I know a girl who wants to be a genetic counselor

  • Thread starter Thread starter Young_Thinker
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

Young_Thinker

Guest
Hi everyone. I have had a couple of university classes with a young lady whom I really like. Yesterday I learned that she wants to become a genetic counselor. When she told me this, I half-jokingly exclaimed something like, “I’m a Catholic, so I could never do that! I am sure that I would get fired for expressing my opinion!” Admittedly, I am romantically attracted to this girl and would like to enjoy at least a friendship with her. So, I was wondering as to whether I should confront her about the immorality of her intended career choice. And if I should confront her about, what might be the best way to go about it (i.e. without alienating her)? I would appreciate any advice.
 
Why do you assume this is an immoral career? When I was pregnant, the hospital set us up to speak with a genetic counselor. It was a Catholic hospital and there was absolutely nothing in the counseling that was even remotely immoral. :confused:
 
Why do you assume this is an immoral career? When I was pregnant, the hospital set us up to speak with a genetic counselor. It was a Catholic hospital and there was absolutely nothing in the counseling that was even remotely immoral. :confused:
I understand that this kind of service can have some benefits. But genetic counseling also seems to encourage mothers to abort their children if they have health problems or for people with hereditary diseases to contracept all of their lives.
 
I understand that this kind of service can have some benefits. But genetic counseling also seems to encourage mothers to abort their children if they have health problems or for people with hereditary diseases to contracept all of their lives.
Not all genetic counselors or geneticists are pro-abortion. In fact, they often save many lives by the work they do. It would be a good thing (and probably interesting too) to discuss with your friend why she wants to do this type of work and how she would go about her practice.
Blessings.
 
Not all genetic counselors or geneticists are pro-abortion. In fact, they often save many lives by the work they do. It would be a good thing (and probably interesting too) to discuss with your friend why she wants to do this type of work and how she would go about her practice.
Blessings.
I see. Thanks for the advice.
 
I understand that this kind of service can have some benefits. But genetic counseling also seems to encourage mothers to abort their children if they have health problems or for people with hereditary diseases to contracept all of their lives.
It’s not about the career but about the facility where one works.

The knowledge that genetic counselors provide is morally neutral. Some people use that knowledge immorally.
 
OK, there can be exceptions. However in this case, it is wise to be cautious and proceed with a healthy skepticism.

Why not ask her position on aborting a baby when there is a positive test for genetic issues.

Ask her position on genetic manipulation to alter the makeup of a new person.
 
It’s not about the career but about the facility where one works.

The knowledge that genetic counselors provide is morally neutral. Some people use that knowledge immorally.
Okay.
 
Hi everyone. I have had a couple of university classes with a young lady whom I really like. Yesterday I learned that she wants to become a genetic counselor. When she told me this, I half-jokingly exclaimed something like, “I’m a Catholic, so I could never do that! I am sure that I would get fired for expressing my opinion!” Admittedly, I am romantically attracted to this girl and would like to enjoy at least a friendship with her. So, I was wondering as to whether I should confront her about the immorality of her intended career choice. And if I should confront her about, what might be the best way to go about it (i.e. without alienating her)? I would appreciate any advice.
I don’t quite understand how genetic counseling is immoral. It is merely informational for parents who want to understand genetic risk during a pregnancy. One of the great things about modern medicine is that treatment for some childhood problems can actually begin prior to birth, and the parents are well informed and prepared for the child’s arrival.
 
OK, there can be exceptions. However in this case, it is wise to be cautious and proceed with a healthy skepticism.

Why not ask her position on aborting a baby when there is a positive test for genetic issues.

Ask her position on genetic manipulation to alter the makeup of a new person.
Good advice. Do you think that there would there be any particular way to broach the subject with her?
 
This girl is probably not going to enjoy a moral interrogation, especially if you don’t know her too well. If you want to get to know her better, then stick to regular topics until you’re a little closer. Ask her about music or films or crack a few jokes.
 
I can understand OPs concern. While the job of a genetic counselor is charitably good, how would they possibly separate the moral duties from the immoral? E.g. the genetic counselor does a good deed by informing the parents that their unborn child has a genetic disorder, then mentions all the services available for support. In this case how could they omit the immoral choice of abortion and continue to be a genetic counselor?
As another poster said, have a talk about that topic when time is right. 🙂
 
This girl is probably not going to enjoy a moral interrogation, especially if you don’t know her too well. If you want to get to know her better, then stick to regular topics until you’re a little closer. Ask her about music or films or crack a few jokes.
I agree that it is not likely to assist in getting to know her, if you come across as judgmental. One way that I broach such topics when I want to find out someone’s opinion, is to wait until the issue is in the news., and then bring it up. Another way would be to take a genuine interest in finding out why she wants to be a genetic counselor, and ask her what the job entails. In the course of that discussion, it would not be unusual to talk about such things as prenatal medical intervention and abortion. Even without asking her moral position directly, you might get a sense of where she stands by how she talks about it.

Here is an excerpt from a job description:

Tasks-The National Society of Genetic Counselors lists these tasks.

Note: The following is a list of sample tasks typically performed by Genetic Counselors. Employees in this occupation will not necessarily perform all of the tasks listed.

Tasks

Provide information and support to families who have members with birth defects or genetic disorders and to families who may be at risk for a variety of inherited conditions.

Identify families at risk, investigate the problem present in the family, interpret information about the disorder, analyze inheritance patterns and risks of recurrence and review available options with the family.

Provide supportive counseling to families.

Serve as patient advocates and refer individuals and families to community or state support services.

Serve as educators and resource people for other health care professionals and for the general public.

Engage in research activities related to the field of medical genetics and genetic counseling.
 
E.g. the genetic counselor does a good deed by informing the parents that their unborn child has a genetic disorder, then mentions all the services available for support. In this case how could they omit the immoral choice of abortion and continue to be a genetic counselor?
The genetic counselors we were referred to were in a Catholic hospital. Abortion was never mentioned or even hinted at. It is quite possible to be a genetic counselor and to do so in a moral way the same as it is possible to be a gynocologist and not prescribe contraceptives or to be a urologist and not perform vasectomies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top