I am in dire need of relationship help. Please

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholicismtrue
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Catholicismtrue

Guest
Hello everyone, for about the past month or so I have been greatly struggling. I haven’t been attending mass regularly since last summer, and I have not been to confession since before last Easter. I have no excuse. Please, read and consider everything I say if you have it in your heart to do so, because I do not know where else to turn to. It is quite a complex situation.

My girlfriend and I are both sophomores in college. We have been dating since our junior year of high school. A little background on us, would be that neither of us had any sort of relationship before our current one. We were good friends for several months before dating. We decided during our senior year that we were considering ourselves to be together in the long term, always discussing the possibilities of marriage and such, therefore we decided to go to the same University together.

My background is pretty normal. I was an emotionless dude with no problems whatsoever who ended up really discovering and growing into his Catholic faith about the same time that me and my girlfriend became friends. My girlfriend however, comes from a very troubled background. Her parents, while “strong” Catholics who always attend mass regularly and brought her up in the faith and always had her go above and beyond in youth ministry and such throughout her childhood, have a completely broken marriage "for reasons still somewhat unclear), are not married in the Catholic Church (her father had a previous marriage which ended with his wife cheating on him and he and my girlfriend’s mother were married in the chapel of the hospital where they worked), and more importantly, her father has been extremely emotionally abusive and neglectful towards her for her entire life, leading her to develop severe problems such as anxiety, depression, and especially IBS which prevented her for the longest time from being able to travel and do many things (although anti depression medicine for anxiety and other things have since helped heal a fair amount of this anxiety and enabled her to do much more with her life), with it being the leading reason why she was obligated to go to the state university close to her house (with me choosing to do the same with not wanting to abandon her in he time of need).

I knew about these problems before we started dating, and especially the first several months when we were dating when her behavior could be extremely erratic and “up and down,” such as inexplicably acting out in order to see if I will “continue to love her” in some ways. As a patient man with a well brought up childhood and loving parents, I was always able to continue to love and care for her, which she always greatly appreciated.

Our first year of college came, and I lived on campus while she commuted from her house, and it was tough, especially for her. With help from her medicine, she finally had enough gone of her anxiety and decided that she would be able to move out of her house and onto the college campus where I would be also. However, at the beginning of this year, both of our families became in dire financial straights and we would be unable to afford to live in dorms, nor did either of us really have anyone who we knew that we could try and pay for an apartment with. I decided to live at my house, and, because I wanted her to finally be able to escape the abuse and pain of her home as well as living conveniently closer to our university, my parents decided to invite her to live with us as well. I decided to sacrifice my room for her, while I made myself a room in our basement, and we’ve lived, as, in “Catholic terms;” “brothers and sisters” ever since. We are both virgins, there is no temptation, discussion, or anything sexual between us, and is not part of the problem at all, so please continue before making any assumptions.

In the past month or so though, I’ve been bombarded by thoughts of unhappiness, and I believe it is because of my relationship. For the first time in almost 3 years, I decided to finally open up to friends, and tell them how I feel about my relationship. Essentially, how I feel, is that despite all I’ve been through with her, all the struggles we’ve overcome, all that I’ve helped her through, all the progress she’s made, I don’t think I want to be with her forever anymore, that is- I don’t want to get married. She is not a bad person, and in fact has probably had quite a good impact on me and taught me a lot about life. But I feel as though I’ve lost my passionate love for her, I don’t always want to be around her, I don’t want her hugging me, I just feel like I want space (one friend described it as being as though I have become sort of a “father figure” to her that she never had). I feel as though more I am burdened by all that we have been through, and somewhat damaged. Before our relationship, I never suffered from depression, struggled with my weight, overeating, possibly developed IBS as well, all things that have appeared within the past year or so. I just feel as though I need a change.
 
I had always told myself that the constant up and downs our relationship, all her emotional struggles, were all just part of bearing my cross, and I needed to ignore my desires, which are selfish, because I could bear this cross. My friends feel that I am far too young to feel like this at the age of 19. That I feel like my relationship is more reflective of that of someone at the age of 30, married or something. I feel so selfish to feel like I want deep down inside to be single, because I feel like it is my obligation to care for her regardless of whether I have a sort of “passionate love” for her or that she “makes me constantly happy,” because life isn’t fun and games and I made a commitment to her and that one day after college I will just HAVE to marry her and you know, start having sex. I have talked to many friends about this and they feel like it would be in my best interest to break up with her- that I “deserve to be happy.” But what am I supposed to do, just go up to her one of these days soon and say “I want to break up with you because I am not happy with you and feel like I have been negatively impacted by your reactions to all the abusive you’ve endured in your life- please pack up your things, leave, and return to live in your abusive house and digress from all the progress that you’ve made with becoming happy?” I am going to study abroad next year and plan on leaving for the whole year, so I considered waiting until the end of this semester to break up because she plans on getting her own apartment for the school year next year when I will be gone which would make things a lot easier and not involve an awkward situation of her having to grab all her things and leave as soon as possible, but my friends say that it is necessary to break up as soon as possible and that there is no “good” way to do it and that, the longer I wait, the more attached she will become.

I feel weighed down by the probable unhappiness that my relationship has caused me. But my question, is it, acceptable, is it, CHRISTIAN, is it, HUMANE, to have a desire to be out of a relationship with someone who is victim of severe abuse simply because a lot of the way they act because of their abuse has possibly damaged me? Am I a coward who refuses to bear a cross that he in some ways made a commitment to carry? Is it “ok” to eventually have different feelings about a relationship and want to end it, even if marriage and future was always considered? Yes, I know you should probably never live with someone before marriage, but you know what, I was concerned for her well being and gave her an escape from the pain and abuse of her households, and it never led to anything questionable such as premarital sex or anything. I feel weighed down and dragged down by all of this and I can hardly bring it to myself to go to mass, let alone confession possibly because I feel like I am living a lie to myself, to God. If anything, I want to please God and show contrition for my sins, and to love and respect my friends and family, and even though my girlfriend has improved much over the years I just feel like I need something different in my life, change. Is it OK that I feel like this? Is it OK that I want to pursue happiness through possibly the single celibate life? Please consider my situation and offer me whatever help you can my brothers and sisters.

Sincerely,
Struggling, God Fearing young man
 
My only advice is to stop talking to “many friends” about this and find a trusted older adult for guidance. The average or even above average 19 year old can’t help you with this, and by running to them you are running the risk of humiliating her.

Go to a priest, parent, counselor or professor that you’re close to.
 
You have a lot of emotions and a lot of guilt. I suggest you talk to a couselor-- perferrably a Catholic one or your priest.

First do not consider for one minute a falling on the sword to marry her and “bear your cross”. This is uncalled for. It is harmful both to you AND to her. She deserves a husband who loves her with all his heart, as you deserve a wife who loves you and that you love in return. Youthful promises of marriage some day are NOT to be taken seriously. If you truly feel you are not called to marriage with her, then do not marry her out of sympathy or guilt.

You need some space. Talk with your parents to see what their guidance is. Taking a break from dating does not mean you must toss her out on the street or back to her abusive environment. You have discovered why it is a bad idea to get both emotionally and financially entagled with someone you are not married to. Your parents invited her into their home, ask their advice on slowing things down emotionally.

Both of you need time to mature. Perhaps your future is together, perhaps it is not.

It is NOT wrong to want to be happy. It is NOT wrong to want to explore other options. It is NOT wrong for a 19 year old to need some space and independence, nor to realize that you are not ready for marriage.
 
You have a lot of emotions and a lot of guilt. I suggest you talk to a couselor-- perferrably a Catholic one or your priest.

First do not consider for one minute a falling on the sword to marry her and “bear your cross”. This is uncalled for. It is harmful both to you AND to her. She deserves a husband who loves her with all his heart, as you deserve a wife who loves you and that you love in return. Youthful promises of marriage some day are NOT to be taken seriously. If you truly feel you are not called to marriage with her, then do not marry her out of sympathy or guilt.

You need some space. Talk with your parents to see what their guidance is. Taking a break from dating does not mean you must toss her out on the street or back to her abusive environment. You have discovered why it is a bad idea to get both emotionally and financially entagled with someone you are not married to. Your parents invited her into their home, ask their advice on slowing things down emotionally.

Both of you need time to mature. Perhaps your future is together, perhaps it is not.

It is NOT wrong to want to be happy. It is NOT wrong to want to explore other options. It is NOT wrong for a 19 year old to need some space and independence, nor to realize that you are not ready for marriage.
^ This.

You got into a relationship of “helper” and you have burned out. She is not helping you, she is draining you. Not intentionally, but people who have been abused and are not able to truly participate in a whole relationship just do that. She will never actually be entirely whole. I know that sounds grim, but it’s just the truth. She can heal, but she will have to do that through therapy and a relationship with God. You can’t heal her wounds by being nice to her, by loving her, God forbid, by marrying her.

You inferred here: (with me choosing to do the same with not wanting to abandon her in he time of need). that you even chose your college because of her. This was not a good choice and I am surprised that your parents allowed it.

I do urge you not to talk to your friends, however. Or if you do, take their opinions with a large salt block, because they don’t know any better than you do, how to handle this sort of thing. Their opinions are coming from as uninformed a place as you’re in. “Getting this over with as soon as possible,” that’s going to cause so much disruption and pain. I think your plan of getting distance once you are abroad and she is out of your parents’ home is a wise one. In the meantime, you can pull back very gently and perhaps begin to mention discerning a vocation. But do go slowly. Just don’t move the relationship forward for now. And talk to your parents about it. They may have some suggestions, knowing the 2 of you, that we here on the forum can’t see.

Just knowing that you are under no obligation to marry her should help free up some of your energy. You are not trapped. And welcome to CAF!!!
 
You have a lot of emotions and a lot of guilt. I suggest you talk to a couselor-- perferrably a Catholic one or your priest.

First do not consider for one minute a falling on the sword to marry her and “bear your cross”. This is uncalled for. It is harmful both to you AND to her. She deserves a husband who loves her with all his heart, as you deserve a wife who loves you and that you love in return. Youthful promises of marriage some day are NOT to be taken seriously. If you truly feel you are not called to marriage with her, then do not marry her out of sympathy or guilt.

You need some space. Talk with your parents to see what their guidance is. Taking a break from dating does not mean you must toss her out on the street or back to her abusive environment. You have discovered why it is a bad idea to get both emotionally and financially entagled with someone you are not married to. Your parents invited her into their home, ask their advice on slowing things down emotionally.

Both of you need time to mature. Perhaps your future is together, perhaps it is not.

It is NOT wrong to want to be happy. It is NOT wrong to want to explore other options. It is NOT wrong for a 19 year old to need some space and independence, nor to realize that you are not ready for marriage.
You have reason about the whole “tangled” part. I think it would be best for me to try and receive counselig from a priest, there are least two that I know well enough to do thst, one of whom actually knew my gilfriend from youth ministry in high school. i think it would be good because i can trust the advice of a holy man more than my own intuition. is it ok to asks proests about this stuff or is it not important because were not married…?
 
You have reason about the whole “tangled” part. I think it would be best for me to try and receive counselig from a priest, there are least two that I know well enough to do thst, one of whom actually knew my gilfriend from youth ministry in high school. i think it would be good because i can trust the advice of a holy man more than my own intuition. is it ok to asks proests about this stuff or is it not important because were not married…?
Priests do talk to single people about things like this! 🙂 And other stuff…You can talk to your priest about ANYTHING, good or bad or in between.

👍
 
1ke gave you an excellent advice here, which is: talk to your parents. They know best than you. And yes, you must talk to a priest (a solid, balanced, orthodox priest, if possible) about this situation, and tell him what you’ve told us and it would be a plus if you could also tell the priest your parent’s opinion.

If you need anything from a fellow struggling catholic young man, feel free to PM me. I’ll pray for you.
 
The feelings you’re describing concerning needing space may be gifts of discernment from the Holy Spirit that you are not ready for marriage. Few nineteen year olds are, especially if they still have a formal education to pursue and a career to launch. Regardless of the dynamics of the specific relationship, it’s not a good idea to date exclusively unless you are really ready to get married in the next several months or so. From what you’ve said here, you’re not, and from what you’ve described of her, she isn’t either.

I do agree that it’s a good idea to sit down with a trusted adult, a parent, a teacher, a priest, whoever, to sort out your feelings about breaking it off, and exactly how to do that in a kind manner. Marriages getting their start in pity for the spouse rarely survive: Sooner or later, the spouse recognized that (s)he isn’t loved in the same way that married people are supposed to love each other. Living in a loveless marriage has to be one of the cruelest day to day mini-martyrdoms for both people involved. Why start from that position? It doesn’t even make any sense on a worldly level.

Both of you are made for better things, and both of you deserve better.
 
Know that if she reacts emotionally to separation then you shouldn’t base a renewal of relationship on guilt. She has to make her own choices as do you.

When caught in a relationship like this in which talk of marriage has occurred, it is a worthwhile thing to consider any children you might have in a marriage.

Is she the mother you want for your children? If you are unhappy with her, are your children likely to be unhappy? Is their childhood likely to be wholesome and happy? If you find the relationship difficult, how would vulnerable little children and vulnerable teens feel and cope? You may be prepared to ‘carry your cross’ but why should your children have to carry your cross?

This is a good question for anyone who stays in a relationship and marries because they are acting as if they are responsible for the happiness of someone else.
We each are responsible for our own happiness and our own choices. And although many people are victims of some sort or other it is up to the person to decide no longer to be a victim. Maybe they won’t make the transition, but there may be less chance that they ever will if we are forever their ‘prop’.

May God guide you. May God bless you and this girl. You have been a blessing to her already, but maybe it’s time for her to mature in wisdom and strength, and maybe that will take a while and maybe it will hurt. Please God she will take charge of her own life and future in God’s grace.
 
You have reason about the whole “tangled” part. I think it would be best for me to try and receive counselig from a priest, there are least two that I know well enough to do thst, one of whom actually knew my gilfriend from youth ministry in high school. i think it would be good because i can trust the advice of a holy man more than my own intuition. is it ok to asks proests about this stuff or is it not important because were not married…?
Yes, certainly you can talk to a priest about this. You may need to make an appointment, but that is part of the priest’s role-- to give spiritual counsel.
 
Ok…I was reading your post and though to myself “parts of this sounds like a marriage” 🙂

But seriously, you are WAY too young to make a decision on getting married(please do not take that wrong). My experience (from being your age at one time…and thinking I was ready to get married to my HS sweetheart and make that commitment at 19) is that I was no where near the person I was when I finally did get married . I waited until I was 39 to get married(no…you do not have to wait THAT long). My point… even though at 19 you think you are “grown up”, there is still much much more to experience and learn along the way…and this life experience changes you. Sometimes, you meet that special person young…and you can grow together. Too often people that meet and marry very young end up “growing” apart. This is because (and this is just my opinion) you are still growing and changing. The things you think are important now, will seem insignificant years from now.

You need to take care of you first. Trust your feelings. Two people should be “rock solid” before considering marriage…speaking for myself, I had no clue how difficult marriage really is. I read somewhere that “true” love is a choice…how true it is.
 
Ok…I was reading your post and though to myself “parts of this sounds like a marriage” 🙂

But seriously, you are WAY too young to make a decision on getting married(please do not take that wrong). My experience (from being your age at one time…and thinking I was ready to get married to my HS sweetheart and make that commitment at 19) is that I was no where near the person I was when I finally did get married . I waited until I was 39 to get married(no…you do not have to wait THAT long). My point… even though at 19 you think you are “grown up”, there is still much much more to experience and learn along the way…and this life experience changes you. Sometimes, you meet that special person young…and you can grow together. Too often people that meet and marry very young end up “growing” apart. This is because (and this is just my opinion) you are still growing and changing. The things you think are important now, will seem insignificant years from now.

You need to take care of you first. Trust your feelings. Two people should be “rock solid” before considering marriage…speaking for myself, I had no clue how difficult marriage really is. I read somewhere that “true” love is a choice…how true it is.
Well, its definitely like that and now I kind of realize that I do need life experiences and stuff. And I am definitely going to seek out the advice of a priest.
 
Help her to see that she doesn’t need you. I know that sounds odd, but she may have developed an unhealthy attachment to you.

Pray that you and others can help her to see that it is GOD who has been helping her all this time. Yes, He may have used you and your family as instruments, but it is God who has been helping her through this. It’s important that you make sure she sees this before you “break the news” to her about the way you feel.

Maybe you could talk about how amazing it is that God puts people in our lives for certain times to fulfill things in our lives…

Also, I think it’s important for you to know that SHE WILL BE OKAY WITHOUT YOU! Yes, she may be hurt, she may say crazy stuff and freak out, but she will be ok. You can’t blame yourself or beat yourself up over it. You are not responsible for her. Prolonging a relationship that you don’t want to be in will be WORSE for her in the long run, and will cause YOU emotional damage as well.
 
Help her to see that she doesn’t need you. I know that sounds odd, but she may have developed an unhealthy attachment to you.

Pray that you and others can help her to see that it is GOD who has been helping her all this time. Yes, He may have used you and your family as instruments, but it is God who has been helping her through this. It’s important that you make sure she sees this before you “break the news” to her about the way you feel.

Maybe you could talk about how amazing it is that God puts people in our lives for certain times to fulfill things in our lives…

Also, I think it’s important for you to know that SHE WILL BE OKAY WITHOUT YOU! Yes, she may be hurt, she may say crazy stuff and freak out, but she will be ok. You can’t blame yourself or beat yourself up over it. You are not responsible for her. Prolonging a relationship that you don’t want to be in will be WORSE for her in the long run, and will cause YOU emotional damage as well.
Thank you Ana. I think that will be part of the hardest part, coming out and saying it and explaining why.
 
In the past month or so though, I’ve been bombarded by thoughts of unhappiness, and I believe it is because of my relationship. For the first time in almost 3 years, I decided to finally open up to friends, and tell them how I feel about my relationship. Essentially, how I feel, is that despite all I’ve been through with her, all the struggles we’ve overcome, all that I’ve helped her through, all the progress she’s made, I don’t think I want to be with her forever anymore, that is- I don’t want to get married. She is not a bad person, and in fact has probably had quite a good impact on me and taught me a lot about life. But I feel as though I’ve lost my passionate love for her, I don’t always want to be around her, I don’t want her hugging me, I just feel like I want space (one friend described it as being as though I have become sort of a “father figure” to her that she never had). I feel as though more I am burdened by all that we have been through, and somewhat damaged. Before our relationship, I never suffered from depression, struggled with my weight, overeating, possibly developed IBS as well, all things that have appeared within the past year or so. I just feel as though I need a change.
This says all that I need to know. Relationships are not “psychological counseling” and they are not an “obligation to support someone with problems”. Relationships are to discern marraige, and it sounds like this relationship has served that purpose. This is a woman who needs help, probably with some actually psychological treatment in the mix, and you have determined that the relationship is an unhealthy one for your spiritual life… that’s the discernment portion. It’s also unhealthy for HER as well to have to depend on your for her “sanity”. So having discerned that this relationship is not right for either you or her, it’s time to break it off.
 
This says all that I need to know. Relationships are not “psychological counseling” and they are not an “obligation to support someone with problems”. Relationships are to discern marraige, and it sounds like this relationship has served that purpose. This is a woman who needs help, probably with some actually psychological treatment in the mix, and you have determined that the relationship is an unhealthy one for your spiritual life… that’s the discernment portion. It’s also unhealthy for HER as well to have to depend on your for her “sanity”. So having discerned that this relationship is not right for either you or her, it’s time to break it off.
This is all true, unfortunately the OP now has the added complication that this girl is living in his parents’ home. It’s a lot more awkward and difficult. But thank God he realized it now rather than after they married.
 
This is all true, unfortunately the OP now has the added complication that this girl is living in his parents’ home. It’s a lot more awkward and difficult. But thank God he realized it now rather than after they married.
Yeah, I didn’t address the “how to break it off” part because of that minor complication. I think that after three/four years of dating, the level of “attachment” isn’t going to get a whole lot greater in the mean time, but on the other hand it is wrong to live a lie…

I’d be strongly torn between the charity of waiting until she’s moving out anyway and breaking it off now… I like to believe I’d be able to break it off now and allow her the chance to move out voluntarily on her own time frame (not to mention, not making her go through living on her own AND breaking up at the same time)… but I’m not sure I’d be able to do that… 🤷
 
Yeah, I didn’t address the “how to break it off” part because of that minor complication. I think that after three/four years of dating, the level of “attachment” isn’t going to get a whole lot greater in the mean time, but on the other hand it is wrong to live a lie…

I’d be strongly torn between the charity of waiting until she’s moving out anyway and breaking it off now… I like to believe I’d be able to break it off now and allow her the chance to move out voluntarily on her own time frame (not to mention, not making her go through living on her own AND breaking up at the same time)… but I’m not sure I’d be able to do that… 🤷
Yeah. While I definitely don’t “feel good” having to wait, doing a lot of research on breaking up relationships seems to indicate that sometimes it is better to be humane and wait it out? But you all are absolutely right about how awkward everything can be, finding time to talk about it, worried about an extreme reaction, begging. At one point we did almost break up a while back due to certain issues and it was almost as if she couldn’t hear it, sort of telling me that I made a commitment that I would not break up with her since she lived with me now. But I explained the situation a bit to a priest, and we will meet Wednesday. Thank God he can offer his help for this situation.
 
Yeah. While I definitely don’t “feel good” having to wait, doing a lot of research on breaking up relationships seems to indicate that sometimes it is better to be humane and wait it out? But you all are absolutely right about how awkward everything can be, finding time to talk about it, worried about an extreme reaction, begging. At one point we did almost break up a while back due to certain issues and it was almost as if she couldn’t hear it, sort of telling me that I made a commitment that I would not break up with her since she lived with me now. But I explained the situation a bit to a priest, and we will meet Wednesday. Thank God he can offer his help for this situation.
Good, I am glad you are going to talk with a priest. I would still urge you to start pulling back very gently, not saying anything about marriage and if she does, find a way to GENTLY start to hint that you both have a lot of growing up to do before you are ready for that huge step…Try to be subtle and pray a lot before you say anything…As long as you are not leading her on into deeper and deeper emotions between now and the time you leave for your journey, I would say it will be easier then. I can put myself in her place and I would probably panic, thinking about the future “Where will I go now?” etc.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top