I have a daughter who is not in communion

  • Thread starter Thread starter couponfit
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

couponfit

Guest
She was devoid of christ for years despite a good upbringing and strong witness and testimony from her parents. Over the past year she has begun to surge in her development of faith and is developing her spirituality in a ver y early stage of growth. Surround her way back to christ through a non denominational evangelical (not a charismatic) church that has a very narrow doctrine a single church unto itself led by a single pastor, and strong passionate following. I am happy for her to have Jesus in her thoughts and see any improvement whatsoever as a blessing and a beginning.

She is now attending catholic church and the evangelical ministry concurrently but she does not take part in the sacraments at catholic church and the evangelical church sees only two ordinances which she does not participate in. She is pondering what Jesus means to her. She wishes to raise her children in spirituality of chriat as neither are baptized but is still developing her own faith. She does this separate from her boy friend who does not practice or feel A calling to christ at this time.

I should note Im her step father and both of her parents died whn she was a child, first her dad then her mom whom I had married and with her moms death she was aided with family who for all purposes did not practice faith or teach her morality in their upbringing of her or even their own children.

So while her mother and father were Alive and while I was married to her mother she grew up in communion with the church but the death caused a personal schism.

she know nows she can talk to a priest about any questions she has and seems very open to the idea.

I dont want to push too hard or pull too hard. I am reserved in my concerns over her church and keep anything negative to myself so as not to disuaed from getting closer to christ all together. So with permission from my priest and in discussion with him I attend both services with her, focusing on praying with my non denominational brothers and sisters on Fridays in addition to going to catholic mass with her on sundays. I find the best part of catholic mass to her is the inclusion of the children in church. In her non denominational church children are moved to youth assembly and youth led prayer and worship. I’d like to build on what we have so fa without making her feel I am judgmental or absolutist in my views and in essense closed minded And divisive.

Any suggestions would be helpful. I approach this matter pastorally and seek the blessing of being guided through unity and love as recognized by Vatican II.
 
She was devoid of christ for years despite a good upbringing and strong witness and testimony from her parents. Over the past year she has begun to surge in her development of faith and is developing her spirituality in a ver y early stage of growth. Surround her way back to christ through a non denominational evangelical (not a charismatic) church that has a very narrow doctrine a single church unto itself led by a single pastor, and strong passionate following. I am happy for her to have Jesus in her thoughts and see any improvement whatsoever as a blessing and a beginning.

She is now attending catholic church and the evangelical ministry concurrently but she does not take part in the sacraments at catholic church and the evangelical church sees only two ordinances which she does not participate in. She is pondering what Jesus means to her. She wishes to raise her children in spirituality of chriat as neither are baptized but is still developing her own faith. She does this separate from her boy friend who does not practice or feel A calling to christ at this time.

I should note Im her step father and both of her parents died whn she was a child, first her dad then her mom whom I had married and with her moms death she was aided with family who for all purposes did not practice faith or teach her morality in their upbringing of her or even their own children.

So while her mother and father were Alive and while I was married to her mother she grew up in communion with the church but the death caused a personal schism.

she know nows she can talk to a priest about any questions she has and seems very open to the idea.

I dont want to push too hard or pull too hard. I am reserved in my concerns over her church and keep anything negative to myself so as not to disuaed from getting closer to christ all together. So with permission from my priest and in discussion with him I attend both services with her, focusing on praying with my non denominational brothers and sisters on Fridays in addition to going to catholic mass with her on sundays. I find the best part of catholic mass to her is the inclusion of the children in church. In her non denominational church children are moved to youth assembly and youth led prayer and worship. I’d like to build on what we have so fa without making her feel I am judgmental or absolutist in my views and in essense closed minded And divisive.

Any suggestions would be helpful. I approach this matter pastorally and seek the blessing of being guided through unity and love as recognized by Vatican II.
You may want to consider reading Patrick Madrid “Search and Rescue”.

My major concern with any Protestant group is that you are a target for evangelization and your attendance is seen as consent that it is the same as any other Church. This is a difficult decision and I am not in your shoes.

You may want to read “Bible and the Mass” and point out to her as you attend Mass…much of what goes on and emphasize what is not going on to dispel the untruths that she may hear…I would point out…

Mary is not the focus of the Mass and for the life of me from start to finish I cannot think of one point when Mary is mentioned…Worship is commenced with the Trinity…Trinitarian through the liturgy of the word and ends with a trinitarian blessing. You may want to point out how Trinitarian Christianity is and should be. You may want to ask where she thinks the Bible came from and get hold of Graham book on Where we got the bible…

Invite her here to CA…Only you know what to do…prayer is always good…🙂
 
Dear Couponfit,

You, sir, are an awesome father! Hats off to you for your continuous role in this young woman’s life! While you may not be her biological father, you are the only parent she has left and your ability to guide and influence her may have eternal impact – good for you for not giving up this crucial job!!!

Your love and concern for your daughter is obvious from your post. It sounds to me like you are doing the right things – consulting with your pastor, inviting her to come to Mass, praying for her and with her.

The only other suggestion I’d have to offer is that us women need support from other women sometimes too. Perhaps there is a woman you know in your parish that is about her age (or a few years older) that would be willing to take your daughter under her wing so to speak? Having a mentor of sorts might be just what your daughter needs. The other woman can invite your daughter in to things in ways that you cannot – like having her check out the women’s club, or volunteering with a parish dance or event, or coming to Bible study or women’s spirituality group. Sometimes, it hard to get involved in the parish, but when you have someone helping you find your way by providing opportunities, it makes a world of difference.
 
I think you are on the right track. Your instincts are correct. It is wonderful that she has such a devoted caring parent. I suggest that you pray for her and let her know that she can come to you if she has any questions. I don’t personally think there is anything wrong with you going to her church as well as your own. An idea would be to invite her to your church such as for a mass or even another nonreligious activity for example a church luncheon. Considering she is exploring, you could always suggest that she attends RCIA since it is also for people who are exploring and asking questions about the Catholic church.

Whatever you do, don’t push it. Give her lots of love, support and prayer. Eventually she’ll figure it out. At least she’s attending both. You are also being smart about keeping your negative feelings to yourself. Voicing them could turn her against you and the Catholic Church. She seems to have a lot on her plate. Exploring is always difficult but God is always there.

There is a simple book you can buy for her it is called: Why do Catholics genuflect by Al Kresta. It’s written in Q and A format which makes it very easy read. Catholics Come Home is another great organization because it helps people who are exploring and questioning the Catholic church by providing ressources as well as providing a mentor to help them. I also suggest that you pray for her boyfriend as well. Sometimes the inactive partner in the relationship will develop the God bug and have this amazing conversion that leads the explorer to Christ.

God is super wonderful. Eventually she’ll figure it out. Just keep praying and being a good dad to her.

Good Luck,
SG
 
It sounds to me like you are doing the right things
It sounds that way to me too. I’m also going to somewhat echo Secret Garden. I think it is great you “dont want to push too hard or pull too hard”. And that you “keep anything negative” to yourself “so as not to dissuade from getting closer to Christ all together”. You said you have permission from your priest to attend the other service. And I especially think it’s great you do not want, as you put it, to make her feel you are judgmental or absolutist in your views and in essense closed minded and divisive. Trust me. To do otherwise could potentially lead to the opposite you hope for. Continue to do what you are doing, pray, and leave the rest to God would be my suggestion. In any case God bless you and your step daughter. She seems blessed to have you in her life. And you to have her in yours. Peace to you both along this journey we call faith.
 
Couponfit,

It sounds like things are headed in the right direction but having endured what your step-daughter has endured, it’s not surprising. I heartily recommend a purchase of the Catholicism DVD set and watch each episode together. Episode Three on the nature of God addresses why there is evil in the world and tragedy we don’t always understand. Episode 8 on the Saints cites Edith Stern who became Sister Teresa Benedicta of the Cross. Prayer, patience, compassion. The whole series gets to one powerful point, God loves us, he searching for us and wants us to fall in love with Him. Will keep you in my prayers.
 
Here is a Catholic site to explain her questions about the faith.
It is easy to use and one topic leads naturally into another.
Or topics can be picked singly. Well written.
She might want to browse this at her leisure, as time permits.

www.davidmacd.com/catholic/mary_in_the-bible.htm

Your doing a good job. And I’m not just saying that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top