The_Reginator
Active member
Another music thread.
This quote “hymns which are doctrinally sound and which amplify the awesomeness of the rite” got me to start a new thread.
(See forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=389673&page=5)
What hymns would you suggest?
This quote “hymns which are doctrinally sound and which amplify the awesomeness of the rite” got me to start a new thread.
(See forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=389673&page=5)
Layman
Regular Member
Join Date: June 30, 2008
Location: London, UK.
Posts: 968
Religion: Catholic
Default Re: Some new contemporary church songs you hate?
Hymns with questionable, Protestant or vague lyrics should be dumped. Fidelity to Church doctrine should outweigh sentiment.
Someone mentioned the Lord Of The Dance. When I heard it, as a young Irish Catholic nerd, I always thought it sounded a bit pagan; like Krishna or Pan was the lord that that was dancing. It’s more in keeping with what a pagan god would do. It doesn’t mention Jesus by name, either. I don’t like the image of Jesus dancing: “Ha ha, I’m about to be cruelly executed, but I’ll keep on boogying!”. It’s garbage, upon reflection.
“To use hymns that amplify the awesomeness of the rite” is really important to me.Less cheese, please! I think nice, sentimental hymns appeal to the ladies in the congregation, who tend to be in the majority, but if you want to convert sinners I think it would be better to use hymns which are doctrinally sound and which amplify the awesomeness of the rite; a propitiary sacrifice rather than a “we’re all saved now” celebration.
What hymns would you suggest?