ID in public schools

  • Thread starter Thread starter edwest2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I have no problems with what you wrote,Anthony.
However, here, we have stepped in what would
constitute as pure philosophy, which I would agree with the Barbarian, is out of the scope of science.

It’s out of the scope of modern science,but that is only because modern science rejects altogether anything that reeks of metaphysics – and that is related to the rejection of the metaphysical in philosophy and in modern society.

My point was only, to point that, Darwnin’s theory of Evolution, which speaks of natural selection as the only directional force, mutation being considered totally random, is, I believe, being challenged.
Some life processes, still very unknown, seem to “cause” mutations to occur in order to survive and possibly to increase in nature…that is, to evolve.

When speaking of the origin of life forms,the emphasis should be on “life”,rather than forms (species). The mutations of living organisms shouldn’t be spoken of like the mutatons of inanimate matter (as with metamorphic rocks). It is a mistake of natural scientsts to do just that. Anything pertaining to the origination of life forms should be thought of in terms which are appropriate to life forms: conception. It is not enough to speak of mutation,because that is only a material process which occurs in Nature. Energy,which constitutes matter,is neither created nor destroyed but only changes forms (mutates).
But all life on earth originates with conception. There’s no room for evolution where the conception of life forms is concerned.
All life forms are complete in their genetic essence at the moment of conception. Conception is precisely what distinguishes the origination of living forms from the origination of non-living forms. And conception brings with it the unknown quantity of spirit,which is from outside of Nature. If it is kept in mind that life forms are conceived and have spirit,then that throws the evidence for evolution in a completely different light. Rather than a Theory of Evolution,we would be looking at a Theory of Creation.
 
Progeny Of Blind Cavefish Can ‘Regain’ Their Sight

ScienceDaily (Jan. 8, 2008) — Blind cavefish whose eyes have withered while living in complete darkness over the course of evolutionary time can be made to see again. In some cases, the offspring of mated pairs originating from distinct cave populations regain vision, researchers found. The result shows that mutations in different genes are responsible for eye loss in separate cavefish lineages that may not have been exposed to light for the last one million years.

just another example of creatures adapting to their environment
 
Progeny Of Blind Cavefish Can ‘Regain’ Their Sight

ScienceDaily (Jan. 8, 2008) — Blind cavefish whose eyes have withered while living in complete darkness over the course of evolutionary time can be made to see again. In some cases, the offspring of mated pairs originating from distinct cave populations regain vision, researchers found. The result shows that mutations in different genes are responsible for eye loss in separate cavefish lineages that may not have been exposed to light for the last one million years.

just another example of creatures adapting to their environment
This doesn’t have much to do with the evolution of species.
The blind cavefish have,according to the researchers,descended from cavefish that could see – but they’re still cavefish.
 
Mich writes:
*I have no problems with what you wrote,Anthony.
However, here, we have stepped in what would
constitute as pure philosophy, which I would agree with the Barbarian, is out of the scope of science. *
It’s out of the scope of modern science,but that is only because modern science rejects altogether anything that reeks of metaphysics – and that is related to the rejection of the metaphysical in philosophy and in modern society.
No. This is wrong. Science doesn’t decide to avoid the metaphysical. It is limited because the method can only work with that which is detectable by the senses; i.e. natural things. It is too weak a method to find God.
My point was only, to point that, Darwnin’s theory of Evolution, which speaks of natural selection as the only directional force, mutation being considered totally random, is, I believe, being challenged.
Goodness, yes. Only that happened over a half century ago. Neutralist theories have modified it. We can, for example, show mathematically, that if there are two distinct forms of an organism, neither of which is selectively different than the other, one will eventually replace the other.
Some life processes, still very unknown, seem to “cause” mutations to occur in order to survive and possibly to increase in nature…that is, to evolve.
Not so far. There have been a few abortive attempts to show this, but so far, it’s a faith thing, not a demonstrated reality. If such a thing could evolve, that would be great. But it doesn’t seem to happen.
When speaking of the origin of life forms,the emphasis should be on “life”,rather than forms (species). The mutations of living organisms shouldn’t be spoken of like the mutatons of inanimate matter (as with metamorphic rocks). It is a mistake of natural scientsts to do just that.
No. It’s a mistake of creationists to do that. We spend a lot of time with creationists (those of us who talk to them), trying to tell them that evolutionary theory does not, and cannot account for the origin of life.
But all life on earth originates with conception.
Not unless you completely revise the meaning of “conception.” Many living things do just fine without fertilization or conjugation.
There’s no room for evolution where the conception of life forms is concerned.
In the sense that no living thing evolves; populations evolve. Two entirely different things.
All life forms are complete in their genetic essence at the moment of conception. Conception is precisely what distinguishes the origination of living forms from the origination of non-living forms.
So, if you cut a planarian in half, and grow two planarians (flatworms), then neither of them is alive? Just one of them? How do you decide?
And conception brings with it the unknown quantity of spirit,which is from outside of Nature.
True. But that’s not part of science. It’s a religious belief.
If it is kept in mind that life forms are conceived and have spirit,then that throws the evidence for evolution in a completely different light.
Nope. Doesn’t matter a bit to science. Does to scientists, though.
Rather than a Theory of Evolution,we would be looking at a Theory of Creation.
Oxymoron. Science can’t go there. Is there some reason that your faith isn’t enough?
 
I personally believe that such an hypothesis ought to be taught in the theory of Evolution, within the science classes. From here, we can let the students decide what type of philosophical implication such hypothesis can lead to.
IMO - I think a case needs to be made that education, especially at the undergraduate level, needs to be concerned with teaching students “factual material” and limiting the amount of classtime to “philosophical implications”. The more “facts” a student knows the more information he has to make an intelligent “interpretation” of those facts. I include this principle for all intellectual disciplines; not just science.

MonFrere
 
Unless you’re teaching an upper level college or graduate class, including speculative ideas is acceptable if you clearly label them as such.

And the reason that the matter is not considered to be factual should also be made clear.
 
Unless you’re teaching an upper level college or graduate class, including speculative ideas is acceptable if you clearly label them as such.

And the reason that the matter is not considered to be factual should also be made clear.
Agreed

MonFrere
 
The blind cavefish have,according to the researchers,descended from cavefish that could see – but they’re still cavefish.
Plus, if they went blind because they were living in caves, that’s the reverse of what evolution would claim. They should have developed new kinds of eyes that could see in the dark, but instead their eyes just lost function and nothing replaced them.
 
Many scientists may share Dobzhansky’s intuitive conviction that the marvelous intricacies of living organisms could not have arisen by the selection of truly random mutations. This minireview suggests that sensitive, directed feedback mechanisms initiated by different kinds of stress might facilitate and accelerate the adaptation of organisms to new environments.
I hope this doesn’t pass without more comment.

It was just said that “creationists have tried to promote” this idea of “directed mutations” here presented in the Journal of Bacteriology.

Dobzhansky’s intuitive conviction sounds very much like the foundation for ID: the marvelous intricacies of living organisms could not have arisen by the selection of truly random mutations.
 
Plus, if they went blind because they were living in caves, that’s the reverse of what evolution would claim.
This might be interesting to watch…
They should have developed new kinds of eyes that could see in the dark,
In the dark of caves, there is no radiation for which they can adapt. You should understand that it’s impossible to see at all in a truly dark enclosure, no matter what kind of receptors you might have. On the other hand, many cave creatures do have alternative senses that allow them to check out their surroundings. Which is what evolution predicts. BTW, it’s not only possible for alternative eyes to evolve, it has happened. The most striking example is of infrared detectors in some snakes. The information from these newly-evolved structures is fed to the optic tectum where a composite visual/infrared image is perceived.

As Everett Dirkson said, people are usually down on things they aren’t up on.
 
It was just said that “creationists have tried to promote” this idea of “directed mutations” here presented in the Journal of Bacteriology.
Creationists, as you know, are notorious for skimming the literature to find something to discredit science. Often, as in this case, they didn’t really understand the paper, and so were completely nonplussed when the “evidence” for “directed mutations” in eukaryotes didn’t materialize.

The irony here, is that while the discovery of directed mutation in organsms would require a revision of the modern synthesis, it would make no difference whatever to Darwin’s theory, which has nothing at all about mutations or how variation actually occurs.

The attempt to make a Darwinian like Dobzhansky into an ID’er is consistent with creationist habits. They made much of non-coding DNA, decades after real scientists had shown at least some of it had other functions.

No doubt they will soon announce the discovery that the Earth is round.
 
Haven’t seen any of that lately among scientists, although creationists have tried to promote it from time to time.
The quote from Dobzhansky was then produced from the Journal of Bacteriology.

Barbarian then tries to say that he knew this already.
The attempt to make a Darwinian like Dobzhansky into an ID’er is consistent with creationist habits …
No doubt they will soon announce the discovery that the Earth is round
The fact is, you didn’t know that the literature existed and you could only reply that creationists had said it.
 
I said:
They should have developed new kinds of eyes
Barbarian then said:
In the dark of caves, there is no radiation for which they can adapt. You should understand that it’s impossible to see at all in a truly dark enclosure, no matter what kind of receptors you might have. On the other hand, many cave creatures do have alternative senses that allow them to check out their surroundings.

Barbarian tries to make it simpler:
Maybe this isn’t clear to you. In the absence of electromagnetic waves, there can be no vision. No waves, no wave receptors evolve.

Barbarian observes:
BTW, it’s not only possible for alternative eyes to evolve, it has happened. The most striking example is of infrared detectors in some snakes. The information from these newly-evolved structures is fed to the optic tectum where a composite visual/infrared image is perceived.

As Everett Dirkson said, people are usually down on things they aren’t up on.
What kind of alternative eyes did the blind cavefish evolve?
:ouch: Good example.
 
Originally Posted by The Barbarian
Haven’t seen any of that lately among scientists, although creationists have tried to promote it from time to time.
The quote from Dobzhansky was then produced from the Journal of Bacteriology.
Dobzhansky has been dead nearly 25 years. I thought you knew.

Barbarian Observes:
The attempt to make a Darwinian like Dobzhansky into an ID’er is consistent with creationist habits …
No doubt they will soon announce the discovery that the Earth is round
The fact is, you didn’t know that the literature existed
The fact is, I pointed out that we haven’t seen much of that recently. Findings from evolutionary development and from molecular biology, you know.
and you could only reply that creationists had said it.
Yep. ID’ers are really great at quote-mining, particularly outdated material. This was a great example.
 
The fact is, I pointed out that we haven’t seen much of that recently.
More evolutionary “fact” overturned in the vast time period of 30 years.

But we can be certain that this year’s “discoveries” are “new facts” much better than the old ones.
 
More evolutionary “fact” overturned in the vast time period of 30 years.
Yep. Evolutionary theory, like all scientific theories, is changed to reflect the evidence. This probably seems backwards to you, as a creationist.
But we can be certain that this year’s “discoveries” are “new facts” much better than the old ones.
So far, that’s been the case. As more evidence accumulates, theories become more refined, and better explain the phenomena they describe.

Been that way for a long time.
 
No. This is wrong. Science doesn’t decide to avoid the metaphysical.

That’s not true. It’s practically a conviction among scientists to avoid drawing metaphysical conclusions from research.

It is limited because the method can only work with that which is detectable by the senses; i.e. natural things.

That’s not true. The investigative methods of science can remain what they are regardless of the metaphysical beliefs of the practitioner. And methods do not account for the whole of science anyway – there is also speculation,interpretation,and theorizing. Belief in a Creator need not get in the way of a scientist’s method,unless you think Pythagorus,Copernicus,Galileo,and Newton were unprofessional.

It is too weak a method to find God.

That’s not even the issue. It isn’t necessarly about the methods,it’s about the interpretation of the scientific evidence which seeks to find ultimate origins in the processes of matter. Since a Creator is out of consideration as the ultimate origin of all life,that leaves chance,necessity,and matter as the ultimate origins. Process and origin are conflated.

No. It’s a mistake of creationists to do that. We spend a lot of time with creationists (those of us who talk to them), trying to tell them that evolutionary theory does not, and cannot account for the origin of life.

That is exactly what evolution and chaos theorists are attempting to account for.

Not unless you completely revise the meaning of “conception.” Many living things do just fine without fertilization or conjugation.

Conception also refers to a specific beginning. Living organisms have specific genetic beginnings,whereas the mutations of inanimate forms don’t – they just evolve.

In the sense that no living thing evolves; populations evolve. Two entirely different things.

Populations are made up of individuals that have their essential genetic make-up from their beginning. Anything relating to the evolution of species has to be brought back to what is unique to life forms.

So, if you cut a planarian in half, and grow two planarians (flatworms), then neither of them is alive? Just one of them? How do you decide?

How does that affect their origination?
The two that came from the one both had the same genetic origination.

True. But that’s not part of science. It’s a religious belief.

It’s a reasonable belief. And if it’s true,then science,if it seeks the truth about life,ought to embrace it.
If science has anything reasonable to say about the origins and nature of life,the belief in spirit had better be a part of science.

Nope. Doesn’t matter a bit to science. Does to scientists, though.

It’s the scientists who determine what should matter to science. Their practice doesn’t do their thinking for them.

Oxymoron. Science can’t go there. Is there some reason that your faith isn’t enough?

This isn’t about the level of my personal faith.

Both religion and science should be guided by reason.
The way that natural scientists ignore the factor of spirit
when they try to understand the origins of life is unreasonable.
 
Originally Posted by The Barbarian

Yep. ID’ers are really great at quote-mining, particularly outdated material. This was a great example.
Again, Barbarian, this article is dated June 2000, written by
Barbara E. Wright, not Dobzhansky. All the referenced articles I ve posted come from science journals and is dated close to this…but you knew this, right;)

Andre
 
Again, Barbarian, this article is dated June 2000, written by Barbara E. Wright, not Dobzhansky.
Dobzhansky’s been dead over a quarter century. The article isn’t quite a decade old. Guess why you can’t get a more recent cite.
…but you knew this, right
Yep.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top