The way I see it, dating is about discernment. Its not about how long you can keep the relationship going. Its about whether or not you can visit each other enough to get an accurate picture of who that person is and to prayerfully discern your vocation this way. If you’re looking for just emotional satisfaction, than I don’t think it can work and I don’t even think that’s the right approach to dating.
I met my husband on Avemariasingles. At the time, we lived about 5 hours apart. We corresponded strictly through email from November till April. He suggested he was interested in meeting me in person in Feburary, but we made plans for after he was done with his semester. I did give him the stipulation that we needed to talk on the phone a bit before meeting. So we had phone dates for awhile. We arranged the first time to talk and he’d start our bashfully asking me to arrange another phone call later on and we’d schedule it for a week later. Eventually he realized we kept scheduling for the same time and day of the week, so things became a little more casual and we just started expecting each other around that time.
I then found out he had come up to visit his parents during a break. This meant he was only 3 hours from me. So I asked him what he’d say if I just drove over there. We already had a date of when we were going to meet, but to me it was just taking too long. I ended up bringing my brother along as “body guard” and he brought his mom along and we met in a public place, found we still liked each other and discussed the whole distance thing and whether or not we should take the effort to continue seeing each other on weekends especially considering the drive time, the cost of gas and the fact that he was planning on studying abroad in Oxford after the summer. We ultimately decided to go with it.
So we saw each other every weekend and sometimes on extended weekends. We usually slept overnight at our parents’ places and kept strict rules on curfews and separate sleeping quarters. It was the best we could do as it was just too far to not spend the night and motels would have made us go broke. Then when he went to Oxford, we corresponded on the weekends through Skype. It was early morning for me and nighttime for him. We’d email each other throughout the week. I have to say during his Oxford time, it didn’t feel so much like discerning new information, but just staying in some contact and praying about what I had learned over the summer about him. He also spent his time in Oxford reconsidering the monastic life. I didn’t know at that time that he had decided by the end of the summer that it was either marry me or join a monastic community.
He decided for a multitude of reasons to only spend one semester in Oxford instead of two. When he returned to the States, he stayed with my parents for awhile and in front of my family on my birthday, he proposed to me. We still were pretty much long distance (he lived when closest to me 3 hours away) for most of our engagement till I finally moved about 4 months before our wedding.
Now, my sister lived even further from her husband. We’re from Wisconsin and her husband lived in Florida. Her husband was actually a friend of mine who had come up to visit me in 2007. My sister only happened to meet him on chance. She wasn’t even supposed to be home that weekend at all, but as soon as she met him, she was hooked. However my mom was convinced I would eventually marry this guy (haha!) and she just became concerned about having a crush on some man who would eventually be her brother in law. They became long distance friends for awhile and eventually their long distance correspondance continued to grow in its interest. So after about two years of long distance friendship and intense interest, they decided to have her fly down to Florida to see if the interest was still there in person. They immediately saw each other and decided “yea we’re definitely dating now.” They somehow made arrangements to fly to visit each other every 2 or 3 months. After about dating this way for 6 months, he proposed to her. Again he moved up just a few months before their wedding.
I don’t think they made the wrong decision at all. I think overall though that you have to pray about it and see where God is guiding you with it. Some people just couldn’t do the long distance thing. Some people would think my sister and I were foolish for marrying men who we got to know over a distance. How can you really know someone that way, they ask? But, I think it can work if its God’s will.
My husband and I started corresponding online in Nov of 07 and officially started courting in April of 08, and got married in April of this year. My sister met her husband in October of '07, officially started courting him in December of 2008, got engaged in July of 2009 and got married in June of this year. Everyone felt sorry for my parents as our weddings were only 8 weeks apart. So we’re still newlyweds, but that’s just how we went about it.