I need help responding to someone on a message board

  • Thread starter Thread starter catholictiger
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

catholictiger

Guest
Is it evil when you want to build a house on top of an ant pile? Not to you, but to the ants it certainly is.
So, when God does his will, it’s not evil to him, but it is to us, and he is aware that it is to us.
Do you know what the word sin in the Hebrew literally means? It means to miss the mark, or miss the target, as in an arrow missing a target.
To sin is to miss a target set by God. Since God sets the targets, he can’t miss, therefore, it is impossible for him to sin.
ill put this in context as best as I can

in this thread we are discussion predetermination (nothing to do with argument but it sparks it)

this guy says There is no free will and gives some scripture to back up his point

I make the claim that if there is no free will why is their evil in the world

he makes the claim that its becuase its the will of God

I respond that would make God partly Evil even though he is all loving

then he responds with the quotations

how do you respond to this scripture would be nice also.

thanks

Im thinking about using an argument that we are created in the image and likeness of God and there for the perfect definition of human love is the definition of Love.

No loving parent would ever force their child to do something, they would let their child go do something even if they knew it could be harmful to them.

So if a loving parent would let their children do what they want why would God not if we are created in his image.
 
This Calvinistic idea of no free will pretty much makes us equal to plants and does no justice to “created in His image.” We simply react to stimulus in accord with our biology? It’s almost a materialist position.

As to Scripture…every single Scripture that exhorts the reader to do something is worded in favor of the individual having the capacity to respond. So that gives you 100s of examples. Here are some others I had jotted in the past on free will.

James 4:8 Draw near to God and He will draw near to you.

Philemon 1:14 but without thy mind I would do nothing; that thy goodness should not be as of necessity, but of** free will**.

Deuteronomy 23:23 You shall be careful to perform what has passed your lips, for you have voluntarily vowed to the Lord your God what you have promised with your mouth.

Jeremiah 18:1-18 The word that came to Jeremiah from the LORD: “Arise, and go down to the potter’s house, and there I will let you hear my words.” So I went down to the potter’s house, and there he was working at his wheel. And the vessel he was making of clay was spoiled in the potter’s hand, and he reworked it into another vessel, as it seemed good to the potter to do. Then the word of the Lord came to me: "O house of Israel, can I not do with you as this potter has done? says the Lord. Behold, like the clay in the potter’s hand, so are you in my hand, O house of Israel. If at any time I declare concerning a nation or a kingdom, that I will pluck up and break down and destroy it, and if that nation, concerning which I have spoken, turns from its evil, I will repent of the evil that I intended to do to it. And if at any time I declare concerning a nation or a kingdom that I will build and plant it, and if it does evil in my sight, not listening to my voice, then I will repent of the good which I had intended to do to it. Now, therefore, say to the men of Judah and the inhabitants of Jerusalem: Thus says the Lord, Behold, I am shaping evil against you and devising a plan against you. Return, every one from his evil way, and amend your ways and your doings.' "But they say, That is in vain! We will follow our own plans, and will every one act according to the stubbornness of his evil heart.’

Jeremiah 2:13 For my people have done two evils. They have forsaken me, the Fountain of living water, and they have dug for themselves cisterns, broken cisterns that are unable to hold water.

2 Timothy 2:12 if we deny Him, He also will deny us.
 
ill put this in context as best as I can

in this thread we are discussion predetermination (nothing to do with argument but it sparks it)

this guy says There is no free will and gives some scripture to back up his point

I make the claim that if there is no free will why is their evil in the world

he makes the claim that its becuase its the will of God

I respond that would make God partly Evil even though he is all loving

then he responds with the quotations

how do you respond to this scripture would be nice also.

thanks

Im thinking about using an argument that we are created in the image and likeness of God and there for the perfect definition of human love is the definition of Love.

No loving parent would ever force their child to do something, they would let their child go do something even if they knew it could be harmful to them.

So if a loving parent would let their children do what they want why would God not if we are created in his image.
You would benefit, I think, from listening to a talk by Dr. Peter Kreeft on this topic:

alabamacatholicresources.com/Downloads/peter-kreeft_fated-free.mp3

Just download the .MP3 file and listen to it on your PC (use free Realplayer or Windows Media Player, etc.), your iPod or iPad, or an MP3 player if you have one. I think he pretty well answers your questions, from a Catholic perspective. 🙂

Oh, and if it comes up (normally it does), and they ask you, “Why does God allow evil?” then you can give the no-brainer theological answer, “In order to bring about a greater good.” Example: Jesus being crucified and dying on the Cross for us. (Great evil happened to Him!) But, through this act, He obtained redemption for all mankind. (Great good!)
 
there is a great little book on this topic called Trustful Surrender. it get into the exact point that you guys are debating and it gives the authentic Catholic position on the matter.

but the bottom line is that you are correct, without sin there would be no suffering. we’d all still be living in the garden of eden.

also without free will there is no true love, God wants us to choose Him over our own desires, that choice is an act of true love, putting His will over our own.

look for that book though, you will love it.
 
ill put this in context as best as I can

in this thread we are discussion predetermination (nothing to do with argument but it sparks it)

this guy says There is no free will and gives some scripture to back up his point

I make the claim that if there is no free will why is their evil in the world

he makes the claim that its becuase its the will of God

I respond that would make God partly Evil even though he is all loving

then he responds with the quotations

how do you respond to this scripture would be nice also.

thanks

Im thinking about using an argument that we are created in the image and likeness of God and there for the perfect definition of human love is the definition of Love.

No loving parent would ever force their child to do something, they would let their child go do something even if they knew it could be harmful to them.

So if a loving parent would let their children do what they want why would God not if we are created in his image.
The person you’re conversing with sounds like a hard core Calvinist who believes in double predestination.
 
The person you’re conversing with sounds like a hard core Calvinist who believes in double predestination.
Yeppers and good luck with that conversation.

What’s funny is I’ve never met a hard core Calvinist that believed himself to be a reporbate.

I wonder why that is ;).

Chuck
 
Yeppers and good luck with that conversation.

What’s funny is I’ve never met a hard core Calvinist that believed himself to be a reporbate.

I wonder why that is ;).

Chuck
As St Francis de Sales wrote

“And when it is said that “in sinning we are incited, pushed, necessitated by the will, ordinance, decree, and predestination of God,”-is this not to blaspheme against all reason, and against the majesty of the supreme goodness ? Such is the fine theology of Zwingle *de prud. *5, 6], Calvin (Instit. I. 17, 18; de Praed.; Instruct. contra Lib.), and Beza (contra Castal.). " But,” says Beza, “you will say that they Could not resist the will of God, that is, the decree; I acknowledge it: but as they could not so they would not: they could not wish otherwise, I own, as to the event and working (energiam), but yet the will of Adam was not forced.” Goodness of God, I call you as my witness! You have pushed me to do evil; you have so decreed, ordained, and willed; I could not act otherwise, I could not will otherwise, -what fault of mine is there? O God of my heart! chastise my will, if it is able not to will evil and wills to will it; but if it cannot help willing evil, and thou art the cause of its impossibility, what fault of mine can there be? If this is not contrary to reason, I protest that there is no reason in the world. The law of God is impossible, according to Calvin and the others (Calv. ant. Sess. conc. Tr.; Luther de lib. Christ.): what follows, except that Our Lord is a tyrant who commands impossible things? If it is impossible, why is it commanded? "

From CHAPTER I. That the teaching of the pretended reformers contradicts reason.

St Francis was very successful in bringing Calvinists back to the Church.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top