Have you not read in the Bible “spare the rod and hate the child”- children sometimes need physical reactions to their tantrums. My 14 year old son and 17 yr old daughter could put on quite a show when they didn’t get their way when they were 3 to 7 yrs old- we ignored them- guess what -they don’t put on a show now when they don’t get what they want. For really young ones when they start walking a great help is a wooden spoon- we bought ten at Sams for a few bucks. Amazing how it focuses thyeir attention when they get a whack on the butt when you tell them NO and they do it anyway.
Please, whatever you do, do not follow this advice! I was raised with the “rod” and can tell you it does so much harm to the parent-child relationship in the long term that it is not worth it. I went through a great deal of reflection after the birth of my child on parenting styles and methods and saw this method as harmful. Raising kids with fear is much different from teaching them respect. I did what I did out of fear of my parents. Would never “confess” any issues because they would be “punished”. Didn’t make a show when I was a teen because I knew that it would lead to harsh treatment, not to caring guidance through what are difficult times. I made mistakes because of this. I also learned not to trust my parents because of the “rod”. Do we try to follow God’s will because we are scared of His punishment, or because we love Him, respect Him and want to be with Him?
I grew up with the view that God was the Punisher, do as you are supposed to to avoid the fires of Hell. I can assure you, without a single doubt in my mind, that if this is how I continued to view God, I would be an atheist - and I understand with this kind of view why atheism is growing. As I grew into adulthood, I realized that our God is a God of Love. Jesus did not punish the sinners, but took them in His arms, assured them He loved them and this feeling of love that they felt was what changed people, not the fear of punishment. People who feel the love of God are much more likely to respect others than those who simply fear punishment. Look at the crime rates - severity of punishment does not equal less crime - feelings of acceptance in society do lead to lower crime rates.
I have 4 young children, one being an almost 4 year old boy (my second oldest). To me the relationship with my children is more important than things that are inconsequential over the long term (i.e. what pair of pants they are wearing, etc.). Does that mean there is no discipline - absolutely not, there is, but discipline as I’ve learned is related to disciple - we are our children’s teachers, just as we are disciples (students) of Jesus. Discipline and punishment are two different things - discipline builds people and relationships while punishment naturally puts people down. My son is not the “strong-willed” one, but my older daughter is. The two year old is still too young to fully comprehend his actions, so it’s just repeating things 70 times 7 times until it finally starts to click with him.
I find that preparation is key, pick out the clothes for the next day in the evening - they know what’s coming in the morning and don’t have to stress about finding clothes. Don’t want to put your coat on leaving the house? Fine, I’ll carry it, even if it has to be discreetly and when you get cold you’ll ask, I will give it and explain why we wear coats. The next cold day, everyone has their coat on, because they understand why they have to wear a coat, not because they fear some punishment from me. It is a natural consequence which is not harmful to the child but a great teacher.
For food, present the healthy options, but if they choose not to eat much, don’t worry, they won’t starve, they’ll eat the next meal. Be considerate of what they like to eat as well - if you know they gag at the thought of tomato sauce, don’t try force them to eat it. If possible, present some choices. Would you like a jam sandwich or a ham sandwich? Would you like chicken or fish, rice or pasta? Is their “request” unreasonable? If not, I have no problem setting out a few different types of sandwiches/food. If we sit down for dinner at the same time everyday, but the child is not hungry at that time, but hungry later, look at snack and meal schedules - maybe they need to be spaced differently. Natural consequences also work with food. Don’t eat, get hungry, eat next time without a fuss. Just don’t give a meal between, or leave the last meal out so they can eat that first.
For activity transitions - warn ahead of time that a transition is coming, you can play for 5 more minutes then we have to go…we need to get going soon… etc. A great example I heard in a parenting seminar - if you are watching your favourite TV show and your spouse jumps in the room and tells you it’s time to go out of the blue - how are you going to react? Ok honey, I’m on my way, or get out of my way? Kids feel the same way and as parents we need to respect that. That might mean that they don’t start watching their favourite show because you know they won’t get to finish it, or that they can’t take out the painting activity, but can colour instead for example.
Bed time - consistent routine, mine is bath, pyjamas, brush teeth, stories, cuddle, small cup of water, sleep. Bed time is rarely an issue in my house. Are there some nights when my boys (2 and 4) who share a room up later than they should be talking from bunk to bunk…yes. I’ll stand at the door and just enjoy their conversations (which I see as relationship building) knowing they will drop in short time. I don’t see the need to fight it, in fact I love the fact that they are able to get along and talk to each other like that and will do everything I can to help strengthen the bond between them.