I think this is an ex cathedra statement

  • Thread starter Thread starter marlo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

marlo

Guest
The statement below by the late Pope JPII, regarding the ordination of Women, has everything needed as regarding to papal infallibility, what do you think?

"Although the teaching that priestly ordination is to be reserved to men alone has been preserved by the constant and universal Tradition of the Church and firmly taught by the Magisterium in its more recent documents, at the present time in some places it is nonetheless considered still open to debate, or the Church’s judgment that women are not to be admitted to ordination is considered to have a merely disciplinary force.

“Wherefore, in order that all doubt may be removed regarding a matter of great importance, a matter which pertains to the Church’s divine constitution itself, in virtue of my ministry of confirming the brethren (cf. Lk 22:32) I declare that the Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women and that this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church’s faithful.”
 
Sure sounds like it, but the rest of the communication’s context needs to be taken into consideration. Where is this taken from?
 
The statement below by the late Pope JPII, regarding the ordination of Women, has everything needed as regarding to papal infallibility, what do you think?

"Although the teaching that priestly ordination is to be reserved to men alone has been preserved by the constant and universal Tradition of the Church and firmly taught by the Magisterium in its more recent documents, at the present time in some places it is nonetheless considered still open to debate, or the Church’s judgment that women are not to be admitted to ordination is considered to have a merely disciplinary force.

"Wherefore, in order that all doubt may be removed
regarding a matter of great importance, a matter which pertains to the Church’s divine constitution itself, in virtue of my ministry of confirming the brethren (cf. Lk 22:32) I declare that the Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women and that this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church’s faithful."
No, it’s not. He is simply invoking the constant teaching of the Church.
 
While it is not an ex cathedra statement, it is an infallible statement. The Pope has two types of infallibility. Formal, which is the type to which you asked about (ex cathedra) and normal, which only requires the Pope to intend to teach the universal Church on matters of faith and morals, which is what this is. Formal infallibility is for matters of greater importance, while normal infallibility is for matters of lesser importance.
 
Scoobyshme’s got it right. Pope John Paul II was reiterating the infallible teaching of the ordinary Magisterium.
 
While it is not an ex cathedra statement, it is an infallible statement. The Pope has two types of infallibility. Formal, which is the type to which you asked about (ex cathedra) and normal, which only requires the Pope to intend to teach the universal Church on matters of faith and morals, which is what this is. Formal infallibility is for matters of greater importance, while normal infallibility is for matters of lesser importance.
Yes. I think that the laity are to assume all such statements are submitted to the faithful as “believed to be true” and we are all under an obligation to accept and concede to it as if true. Those that refuse to accept this kind of statement and challenge it insubordinate themselves and that can be a grave matter.

Essentially JPII by making a universal proclamation has made the topic off limits to casual speculation or further debate.

James
 
Thanks you, however, if its an infallible statement, it should be spoken by the Pope ex cathedra right? so, its an ex cathedra statement?
While it is not an ex cathedra statement, it is an infallible statement. The Pope has two types of infallibility. Formal, which is the type to which you asked about (ex cathedra) and normal, which only requires the Pope to intend to teach the universal Church on matters of faith and morals, which is what this is. Formal infallibility is for matters of greater importance, while normal infallibility is for matters of lesser importance.
 
Thanks you, however, if its an infallible statement, it should be spoken by the Pope ex cathedra right? so, its an ex cathedra statement?
No. Those who have pointed out that Pope JPII was restating the constant teaching of the universal magisterium are correct. Here are the words of Pope Benedict XVI when he was Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith:
This teaching requires definitive assent, since, founded on the written Word of God, and from the beginning constantly preserved and applied in the Tradition of the Church, it has been set forth infallibly by the ordinary and universal Magisterium (cf. Second Vatican Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church Lumen Gentium 25, 2). Thus, in the present circumstances, the Roman Pontiff, exercising his proper office of confirming the brethren (cf. Lk 22:32), has handed on this same teaching by a formal declaration, explicitly stating what is to be held always, everywhere, and by all, as belonging to the deposit of the faith.
 
Thanks you, however, if its an infallible statement, it should be spoken by the Pope ex cathedra right? so, its an ex cathedra statement?
The document by pope John Paul II on the Catholic Churches inability to Ordain Women re-iterates the constant teaching of the infallible ordinary magisterium. It is not an extraordinary teaching of the pope speaking Ex Cathedra.
 
Just because a teaching is a reiteration of magisterial teaching, doesn’t mean it is ineligable to be ex cathedra. In fact, all *ex cathedra *statements need to be stating something already taught by the Church, explicitly or otherwise.

This particular declaration fits only 3 of the 4 requirements stated by the First Vatican Council in Pastor Aeternus.

The one thing that is missing is for this document to be addressed to all of the members of the Church–which it is not. It is addressed only to bishops, hence, it cannot be an *ex cathedra *statement. If it had been addressed to the universal Church, I believe it could have been considered ex cathedra.
 
Just because a teaching is a reiteration of magisterial teaching, doesn’t mean it is ineligable to be ex cathedra. In fact, all *ex cathedra *statements need to be stating something already taught by the Church, explicitly or otherwise.

This particular declaration fits only 3 of the 4 requirements stated by the First Vatican Council in Pastor Aeternus.

The one thing that is missing is for this document to be addressed to all of the members of the Church–which it is not. It is addressed only to bishops, hence, it cannot be an *ex cathedra *statement. If it had been addressed to the universal Church, I believe it could have been considered ex cathedra.
An Ex Cathedra pronouncement is not something that is analyzed to see if it might “fit” the definition. An Ex Cathedra pronouncement is made with that clearly in mind when it is made by the pope. A Pope cannot accidentally make an Ex Cathedra statement. It either was intended to be or it wasn’t.
 
How about all the statements lately by the Pope and many of the US Bishops condemning abortion as an intrinsic evil. They are all speaking with one voice, I would think that would be some form of ex cathedra? I hope so, anyway, not that there ever was any debate on it…
 
How about all the statements lately by the Pope and many of the US Bishops condemning abortion as an intrinsic evil. They are all speaking with one voice, I would think that would be some form of ex cathedra? I hope so, anyway, not that there ever was any debate on it…
No
 
An Ex Cathedra pronouncement is not something that is analyzed to see if it might “fit” the definition. An Ex Cathedra pronouncement is made with that clearly in mind when it is made by the pope. A Pope cannot accidentally make an Ex Cathedra statement. It either was intended to be or it wasn’t.
One of the conditions established by Vatican I is that the pope intentionlly makes a binding decision. Hence, I grant that the pope makes such a statement consciously. However, he need not call it an ex cathedra statement per se. Such statements certainly do need to be analyzed to see if they fit certain criteria otherwise you would have to conclude that there have been no ex cathedra statements before the First Vatican Council which officially declared the doctrine of papal infallibility.

Earlier statements–even from the first several centuries of the Church are considered ex cathedra because they meet those criteria established by the council.
 
This is an area where I wish the current pope would sit down with all his historians and theologians and scholars and once and for all put together a definitive ex-cathedra list of ex-cathedra proclamations.

Catholics have nothing to hide and it makes us look silly to non-Catholics when we even have to debate among ourselves which statements meet the formal criteria. Ironically, it hardly matter which are formally ex cathedra or not since the laity as well as the clergy MUST assent to any teaching of faith and morals taugh as as “believed to be true” irrespective if its ex cathedra or not.

But to disambiguate it once and for all there should be a special papal ex-cathedra seal that must be affixed to every formal written statement that is intended to be spoken ex-cathedra.

Vatican I requires the following:
According to the teaching of the First Vatican Council and Catholic tradition, the conditions required for ex cathedra teaching are as follows:
  1. “the Roman Pontiff”
  2. “speaks ex cathedra” (“that is, when in the discharge of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, and by virtue of his supreme apostolic authority….”)
  3. “he defines”
  4. “that a doctrine concerning faith or morals”
  5. “must be held by the whole Church” (Pastor Aeternus, chap. 4)
For a teaching by a pope or ecumenical council to be recognized as infallible, the teaching must make it clear that the Church is to consider it definitive and binding. But sadly, there is not any specific phrasing required for this. However, it is usually indicated by one or both of the following: (1) a verbal formula indicating that this teaching is definitive (such as “We declare, decree and define…”), or (2) an accompanying anathema stating that anyone who deliberately dissents is outside the Catholic Church.

I say its time to put our pope to work and use the charisma of papal infallability to interpret all the prior papal statements and infallibly rule once and for all on which ones are infallable ex cathedra teachings and formalize a cannon of ex-cathedra proclamations. Frankly, the church seems to be almost afraid to use its power to interpret its own rulings since it knows non-Catholics are waiting in the wings for a retraction so they can say “aha - see you are fallable afterall.”

James
 
I don’t honestly think that such a listing would be a prudent course. If there were a bunch of statements going around that were being claimed as infallible which were not, I might see the need, but this isn’t really the case. That is why the Church canonized the Scriptures and list of ecumenical councils, because there were others around that falsely claimed the status.

What you propose would be extremely difficult, especially as theologians still debate how the criteria are to be applied–that being said (and as you pointed out) there are actually no need for such a list, because even in cases where someone might not be certain, the decree is usually still conscious binding anyway, so it makes no difference to them in a practical moral sense.
 
I don’t honestly think that such a listing would be a prudent course. If there were a bunch of statements going around that were being claimed as infallible which were not, I might see the need, but this isn’t really the case. That is why the Church canonized the Scriptures and list of ecumenical councils, because there were others around that falsely claimed the status.
What you propose would be extremely difficult, especially as theologians still debate how the criteria are to be applied–that being said (and as you pointed out) there are actually no need for such a list, because even in cases where someone might not be certain, the decree is usually still conscious binding anyway, so it makes no difference to them in a practical moral sense.
First of all, you were right vis-a-vis Br. Rich.
But think about the implications of what you are saying above. The whole charism of infallibility is supposed to be an integral part of the church’s mission to proclaim the truth. Infallible proclamations are supposed to be a clear beacon of truth to the fiathful and to the world; at least that is how several priests have explained it to me. Yet you are saying that the criteria for an infallible proclamation are far from clear or settled, and you are right. Can you not see that that undermines the entire supposed purpose of having a category of “infallible” proclamations?
Contrary to what a previous poster said, there is much to fear in compiling a list of “infallible” declarations, as some of them, little known to modern Catholics, are quite problematic.
 
On the contrary, I believe the criteria quite clear. Vatican I gave a concrete explanation and four criteria. There is no real doubt about the criteria themselves, but how those criteria are applied to certain concrete documents is something not always agreed upon. For instance, since there is no formula for a pope expressing that his intention is to bind consciences, some people wish to think that most definitions are not infallible.
Contrary to what a previous poster said, there is much to fear in compiling a list of “infallible” declarations, as some of them, little known to modern Catholics, are quite problematic.
I have a major problem with this statement, however. There are absolutely no infallible declarations that the Church is ashamed of or problematic if understood. The Church has nothing to hide from the truth. Please give an example of one such declaration that you believe to be infallible yet “problematic”.
 
This is an area where I wish the current pope would sit down with all his historians and theologians and scholars and once and for all put together a definitive ex-cathedra list of ex-cathedra proclamations.

Catholics have nothing to hide and it makes us look silly to non-Catholics when we even have to debate among ourselves which statements meet the formal criteria. Ironically, it hardly matter which are formally ex cathedra or not since the laity as well as the clergy MUST assent to any teaching of faith and morals taugh as as “believed to be true” irrespective if its ex cathedra or not.

But to disambiguate it once and for all there should be a special papal ex-cathedra seal that must be affixed to every formal written statement that is intended to be spoken ex-cathedra.

Vatican I requires the following:
According to the teaching of the First Vatican Council and Catholic tradition, the conditions required for ex cathedra teaching are as follows:
  1. “the Roman Pontiff”
  2. “speaks ex cathedra” (“that is, when in the discharge of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, and by virtue of his supreme apostolic authority….”)
  3. “he defines”
  4. “that a doctrine concerning faith or morals”
  5. “must be held by the whole Church” (Pastor Aeternus, chap. 4)
For a teaching by a pope or ecumenical council to be recognized as infallible, the teaching must make it clear that the Church is to consider it definitive and binding. But sadly, there is not any specific phrasing required for this. However, it is usually indicated by one or both of the following: (1) a verbal formula indicating that this teaching is definitive (such as “We declare, decree and define…”), or (2) an accompanying anathema stating that anyone who deliberately dissents is outside the Catholic Church.

I say its time to put our pope to work and use the charisma of papal infallability to interpret all the prior papal statements and infallibly rule once and for all on which ones are infallable ex cathedra teachings and formalize a cannon of ex-cathedra proclamations. Frankly, the church seems to be almost afraid to use its power to interpret its own rulings since it knows non-Catholics are waiting in the wings for a retraction so they can say “aha - see you are fallable afterall.”

James
Thank you. I agree 100%.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top