How to discern a relationship- help please!

  • Thread starter Thread starter koala7
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

koala7

Guest
My boyfriend is from Australia and I’m from the USA. We have been dating for a year and a half, most of that time we were living and working in Europe. Now we’re in the USA. He has been offered a job and is willing to stay here up to three years until I graduate from college. After, he wants to go back home, maybe get married there, maybe we’ll get married before I graduate, who knows. But in the end he wants to end up living at home which is completely understandable. I have no real attachment to my home in the USA except for my family and friends. I am an only child and I’m really close to my parents. I hate the idea of moving to the opposite side of the world and not being here for them in a few years and especially when they’re older. But I’m completely in love with my boyfriend. We’ve talked about moving to Australia for up to 8 years after I graduate in three years time then moving back to the USA for another 10 years. We have the flexibility as we have no problem with housing in either country and think it would be a good experience for the kids (if God decides to bless us). But at the end of the day I know he wants to end up in Australia, even though he’s open to moving back to the USA after 8 years of living in Australia, life happens and sometimes plans don’t work out.

He spent the last few months in the USA and flew home last week so we’re spending about a month apart. I’m joining him in Australia after Christmas for two months to see his home then we’re coming back to the USA in February to start work and school.

Being apart from each other makes us realize how much we care and miss each other. We both have the feeling we want to be with one another forever but sometimes it’s so hard to imagine it as we’re from opposite sides of the world. :-/
 
Also I just wanted to add since we both aren’t working or going to school right now we’ve been praying together (well we have always prayed together) and going to daily mass 2-3 times a week plus Sunday mass. I also try to pray the rosary every night for us but nothing is too clear yet.
 
There will never be a good place.

If you spend 8 years in Austriala by then you will likely have 2-3 small children. Then youd immigrate to the US. The children would grow to young teens and then you’d yank the rug out from under them and move again.

My “uncle” married a Phillipino woman. She immagrated to the US. They spent 1mo in the phillipines together every year…she went 2 weeks earlier and left 2 weeks after with the kids.

When their youngest turns 21/finishes undergrad they will move to the phillipines perminatly…and visit the US on occasion.
 
Also I just wanted to add since we both aren’t working or going to school right now we’ve been praying together (well we have always prayed together) and going to daily mass 2-3 times a week plus Sunday mass. I also try to pray the rosary every night for us but nothing is too clear yet.
👍

You gotta take the risk…We got married and moved 2 states away from my home area…into another climate completely…It was a hard adjustment at first. I know that’s different from moving so far away to Australia…But tons of people have done just that, all over this wide world of ours. You will have to compromise, and you will always be a little homesick…but you found your special man…that’s so wonderful…

:love:
 
Very true!

I really don’t like the idea of leaving my parents though as I’m an only child. I’ve lived abroad for the last 3 years of my life. I’m now 22. When I lived abroad I was homesick and missed them so much. 😦

I just want them to be there when I have kids. I want my kids to know them and all of my aunts and uncles and cousins. :-/

But I really care about my boyfriend. I don’t know I have a weird feeling moving every 8-10 years would work as money and immigration won’t be a problem. Military families move every 3-4 years around the country and even to other countries and most kids are well-rounded and happy right? I guess the most important thing is having a close-knit, supportive family…

Thanks for sharing the story about the Phillipino and American couple.
There will never be a good place.

If you spend 8 years in Austriala by then you will likely have 2-3 small children. Then youd immigrate to the US. The children would grow to young teens and then you’d yank the rug out from under them and move again.

My “uncle” married a Phillipino woman. She immagrated to the US. They spent 1mo in the phillipines together every year…she went 2 weeks earlier and left 2 weeks after with the kids.

When their youngest turns 21/finishes undergrad they will move to the phillipines perminatly…and visit the US on occasion.
 
I guess you’re right. I could totally move to California (I live on the east coast) because I could easily fly home but living on the opposite side of the world would be so difficult… 😦 Especially visiting with kids etc…

I want to take the risk because I care about him but I still have a lot of praying to do. I honestly have doubt and am not completely sure if this is meant for me. I couldn’t imagine being with out him but it’s such a big sacrifice…

Congratulations on your marriage!
👍

You gotta take the risk…We got married and moved 2 states away from my home area…into another climate completely…It was a hard adjustment at first. I know that’s different from moving so far away to Australia…But tons of people have done just that, all over this wide world of ours. You will have to compromise, and you will always be a little homesick…but you found your special man…that’s so wonderful…

:love:
 
I guess you’re right. I could totally move to California (I live on the east coast) because I could easily fly home but living on the opposite side of the world would be so difficult… 😦 Especially visiting with kids etc…

I want to take the risk because I care about him but I still have a lot of praying to do. I honestly have doubt and am not completely sure if this is meant for me. I couldn’t imagine being with out him but it’s such a big sacrifice…

Congratulations on your marriage!
😉 That was 22 years ago, hon! Been a lot of ups and downs since then. I wish you the best in your discernment. Try to get to adoration, it helps me so much.
 
I thought I could share my experience growing up in a family that moved a lot (mostly across the USA, though we also spent four years in Canada.) I adjusted pretty well and because my parents were attentive to my schooling I was never behind as the result of a move (usually ahead.) Getting involved and settling down, even if you’re unsure exactly how long you’ll be in one place, will teach kids how to make connections and help them feel grounded. Strong family connections will make transitions easier because peers are never primary support.

I also found that living in many places gave me a much less “me-centric” worldview. I understood that others had differing perspectives and they were worth listening to even if my own perspective wouldn’t change.

Moving a lot does NOT spell doom for children although it presents a few different challenges. God bless you as you discern this relationship.
 
I moved around a lot as a child, but this is not precisely what this is about. This is not only about whether moving or not is a good idea. This is about a cross-cultural marriage, one where the two parties are from opposite sides of the world.

Having grown up in Japan but having been born in the US, I am somewhat familiar with the concept. 😉 Do not assume that moving from one country to another because you want to be near your parents or he wants to be in his home country is necessarily feasible just because moving in the abstract is feasible. You will want to be living in the US; he will want to be living in Australia. It is not simply a matter of “let’s live in the middle”. If he wants to live in Australia, California is not the same thing.

I do not want to be discouraging of your relationship necessarily. I want you to think about this seriously. I know that, if it came to it, I would choose my husband over my parents. Once you are married, you might have to rethink things, depending on where you are able to find a job, depending on your children’s lives, depending on any number of things. Do not marry thinking that living near your parents is a requirement. Once you are married, your husband will outrank your parents.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top