I don't know if I've ever committed a mortal sin

  • Thread starter Thread starter TomS333
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TomS333

Guest
I am unsure whether or not I have ever committed a mortal sin.
What are the rules on what counts as a mortal sin? And is there an exemption if you forget/do not know that you have committed a mortal sin?
 
Do you see this thread of yours
40.png
Am I in the wrong or is she? Moral Theology
There’s a girl who I used to have feelings for. Let’s call her Ruth. She’s an altar girl at her church. Ruth and I were really good friends for ages before and for a while after I asked her out. She started flirting with me in September 2016. I confessed my feelings for her in December of 2016 and she said No. She and I stayed friends until the end of November 2017. It was October 2017 when Ruth suddenly decided she felt uncomfortable around me “because I had feelings for her” even though she …
Do you see where you say

(6). I hate her and now I want to hurt her (7), I don’t think I will hurt her, it’s just a desire to see her punished. I just can’t forgive her.
I heard her bitching about me earlier today to one of her friends, and it just made me so angry. I managed to walk away and cool off though.

Well I know you are not Catholic yet but that’s pretty heavy.

We also believe we must stay celibate and practise chastity unless married. That includes no masturbation.
 
It’s not, neither is chastity. This man is not catholic ,and is in relationships. Asked what counts as mortal sin.

I am guessing he knows theft, murder, aggravated assault are no brainers. In my experience. And in reading this forum, many don’t know fornication etc is a sin.
 
Last edited:
Even though one may not be committing an actual mortal sin (knowledge, grave matter, will), still when one sins in a grave matter he has committed objective mortal sin, and that in turn still does damage to The Body of Christ.
 
I have no clue, OP, but I have never ever come across a person who didn’t display spitting anger, or has not told a huge lie.

Mortal sin is not limited to murder, adultery, or blasphemy.
 
Then don’t get too cocky and thank God.
Yes its perfectly within grasp of all the baptised never to commit a fully culpable grave disorder.
 
You are mistaken.
It is relatively common for the baptised to live a life without committing a single personal mortal sin.
Especially those who received baptism as babies.

You are either confused with “objective mortal sin” or committing venial sins.
 
Last edited:
You do not seem to understand what a “mortal sin” is.
You are confusing personal mortal sin with engaging in “grave matter”.

The question is re the former not the latter.
As you say, the latter is still of great concern even if not an actual mortal sin.
 
Last edited:
And is there an exemption if you forget/do not know that you have committed a mortal sin?
Yes, mortal sin requires knowledge, but to be clear this does not mean you must be thinking explicitly at the moment of committing it “I know this is a mortal sin”. I suppose it is possible to forget that something is gravely sinful, but in general I find it unlikely.
 
I think we are on the same page here, just different wording.
 
Why does everything on CAF have to come down to masturbation. This is bonkers.
I think it might be because it is the action most familiar to everyone who is or has ever gone through their youth and had to deal with awakening sexuality.

Suggest the OP get a copy of the Catechism or the Catholic Church and read thoroughly section 2352. It deals with that issue.
 
I agree it’s definitely possible but “relatively common” sounds like a stretch.
 
I am unsure whether or not I have ever committed a mortal sin.

What are the rules on what counts as a mortal sin? And is there an exemption if you forget/do not know that you have committed a mortal sin?
If you don’t have a copy of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, it’s online free, AND searchable:
http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm

Mortal sin is addressed here:
http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p3s1c1a8.htm#II

When in doubt about mortal sin, talk to a priest.
 
Because it is almost impossible for people, especially the unmarried, to resist this normal and strong biological impulse and causes them great mental anguish and guilt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top