Human bodies in heaven?

Status
Not open for further replies.

The_Reginator

Active member
I thought I had a bit of a revelation a year or so ago.
I was reflecting on the Apostles Creed and something from a university course came back to me.

From the Apostles Creed:
…
I believe in the Holy Spirit,
the holy catholic Church,
the communion of saints,
the forgiveness of sins,
the resurrection of the body,
and life everlasting. Amen.
I recall the professor of this particular religion course pointing out that Christians have a different belief than eastern religions which stress the existence of the spirit only (often as us becoming part of ‘the great spirit’.) Christians however profess to believe in the resurrection of the body.

So for some time now I’ve been thinking that the Second Person of the Holy Trinity has a human body. That Jesus’ resurrected and glorified body ascended into heaven and is ‘still’ there.
And Mary’s too.
(At the Transfiguration the apostles Peter, James, and John saw Moses and Elias on the mountain top.)

Others here at CAF have been insisting that God is purely spirit and that there are no human bodies in heaven, only our spirits.

What does the Church teach us on this? I’ve had a quick look at the Catechism but I couldn’t find the answer.

Thanks, Reg.
 
**This is my understanding. At this moment and until the Second Coming, there are two human bodies in heaven, Jesus Christ and the Blessed Virgin Mary.

One of my most spiritually profound images is when I pray to Mary I know she can take her hand and touch her Son’s arm or shoulder and plead on my behalf.
**
 
Indeed the only two bodies in heaven right now (If you can say right now, since there is no time in heaven), are Our Lord and Saviour and his most Blessed Virgin Mother, Our Lady.
 
**This is my understanding. At this moment and until the Second Coming, there are two human bodies in heaven, Jesus Christ and the Blessed Virgin Mary.

One of my most spiritually profound images is when I pray to Mary I know she can take her hand and touch her Son’s arm or shoulder and plead on my behalf.
**
👍
 
Others here at CAF have been insisting that God is purely spirit and that there are no human bodies in heaven, only our spirits.

What does the Church teach us on this? I’ve had a quick look at the Catechism but I couldn’t find the answer.
REGARDING THE PRESENCE OF JESUS’ BODY IN HEAVEN:
The Divine Nature of God is pure/ly spirit. But the 2nd Person in the Trinity assumed a human nature in addition to His Divine Nature. So Jesus’ Divine nature is pure spirit and His human nature is both spirit (human soul) and material (human body). It was His human nature that underwent death (separation of human body and human soul) and was resurrected (reunion of body and soul).

CCC 626 Since the “Author of life” who was killed is the same “living one [who has] risen”, The divine person of the Son of God necessarily continued to possess his human soul and body, separated from each other by death:
By the fact that at Chnst’s death his soul was separated from his flesh, his one person is not itself divided into two persons; for the human body and soul of Christ have existed in the same way from the beginning of his earthly existence, in the divine person of the Word; and in death, although separated from each other, both remained with one and the same person of the Word.
vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P1P.HTM
(It would be good to read all four paragraphs: #625-628)

Jesus ascended into heaven with both His natures.
CCC #659 …Jesus’ final apparition ends with the** irreversible entry of his humanity into divine glory**, …where He is seated from that time forward at God’s right hand. …

#663 Henceforth Christ is seated at the right hand of the Father: “By ‘the Father’s right hand’ we understand the glory and honor of divinity, where he who exists as Son of God before all ages, indeed as God, of one being with the Father,** is seated bodily after he became incarnate and his flesh was glorified**.”
vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P1T.HTM

REGARDING THE PRESENCE OF OUR BODIES IN HEAVEN (or hell):
CCC #997 In death, the separation of the souls from the body, the human body decays and the soul goes to meet God, while awaiting its reunion with its glorified body. God in his almight power, will definitively grant incorruptible life to our bodies by reuniting them with our souls, through the power of Jesus’ Ressurection

#998 Who will rise? All the dead will rise, “those who have done good, to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil, to the resurrection of judgment.”
vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/__P2H.HTM
(Again, it would be good to read the whole section - #988 thru 1004)
 
Indeed the only two bodies in heaven right now (If you can say right now, since there is no time in heaven), are Our Lord and Saviour and his most Blessed Virgin Mother, Our Lady.
Erm… Enoch and Elijah? That’s four…
 
**
Erm… Enoch and Elijah? That’s four…
**

IMHO I do not believe we can be assured of this…it iis part of the of the OT when the gates of heaven were still closed. My question would be…if Enoch and Elijah were in heaven…how would that affect our salvation? Why would these two OT figures impact us today?

I firmly believe that the ONLY two humans that matter in the salvation story are Jesus and Mary…not Enoch and Elijah. Are they important…YES…are they central to our salvation…no.
 
**
IMHO I do not believe we can be assured of this…it iis part of the of the OT when the gates of heaven were still closed. My question would be…if Enoch and Elijah were in heaven…how would that affect our salvation? Why would these two OT figures impact us today?

I firmly believe that the ONLY two humans that matter in the salvation story are Jesus and Mary…not Enoch and Elijah. Are they important…YES…are they central to our salvation…no.**
You raise a good point too, but now I’m stuck in the middle:o

Could it be that they are in Limbo? (even though that’s purely a concept?)

I just recently listened to the good Fr Mitch Pacwa speak about the end times, specifically in Revelations.

He talks about how Enoch and Elijah are still living…they’re alive, somewhere! Now, I suppose someone could assume they’re in heaven, as I have. Or, one could assume they’re living underground in Israel, or in some remote destination/island that human geography has looked over time and time again.

Now, the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church has never defined anything dogmatically regarding Elijah and Enoch.

However, the book of Sirach (44:16) says “Henoch pleased God, and was translated into paradise, that he may give repentance to the nations.” And regarding Elijah, the fourth book of Kings (2:11) says “And as they went on, walking and talking together, behold a fiery chariot, and fiery horses parted them both asunder: and Elias went up by a whirlwind into heaven.”.

Two of those could be interpreted as meaning their bodies ascended into Heaven, or that their souls did. But, I would like for a Priest to answer as to what one it is, or if you can find a reference from a Priest/scholar/Saint regarding the matter, please do! 🙂
 
Two of those could be interpreted as meaning their bodies ascended into Heaven, or that their souls did. But, I would like for a Priest to answer as to what one it is, or if you can find a reference from a Priest/scholar/Saint regarding the matter, please do! 🙂
If their souls acended into heaven and not their bodies wouldn’t that mean they died ?
 
Right, that’s what confuses me.
At the Transfiguration Our Lord was accompanied by Elijah and Moses. No one believes Moses went straight to Heaven, yet there he was, WITH Elijah, speaking with the Lord. That speaks volumes to me. IOW, there is place, maybe what we used to call Limbo (limbus Patrem,) where the OT saints waited for the coming Messiah. The Biblical account of Enoch and Elijah being swooped up into heaven, may have been accurate for that Covenant. We can also see in Our Lord’s parable of Lazarus and the rich man, that Lazarus is in the bosom of Abraham (their way of describing a final reward.) Lazarus finds comfort and peace here (even if it is not heaven.)
 
Erm… Enoch and Elijah? That’s four…
And I believe Moses is also a possibility. Deuteronomy says that God buried him and no man has ever seen his tomb. And he was present at the transfiguration. So that might make 5.

As to the OP post. I don’t know who on CAF says that there are no human bodies in Heaven. That is certainly a mistaken notion.

I would add, that it seems to me that Heaven and Hell both most have some type of physical (is temporal the right word?) existence, it is not just a spiritual place or “state” (such as purgatory);since bodies do reside in Heaven, and they will reside in Hell.
 
IMHO I do not believe we can be assured of this…it iis part of the of the OT when the gates of heaven were still closed. My question would be…if Enoch and Elijah were in heaven…how would that affect our salvation? Why would these two OT figures impact us today?
nonetheless, the scriptures record that Enoch and Elijah are in heaven, as per God’s keeping His promises of the old covenant, which was and remains valid, even if fulfilled.

Furthermore, Enoch and Elijah BOTH play involved roles in the salvation narrative. As to their return, this was, according to the Catholic Encyclopedia, a near unanimous belief held by the church fathers. Among assertions towards Enoch and Elijah, Elijah will announce the second coming of the messiah and Enoch will enumerate the judgements of God upon the unGodly (from the epistle of St Jude).

As to your question of why two old testament figures would impact us today… WHAT??? Really? Are you not aware that the new covenant and the old covenant are intricately connected? That the New Covenant is the perfection and fulfillment of the Old? That the continuity of God’s plan extends from the very moment of creation all the way to the final judgement???

**
I firmly believe that the ONLY two humans that matter in the salvation story are Jesus and Mary…not Enoch and Elijah. Are they important…YES…are they central to our salvation…no.
**

The only two people that matter in the salvation story are Jesus and Mary? What church teaching says that??? What about David, Moses, Noah, Elijah, Abraham, John the Baptist, Adam, Eve, and the bevvy of other actors of the old testament upon which the plan of God was advanced towards God’s ultimate plan of salvation for man? To discard the old covenant and God’s chosen prophets, judges, kings, and servants this way is beyond the pale…
 
A fascinating statement on this subject was made by a Dr. Richard Eby during one of those near death experiences!

near-death.com/forum/nde/000/91.html
“Lord Jesus, why am I now a neuter? I was a man.”
"Yes, Dick, you were always a man, a child of God who returned our love by telling others of the good news about me. Remember? You read in my book the very first order I gave to Adam and Eve: �Be fruitful and multiply!’ I told them to replenish the Earth, not heaven. Again I told the Sadducees (who did not believe in a resurrection) that they �knew not the scriptures’ when they speculated about wives in heaven. I explained that after resurrection all would be like angels who do not marry nor raise families. Everything in heaven is created or re-created into perfection! It is all in my book. None other is truth!
“In fact, everything that my children need to know about how God thinks and works and judges and rewards, either before or after the cross, is already in my book. That is why I commanded mankind to �engrave my words upon their hearts,’ and to pass them along from generation to generation. I wanted everyone to hear and know just who I AM, the Messiah, their one hope of salvation, their most high God.”
I checked my body again: truly celestial! Its senses were too keen to describe.
(Weightless, painless, instantly responsive. Comfortable and totally peaceful. Unaware of any disharmony elsewhere. Thinking with the mind of Christ. Sensing that I was IN him somehow).
He had said so clearly, “I and the Father are one.”
He had prayed so fervently “that they all may be one, as thou, Father, art in me, and I in thee; that they may be also one in us!,” the Father declared it done!
 
Other than the special few people who were assumed up to Heaven in their bodies, everybody else is waiting for the general Resurrection, when they will receive glorified bodies.

(Well, not very glorified bodies in the case of people in Hell, who are being resurrected just to get their judgment and go back to Hell.)

There’s absolutely no reason to think that glorified bodies will be neuter, either. Humans will be busy doing other stuff than sex; but certainly God didn’t create us male and female at the very beginning just to undo it at the end. If God wanted our bodies to be neuter, He just would have created us as big ol’ amoebas.
 
And I believe Moses is also a possibility. Deuteronomy says that God buried him and no man has ever seen his tomb. And he was present at the transfiguration. So that might make 5.

As to the OP post. I don’t know who on CAF says that there are no human bodies in Heaven. That is certainly a mistaken notion.

I would add, that it seems to me that Heaven and Hell both most have some type of physical (is temporal the right word?) existence, it is not just a spiritual place or “state” (such as purgatory);since bodies do reside in Heaven, and they will reside in Hell.
Jude 1:9 Yet the archangel Michael, when he argued with the devil in a dispute over the body of Moses, did not venture to pronounce a reviling judgment upon him but said, “May the Lord rebuke you!”*
 
I would add, that it seems to me that Heaven and Hell both most have some type of physical (is temporal the right word?) existence, it is not just a spiritual place or “state” (such as purgatory);since bodies do reside in Heaven, and they will reside in Hell.
Are we so sure that Heaven and Hell are physical? Is heaven somewhere, in the sense of physics’ understanding of the structure of the universe (e.g., linked space-time)? I’d be afraid to suggest that Heaven and Hell operate according to the physical laws of the universe. They may not have any physicality which our minds could actually understand (in that our brains are wired to interpret our 3-dimensional vision and perceive time as a 1-dimensional unidirectional flow).

Concepts of “space,” “time,” “existence,” and “matter” are very much contingent on how physics works. Under General Relativity, space is the product of matter and energy. I don’t want to suggest that Heaven needs to have the same type of matter and energy that we find in our universe. I don’t think Heaven or Hell need to be comprised of any matter that regularly interacts with our universe (else, humanity might someday “detect” it using space telescopes).

In that regard, I don’t know if/how a physical body could enter heaven. A “glorified” body, or “spiritual body” probably would not operate on the same principles as our present bodies. Christ’s Ascension, for example, didn’t just take him up into the sky… it’s not like he was beaming up to the Mothership.

Entering heaven or hell seems like it must involve a departure from the fundamental makeup of our world, and looking and perceiving with whole new senses. How the bodies of humans, already mentioned, would enter heaven is beyond me.

I’d like to ask whether one of the thieves with whom Christ was crucified might also be in heaven. Luke 23:43 is where Christ says to one of the criminals, “today you will be with me in paradise.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top