I went to make a general confession and was stopped. Is that fine?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Gabrielle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you for your (name removed by moderator)ut Father. And thank you @TheOldColonel. I appreciate both your (name removed by moderator)uts. On Father’s side, I want to say that I do have scrupulous tendencies and that most of the sins on my list, with the exception or maybe 3, I’d confessed in the past in separate confessions. I have always wondered if they were not good confessions for one reason or the other, so I believe that perhaps the Priest who heard my confession may have recognized scruples. For TheOldColonel, I appreciate your taking the time to advice me on multiple ocasions :). My last intention was to start an argument and I’m sorry for that.
 
Last edited:
The remaining pages are still important. Find a priest who is patient and kind enough to allow you to fully confess. A priest who is overwork, who hears confessions 15-20 hours a week, may lose his patience or falsely believe he has become so talented as to not need to hear every word. But that is not in keeping with the spirit of the sacrament. Indeed, the penitent traditionally informs the priest when the confession of sins is complete, not the other way around.

I approach my own confessions utilizing a leadership concept I learned in the service. S.M.A.R.T.

Specific: know what you need to do
Measurable: know when you’ve done it
Attainable: Know how to do it
Relevant: Make actions relevant to your goal
Time: Take the time you need to accomplish the goal completely

A priest who stops your confession is interfering with a number of these points. It’s no wonder you feel as if something has no closure.
 
Last edited:
You have been forgiven, in each confession. Burn the pages, and then make serious work of finding a confessor who can work with people who suffer from scrupulosity. It is a heavy burden.

And good advice is to stay away from forums, as they will exacerbate your problem.
 
Definitely the best thing to do is to have a regular confessor who can help you deal with your scruples. Getting advice on how to deal with the doubts is what will help you eventually put them aside; going to different priests and reading off the entire list of possible sins every time you have a doubt is only going to feed them going forward.

But it’s understandable that you feel there are things you still need to confess. That’s why it’s best to have your confessions be with a priest who has come to understand your situation, so you grow to trust his advice and learn which things can be put to rest.
 
Last edited:
What advice do your confessors give you when they recognise you have scruples?
 
We have so few priests willing to share their expertise and training here…please let’s be kind to them when they patiently correct us.
 
They don’t really say anything. I have told them that I have scruples, but only one really gave me advice, which almost left me a little more confused. I have tried to find a single confessor because everyone tells me this is a good thing. I really have tired to get rid off this thing I don’t want to say anything wrong, or in any way saying anything against the very kind priests I’ve met, but it does seem like they may already be too busy to take on another person, and I don’t want to burden them with me. So I’m kind of trying to do it on my own.
 
It is not hard to confess to a single priest.
One chooses to only confess when he is available - or one makes an appointment.
 
I guess I never saw it this way. I always thought I’d have to ask him if he was willing to take me on. I didn’t just want to dump my scruples on them without knowing. I know I am burden so I wasn’t sure if it would be unkind to just you know, show up. But I will try and do this 🙂
 
Last edited:
It seems the priest is suggesting that you just throw the 10 pages in the garbage and get on with your life. You must have led quite a life to require 10 pages. Maybe you should write a book.
 
There is no need. A trained priest told you what to do in the confession.
This is what you must do. Doubt will only harm you.
Priests know what they are dealing with and advise accordingly, despite what CAF posters believe.
TRUST your confessor, let it GO.
 
When it comes to scrupulosity, it seems to me that sometimes finding a priest who is willing to listen to ten pages may be counterproductive. Paradoxically, the more a scrupulous person is enabled to pore over and through such a list, the worse the scrupulosity becomes. A tendency to scrupulosity can feed on attention, and sometimes must be put on a diet. Just my opinion. I don’t claim any expertise.
 
Your confessor did the right thing. It’s the opinion of St. Alphonsus de Liguori to treat the concerns of scrupulous individuals as a non-issue. Next time make sure you put all mortal sins at the top of the list, then say venial sins. Don’t reconfess sins you forgot at previous confessions either if you’re scrupulous.
 
You see I think the only problem with this is that I have the hardest time telling between mortal and venial sins. Everything that I do to me seems mortal. Either because of my feelings at the time, thoughts, etc. So it does kind of turn into this endless circle of sins. I also have OCD so I’m not altogether sure how much control I have over this thing :confused:
 
Last edited:
This is exactly why you should take the burden of those thoughts off of yourself and simply hand it to the priest, doing exactly what he tells you.
 
Am I able to go to communion? He said I was, but he also mentioned that even people who thought they were in the state of sin could make an act of contrition receive and make it an intention to go to Confession as soon as they could, which to me seemed wrong. Either way, what should I do?
Just a brief survey of your story and question, you are probably looking for spiritual direction/insight on Confession.

First, on spiritual direction, should make an appointment with a priest on the basis of Confession. Just explain what happened. You don’t neceratily need to tell him your sins right then and there. But he could afford time as apart from that visit to take your Confession once more. He may also tell you it may not be necessary as you have been already absolved of your sins.

Second, on Confession, there is venial and grave matter.

Venial unconfessed means purgatory (I.e. Not hell.) A general Confession is generally all that is needed, if and only if they are venial sins.

As for grave matter unconfessed, you end in hell. But grave matter means you had full knowledge, willfully did it (consented with full will and knowledge - like knowing fire burns, it destroys, and you put your hand in it deliberately and anyways, as an example), and finally matter (the sin has to be one of the Seven deadly sins or fit in those categories.) Thus, all three - matter, knowledge, and will - must be met in order for a sin to be grave. But even if the sin was out of compulsion (I.e. no control of your own), but fell under one of the Seven Grave Matter categories, you can still tell the priest the specifity of the incident (which would mean him asking whether you met the three necessary measures for it to be considered grave or not. Or, if you understood at the time you had failed to meet all three measures of gravity of the sin to be called grave matter, you can tell him.

Remember (and this is not a work around or lessening one’s responsibility around a grave sin, but to be clear on moral objective view of responsibility) you would had to known the sin was grave enough and you met all three measures that it to be considered grave (at the time you committed the sin, not after.) For if you learned about the knowledge, will, and matter after the fact, then it doesn’t make the offense grave, but venial. For out of ignorance you did not know. And thus, as my friend says, “welcome to the human race.”
 
Last edited:
hand it to the priest, doing exactly what he tells you.
Yes, this is crucial. Find a faithful confessor, OP, and obey him. Obedience is the cure for scruples.

You will know if you committed a mortal sin because it requires full knowledge. They stick out like a sore thumb in your conscience as complete compliance to a grave sin.
 
Everything IS fine. Relax. You are forgiven and a favorite friend of God. With a friend like that, what’s to worry? A priest had to remind of that also. I mentioned a general confession I did way back and I stated I was worried that I forgot some. He said I was completely forgiven, not a single crumb or remnant remains to tarnish the absolution.
 
Last edited:
If I needed advice on a military matter, I would trust a colonel. If I needed advice on Confession, I myself would trust a priest. 😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top