Hypothetical Question re: sex change

  • Thread starter Thread starter JMKC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JMKC

Guest
This is an unusual hypothetical question. Let’s say a man and woman marry. Years later, the man decides to get a sex change. Eventually, he realizes his fault and he and his wife reconcile. Would they be able to have sexual relations despite the fact that he doesn’t have the proper part to engage in full intercourse?
 
This is an unusual hypothetical question. Let’s say a man and woman marry. Years later, the man decides to get a sex change. Eventually, he realizes his fault and he and his wife reconcile. Would they be able to have sexual relations despite the fact that he doesn’t have the proper part to engage in full intercourse?
How would they have sexual relations if he has effectively amputated his genitals?
 
Since the church does and always did and always will consider him a MAN…yes!

.
What the Church considers isn’t relevant in this case. If he no longer has “the proper part to engage in full intercourse” then intercourse is not possible.
 
Makes sense. A different hypothetical scenario, then. What if both spouses had surgeries so that intercourse was possible, but in reverse. Would this be a valid conjugal union, or would the previous surgeries, though regretted, render the act immoral?
 
Makes sense. A different hypothetical scenario, then. What if both spouses had surgeries so that intercourse was possible, but in reverse. Would this be a valid conjugal union, or would the previous surgeries, though regretted, render the act immoral?
No, it would not be possible for them to engage in properly ordered sexual intercourse. One must remember that marital intimacy is not an “anything goes” endeavor. It is always subordinated to the requirement that each act be per se apt for generation of life.

The man lacks a penis and cannot ejaculate, the woman lacks a vagina, and therefore a completed act of intercourse cannot occur in such a situation.
 
No, mutual masturbation without actual sex (an act open to the creation of life) is not allowable for Catholics.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top