whys”. So following all my own advice above I learned alot and I’m alot more secure about answering questions.There is a reason for everything.

I look at people like your friend like teenagers who have no respect but still need the answers. So with love in my heart for all of His children I make an attempt to teach those who ask.

Also remember to tell your friend that Jesus picked 12 regular sinful men as Apostles. One betrayed Him and the rest left Him. There has been scandle in the Church from the begining.
 
Hi

as if you didn’t have enough links to follow - try here

Biblical evidence for Catholicism well over 150 papers on defense of the Faith using Scripture. Also a Dave Armstrong site, but it’s all free 😃

Hope this helps

Peace

John
 
Regarding your friend’s claim that the Church is just “the members in it”, that is true, but let him understand that members do not really last in the Church, unlike what he believes (Baptists believe in the ONCE-SAVED ALWAYS SAVED thing, which can mean that once you were a part of the church you cannot separate from it) . Let him understand that God can cut off unruly members from the Church, because it is not the branches that supports the roots, but the roots that supports the bramches.

Understand what St Paul is saying beneath:
Code:
"If the first piece of dough is holy,
the lump is also; and if the root is holy,
the branches are too.

"But if some of the branches were broken off,
and you, being a wild olive, were grafted
in among them and became partaker wit
h them of the rich root of the olive tree,

"do not be arrogant toward the branches;
but if you are arrogant, **remember that
it is not you who supports the root, but
the root supports you.
**
"You will say then, “Branches were broken
off so that I might be grafted in.”

"Quite right, they were broken off for their
unbelief,** but you stand by your faith.
Do not be conceited, but fear;

"for if God did not spare the natural branches,
He will not spare you, either.
**
"Behold then the kindness and severity of
God; to those who fell, severity,** but to you,
God’s kindness, if you continue in His
kindness; otherwise you also will be cut off.
**
"And they also, if they do not continue in
their unbelief, will be grafted in, for God is
able to graft them in again.

"For if you were cut off from what is by nature
a wild olive tree, and were grafted contrary
to nature into a cultivated olive tree, how
much more will these who are the natural
branches be grafted into their own olive tree?

(Romans 11:16-24, emphasis mine)
 
Wow, thanks so much, everyone! All the posts here are really great.

I’m amazed by all the scripture quotes. How does everyone remember the references to these scriptures? I don’t mean memorizing them, but for instance I know that to talk about the institution of the Church, go to Matthew 16:18-19, but people seem to know of so many more for so many different issues.

Gookykookypig, I really like those verses from Romans 11. 😃 Thanks for your excellent explanation of many of those points.

I forgot ot mention, his problem with baptism. He brought up that Jesus said that all should believe and be baptized, and emphasizes that the believing comes first, before the baptism. Obviously, he is against infant baptism. I don’t have any answer for this, except that the Bible never says when to baptize.

fellowChristian, thanks for those pointers .I’m learning a lot, but it’s a process, and I’m not completely settled in yet. I’ve learned so much just by reading these forums though. I guess it’s been a month already since I joined here.

Ukfan, thanks so much for that verse. I was trying to say something like that, but didn’t have a specific verse to back me up. I said there surely must be one true Church, and I think it’s much more likely to be the one started by Jesus Himself, rather than one of the 30,000 Protestant denominations that have broken off in the last 400 years, many of which are a splinter of a splinter of a splinter … of the Catholic Church.

Yeah, I have no idea how he tied the Word into the Bible. He knew what the Word meant, but somehow still made that connection.

Yes, I told him his aunt was in error regarding that issue, and that only God can judge. He kept saying that I believed only Protestants weren’t sure about their salvation if the Catholic Church is right, and I said no, no one can be sure, but Catholics have a better chance because we have all of the resources of the Church, including reconciliation and the other sacraments, at our disposal to come closer to God. I reminded him the Bible says to work out our salvation with fear and trembling, though I couldn’t remember which verse it was, but he didn’t deny that. His response to that didn’t really make any sense.

To everyone else, thanks for the links. I will work through them soon.
 
I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.
Remember that The Church isn’t all on Earth actually,
there’s the CHURCH MILITANT: Earth,
the CHURCH SUFFERING: Purgatory,
and the CHURCH TRIUMPHANT: Heaven.

So he’s wrong,
if he was speaking about those on Earth as being the only existing members.
 
He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years…
Of course there is something to say to that. Baptist preachers aren’t perfect either. There have been LOTS of scandals among Protestant leaders. If the sins of one in authority is enough to discredit the whole church, he’d better put on his running shoes. He’ll never find a true church using that line of reasoning.
He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. … :confused:
He is the confused one. Without the Church’s Sacred Tradition, he wouldn’t have a BIble. It wasn’t written as Jesus spoke. It was the Church which decided which books to include in the canon of scripture, and it was not codified until the 3rd (4th?) century. These decisions were reached by considering each book based on how well it’s contents fit with the Tradition passed down by the Apostles, whether or not the claimed authorship was likely to be authentic, how closely it was written to the living memory of Christ and the Apostles, and how well it pertained to those things believed necessary to salvation. Paul himself cautions new believers in his letters to compare any new doctrine they are taught to the scriptures (the OT, which was all they had at the time) and the teachings he and the other Apostles gave them (Tradition) in order to be sure of their authenticity.
His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.
How sad-- they want their Jesus without Mary (impossible, for it was she that gave Him human flesh) and their salvation without the crucifixion (also impossible, for it was His death that makes the Ressurection such a glorious miracle). Think about it-- would you continue to call a friend a friend if he dissed your mother? Remember, we don’t worship Mary, but revere her as the Mother of God. This she clearly is, for Jesus is God, and Mary is His mother. Part of the problem here is that the Baptists are largely convinced we worship her as equal to Christ. This is not so, but we do recognize and celebrate her special role in bearing the Christ child, a role she was specially chosen for from the beginning of time.
I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.
Actually, all baptized Chirstians are to some degree a part of the Church, whether they recognize that fact or not. The disunity is created by the very same sin that caused the need for baptism into Christ’s salvation to begin with: disobedience. People found it hard to keep to Church doctrine, and therefore they branched off. SInce the first thing they rejected was the authority of the magisterium, there suddenly was no authority, so it split, and split, and split, ad nauseum based on varying personal opinions. Despite all this, we still have more in common with most Protestants than we have differences. Having been baptized, they are part of the body of Christ, though obviously they are not in perfect union with the Church. But it is clear in the scripture, that this continued fracturing is not what Christ intended. Surely the Holy Spirit, part of the Holy Trinity and the same yesterday, today, and forever, has not led all these people all these different directions. Any intelligent person should be able to see that. And the one Church that has stood from the beginning is?
He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic…
This was a common teaching in his aunt’s day, but it is a misunderstanding of Church doctrine. The doctrine stated that there is no salvation outside the Church. This remains so. However, it is more a commentary on the mystery of salvation and the Church, not on who can or will be saved. Salvation was revealed through Jesus, His saving act, and the Church He founded through the Apostles, to whom He gave His authority. Catholic belief allows for people to be ignorant or in error but still attain salvation. The question then is, if your friend knew that the Church is as it was intended by Christ and that it is His will that all be joined to her, would he still reject the Church? If so, he’s lost. If he’d be willing to swallow his pride and bend to God’s will, he may be saved. In other words, his aunt was espousing a misunderstanding of doctrine, not Church teaching. This means, essentially, that he has a personal problem with his aunt, not a problem with the Church. How sad that he can’t see the difference.
 
I have a friend who, every time he sees me, keeps trying to sway me away from Catholicism. He is a Baptist.

I find it challenging because I’m very new to the faith, and though I’m confident the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, my foundation is still weak until I learn more, which I have been working on.

We had this 30-minute conversation today, and though I thought I did decently, I had to eventually ask him not to try to sway me, as I’m confident the Church is right, but my foundation of knowledge is still a bit weak.

He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years. I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.
First of all, ask him to show you where scripture says this. He won’t be able to, because nowhere does scripture say the church is “just all of the individuals within it.”

Besides, the Church has to be more than “just all of the individuals within it” since scripture says the Church is the Body of Christ. See Colossians 1:24.
He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible. :confused:

His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.

I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.

He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell.

This is the first time I’ve had to defend myself, and I didn’t appreciate him trying to do this, but I’d appreciate any comments about the above, or further explanation. Also, whether I should try to avoid (which I already do) such need to defend myself, and how I can do so. I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.

There’s no chance of me falling out of faith, because honestly I think if the Catholic Church isn’t true, no other church is true, either, but I definitely believe the Bible is true, therefore I believe the Church is true. I just want to understand these things better, both for myself and if I should ever need to defend myself again.
I ***highly ***recommend you visit The Bible Christian Society at:
biblechristiansociety.com/download and check out the free downloads, especially the one entitled “Apologetics for the Scripturally Challenged.” Despite its title, this talk is mostly about *strategy *when engaging non-Catholics in discussion, which seems to be what you’re having the most trouble with. You can get this talk, and all the others there (which cover the other topics your friend wants to discuss) in either free MP3 downloads or as free CDs or cassettes.

Hope this helps!
 
I forgot ot mention, his problem with baptism. He brought up that Jesus said that all should believe and be baptized, and emphasizes that the believing comes first, before the baptism. Obviously, he is against infant baptism. I don’t have any answer for this, except that the Bible never says when to baptize.
We baptize infants based on the faith of their parents. The Jews were told by God to circumcise all males on the 8th day after birth. This brought them into the covenant. It was never questioned whether they should choose for themselves. It was done becasue of their parents’ faith, and in the process, the parents accept the responsibility to raise their children in the covenant and teach them the faith. As Catholic parents, we are called to do the same. Because we believe that the sacrament imparts special graces to the child to assist him on his journey in Christian faith, and because we believe in the need for cleansing of original sin, we baptize our infants. IT is precisely becuse we take Christ at His word, that the sacraments we celebrate actaully accomplish that which they physically symbolize (cleansing from sin and death & ressurection with Christ, in the case of baptism) that we insist on baptizing our children as early as possible. It would not be prudent to risk their salvation by depriving them of this cleansing and sacramental grace.

There are many Protestant sects that agree with your friend, that it is a personal decision, but from the beginning this was not so. In The Acts of the Apostles, whole families, including children (obviously some would have been too young to express personal faith), were brought into the fold through baptism. Many Protestant churches, including the Lutherans, Episcopal, Methodist, and Disciples of Christ, also baptize babies.

As Christian parents, we are called to raise our children in the faith. That begins with the sacraments and living as an example while teaching them as they grow the truths of our faith. Though there is only inferential support for the Catholic practice in Scripture, there is no more support for the Baptist take on it either. Since this was traditionally done in the Church from the time of the early Church fathers and not questioned until the Reformation in the 16th century, I tend to think that it is more likely that the Catholic Church has the more authentic interpretation.

Though this concept of having a personal relationship with Jesus Christ that is so harped on by many Protestants is important, this is not the beginning and end of Christian faith. You would be hard put to find any saint in the Church’s history that did not see their relationship with God as personal. However, it is also important that we remember our place–God is God, and we are not. This means we are also called to obedience, even when we don’t entirely understand. This part of the relationship is skipped over by many because it is entirely uncomfortable for us to recognize that in the scheme of things, each of us is no more significant than a single grain of sand, and the Kingdom of God is NOT a democracy.

The miracle of this is that He cares for us so much that He knows every individual hair on our heads! Jesus loves us so entirely and unconditionally, that despite our continual rejection of Him through sin, He readily laid down His own life for our sake. He who is God, gave nothing less than Himself for His creatures. All He asks of us is to keep His commandments. If we refuse to be joined to the Church He founded over petty squabbles regarding the interpretation of scripture, what does that say about our willingness to be obedient to Him?
 
I have a friend who, every time he sees me, keeps trying to sway me away from Catholicism. He is a Baptist.

I find it challenging because I’m very new to the faith, and though I’m confident the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, my foundation is still weak until I learn more, which I have been working on.

We had this 30-minute conversation today, and though I thought I did decently, I had to eventually ask him not to try to sway me, as I’m confident the Church is right, but my foundation of knowledge is still a bit weak.

He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years. I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.

He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible. :confused:

His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.

I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.

He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell.

This is the first time I’ve had to defend myself, and I didn’t appreciate him trying to do this, but I’d appreciate any comments about the above, or further explanation. Also, whether I should try to avoid (which I already do) such need to defend myself, and how I can do so. I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.

There’s no chance of me falling out of faith, because honestly I think if the Catholic Church isn’t true, no other church is true, either, but I definitely believe the Bible is true, therefore I believe the Church is true. I just want to understand these things better, both for myself and if I should ever need to defend myself again.
I think that you may need to find new friends.I know that if if I had a friend who tried to get me to change my faith or attacked Catholicism,the very core of my being every time he saw me,I would not grace his company with mine very often.I suggest you tell this friend in no uncertain terms to BACK OFF and demonstrate some respect for your Faith and your personal choices regarding it.Advise him that if he feels so strongly about it,to pray for your soul,that you’ll pray for his and everyone will win.But start by standing up on your hind feet and letting him know that you will not tolerate further insult to your Faith.I wonder if simply being in his presence is a near occasion of sin.
 
seeker of God;:
He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years.
Pure, irrelevant speculation and unsupported claims.
he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it.
And what is his point? Are not there different members with different gifts? How does the fact that the Church is “just all of the individuals within it” argue for or against Catholicism? It doesnt at all.
He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition.
That belief IS a tradition! 😉 I’d point that out for starters. Even worse for his position, the Bible is a Tradition. No where is there a table of contents for the Bible. Nowhere does a single OT book tell us there will be a NT. None of the NT identifies what we have as Scripture. In short, there was no Bible until the Catholic Church established the canon back at the councils of Hippo (4th century), Carthage and Trent (15th Century). If he choses to reject that Tradition then simply stop listening to his alleged biblical claims and ask him, “By what authority do you claim the Bible to be the Word of God?” The truth is that someone told him that the Bible is the word of God…thats a tradition.
somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible. :confused:
Again, there is no such thing as the Bible in the Apostolic era. He is grasping at straws because his theology requires it in order to justify itself. Jesus is the Word of God.
His biggest problem was with Mary.
I wouldnt go there - just stick to “by what authority do you accept the book in your hand as the Bible?”
He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.
This discussion will not go far - the Bible is vague on what, exactly, constitutes the Church because the Bible was never meant to stand on its own. The Church is the “body of Christ” the Church is the “pillar and foundation of truth” as well. Notice it is the Church which is the pillar and foundation of truth - not the Bible.
He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic.
Simply let him know you dont really care about his aunt or her views or his anger issues with her. Its totally irrelevent.
I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.
Do some reading. Check out the Library section at the very top of this page and check out the “tracts” in the drop down menu.
Catholicism and Fundamentalism by Karl Keating is a good read to get a taste of some of the issues from a purely apologetics standpoint. Born Fundamentalist, Born Again Catholic by David Curry (convert) is a shorter, less hostile read which is also excellent.
 
I think that you may need to find new friends.I know that if if I had a friend who tried to get me to change my faith or attacked Catholicism,the very core of my being every time he saw me,I would not grace his company with mine very often.I suggest you tell this friend in no uncertain terms to BACK OFF and demonstrate some respect for your Faith and your personal choices regarding it.Advise him that if he feels so strongly about it,to pray for your soul,that you’ll pray for his and everyone will win.But start by standing up on your hind feet and letting him know that you will not tolerate further insult to your Faith.I wonder if simply being in his presence is a near occasion of sin.
It may be so. We’re in the same fraternity so it’s a bit difficult.

It makes me angry how much disrespect people have for other’s faith. Another person that I know, today disrespected Jesus, referring to certain sexual terms, and then calling Him gay. I was shocked and ended up just walking away. I could tell that he wanted me to be provoked, as then he was talking about how he worships the devil.

I ask myself what jesus would do in such situations, as I don’t know how to react. I try to keep my anger at bay.
 
It may be so. We’re in the same fraternity so it’s a bit difficult.

It makes me angry how much disrespect people have for other’s faith. Another person that I know, today disrespected Jesus, referring to certain sexual terms, and then calling Him gay. I was shocked and ended up just walking away. I could tell that he wanted me to be provoked, as then he was talking about how he worships the devil.

I ask myself what jesus would do in such situations, as I don’t know how to react. I try to keep my anger at bay.
Get your WEAPON-the rosary and PRAY for them.Remember you are in the BEST company.The world reviled Christ and it reviles YOU.Don’t take it personally pick up your cross and truck on bubba,but DON"T take any guff from these people.If necessary turn your back and shake the dust off your sandals.👍
 
I have a friend who, every time he sees me, keeps trying to sway me away from Catholicism. He is a Baptist.

I find it challenging because I’m very new to the faith, and though I’m confident the Catholic Church has the fullness of truth, my foundation is still weak until I learn more, which I have been working on.

We had this 30-minute conversation today, and though I thought I did decently, I had to eventually ask him not to try to sway me, as I’m confident the Church is right, but my foundation of knowledge is still a bit weak.

He hates the Church because he has known of some corrupt priests, and he says the Catholic Church has done more harm than good in the last thousand years. I kept trying to emphasize that individuals within it can be in error, and can sin, even up to the Pope, it is just the Church that is infallible. He doesn’t see the distinction, as he says the Church is just all of the individuals within it. I have nothing to say to that, though I still think it’s more than that.

He tried to argue that only the Bible should be believed, and not tradition. When I said nowhere does the Bible teach sola-scriptura, he said that when it says the Word became flesh, and that we have to believe in that Word. Well, I thought the Word referred to Jesus, but somehow he equated that to also referring to only believing in the Bible. :confused:

His biggest problem was with Mary. He said that she called Jesus her savior, and I said yes, he saved her from ever falling into sin. He wouldn’t accept this proposition.

I said that Jesus started one church, which He prevents from being in error. He said the Church is the entire body of believers (Catholic and Protestant). I have no response, but said there is too much disunity among the Protestants to be included in that.

He was also angry that his aunt would tell him that he would go to hell if he wasn’t Catholic. I said only God can judge, and Protestants are in imperfect communion with the Catholic Church, but it doesn’t mean they are all going to hell.

This is the first time I’ve had to defend myself, and I didn’t appreciate him trying to do this, but I’d appreciate any comments about the above, or further explanation. Also, whether I should try to avoid (which I already do) such need to defend myself, and how I can do so. I definitely don’t feel settled in my faith enough yet to debate with someone, and said so several times.

There’s no chance of me falling out of faith, because honestly I think if the Catholic Church isn’t true, no other church is true, either, but I definitely believe the Bible is true, therefore I believe the Church is true. I just want to understand these things better, both for myself and if I should ever need to defend myself again.
You have gotten alot of good advice from prior posters. My advice to someone so new to the faith is not to get invovled in this type of debate. It does you no good and upsets you. Continue to study and learn. Ask your priest for books, papers etc to read to understand your faith in a deeper manner. Read the catechisms and know them. Then pray, pray pray.

As to your “friend”, no he is not a friend. A friend would not do this. This is being a bully. He sees you as a mark, some one to convert. To save you from yourself and the eeevvviiilll katholic church cult. If you can not or do not wish to avoid him, lay down some rules of conduct. Be firm and if he strays, end the conversation. Rule…my faith is off limits. Or any talk about faith is off limits. If he is a friend he should respect that.

I had to lay the similar ground rules for family and friends when I left the SBC and enter Anglicanism. It is easier for me as I have been a Christian for my entire life and was a SBC minister for 4 years, 2 years ordained. Even had a church. My family and friends did not want to understand, but save me from the evil Anglican church. If I did not lay the rule down, I would constantly be defending myself against the same charges over and over and over. Like your baptist friend, they are not interested in discussion but conversion.

Once you are properly grounded, blow him out of the water. Hey, it would be a just war of defense.👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top