How to mend a broken family relationship

  • Thread starter Thread starter Serap
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My hope was that *her *husband would have some pull with her, if he had ideas about what to do. Her self-martyrdom can’t be easy on him, either, nor their child. OTOH, if he won’t draw any boundaries inside his own family, that can’t be helped by anyone on the outside.

If your SIL won’t draw boundaries with your MIL and won’t take care of herself, there is nothing you can do but “detach in love” as they say in the co-dependency recovery circles. Melody Beattie’s “Co-Dependent No More” has a lot of good stuff in it on that topic. Most libraries have it. Maybe that will help you.
Detatch in love…will it really come to that? (rhetorical question) Deep inside, I feel you are right. I think my husband has already begun this process. He has repeatedly said that he’s done with her and that he feels bad that his mom is caught in the middle.

I hate this feeling of not knowing what the outcome will be…sell the house, get along, continue in the same house living separately…??? It’s hard.
 
Serp,

I think this is a case where stressed people do funny things, caring for an ill parent can be like caring for a special needs kid. I know in other threads you’ve mentioned how difficult your son was when he was young. You weren’t keen on letting other people help. It can be twice as hard when it’s a parent and it’s an embarrassment/guilt factor, too.

I would see if you can get hospital social workers to speak with your sister as far as her emotinal state. Sometimes coming from outside the family helps.
 
Serp,

I think this is a case where stressed people do funny things, caring for an ill parent can be like caring for a special needs kid. I know in other threads you’ve mentioned how difficult your son was when he was young. You weren’t keen on letting other people help. It can be twice as hard when it’s a parent and it’s an embarrassment/guilt factor, too.

I would see if you can get hospital social workers to speak with your sister as far as her emotinal state. Sometimes coming from outside the family helps.
and with my son, I was working full-time, so I had breaks away from him daily. My SIL works from home and is always near her mom (even if the caregiver is there too).
 
Detatch in love…will it really come to that? (rhetorical question) Deep inside, I feel you are right. I think my husband has already begun this process. He has repeatedly said that he’s done with her and that he feels bad that his mom is caught in the middle.

I hate this feeling of not knowing what the outcome will be…sell the house, get along, continue in the same house living separately…??? It’s hard.
“Detach with love” does not mean putting the person out of your life, or at least not always. It means refusing to be a character in a false drama someone else is trying to put on. It is possible to teach other people that you have boundaries in a healthy place, and for them to learn to live with them. They may not like your boundaries, but if you learn to enforce them without a counter-drama, after the initial (inevitable) flak, they can learn to take their drama to someone who will listen to it.

If you haven’t read Melody Beattie’s book, I highly recommend it. I don’t think a person has to be co-dependent in some clinical sense of the term in order to profit from it. After all, aren’t we all in dramas we don’t need to be in sometimes, including dramas of our own making? Read her book, she has some theories that have really helped me.
 
“Detach with love” does not mean putting the person out of your life, or at least not always. It means refusing to be a character in a false drama someone else is trying to put on. It is possible to teach other people that you have boundaries in a healthy place, and for them to learn to live with them. They may not like your boundaries, but if you learn to enforce them without a counter-drama, after the initial (inevitable) flak, they can learn to take their drama to someone who will listen to it.

If you haven’t read Melody Beattie’s book, I highly recommend it. I don’t think a person has to be co-dependent in some clinical sense of the term in order to profit from it. After all, aren’t we all in dramas we don’t need to be in sometimes, including dramas of our own making? Read her book, she has some theories that have really helped me.
Thank you so so much. I am so greatful.
 
Thank you for sharing your story. You showed me an angle that I had not thought of. I will wait until my husband is in a good frame of mind and perhaps appeal to his inner hero.

God forbid, what if something happened to his mother!!
Yes extremely good advise from LSK I certainly find myself in his position.

Yes the only loser is your mother-in-law while you all are trying to learn the reality of life, time is moving on and there’s always loses in the game, my saying has always been one doer is worth 100 offers. But of course a lot of carers do not want help because of various reasons, getting the shopping can help a great deal I don’t know does your mother-in-law is suffering from dementia that can eventually be a huge strain on the carer it may pay you to read about dementia and Alzheimer’s. Bob DeMarco runs a wonderful website called Alzheimer’s reading room, alzheimersreadingroom.com/2012/11/dementia-image-dementia-challenge-and.html

Well any form of brain injury can cause dementia, I do consider a stroke is a form of brain injury. My wife suffered a brain injury and all the problems she suffers are the same as dementia and Alzheimer’s.
 
Thank you so so much. I am so greatful.
As you read it, if you realize that it is the drama queen/king in your life who is the co-dependent, remember this: You can’t “fix” him or her. You can only act in a healthy way around the person yourself, and give the person openings to choose to do the same and validation when they do. The rest is up to them. If you forget that, you’ll get sucked right back into their drama cycle.
 
As you read it, if you realize that it is the drama queen/king in your life who is the co-dependent, remember this: You can’t “fix” him or her. You can only act in a healthy way around the person yourself, and give the person openings to choose to do the same and validation when they do. The rest is up to them. If you forget that, you’ll get sucked right back into their drama cycle.
Yes, my SIL is a very dramatic individual and she has a tendency to accuse me of scheming over various things. I am not the scheming type at all…in fact, I’m too busy to scheme out anything.

SIL is unhappy with herself…she is obese, inactive and has unhealthy eating habits, which she tries to share with my daughter and I very much dislike it. My SIL accused me of thinking that she is a bad cook and person and that I am teaching my daughter bad body image. I think that’s completely untrue. I do however, not like it when my SIL feeds my daughter food that is high in fat and lacks nutrition.

Since the fight, my SIL has stopped cooking for my daugther. I am glad that she is not anymore b/c we buy food for our caregiver to cook for my kids.
 
Yes, my SIL is a very dramatic individual and she has a tendency to accuse me of scheming over various things. I am not the scheming type at all…in fact, I’m too busy to scheme out anything.

SIL is unhappy with herself…she is obese, inactive and has unhealthy eating habits, which she tries to share with my daughter and I very much dislike it. My SIL accused me of thinking that she is a bad cook and person and that I am teaching my daughter bad body image. I think that’s completely untrue. I do however, not like it when my SIL feeds my daughter food that is high in fat and lacks nutrition.

Since the fight, my SIL has stopped cooking for my daugther. I am glad that she is not anymore b/c we buy food for our caregiver to cook for my kids.
When finances allow you and your husband to live a bit further from your in-laws, I’d seriously consider it. In the meantime, at least you can have some peace on your side of the wall by, with God’s help, “accepting the things you cannot change; having the courage to change the things you can, and being given the wisdom to know the difference.”

Hang in there!
 
When finances allow you and your husband to live a bit further from your in-laws, I’d seriously consider it. In the meantime, at least you can have some peace on your side of the wall by, with God’s help, “accepting the things you cannot change; having the courage to change the things you can, and being given the wisdom to know the difference.”

Hang in there!
Yes, I think I’m finally beginning to understand the true meaning of that prayer. I do feel it will be time for me to set important boundaries when my husband and her inevitably patch things up. I need to learn how to set boundaries with her without drama.

I honestly won’t mind if we sell the house and move. Worse things could happen and I’m a firm believer that we are often hit with blessings in disguise.
 
Yes, I think I’m finally beginning to understand the true meaning of that prayer. I do feel it will be time for me to set important boundaries when my husband and her inevitably patch things up. I need to learn how to set boundaries with her without drama.

I honestly won’t mind if we sell the house and move. Worse things could happen and I’m a firm believer that we are often hit with blessings in disguise.
I think that after you move I would expect her to complain about her new neighbors as if they were your fault, and I think in that place I would feel free to respond by thanking Heaven for getting me out of that building. But that’s just me…I will only live in a “plex” or and apartment again if finances dictate that I need to. Good fences make good neighbors!! When it comes to close relatives, the other side of the same town is not too far to set as a minimum distance, not by any means.
 
As you read it, if you realize that it is the drama queen/king in your life who is the co-dependent, remember this: You can’t “fix” him or her. You can only act in a healthy way around the person yourself, and give the person openings to choose to do the same and validation when they do. The rest is up to them. If you forget that, you’ll get sucked right back into their drama cycle.
This advice is so great. I did a search for family drama (because we’re going through it and are the target for everyone’s sarcasm and criticism right now) and was so happy to find this thread. I will be mentioning this advice to my husband when I get home.

It’s something we know and have been working through (his family is big time co-dependent and dramatic) and my husband has come a long way from allowing them to manipulate him but it does bug me a lot and so I need the advice. I do struggle with wanting family to like me (I no longer care about non-family opinion of me which is a big step for me since I was always a people pleaser growing up) but the in-laws, that I am working on.

I have seen how drama affects families (my dad’s family, it has sometimes caused years-long silent treatments, something I always thought was wrong) and when it comes to terminally ill family member (as in the case we are dealing with right now) I find that there are a lot of assumptions and a lot of unsaid expectations on others. So, again, thank you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top