I have a 3 year old boy

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lucky_Scrunchy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lucky_Scrunchy

Guest
who will be 4 in March. He is EXTREMELY defiant, strong-willed, and everything is a battle with him. On top of losing my father three weeks ago, I’m on the verge of tears over my son. I’m sick of every little thing being a battle of the wills. Nothing I do seems to help in the discipline area.

I would appreciate advice from mothers or fathers who are or were in the same boat as I.
 
Have you heard of Doctor Ray Guarendi? He’s Catholic, he has ten kids - often adopted as a little bit older kids who were troubled. He is so full of humor, common sense, and yet a strong sense of discipline. Listen for him on Catholic radio or find him at drray.com
I have several boys, some strong-willed, and I’ve struggled too. Listen to Dr. Ray, it’ll help. I like his book Discipline that lasts a lifetime. It’s in a question and answer format - very practical questions (my kid won’t eat, what do i do, etc…) and commonsense answers with lots of humor. God bless, and try to enjoy. Your son is really cute and funny at this stage, though yes, a great deal of work!
 
who will be 4 in March. He is EXTREMELY defiant, strong-willed, and everything is a battle with him. On top of losing my father three weeks ago, I’m on the verge of tears over my son.** I’m sick of every little thing being a battle of the wills. **Nothing I do seems to help in the discipline area.

I would appreciate advice from mothers or fathers who are or were in the same boat as I.
Describe a typical day with him. I can’t give you much advice unless you give me more information. What are his triggers for battling with you? Is it really defiance or is he just trying to be more independent than you think he should be or can be? Have you arranged his environment for success and not failure? Tell us more about what he does and we will give you suggestions.

I can tell you just about everything that DOESN’T work with a strong-willed child because I’ve done it. Can tell you a few things that did work. Unfortunately my little hard-head is a lot like me so we crossed swords a whole lot while he grew up. I didn’t realize or want to admit that until just the last couple of years.
 
My son isn’t this old yet, but I would highly recommend this author (his theology is spot on and his books have helped my marriage a lot, so I picked up his book on parenting too): Greg Popcak’s Parenting with Grace.

He has disciplinary techniques that build on each other from toddlerhood through adolescence, using a foundation of love rather than trying to break a child’s will or spirit (as I’ve seen in other parenting books, especially those authored by evangelical Protestants.)
 
Have you heard of Doctor Ray Guarendi? He’s Catholic, he has ten kids - often adopted as a little bit older kids who were troubled. He is so full of humor, common sense, and yet a strong sense of discipline. Listen for him on Catholic radio or find him at drray.com
I have several boys, some strong-willed, and I’ve struggled too. Listen to Dr. Ray, it’ll help. I like his book Discipline that lasts a lifetime. It’s in a question and answer format - very practical questions (my kid won’t eat, what do i do, etc…) and commonsense answers with lots of humor. God bless, and try to enjoy. Your son is really cute and funny at this stage, though yes, a great deal of work!
+1 on this. One thing that has worked with our kids is giving them options…makes them feel like they are making teh decisions even though the choices are pre-determined by you.

Example: If he/she won’t wear pants when you want pants on him/her: “If you don’t want to wear these pants, you may choose these other pants instead. Which ones would you like to wear?” OR “If you do not want to eat your dinner, you may have plain bread instead. Which would you like for dinner, the meal I prepared, or a plain piece of bread?” (Yeah, food stuff can get controversial…so that’s about all I’ll say on that… 😉 )
 
Oh, something that I just remembered…and I have only just learned this myself. Children at that age are developing a sense of “self”. While they need plenty time with parents, they are also in a stage of identifying who they are, as a person seperate from Mom or Dad. The trick is to allow that development while still maintaining good boundaries, teaching him/her to accept your “no”, and also teach them that they also have a valid “no” that they can use…so long as it doesn’t clash with your “no”.

Ans pick you battles. Not everything is worth arguing over. Red socks with a purple shirt and blue pants may make your nerves shiver…but it won’t hurt anyone.

When you figure out a trouble-free way to do that, please let me know so I can use it! 😃
 
Lucky–I think I have his brother(Nick) who will be 3 on Thursday, he is in the kitchen in his high chair screening at the top of his lungs right now because he will not stay in his bed for a nap so I have to put him in there everyday at nap and at bed time!!! This too shall pass, you have so much stress with the loss of your dear father, I think our kids can sense this and they act out. Why can’t they sense this and act better???

I’m eagerly awaiting others advice, but you are not alone!!! I have all Dr. Ray’s (Guarendi) books, listen to his show(EWTN) when I can, absolutly love him. Wishing I could send my little angel to the Guarendi house for a few weeks;)!!

:hug3:

chris
 
who will be 4 in March. He is EXTREMELY defiant, strong-willed, and everything is a battle with him. On top of losing my father three weeks ago, I’m on the verge of tears over my son. I’m sick of every little thing being a battle of the wills. Nothing I do seems to help in the discipline area.

I would appreciate advice from mothers or fathers who are or were in the same boat as I.
I am so sorry to hear about the stress you are experiencing :-/

My daughter is VERY strong-willed and defiant. She also loves her independence and goes to pieces if we try to help her do things, like wipe her bottom (she’s only 2.5, still needs a little help) or get dressed (she had a history of popping buttons by pulling things over her head).

here is what works for us:
consistency, consistency, consistency, Always follow through on threats - don’t make them if you will not intend on following through. “If you hit me again, you go to time out”, and then follow through with a time out.
Staying calm is huge for us. If I get stressed out and raise my voice, it makes her worse. If I can’t stay calm, I leave the room and take some slow deep breaths until I am better.
Routine - this helps us a lot. She has a weekday routine, and a weekend routine. Occasional breaks happen, like when there’s a late night and my mom watches her, or she goes and stays at my parent’s house for a night. Bedtime comes within a 30 minute window, same with meals. It sounds boring, but she does REALLY well with this type of thing.

That’s all I got, dear :-/
Except this: Cut back on TV if they watch more than an hour a day. It can be mondo stimulating and make them incorrigible! We found this out the hard way :rolleyes:, cancelled our cable, and it actually helped a bit. Nothing dramatic, but a definite improvement.

Best luck, especially in your time of grief 😦
 
I am so sorry - I completely missed that your father had passed away!!!

😦

Well, your patience may be depleted from grief. Try to cut yourself and your son a little slack, don’t start a new discipline program with him at the moment.

When you log back in, please tell me what you have tried and what hasn’t worked, and I’ll try to help. The other posters who said that consistency is critical are right, and you may not be in the best frame of mind to enforce things right now. I hope your husband is helping you.
 
A few of my friends are raving about a book called Don’t Make Me Count to 1, 2, 3. It incorporates the bible as a teaching tool for why we do and do not do things. They’ve read it and use the methods on their children as young as 3. I haven’t read it myself, so I don’t know exactly what it entails but thought I’d throw it out there.
 
I understand where you are coming from with a strong-willed little one. My son was very difficult at that age. I tried to give him choices, but at times he was too smart for his own good. I’d say, “you can wear the blue pants or the red pants, which do you want?” and he’d counter back that he wants to wear the jeans that he was wearing yesterday. When I told him that they were dirty, so that wasn’t one of his choices, it would set him off all over again.

The main thing with strong-willed kids is consistency. They have to know that X behavior is not allowed ever, at any time, and that the consequence will always be Y punishment. Don’t threaten something unless you are willing to follow through on it. (This was something I had to learn. My son thought nothing of empty threats because he could tell that I didn’t really mean it. Once he figured out that I was going to follow through on whatever threat I gave him, he stopped pushing the boundaries quite as much.) Part of being a kid is testing Mom and Dad to see if they really mean what they say.

A big thing is also to keep your cool and not “blow your fuse” at them. They do enjoy getting a rise out of their parents, to some degree it’s a game kids play. It can be extremely difficult to not yell and get angry. But your kids need to understand that they must behave all the time, not just when Mom gets angry. It’s alright to be angry, of course. Just as long as your kids don’t start thinking that they only get punished because Mom is angry.

I’m very sorry to hear about your father passing away, that must make things even more difficult right now. I’ll say some prayers for you and your family.
 
…The main thing with strong-willed kids is consistency. They have to know that X behavior is not allowed ever, at any time, and that the consequence will always be Y punishment. Don’t threaten something unless you are willing to follow through on it…
Yes…excellent advice.
 
The main thing with strong-willed kids is consistency. They have to know that X behavior is not allowed ever, at any time, and that the consequence will always be Y punishment. Don’t threaten something unless you are willing to follow through on it.
…
A big thing is also to keep your cool and not “blow your fuse” at them. They do enjoy getting a rise out of their parents, to some degree it’s a game kids play.
…
I’m very sorry to hear about your father passing away, that must make things even more difficult right now. I’ll say some prayers for you and your family.
All excellent advice–seconded. I have 3 boys, from 21 to 5, and for what it’s worth, I always thought 3 was a much more difficult age than 2, despite all the talk about “terrible twos”. Despite all the pushback, what he really needs from you is consistency. Just remember, you’re the “mom”–act like it and keep your cool. I think boys at that age also are starting to respond well to their dads. Can you encourage your husband to help with him?

So sorry to hear about the loss of your dad. In my prayers.
 
Have you not read in the Bible “spare the rod and hate the child”- children sometimes need physical reactions to their tantrums. My 14 year old son and 17 yr old daughter could put on quite a show when they didn’t get their way when they were 3 to 7 yrs old- we ignored them- guess what -they don’t put on a show now when they don’t get what they want. For really young ones when they start walking a great help is a wooden spoon- we bought ten at Sams for a few bucks. Amazing how it focuses thyeir attention when they get a whack on the butt when you tell them NO and they do it anyway.
 
Prayer for the repose of your father’s soul.

You’ve gotten lots of great advice so far. What I will repeat is that everything isn’t worth a battle of wills. Clothes that don’t match, slightly dirty favorite outfits, eating everything on his plate, stuff like that isn’t even worth noticing.

My daughter regularly wore two different shoes (along with a ‘matching’ outfit) and the only reaction we ever got was, “dressed herself today, huh?”. It’s just not worth fighting over, especially now when your emotions are fragile.

As for food, usually that’s not worth fighting over either. You shouldn’t be a short-order cook, and he shouldn’t get tons of sweets, but other than that, right now if he has bread and milk for dinner because he doesn’t want what you cooked, that’s fine.

Routines are great, and so is limiting the options he has available. Maybe put away certain toys right now. Noisemakers, toys with tons of little parts, etc. you don’t need to deal with. More time running around outside would probably help you both. Hope you get a string of sunny days, even if it is cold!

Again, praying for you!
 
As for food, usually that’s not worth fighting over either. You shouldn’t be a short-order cook, and he shouldn’t get tons of sweets, but other than that, right now if he has bread and milk for dinner because he doesn’t want what you cooked, that’s fine.
I agree with this advice! When my son was 3, we fought constantly over eating all his food. Recently my DH and I have started to stop fighting with him, and the stress has gone down quite a bit. He’s a great eater now!

We chose to let DS go hungry for a meal if he doesn’t want to eat what we are eating; we don’t want to go to the trouble of making separate meals just because he is being picky. Some parents don’t want to let their kids go hungry, so the bread and milk option works for them. (My son would live on milk alone if we allowed it, which is why we went for the “let him go hungry” option.) Every time he complains about food, we just tell him, “that’s ok if you don’t want to eat it. You can wait until the next meal time.” At first he thought it was great because he got to keep playing while the rest of us were having dinner. But when he was hungry a couple hours later and found out that he really did have to wait until the next mealtime, he started eating meals with the family again without any fuss. It works great on my 3 year old daughter, too. She was starting to get picky, but she’s eating like a champ now as well.
 
Have you not read in the Bible “spare the rod and hate the child”- children sometimes need physical reactions to their tantrums. My 14 year old son and 17 yr old daughter could put on quite a show when they didn’t get their way when they were 3 to 7 yrs old- we ignored them- guess what -they don’t put on a show now when they don’t get what they want. For really young ones when they start walking a great help is a wooden spoon- we bought ten at Sams for a few bucks. Amazing how it focuses thyeir attention when they get a whack on the butt when you tell them NO and they do it anyway.
I had a hefty dose of that spoon and the belt. I am 40 and to this day I am upset about it. A good priest friend of mine told me that a rod for a Biblical shepherd was never used to beat sheep. It was used to gently guide them. That is why it says “Thy rod and staff they comfort me.” I am very happy to finally hear what God really meant.

The three’s can be awful and being consistant can really help. I also prayed to my kids patron saints. Hang in there because they grow out of it. Try to get a babysitter if you can once in awhile.
 
I am not a mother but I have worked with kids throughout the years. The suggestion offered are excellent ones and are what I have used with kids. One of the most important things I learned is to be CONSISTENT and follow thru with enforcing rules. My neice would have a tantrum every morning when getting dressed for school (preschool thru 1st/2nd grade). She loved clothes (dresses, lacey socks, tights & patent leather shoes, matching hair accessories every day) and happy to change into several outfits a day. Emily and her Mother chose her school outfit the night before and her clothing was laid out for the next morning. She was given options of what she could wear and there was no negotiation the next day. This approach worked very well for her.
 
Have you not read in the Bible “spare the rod and hate the child”- children sometimes need physical reactions to their tantrums. My 14 year old son and 17 yr old daughter could put on quite a show when they didn’t get their way when they were 3 to 7 yrs old- we ignored them- guess what -they don’t put on a show now when they don’t get what they want. For really young ones when they start walking a great help is a wooden spoon- we bought ten at Sams for a few bucks. Amazing how it focuses thyeir attention when they get a whack on the butt when you tell them NO and they do it anyway.
Please, whatever you do, do not follow this advice! I was raised with the “rod” and can tell you it does so much harm to the parent-child relationship in the long term that it is not worth it. I went through a great deal of reflection after the birth of my child on parenting styles and methods and saw this method as harmful. Raising kids with fear is much different from teaching them respect. I did what I did out of fear of my parents. Would never “confess” any issues because they would be “punished”. Didn’t make a show when I was a teen because I knew that it would lead to harsh treatment, not to caring guidance through what are difficult times. I made mistakes because of this. I also learned not to trust my parents because of the “rod”. Do we try to follow God’s will because we are scared of His punishment, or because we love Him, respect Him and want to be with Him?

I grew up with the view that God was the Punisher, do as you are supposed to to avoid the fires of Hell. I can assure you, without a single doubt in my mind, that if this is how I continued to view God, I would be an atheist - and I understand with this kind of view why atheism is growing. As I grew into adulthood, I realized that our God is a God of Love. Jesus did not punish the sinners, but took them in His arms, assured them He loved them and this feeling of love that they felt was what changed people, not the fear of punishment. People who feel the love of God are much more likely to respect others than those who simply fear punishment. Look at the crime rates - severity of punishment does not equal less crime - feelings of acceptance in society do lead to lower crime rates.

I have 4 young children, one being an almost 4 year old boy (my second oldest). To me the relationship with my children is more important than things that are inconsequential over the long term (i.e. what pair of pants they are wearing, etc.). Does that mean there is no discipline - absolutely not, there is, but discipline as I’ve learned is related to disciple - we are our children’s teachers, just as we are disciples (students) of Jesus. Discipline and punishment are two different things - discipline builds people and relationships while punishment naturally puts people down. My son is not the “strong-willed” one, but my older daughter is. The two year old is still too young to fully comprehend his actions, so it’s just repeating things 70 times 7 times until it finally starts to click with him.

I find that preparation is key, pick out the clothes for the next day in the evening - they know what’s coming in the morning and don’t have to stress about finding clothes. Don’t want to put your coat on leaving the house? Fine, I’ll carry it, even if it has to be discreetly and when you get cold you’ll ask, I will give it and explain why we wear coats. The next cold day, everyone has their coat on, because they understand why they have to wear a coat, not because they fear some punishment from me. It is a natural consequence which is not harmful to the child but a great teacher.

For food, present the healthy options, but if they choose not to eat much, don’t worry, they won’t starve, they’ll eat the next meal. Be considerate of what they like to eat as well - if you know they gag at the thought of tomato sauce, don’t try force them to eat it. If possible, present some choices. Would you like a jam sandwich or a ham sandwich? Would you like chicken or fish, rice or pasta? Is their “request” unreasonable? If not, I have no problem setting out a few different types of sandwiches/food. If we sit down for dinner at the same time everyday, but the child is not hungry at that time, but hungry later, look at snack and meal schedules - maybe they need to be spaced differently. Natural consequences also work with food. Don’t eat, get hungry, eat next time without a fuss. Just don’t give a meal between, or leave the last meal out so they can eat that first.

For activity transitions - warn ahead of time that a transition is coming, you can play for 5 more minutes then we have to go…we need to get going soon… etc. A great example I heard in a parenting seminar - if you are watching your favourite TV show and your spouse jumps in the room and tells you it’s time to go out of the blue - how are you going to react? Ok honey, I’m on my way, or get out of my way? Kids feel the same way and as parents we need to respect that. That might mean that they don’t start watching their favourite show because you know they won’t get to finish it, or that they can’t take out the painting activity, but can colour instead for example.

Bed time - consistent routine, mine is bath, pyjamas, brush teeth, stories, cuddle, small cup of water, sleep. Bed time is rarely an issue in my house. Are there some nights when my boys (2 and 4) who share a room up later than they should be talking from bunk to bunk…yes. I’ll stand at the door and just enjoy their conversations (which I see as relationship building) knowing they will drop in short time. I don’t see the need to fight it, in fact I love the fact that they are able to get along and talk to each other like that and will do everything I can to help strengthen the bond between them.
 
It is not easy to parent in this way at all. You do have to be on top of your game all the time - which in your case, with the loss of your father is very difficult. You have to plan out your day well. I also realize that anytime we do have issues, especially when getting ready to get somewhere on time, it’s my fault when things don’t go smoothly because I haven’t planned and prepared well enough.

Sometimes all the child really needs is some attention…hugs, kisses, a chat, cuddles. I know it doesn’t always fit in our schedules, but sometimes it just has too. I know when they are in their moods and we are rushing, that’s the hardest time to give them what they need. They need to learn to control their emotions, so if we are freaking out and making battles out of everything, that is what they are going to do. I know this is much easier said than done, but like I tell my wife, if we want our kids to stop yelling, we need to lead by example.

What I know is this, 20 years from now you won’t remember all the small fights, but your children will remember how they were treated. When you feel exasperated, give him a big hug, tell him you love him. Tickle and play, know that you might be a little late for work that day, but that’s just life.

Does it always go smoothly…absolutely not. But you can’t go wrong with love. The relationship between parent and child is something I feel very strongly about, so I apologize for the rant.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top