How to make Yankee Pot Roast

  • Thread starter Thread starter catechumen08
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have two ways to do this.

The lazy way:

In a big dutch oven on the stovetop, brown the chuck or brisket. trim no fat unless you are a fat hater. When brown, turn off the stove, and cover the roast in onion soup mix (two packs). Just roll it around right there in the dutch oven. Wash the potatoes, carrots and celery, but don’t peel them, and only cut them up to make sure they fit in the pot. If you are adventuresome, add a few mushrooms if they are not too expensive. Add a 1/4 to 1/2 cup of red wine. Put the lid on the dutch oven. Stuff it in the oven at 225 degrees until the veggies are done, and the meat is ready, which can be up to 6 hours.

The more-effort way:

Perform the same browning ritual, making sure to salt the meat to achieve decent browning (I like kosher salt for this). You will already have on hand 1 medium onion, sliced thinly, which you will layer on the meat. Tuck the potatoes, celery, mushrooms and carrots around the edges, again making sure NOT to peel, only wash, and not to cut unless necessary. Add another thinly sliced onion over that. Add a half-cup red wine, 1 TSB. basil, and a sprig or its equivalent of thyme.

Lid on, into the oven, 350 degrees, about an hour to an hour and a half.

Now the fun part: Scoop the meat and veggies out of the pot and into a serving bowl or onto a platter, keeping as much liquid as possible in the pot.

In a separate container, mix together 2-3TBS flour and some lukewarm water to make a slurry (not quite paste, not quite flour water). Add 1 TBS Kitchen Bouquet or some other carmelization product. Stir well.

Put the dutch oven back on the stovetop, low heat, and slowly stir the slurry into the juices. Keep stirring until the gravy reaches the desired consistency for your family, and the gravy doesn’t have that uncooked flour taste.
 
I don’t really know what a yankee roast is, but my mom used to cook her roast with carrots and potatoes. I don’t like mine to cook that way, so I just toss a roast in the crock pot for about 8 hours on low with a little seasoning, make gravy when it’s done, and serve with mashed potatoes and green beans. My favorite meal ever!! 😛
 
oh, and if you put the fat side up it helps keep it juicy in the crock pot.
 
I don’t really know what a yankee roast is, but my mom used to cook her roast with carrots and potatoes. I don’t like mine to cook that way, so I just toss a roast in the crock pot for about 8 hours on low with a little seasoning, make gravy when it’s done, and serve with mashed potatoes and green beans. My favorite meal ever!! 😛
I also like pot roast with egg yolk noodles. Instead of the potatoes, towards the end of he cooking time, cook up a batch of noodles (Kluskis, Polish, egg yolk, all the same thing, those wide soup noodles). Drain, then add two TSB of butter (real butter) and a package of onion soup mix. Toss, adding a little juice from the pot roast to thin it to a gravy consistency.
 
I also like pot roast with egg yolk noodles. Instead of the potatoes, towards the end of he cooking time, cook up a batch of noodles (Kluskis, Polish, egg yolk, all the same thing, those wide soup noodles). Drain, then add two TSB of butter (real butter) and a package of onion soup mix. Toss, adding a little juice from the pot roast to thin it to a gravy consistency.
My mom likes this also with mashed potatoes on top. I think it’s a traditonal dutch meal?
 
What makes it “Yankee,” as opposed to “regular” pot roast?

Betsy
 
👍 Don’t care if it’s really “Yankee” or really “dutch”. It’s got flavor, tatses like I’ve been working for hours, it’s MEAT, it’s STARCH, I love it.
 
Woohoo! Just got the crock pot in the mail yesterday! Guess what I’m going to be cooking this weekend?
 
You’ll have to let us know how it turns out. I think crock pots are the most fabulous way to cook meat, especially on a budget. You can get away with the less expensive roats since it will slow cook all day. Try a cheap roast in the oven and it’s tough.
 
I like crock pots for slow-cooking soups, stews and sauces. I like dutch ovens for roasts and braising meats, along with a bunch of other stuff I learned how to cook, such as pie and cake and dumplings. But then, I have a yen to join one of theose trail drives off Food Network.
 
OK, how many of us have had a craving for and prepared a pot roast since the inception of this thread? Please step forward and give us a big smile (and share which recipe you used)

😃
(I used my own recipe with the mushroom and onion soups, served over wide egg noodles, an idea I got from another post)
 
OK, how many of us have had a craving for and prepared a pot roast since the inception of this thread? Please step forward and give us a big smile (and share which recipe you used)

😃
(I used my own recipe with the mushroom and onion soups, served over wide egg noodles, an idea I got from another post)
Me. And I made potatoes AND egg noodles.
 
I haven’t read through the entire thread, so please forgive me.

It doesn’t get any easier than the way I cook my roast. I use the Reynold’s oven bags and:

1 English cut roast, seasoned with garlic powder & pepper (or Mrs. Dash) on both sides.

1 envelope au jus gravy mix

1/2 envelope of cool water

Sliced onions if you like

Put the dry mix in the bag. Add the water & “smush” it all around. Put the roast in the bag & loosely tie it. Place on a shallow baking pan. Poke a few holes in the bag so it doesn’t burst. Bake at 325° for 2-1/2 hours. It’s absolutely amazing. You can add a can of ready made gravy if you want to thicken it a little for potatoes or hot sammiches.

I always cook my veggies separately, because we aren’t much for mushy potatoes & carrots. I usually roast them in a separate pan with onion, garlic & rosemary (toss all with olive oil) while the roast is cooking.
 
Hi all! I’m trying to find a quick, easy - and tasty - recipe for Yankee Pot Roast. The ones I find online are a bit too complicated for me - yea, I’m not much of a cook. Anyway, I’m looking for one that has as its ingredients, carrots, celery, gravy, and of course, beef! And oh, did I mention, simple? Haha!

Thanks a bunch in advance!
It requires a pot and a New Englander:D

(just a little fun for a southerner)
 
Question from a former Yankee…
Doesn’t anybody do cooked cabbage and onions with it too?
First, as a Yankee transplant myself, I’m goingt o say this: Once a Yankee, always a Yankee. (Kinda like the Marines, haha!)

But as adding for cabbage? I thought that that’s usually found in a thinner soup and called a boiled dinner.
What makes it “Yankee,” as opposed to “regular” pot roast?
Betsy
It’s based on old cast iron pot un the fireplace recipes from New England settlers. It’s made so that until almost the last minute you can always stretch the recipe and add more veggies and stock. And you can cut up the leftovers, thicken the stock, and put it into a pot pie later in the week (if there’s any left over!) Also, it’s heartening in cold weather. You’re not going to have pot roast and sip mint juleps on the verandah, right? 😉
 
I have a pot roast in the crock pot now:
  • 2 3/4 lb chuck eye roast
  • extra virgin olive oil
  • 2 cups beef broth
  • 1/2 cup red cooking wine
  • baby carrots
  • celery (cut in 1 inch pieces)
  • 5 red potatoes (quartered)
  • 2 onions (quartered)
  • 8 oz sliced mushrooms
  • basil, salt, pepper, bay leaves
    1. Braise the roast until brown on both sides in olive oil
    2. Sautee mushrooms in the same olive oil used for the roast.
    3. Put vegetables potatoes, mushrooms, broth, wine and spices in the bottom of the crock pot
    4. put roast on top.
    5. Cook on high for 5 hours or low for 10
      Since I got a late start on the roast (water outage). I am cooking on high 1 hour and low for 8
    And before anyone asks: Male, single, unattached, not looking :mad:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top