I got two really good questions...whats your view?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DaMooksta
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DaMooksta

Guest
(Question 1) In book 1 Sam 16:14, God and evil can’t dwell in the same place right?.. so how is it that God can send evil spirits?.. It doesn’t make sense to me that God can affiliate himself with evil, he is all good. What is your interpretation on this.

(Question 2) Is God Really All knowing?..1 Sam 15:35 It says “the Lord repented” God is perfect, God shouldn’t make mistakes, Why is it he is repenting…if he was all knowing he would have known what Saul was going to do and he wouldn’t have chosen him. If he did know what he was going to do, It would be to bring a greater good out of it. So if God is “perfect/all knowing” he would not be repenting…right?..what is your interpretation on this.
 
The first question is an excellent one. I am reading through the Bible this year cover to cover and that was actually the EXACT question I have written down. I intend to ask my pastor about the original Hebrew text and his opinion. Question 2. My Bible says regretted. Which makes more sense. Saul did not follow in the Lord’s ways so this grieved Him.
 
(Question 1) In book 1 Sam 16:14, God and evil can’t dwell in the same place right?.. so how is it that God can send evil spirits?.. It doesn’t make sense to me that God can affiliate himself with evil, he is all good. What is your interpretation on this.

(Question 2) Is God Really All knowing?..1 Sam 15:35 It says “the Lord repented” God is perfect, God shouldn’t make mistakes, Why is it he is repenting…if he was all knowing he would have known what Saul was going to do and he wouldn’t have chosen him. If he did know what he was going to do, It would be to bring a greater good out of it. So if God is “perfect/all knowing” he would not be repenting…right?..what is your interpretation on this.
You are reading human interpretations and understandings of God from centuries ago. That’s all.

No, God does not send evil spirits. Yes, God is all-knowing.

Anything else we can help with?
 
(Question 1) In book 1 Sam 16:14, God and evil can’t dwell in the same place right?.. so how is it that God can send evil spirits?.. It doesn’t make sense to me that God can affiliate himself with evil, he is all good. What is your interpretation on this.
You’re using an over-simplified definition of evil. Evil in modern english context is having to do with moral wrong. In older forms of language, evil also refers to anything causing suffering.

Hence, God turns not to Demons (evil spirits) but to spirits who were responsible for carrying out the punishments of sin on places like Soddom and Gamora.
(Question 2) Is God Really All knowing?..1 Sam 15:35 It says “the Lord repented” God is perfect, God shouldn’t make mistakes, Why is it he is repenting…if he was all knowing he would have known what Saul was going to do and he wouldn’t have chosen him. If he did know what he was going to do, It would be to bring a greater good out of it. So if God is “perfect/all knowing” he would not be repenting…right?..what is your interpretation on this.
Same problem. Repent is also translated as “turning away from.” This doesn’t put negative light on the idea of God’s all knowing. God may have deliberately planned to turn away from someone. This is part of the mystery of trying to understand a timeless infinite God in terms of a temporal finite universe.
 
Sending evil spirits is a metaphor. The Lord departed from Saul and permitted him to be tormented with violent fits of rage on account of his own sins.
 
(Question 1) In book 1 Sam 16:14, God and evil can’t dwell in the same place right?.. so how is it that God can send evil spirits?.. It doesn’t make sense to me that God can affiliate himself with evil, he is all good. What is your interpretation on this.

(Question 2) Is God Really All knowing?..1 Sam 15:35 It says “the Lord repented” God is perfect, God shouldn’t make mistakes, Why is it he is repenting…if he was all knowing he would have known what Saul was going to do and he wouldn’t have chosen him. If he did know what he was going to do, It would be to bring a greater good out of it. So if God is “perfect/all knowing” he would not be repenting…right?..what is your interpretation on this.
Yes, God does not send evil spirits and God is all knowing.

That is what the Church teaches, despite the perceptions of people in different times, and their expressions of their understanding of God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top