I finally understand masturbation

  • Thread starter Thread starter PennitentMan
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is that a joke? You can’t be serious about the fetus masturbating.
This is from the parentcenter.babycenter.com forum:

On the BBC program ‘The Human Body’ (presented by Robert Winston) they showed an ultrasound scan of a female fetus having an orgasm inside the womb. The fetus was not touching the vagina with her hand, but was moving her thighs and squeezing her clitoris, and would then give a little shiver…

(The mother commented to her Dr that she felt the fetus doing odd movements, hence the reason for the scan…)
 
CCM08; You don’t masturbate to thoughts of fine wine or the arts said:
That is, frankly, the stupidest thing I have ever heard. Your justification has failed, you’re arguments are foolish and completely lacking of any merit. Now you’re merely grasping at straws because you’re too proud to admit your mistake.
 
QUOTE=CCM08;2291739 That is, frankly, the stupidest thing I have ever heard. Your justification has failed, you’re arguments are foolish and completely lacking of any merit. Now you’re merely grasping at straws because you’re too proud to admit your mistake.

Thank you for your kind words.
 
I’m pretty sure she is.
I’ve actully heard this before and I don’t buy it. Not for two seconds.
Sad to say this is a constant debate I’ve heard for years. I argue with my educated daughter on this. I think the medical profession pushes it.

It is the premise for the sexual revolution that we are sexual from birth and we are denying our sexuality by not acting on it. Just as we desire food from birth to survive, we need and desire sex from birth.

I have heard also from my husband how sex “keeps you healthy” or I should say “keeps him healthy”.
 
Just one observation:

you get from this line
As Christ says, to look upon a woman with lust in your heart is to commit adultery with her.
Masturbation is sinful, there is no way to get around it.
to this line by assuming that masturbation is synonimous with fantasy.
It’s not.

Lust of the heart is adultery and is a sin yes, but that is totally seperate from masturbation.
One can commit lust of the heart without masturbation and one can also masturbate without any lust of the heart.
 
orignally posted by Enoch
This is because when we do something that violates the natural law imprinted on all of our hearts is causes an inner-turmoil in our very soul. This turmoil needs to be soothed and there is only one of two ways to do that. Either confess that we have engaged in a sin of grave matter and firmly resolve to avoid it in the future with God’s grace, or we find some way to justify it in our own mind. In some cases we even try to draw others in an attempt to “give away the sin”. Either way, the turmoil is neutralized.
However, please remember that at the instant of out death we will all be standing before the throne of the King of Glory and his heavenly court where all loopholes will be closed all human rationalizing is nonexistent. Every intension behind every single moment of our lives will be laid before us and we will have to account for the intension behind every single thing we’ve done/not done during our earthly trials and hold them up to the light of the beatific vision. Yes, all of them, and if you are like me, it won’t be pretty.
The saddest thing I see on this thread is people who equate their temporal earthly existence with their eternal spiritual existence, and seem to hold their trials of the flesh with more importance than their trials of the spirit.
Like I said in an earlier post, satan would love for us to believe that our sexuality is nothing more than an animalistic, biological urge that needs to be satisfied. When we believe this we turn it into nothing more than a mechanical action and remove all beauty from it and thus rationalize our behavior via satan’s loophole.
Well said. Thanks
 
Sad to say this is a constant debate I’ve heard for years. I argue with my educated daughter on this. I think the medical profession pushes it.

It is the premise for the sexual revolution that we are sexual from birth and we are denying our sexuality by not acting on it. Just as we desire food from birth to survive, we need and desire sex from birth.

I have heard also from my husband how sex “keeps you healthy” or I should say “keeps him healthy”.
I agree.

I actually attempted to look it up for some real information and found basically nothing. There were medical sites that talked about how your toddler needs privacy so she/he can masturbate but then nothing remotely factual. Children are curious about there body’s so they play with themselves (not something to be encouraged imo), they learn about everything at that age by touch. For me it takes a sick person to look at a child’s God given curiosity and call it masturbation.
 
gam197 I have heard also from my husband how sex “keeps you healthy” or I should say “keeps him healthy”. [/QUOTE said:
And you don’t agree? Your poor husband. Can I have him? 🙂
 
QUOTE=LJN21 I actually attempted to look it up for some real information and found basically nothing.

All you have to do is go to bbc.com and order the dvd. Or maybe you can get it at your local library. Then all your questions will be answered.
 
I think some of the arguements about unborn babies self-pleasuring in the womb is rather missing the point:mad:

It is about adults thinking things that are against holy purity.
We know that once we succomb to the temptation, are defences are considerably weakened against future temptations of the same, similar and all things moral.

We also know that the healing from the Sacrament of Reconciliation restores our strength and ability to say ‘no’ to similar temptations in the future.🙂

That is my understanding of what this thread is all about
 
Children (born and unborn) are incapable of any mortal sin because they lack the intelligence and maturity level needed to understand the nature of sin. This is simply due to the fact hat they do not yet have a fully developed brain.

Unfortunately, the lack of intelligence and maturity still holds true for some adults who DO have a fully developed brain.😦
 
I came across a quote today that made me think of this thread. I don’t mean it to discourage or point fingers, instead I simply mean to illustrate that even long ago a Saint in the highest reaches of the Church recognised the danger of impurity, in both scope and magnitude.

St. Alphonsus, Bishop and Doctor of the Church, “Sin against purity are the sins which fill hell with souls. In other vices the devil fishes with the hook, in this he fishes with the net. So that by impurity he gains more for hell thank by all other sins. Indeed I do not hesitate to assert that all those who are dammed are dammed on account on this one vice of impurity or at least not without it.”
 
I am a married man and have been for over 50 years to the same woman. A combination of health problems and low libido has left my wife (age 72) with no desire for sexual intimacies. However, though I am 75 years old, my sexual drive has not mitigated and many times I am overwhelmed by my need for sexual fulfillment. Adultery is not even a consideration so all that’s left for sexual satisfaction is masterbation… I have read the cathecism and discussed with four different priests.as to whether masterbation, in my situation, is a mortal sin or not. I got four different answers from its no sin to yes its a mortal sin. Has anyone had or know of a similiar situation and can render some advice for an answer?
 
You need to pray to God that He helps you quit it, instead of praying to help you understand it!
Why risk hell?
If your problem is that you think you will not ejaculate anymore, that is not true because you will begin to have dreams, once you quit masturbation. But try not to think too much in those dreams or desire them. With time you will even forget about the dreams at all.
 
This thread is 10 years old. Start a new thread if required. Forum rules outlaw resurrecting old threads.
 
With all due respect, that is your opinion.
What he needs to do is continue to pursue the relationship that a husband and a wife should have. He really needs to not give up on communicating his needs, connecting with his wife, and seeking professional counseling for the two of them.[/quoted]
 
First of all, I want to thank W&W for her support here. Thanks also to all the people who gave me compassion and support and prayers.

You know, yesterday when I posted this, a good friend here asked me why I even bother…Some responses have been very harsh to this question/statement. Being a relatively new Catholic I do not have the benefit of years of experience here.
W&W was correct, but I’d like to change one word…not Super Catholics, but super-conservative-hard-line-no-room-for-any-error Catholics.

I’m trying to do the best with the situation I’m in.
BlessedToo, of course I make this choice begrudgingly. Do you expect me to leap out of bed in the morning and say: “Wahoo! Another day of struggles! Anther day of rejection from my wife! Yeah, let’s go!”
I find it really difficult to accept this. Do you blame me? Sure I love my wife, I love her dearly and I will stay by her side. I live my vows daily. But each time I approach her, I get shot down - even last night when she was feeling “much better” as she said, still nothing.
My Love Language is physical contact and intimacy. I have told her this countless times, but she still does not reciprocate. I feel rejected and un loved. I’m not going to rejoice about that…not any time soon anyway.

Anyway, thanks to everyone who responded. I’m gone.
I know you say you are gone but in case you revisit–I just finished a book on the Fatima–I can’t remember the title (sorry)–but part of it discussed the lives of the two youngest visionaries and how they embraced suffering and making sacrifices because of their deep love for God and because of their desire to offer them for the conversion of sinners. They had a deep peace in their sufferings and in the sacrifices they made. I think if you read about the lives of the early Christians you’ll see them embrace the sufferings in their lives and their situations with a great peace in knowing God and in attempting to do his will. So much of life is about attitude and expectations. Here is what I find for myself–when I’m focused on my wife and on doing things for her–making sure this or that is done around the house and when I focus on prayer and Bible study–it’s much easier for me to not think about my needs and desires, but when I let my mind wonder to what I want, to what I think I need–it’s much harder. You mentioned your love language – do you know what your wife’s is? As Christians we need to learn to focus on the needs of others and not worry quite so much about our needs–that’s where the peace will come from. St James has some words about how we should greet our sufferings I believe. Am I very good at this?–by all means no–but it is what I am striving for and continually reminding myself of.

The peace of Christ,
Mark
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top