I keep getting humility and self-esteem confused

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Holly3278

Guest
Hey everyone. I am having an issue that I need some advice with. I keep getting humility and self-esteem confused. As you know, humility is a virtue. Well, self-esteem is also supposed to be a good thing but not a virtue. Basically I am having trouble discerning the difference between improved self-esteem and being prideful. I’d appreciate any (name removed by moderator)ut and advice you can offer.
 
Hey everyone. I am having an issue that I need some advice with. I keep getting humility and self-esteem confused. As you know, humility is a virtue. Well, self-esteem is also supposed to be a good thing but not a virtue. Basically I am having trouble discerning the difference between improved self-esteem and being prideful. I’d appreciate any (name removed by moderator)ut and advice you can offer.
Humility means we understand that everything we are and all our talents and abilities come from God. Pride therefore is a lie, because it claims we are the author of these things. Humility understands God could take it away in an instant.

Self-esteem is not a Christian concept, because the concepts of self esteem and self hatred assume that we generate our own reality. In contrast, Christianity says that we are to embrace God’s voice of love for us, and reject the message of the evil one who says we are unlovable or we need to do evil things to find satisfaction. So Christians do not have “self esteem”, they embrace God’s voice of love and peace and “everything is going to be ok”. They do not have “self-hatred”, they reject the voice of the evil one who tries to make us believe that our personal faults cannot be mitigated and healed when we trust our Heavenly Father.
 
Humility means we understand that everything we are and all our talents and abilities come from God. Pride therefore is a lie, because it claims we are the author of these things. Humility understands God could take it away in an instant.

Self-esteem is not a Christian concept, because the concepts of self esteem and self hatred assume that we generate our own reality. In contrast, Christianity says that we are to embrace God’s voice of love for us, and reject the message of the evil one who says we are unlovable or we need to do evil things to find satisfaction. So Christians do not have “self esteem”, they embrace God’s voice of love and peace and “everything is going to be ok”. They do not have “self-hatred”, they reject the voice of the evil one who tries to make us believe that our personal faults cannot be mitigated and healed when we trust our Heavenly Father.
Thank you very much Father Jones. I really appreciate this answer. It was very helpful. 🙂
 
I’m not a shrink or a theologian, but here’s my take:

I think they are two sides of the same coin.

If we’re humble, we know our “place” in God’s creation and plan, and act according to that knowledge. If we have proper self-esteem, we do not veer from that known place, either denigrating ourselves below our proper status as children of God, nor elevating ourselves above that station. Our humanity is worthy of respect, but only to the point where we start departing from the truth.
 
The most important esteem we should have is the knowledge (not necessarily the feeling…feelings come and go, as God allows) that we are His children.

That He is Our Father.

Nothing…nothing…can shake us if we struggle to believe this…and to see all events of our lives…good or bad…as part of God’s plan for us. Our Father is right next to us.

This is called ‘divine filiation’.

This divine esteem is far more than secular self-esteem, or confidence… Divine filiation brings joy, strength, serenity, and warmth even amid troubles.

We are His children…and He is our loving Father, desiring great unity with us. More mind-blowingly, He is always desiring EVER GREATER unity with us!! Closer…closer…closer still.

Sometimes “self-esteem” can actually “get in the way” of greater unity…we forget about God (in the present moment)…we begin to think we can do anything worthwhile without Him. But we can’t!
 
Have a high esteem towards LOVE and God, but avoid self-esteem like a plague. Mainstream psychology teaches the self-esteem is healthy but rise above to true esteem and you will see that it is as nothing. Self-esteem was seen in psychology as the cure to neurosis, and the job of ‘successful’ psychologists was to build self-esteem in such patients. The problem was that they ignored the underlying causes to neurosis, and patients would always loss their self-esteem time and time again and psychologists would need to constantly rebuild their self-esteem consequentially. Again, self-esteem is falsely attributed to mental health, and there is no need for it in psychology if you have genuine esteem and humility.

Humility involves the lack of pride, and is always a good virtue.
 
Hey everyone. I am having an issue that I need some advice with. I keep getting humility and self-esteem confused. As you know, humility is a virtue. Well, self-esteem is also supposed to be a good thing but not a virtue. Basically I am having trouble discerning the difference between improved self-esteem and being prideful. I’d appreciate any (name removed by moderator)ut and advice you can offer.
Self esteem is an ego concept. A more correct term would be “self-pride”. The secular world considers it to be emotionally healthy to have self pride. Christ however calls us to sacrifice our ego, our worldly self, and die to the things of this world such as self pride. In exchange we are given the Peace of Christ which surpasses human understanding. That’s not to say the ego gives up easily and there isn’t a period of turmoil though.
 
Sacred Scriptures says: Let each esteem others as better than themselves. This requires true humility to do – one’s high self-esteem might make this somewhat difficult to do. We can not be good Christians without humility; we can/will be good Christians when we esteem others as better than ourselves, which does not require any self-esteem on our part, but only true and perfect humility. Let us pray for true humility and not worry about self-esteem. God bless you, Holly.
 
The spiritual masters in Christianity all tell us that knowledge of Christ will also bring knowledge of self, not the false self, but the true self. In this knowledge we are humbled because we come to understand that nothing we have was of our own doing, but given to us by God.

Therefore, who can boast before the Lord God?

Jim
 
The spiritual masters in Christianity all tell us that knowledge of Christ will also bring knowledge of self, not the false self, but the true self. In this knowledge we are humbled because we come to understand that nothing we have was of our own doing, but given to us by God.

Therefore, who can boast before the Lord God?

Jim
That is very interesting Jim. I like it. 🙂

I have a question for you. Sometimes when people praise or thank me for saying something good I will, in an attempt to be humble, say “I give all the glory to God for I cannot do anything good without His grace.” Would you say that saying this is a good thing and that it is a reflection of where you said “In this knowledge we are humbled because we come to understand that nothing we have was of our own doing, but given to us by God.”?
 
That is very interesting Jim. I like it. 🙂

I have a question for you. Sometimes when people praise or thank me for saying something good I will, in an attempt to be humble, say “I give all the glory to God for I cannot do anything good without His grace.” Would you say that saying this is a good thing and that it is a reflection of where you said “In this knowledge we are humbled because we come to understand that nothing we have was of our own doing, but given to us by God.”?
Just say thanks, and move on and silently praise God for giving you this level of truth.

To go further only draws attention to yourself rather than God, regardless of your words.

Jim
 
Just say thanks, and move on and silently praise God for giving you this level of truth.

To go further only draws attention to yourself rather than God, regardless of your words.

Jim
Thanks Jim! I wondered if you’d say that. That was precisely what my spiritual director, Fr. Ray, told me when I asked him about it a while back. :o
 
I would like to add that good self esteem is important. It is true that the best self esteem should be based on chrisitan principles, but at the same time, God give us all the natural virtues as well for our good. The problem comes in when we do not measure up to our neighbor or our fellow worker who is better than we are in some area.

It may not be the best thought to have, comparing ourself to others, but isn’t it a fact that in some cases if we don’t, then we lose out. These natural talents do reflect on who we are in the everyday walk of life. I know in the christian sense it dosen’t. But then we are still living in this world.

I believe that our accomplishments/failures do reflect who we are in a certain way in the here and now.

We could tell a person all day long that they should have all kinds of good christian ideas about themselves, but how is this helpful if they indeed are having many problems which seem insurmountable. I don’t mean to say that understanding themselves in the view of God is not helpful, but they still need a good understanding from others as well.

I would tend to lean toward good wholesome natural thoughts and ideas to help as well as the christian thoughts. Somewhere I heard that “grace builds on nature”.

I’m not poo pooing christian reflection on self as a good way to self value, but I also believe that these natural virtues are of great help too and support the christian virtues.

Just a few thoughts.​

“Day is done, but Love unfailing dwells ever here. Shaddows fall, but hope, prevailing, calms every fear.” (hymn)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top