Hypothetical question: Godparents

  • Thread starter Thread starter AlieMarie728
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AlieMarie728

Guest
Hypothetically speaking, if my husband and I had a child and a) everyone on his side of his family is non-Catholic or not practicing any religion of any kind; b) both of my siblings were baptized and raised Catholic but no longer attend church (not even on Christmas and/or Easter) and c) we have no practicing Catholic friends, whom would we be able to choose to be godparents to that child?
 
🍿 I was thinking of this the other day. I do have some cousins that are Catholic. We aren’t close. Like, we hang out at the family reunion, but we didn’t grow up together or anything like that. It would be nice to know what to do. 🙂
 
Hypothetically speaking, if my husband and I had a child and a) everyone on his side of his family is non-Catholic or not practicing any religion of any kind; b) both of my siblings were baptized and raised Catholic but no longer attend church (not even on Christmas and/or Easter) and c) we have no practicing Catholic friends, whom would we be able to choose to be godparents to that child?
The most devout man and/or woman in your parish.
 
Hypothetically speaking, if my husband and I had a child and a) everyone on his side of his family is non-Catholic or not practicing any religion of any kind; b) both of my siblings were baptized and raised Catholic but no longer attend church (not even on Christmas and/or Easter) and c) we have no practicing Catholic friends, whom would we be able to choose to be godparents to that child?
if you cannot find a friend or family member that is a “practicing Catholic” they will probably assign you one…

hopefully if your a registered Parishioner that is involved somewhat you should have some friends there that are able to fit the bill -

This same thing happened with me and my wife, luckily my wifes friend happened to be a practicing Catholic - reunited their old friendship and now she is the Godmother of my Daughter.
 
In choosing to have your child baptized in the Catholic church, you are consecrating that child to God and agreeing to raise him or her in the Catholic faith. The choice of Godparents is an important one, they must be practicing Catholics, firm in their faith, as they are agreeing to insure your child is educated in the faith in the event that you and your spouse are unable to do so.
As you attend Mass regularly (also a condition of having a child baptized), you may meet and get to know other young parents who are strong in their faith. Also your priest may have some suggestions for choosing Godparents. While it would be nice to include family members,if they are not practicing they are definately not a prospective Godparents.
I will pray for you as you discern and discuss, and pray that family members return to th "One Holy Catholic and Apostolic church. God Bless You.:blessyou:
 
In choosing to have your child baptized in the Catholic church, you are consecrating that child to God and agreeing to raise him or her in the Catholic faith. The choice of Godparents is an important one, they must be practicing Catholics, firm in their faith, as they are agreeing to insure your child is educated in the faith in the event that you and your spouse are unable to do so.
As you attend Mass regularly (also a condition of having a child baptized), you may meet and get to know other young parents who are strong in their faith. Also your priest may have some suggestions for choosing Godparents. While it would be nice to include family members,if they are not practicing they are definately not a prospective Godparents.
I will pray for you as you discern and discuss, and pray that family members return to th "One Holy Catholic and Apostolic church. God Bless You.:blessyou:
I agree with this. If I had been Catholic when my daughter was born, I would have probably searched out someone with a strong faith that wouldn’t miind being a godparent. Actually, I think two, a man and a woman, are usually picked. Perferably someone who wouldn’t mind being named in a will as to who would get custod of the child if anything happens to you.
 
The most devout man and/or woman in your parish.
This issue came up when we were trying to have children. ^^^THIS was my answer to the problem. I would have insisted on asking my best friend to be godmother, because she is the most faith Catholic woman I know and would have been very active in the child’s faith life.
 
I think I have a problem plucking someone I don’t know out of the parish. I don’t want some strange person taking care of my child if I die.
 
I think I have a problem plucking someone I don’t know out of the parish. I don’t want some strange person taking care of my child if I die.
I would not be comfortable with a stranger either, but being a godparent does not mean you assume the responsibility for a child if both parents die. That is a separate legal issue.
 
In choosing to have your child baptized in the Catholic church, you are consecrating that child to God and agreeing to raise him or her in the Catholic faith. The choice of Godparents is an important one, they must be practicing Catholics, firm in their faith, as they are agreeing to insure your child is educated in the faith in the event that you and your spouse are unable to do so.
As you attend Mass regularly (also a condition of having a child baptized), you may meet and get to know other young parents who are strong in their faith. Also your priest may have some suggestions for choosing Godparents. While it would be nice to include family members,if they are not practicing they are definately not a prospective Godparents.
I will pray for you as you discern and discuss, and pray that family members return to th "One Holy Catholic and Apostolic church. God Bless You.:blessyou:
I would not be comfortable with a stranger either, but being a godparent does not mean you assume the responsibility for a child if both parents die. That is a separate legal issue.
So, basically a godparent is just for show? They would vow to help instruct the child just for the ceremony? If we don’t that seriously, then why would anyone take any other sacrament seriously?
 
I think I have a problem plucking someone I don’t know out of the parish. I don’t want some strange person taking care of my child if I die.
Then get to know some people in your parish. You have 9 months’ warning that your child is going to need godparents. If you are a practicing Catholic and you don’t know any practicing Catholics, you’re doing it wrong.
 
So, basically a godparent is just for show? They would vow to help instruct the child just for the ceremony? If we don’t that seriously, then why would anyone take any other sacrament seriously?
Jackie means that the godparents do not automatically assume legal or custodial responsibility for the child, as is often believed to be the case. The parents could choose godparents with that transfer of custody in mind, but it would have to be executed by a separate legal document; it is not presumed in the law. The godparents are still bound before God to assist the parents or guardians in raising the child in the Catholic faith to the extent they are able.
 
So, basically a godparent is just for show? They would vow to help instruct the child just for the ceremony? If we don’t that seriously, then why would anyone take any other sacrament seriously?
They are supposed to support the parents in raising the child in the faith. They have no legal standing and do not necessarily take on the care of the child should both parents die. That is a separate issue that the parents need to arrange for via a will.

And, the appointment of Godparents is not a sacrament. The baptism itself is. No one suggested we not take the sacrament of baptism seriously!
 
Then get to know some people in your parish. You have 9 months’ warning that your child is going to need godparents. If you are a practicing Catholic and you don’t know any practicing Catholics, you’re doing it wrong.
Seeing that I’m just in RCIA, I’m not a Catholic yet. Isn’t RCIA a time to ask these type of questions? Thanks for assuming I’m doing it all wrong when I haven’t even gotten started.
 
They are supposed to support the parents in raising the child in the faith. They have no legal standing and do not necessarily take on the care of the child should both parents die. That is a separate issue that the parents need to arrange for via a will.

And, the appointment of Godparents is not a sacrament. The baptism itself is. No one suggested we not take the sacrament of baptism seriously!
The point of godparents is for the sacrament of baptism. To be assigned a godparent at random does seem like it isn’t taken seriously. I do understand that it is a seperate issue. One would assume that those who promised to help with the child would also be the ones in the will. That really couldn’t be if the person was picked at random.
 
Seeing that I’m just in RCIA, I’m not a Catholic yet. Isn’t RCIA a time to ask these type of questions? Thanks for assuming I’m doing it all wrong when I haven’t even gotten started.
If you’re in RCIA, you’ve already been involved in the parish for months and you know other practicing Catholics or soon-to-be Catholics. Besides, we’re talking about a hypothetical situation - the “you” was generic.
 
My son has a Catholic godmother and a Lutheran godfather. My daughter only has a Catholic godfather. No godmother.

We just don’t have many Catholic friends, and most of our relatives are out of the questions. If we are blessed with more kids we will need to start repeating God parents.

Posted from Catholic.com App for Android
 
The point of godparents is for the sacrament of baptism. To be assigned a godparent at random does seem like it isn’t taken seriously. I do understand that it is a seperate issue. One would assume that those who promised to help with the child would also be the ones in the will. That really couldn’t be if the person was picked at random.
I would definitely not assume that. I have four (almost 5) kids, and they all have different godparents. Surely, my kids would not go 5 separate ways if my husband and I were to die! They would remain together. Some of my kids godparents are too old or too young to take on my children, and some are not suited to parenthood. My sister and brother in law would get my kids if we died. They are cafeteria catholics, but they are the reasonable choice because they are also raising kids right now, live in our city, are willing to take in all five, and are closest to my kids.
 
The point of godparents is for the sacrament of baptism. To be assigned a godparent at random does seem like it isn’t taken seriously. I do understand that it is a seperate issue. One would assume that those who promised to help with the child would also be the ones in the will. That really couldn’t be if the person was picked at random.
There is no such assumption. I don’t know anybody who has the same godparents for all their kids, and who would want to send every kid to a different house if both parents died? Or in the case of my oldest son, whose godfather is a priest, he could certainly not be expected to take custody of his godson. The godparents would simply be made aware of where the kids are living and who is now raising them, and keep in contact, be spiritual mentors, and continue to pray for their godchildren and encourage them in the faith. A godparent not previously known to the parents before baptism would still incur a spiritual relationship with the family by virtue of being godparents (both the parents and the godparents have to consent anyway, so you can’t be forced to have any particular person as godparent) and presumably that relationship would deepen as time goes by and the godparents become part of the child’s spiritual life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top