How to forgive

  • Thread starter Thread starter StrugglingC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you, montee, for sharing your story. It is encouraging to know that there is someone who did what I am trying to do. Yes, I need to pray more. I am in process of improving my prayer life. Thank you again for the encouragement.
 
StrugglingC,
I’m not sure this is about forgiveness as much as putting too much emphasis on her disrespectful opinion of you. Yes, you need to forgive her, but until her opinion is less important to you, I’m not sure how easy it will be for you to let go of her comments.

I know this is difficult, especially when it seems your self-esteem has already taken a lot of hits, but it would perhaps be best for everyone if you stop focusing on what she thinks of you. You may not even realize you’re doing it, but that’s what it sounds like. (And I apologize in advance if I’m way off, it’s just that a lot of what you said sounds so similar to my past.) I also think your husband needs to stand up for you and not allow her to criticize you in his presence, but you cannot force him to do that. So let’s focus on what you can do.

It’s much harder to forgive someone if you keep putting yourself in a position where they can (and are likely to) hurt you again and again–that is to say, you’re* letting her get to you. It’s a choice. The good news is, you can also choose* not **to let her criticisms get to you. Yes, it’s a decision, albeit not always an easy one!

Perhaps she has little respect for you because you seem to have little respect for yourself. I hope that didn’t come out wrong; my intent is not to excuse her behavior, nor to criticize you–in fact, I struggle with this myself. (A lot.) I really want people to like me, to respect me, and to appreciate me. But I’ve found that doing things (or not doing things) in order to please someone else (or being too worried about what they think of my choices) just ends up making BOTH them and me respect me* less*.

When I make what I believe is the right choice, I may be criticized–I have to learn to accept that. I try to remember that others are entitled to their opinion–but** that doesn’t automatically make them right and me wrong.** I have to remind myself that people sometimes criticize only because they didn’t get to make the decision themselves (even if it’s not their decision to make)!

Also, please be careful. Some of the things you said worry me. When someone’s opinion becomes overly important to you, every perceived criticism eats away at your self-esteem (and when she’s complimenting someone else, you may perceive it as, “she thinks that person is better than me.”). If you put too much emphasis on what she thinks of you, then you may be (or may start) putting her opinion on a pedestal–above yourself, your husband… perhaps even above God. I know this from experience.

It starts as a small, nagging doubt… “I suppose if I do this, X will have something to say about it. Maybe I should do that instead… at least then, X won’t be quite so critical.” And then it slowly grows into a distraction… “Honey, what did X have to say about me when you saw her today? No, please tell me, I won’t get upset.” And eventually, it grows into doubt, jealousy, and insecurity. “I can’t believe she criticized my housekeeping even though I just cleaned before she came over. And yet last week, she complimented Y on her cooking! Y can’t boil water without burning it!”

The problem is, when I consider X’s opinion first and most important, I often** forget to consider God’s will for me.** Focusing on God’s will will help you to put her opinion aside and make decisions you are happy with, even if she’s not. You can’t put both God’s will and X’s first at the same time–one must come before the other. Which will it be?

HTH. Prayers for you!
 
StrugglingC,
I’m not sure this is about forgiveness as much as putting too much emphasis on her disrespectful opinion of you. Yes, you need to forgive her, but until her opinion is less important to you, I’m not sure how easy it will be for you to let go of her comments.

I know this is difficult, especially when it seems your self-esteem has already taken a lot of hits, but it would perhaps be best for everyone if you stop focusing on what she thinks of you. You may not even realize you’re doing it, but that’s what it sounds like. (And I apologize in advance if I’m way off, it’s just that a lot of what you said sounds so similar to my past.) I also think your husband needs to stand up for you and not allow her to criticize you in his presence, but you cannot force him to do that. So let’s focus on what you can do.

It’s much harder to forgive someone if you keep putting yourself in a position where they can (and are likely to) hurt you again and again–that is to say, you’re* letting her get to you. It’s a choice. The good news is, you can also choose* not **to let her criticisms get to you. Yes, it’s a decision, albeit not always an easy one!

Perhaps she has little respect for you because you seem to have little respect for yourself. I hope that didn’t come out wrong; my intent is not to excuse her behavior, nor to criticize you–in fact, I struggle with this myself. (A lot.) I really want people to like me, to respect me, and to appreciate me. But I’ve found that doing things (or not doing things) in order to please someone else (or being too worried about what they think of my choices) just ends up making BOTH them and me respect me* less*.

When I make what I believe is the right choice, I may be criticized–I have to learn to accept that. I try to remember that others are entitled to their opinion–but** that doesn’t automatically make them right and me wrong.** I have to remind myself that people sometimes criticize only because they didn’t get to make the decision themselves (even if it’s not their decision to make)!

Also, please be careful. Some of the things you said worry me. When someone’s opinion becomes overly important to you, every perceived criticism eats away at your self-esteem (and when she’s complimenting someone else, you may perceive it as, “she thinks that person is better than me.”). If you put too much emphasis on what she thinks of you, then you may be (or may start) putting her opinion on a pedestal–above yourself, your husband… perhaps even above God. I know this from experience.

It starts as a small, nagging doubt… “I suppose if I do this, X will have something to say about it. Maybe I should do that instead… at least then, X won’t be quite so critical.” And then it slowly grows into a distraction… “Honey, what did X have to say about me when you saw her today? No, please tell me, I won’t get upset.” And eventually, it grows into doubt, jealousy, and insecurity. “I can’t believe she criticized my housekeeping even though I just cleaned before she came over. And yet last week, she complimented Y on her cooking! Y can’t boil water without burning it!”

The problem is, when I consider X’s opinion first and most important, I often** forget to consider God’s will for me.** Focusing on God’s will will help you to put her opinion aside and make decisions you are happy with, even if she’s not. You can’t put both God’s will and X’s first at the same time–one must come before the other. Which will it be?

HTH. Prayers for you!
Thank you.

You are right on. I have become obsessed with this woman. This irritates me because I don’t want her to be important in my life. I am obsessed with her because she destroyed what I was protecting with my husband. All the efforts we were putting in. Trying my very best wasn’t good enough for her. She walked all over us, did unthinkable behavior (i.e. using our children to get satisfaction, talking badly about us in front of them), and never apologized…

I want to come to peace with this. I don’t want to think about her. I don’t want to deal with her in my life. But she keeps butting in. Now she, not just her behavior, is a source of distress… I’ve cried to God so many times. I am still holding onto him. I am working on this with a Catholic counselor. I am taking baby steps…
 
…I got married in church, had kids, and have been taking care of the whole family with my husband. I guess I’m not good enough. She cannot let go of the past where SHE was the one to do all those things for my husband and his kids. She openly praised his ex, who never got married and had two kids with two different men, for being a good mom. I don’t know about someone with a child being a good mom while she sleeps around and gets pregnant with someone who runs away from her… Even if she believed it, why did she have to tell me that? Insensitive…can I say?
I missed this. I think it is actually praiseworthy to get into the habit of praising your grandchildren’s mother, lest you get into the habit of denigrating her and your grandchildren hear you bad-mouthing their mother. That would not be good for them. Children benefit when their parents are shown as much respect as is honestly possible. And yes, a woman who makes very bad choices with regards to her sexual partners can be a very good mother in other respects. It is typical that we have our strong suits and our weak spots.

Unfortunately, your MIL may have incorrectly surmised that you think your pursuit of virtue makes you better than the mother of her grandchildren, and so she may have made it her business to “bring you down a notch.” Not a nice thing to do, but it is a temptation when we give ourselves the idea that someone else is just a bit too full of herself. She may have just felt a need to defend someone not present to defend herself. If that is the case, then she may see what are really efforts to please her as being efforts to show off yourself as some kind of a paragon, and those may paradoxically work against your goal of reaching a good relationship with her.

At any rate, it is humble and praiseworthy to teach yourself to gladly bear other people praised and their failures down-played, even if they are great sinners. Give and gifts will be given to you; a good measure, packed together, shaken down, and overflowing, will be poured into your lap. For the measure with which you measure will in return be measured out to you. I think you get that; just realize that it extends to being compassionate with your husband’s ex, who feels not like a fellow sinner, but like competition. She isn’t competition. You can afford to be gracious about her

When the children get old enough to make decisions that could lead them down a similar path, it is enough to point out that these things are sinful because of all the pain they cause. You do not have to make the sinner out to be a bad person, and you do not have to fear pointing out any merits the errant parent had or has. After all, the woman who anointed the Lord’s feet with was thought a great sinner by her contemporaries, but the Lord said she would be remembered through the ages for her act of great love. That is what God cares about; it is OK to be that generous ourselves. So by all means give up any sense of competition with the mother of the children or with your husband’s mother. Practice gratitude that they cared for those now in your charge for all the time they did, and give them respect for having done work that you know to be demanding. Do not consider yourself their superior, even if there are objective measures that could lure you in that direction, for you do not know how far you exceed them not just in the end result, but in your starting aptitudes, graces, and other gifts. There is no little spiritual peril to be hazarded by going in the direction of comparing yourself favorably with others, so try at all costs to avoid it. I think that practice will lessen the hurt you feel when others are praised while you find yourself unfairly criticized.
 
Thank you.

You are right on. I have become obsessed with this woman. This irritates me because I don’t want her to be important in my life. I am obsessed with her because she destroyed what I was protecting with my husband. All the efforts we were putting in. Trying my very best wasn’t good enough for her. She walked all over us, did unthinkable behavior (i.e. using our children to get satisfaction, talking badly about us in front of them), and never apologized…

I want to come to peace with this. I don’t want to think about her. I don’t want to deal with her in my life. But she keeps butting in. Now she, not just her behavior, is a source of distress… I’ve cried to God so many times. I am still holding onto him. I am working on this with a Catholic counselor. I am taking baby steps…
The other thing you could do is to try the little way of St. Therese. Here is how one writer described it: Thérèse’s life in the convent was small and simple, but within the confines of her life she was given the opportunity for action. So when an older nun asked for help, but was ungrateful, Thérèse gave her more help with her willing smile. When faced with a difficult sister she went to extraordinary lengths to befriend her and show her that love which everyone else, including Thérèse, found difficult. The whole community and the unlovable nun herself were convinced that she was Thérèse’s favourite friend. Only later did it emerge how hard Thérèse had worked to love and understand the unlovable sister. In her loving prayerful actions Thérèse doesn’t tell us how to evangelise—she shows us.
–from St Thérèse of Lisieux - Model for Missionaries by Dwight Longenecker

Keep in mind that these things caused St. Thérèse true suffering. This was hard for her to do, and these were people that drove her a bit nuts. It took a lot of prayer for her to keep it up. So do not be discouraged about your MIL. Do your best to be good to her even if she treats you badly, and you will be storing up treasure in heaven and being a good evangelist for your children and stepchild.
 
Thank you.

You are right on. I have become obsessed with this woman. This irritates me because I don’t want her to be important in my life. I am obsessed with her because she destroyed what I was protecting with my husband. All the efforts we were putting in. Trying my very best wasn’t good enough for her. She walked all over us, did unthinkable behavior (i.e. using our children to get satisfaction, talking badly about us in front of them), and never apologized…

I want to come to peace with this. I don’t want to think about her. I don’t want to deal with her in my life. But she keeps butting in. Now she, not just her behavior, is a source of distress… I’ve cried to God so many times. I am still holding onto him. I am working on this with a Catholic counselor. I am taking baby steps…
Why are you trying to please her? This is why you cannot "let go of it,"as your husband feels. I experienced some of what you experienced, with my mother-in-law, but I never tried to please her because I did not care what she thought about me. My husband was never strong enough to tell her straight to her face to quit her interference. Forgiveness can take time and it takes longer for the hurt to ease, but it must be done. Telling yourself that you don’t want to think about her only results in further obsessing about her and her bad behavior. It’s like someone in a crisis situation should never tell others “Do not panic” because all they will hear is “panic”! You tell them “keep calm” and they are far more likely to remain calm. So each time you find yourself thinking about her, get up, do something different, focus on something pleasant. That’s the only way you will be able to let it go, which you must do. All the time you are hurting and obsessing over the hurts, she’s out enjoying herself. She’s not worth it.
 
Thank you Easter Joy.

I’m sorry I wasn’t clear on some things. I never talk badly about my stepchildren’s biological mother in front of them. I don’t do that in front of this lady either. However, she did talk badly and rolled her eyes about the mother with us, adults.

I even defend the mother of my stepchildren when they complain about her. I have scolded them for disrespecting her on different occasions, as well.

I also do not talk badly about this lady in front of our children. I am always very careful.
 
Thank you.

You are right on. I have become obsessed with this woman. This irritates me because I don’t want her to be important in my life. I am obsessed with her because she destroyed what I was protecting with my husband. All the efforts we were putting in. Trying my very best wasn’t good enough for her. She walked all over us, did unthinkable behavior (i.e. using our children to get satisfaction, talking badly about us in front of them), and never apologized…

I want to come to peace with this. I don’t want to think about her. I don’t want to deal with her in my life. But she keeps butting in. Now she, not just her behavior, is a source of distress… I’ve cried to God so many times. I am still holding onto him. I am working on this with a Catholic counselor. I am taking baby steps…
I have had to struggle with some similar issues, only in my case, it’s the opposite gender who has been subversive within my family. There have been times when I have truly wanted to strangle him. I see a counselor too, and she has changed my perspective on several aspects of his behavior. She forced me to see things from his POV, not in order to excuse his acts, but to see that he wasn’t necessarily doing what he did in order to destroy our family. In his own mind, he has the right to give advice, because he is the elder statesman of the family. Even if it’s the WRONG advice, and totally undermines our values and morals, he wants to be the adviser.

I agree with the person who advised you to pray for your difficult relation. Pray when you want to pray the least. Take her to adoration with you and put her in front of Jesus! (I don’t mean literally, but you are already giving her a lot of real estate inside your head!) Offer intentions for her at every Mass. Put her name onto prayer lists. Light candles for her. And pray to be willing to forgive her.

“Dear Jesus, please help me to be willing to forgive X. Change MY heart so that no matter what she chooses to do, I remain close to you at all times, and not bitter and filled with hurt.”

You know what they say…Resentment is like taking poison and waiting for the OTHER person to die.
 
Thank you TheRealJuliane.

I do pray for her and our relationship. I pray for the marriage as well as my husband. I pray for all our children. I pray God to help me forgive. I pray for the mother of my stepchildren. But I have never done candles. I think I will do that.

On a separate note, I have asked my husband if he prays for me. To my surprise, he got offended and said he didn’t want to be told what to pray about. (I did not forcefully ask him to pray for me. I simply asked if he does.) This made me sad…
 
Thank you Easter Joy.

I’m sorry I wasn’t clear on some things. I never talk badly about my stepchildren’s biological mother in front of them. I don’t do that in front of this lady either. However, she did talk badly and rolled her eyes about the mother with us, adults.

I even defend the mother of my stepchildren when they complain about her. I have scolded them for disrespecting her on different occasions, as well.

I also do not talk badly about this lady in front of our children. I am always very careful.
No, no, no…I realized that you yourself didn’t talk badly about the mom of the stepchildren. I meant that there is good reason for your MIL to have a habit of speaking well of your stepchildren’s mom in front of the stepchildren. When your MIL was taking care of your stepchild, talking well about that mother was part of your MIL doing her job well. Unlike that mother, you are someone your MIL may see as competition for a niche of fame in the Mom Olympics. Hence why she is more gracious to one she sees as less than her while being so hard on the one who seems to be doing better.

My impression is that you don’t speak badly about any of them, except to complain to your husband that your MIL hurts your feelings. He’s apparently not a good candidate for that kind of support. Regretable, but not unusual. Lots of sons are like that. You, however, have a source of support in your faith. I’m not saying that counselling couldn’t be very valuable, but I think that depending on God to support you and give you strength is where your reliable help is going to come in the years to come.

Do not worry that you struggle. That is not necessarily a bad sign, that this is hard for you. That happens, when times are hard and you don’t take an easy way out. Hang in there!! The Crucifix doesn’t teach that bad things never happen to those who are faithful, but that if we are faithful, God can take the worst thing in the world and make it into the best thing in the world. That is why we Catholics still have the corpus on the Cross, and do not only have empty crosses as our inspirational symbols.
 
Thank you Easter Joy. I need a crucifix in my kitchen and at work…
 
Thank you Easter Joy. I need a crucifix in my kitchen and at work…
We all do!

Do not, do not, do not beat yourself up because this situation pains you. The Lord did not say, “Come to me, all you who are heavy burdened, so I can beat you up about not being a better person”. He didn’t say, “Heavy burden? What heavy burden? Quit feeling sorry for yourself!!” He didn’t die so we could feel free to sin, but he also did not die in order to torture us about our sins, either. He died to free us from what our sins do to us, what the sins of others do to us. God understands, God is our advocate, God is our savior.

If this were happening to a friend of yours, you would be understanding. You’d understand why she hurt so much, you’d feel for her, you’d want to help her find strategies to cope with it, you’d want her to make spiritual mileage out of the suffering that charity required her to face. We all want that for you, and we all hope you’ll feel free to give yourself what you would give to anyone you loved! 👍
 
You’ve gotten lots of good advise.

I’ve had some major problems with my inlaws. And the often say rude things to me, and always “that’s not what they meant.” They attack everything that is me. My stories are long and nearly entertaining. They’d make a sick comedy.

Here’s a little trick I used with DH, who is usually never around when my in laws say some jaw dropping things. Who also didn’t want to confront them.

Keeping in mind my inlaws do not live close. They may come to visit us. I will be a gracious hostest. I will make meals etc., allow them to take the children out. I will not go with our children to them. We only get so much vacation time, they have lost the worthiness of us spending it on them.

Finally, I told DH, he needs to have a conversation with them. They may not talk down the Catholic Church, They may not talk down to me. They may not correct my parenting. They may not undermine my decisions. He can explain this however he likes.

If they break the rules, I will stop their statements instantly. There will be no negotiation or arguement. I’ve not really had to inforce this much. Only on occassion. And if they say something to the children that I do not approve of, or if they do something I don’t approve of, I just correct them infront of the children. Oh, Grandma doesn’t know that’s not the truth. Oh, did you trick your grandmother into letting you eat something you know you’re not allowed to have? There have been some really silly exchanges, but they get what they ask for.
 
When we cannot forgive

Heavenly Father help us to recover where injury goes beyond ordinary forgiveness and our hearts are in some way crushed, and our lives changed and devalued. Help us to find a way to forgive when we cannot smile or encounter the offending person with warmth because they have destroyed something in us, or in those whom we love…

Father please help us to forgive when it seems we cannot forgive…because they do not understand how badly they have hurt us, and do not seek in any real way to acknowledge or try to heal the hurt they imposed on us. And even when we tried to tell them from the bottom of our heart but they would not listen, please help us to forgive.

Father help us to forgive when those who hurt our lives do not even remember how badly they have wounded us, and go on with their lives without concern, while we remain still held in some kind of time capsule with the consequences of their unfeeling and uncaring and attack.

Father, help us to forgive when those who wounded us by ignoring our needs and requests, yet who desire us to ignore their offense, and expect us to respond to their hints or manipulations while they make no concessions or apologies.

Help us to forgive those who impose their own conditions and rules upon us, without respecting that our hurt is real and radical, while they make us feel that they only desire our capitulation without justice, apology, or generosity from them.
Wow. This is an amazing prayer. Praying it felt like it was written especially for me. Thank you for this gift.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top