If a priest is at a Mass, must he celebrate?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Vittorio23
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

Vittorio23

Guest
In general, if a priest is at a Mass, must he celebrate? Not necessarily a celebrant or con-celebrant, but must he utter the words of consecration along with the celebrant?

Today, there was a visiting priest celebrating Mass and our parish priest was there too. Except, our parish priest did not participate in celebrating the Mass, rather he took place as if he were an altar server. With the exception that he preached the homily (at which time he wore a stole, at all other times he had taken it off). Neither did he receive holy communion. But he did distribute the Precious Blood? (He wore his stole at this point as well.) I’m not sure the reasoning behind all of this. The only thing I can think of is that he had already celebrated Mass early in the morning at our missionary parish.
 
It is not necessary for a priest to be a celebrant at a mass he simply aends, especially if he has already celebrated or is celebrating later.

However, it is odd that the pastor would not celebrate at his own parish church, and would leave it to another.
 
In general, if a priest is at a Mass, must he celebrate? Not necessarily a celebrant or con-celebrant, but must he utter the words of consecration along with the celebrant?

Today, there was a visiting priest celebrating Mass and our parish priest was there too. Except, our parish priest did not participate in celebrating the Mass, rather he took place as if he were an altar server. With the exception that he preached the homily (at which time he wore a stole, at all other times he had taken it off). Neither did he receive holy communion. But he did distribute the Precious Blood? (He wore his stole at this point as well.) I’m not sure the reasoning behind all of this. The only thing I can think of is that he had already celebrated Mass early in the morning at our missionary parish.
Sounds like something you should ask the priest directly about if you are that curious.
 
It sounds as if everything was in perfect order.

A priest should attend Mass as if he is a layperson. If he chooses not to concelebrate, he is to ‘sit in choir’, which means that he dresses in a cassock and surplice and sits in or near the sanctuary. ( Watch a Papal or Episcopal Mass, there will usually be priest assisting the Pope or Bishop who is dressed in a cassock and surplice, this person is not a celebrant, but rather ‘in choir’)

A priest (or Deacon) in choir is still a member of Holy Orders, and as such, is permitted to both read the Gospel and\or preach the homily, and he was correct to place his stole on to do so.

Also, as a cleric in Holy Orders he has an obligation to assist in the distribution of Holy Communion.

So far, all is in order.
 
What if a priest is on vacation somewhere away from his home diocese? Can he not just attend Mass as a “regular” person unknown to anyone else?

Just curious.
 
It sounds as if everything was in perfect order.

A priest should attend Mass as if he is a layperson. If he chooses not to concelebrate, he is to ‘sit in choir’, which means that he dresses in a cassock and surplice and sits in or near the sanctuary. ( Watch a Papal or Episcopal Mass, there will usually be priest assisting the Pope or Bishop who is dressed in a cassock and surplice, this person is not a celebrant, but rather ‘in choir’)

A priest (or Deacon) in choir is still a member of Holy Orders, and as such, is permitted to both read the Gospel and\or preach the homily, and he was correct to place his stole on to do so.

Also, as a cleric in Holy Orders he has an obligation to assist in the distribution of Holy Communion.

So far, all is in order.
Keep in mind though, that a chaplain of honor to a prelate who attends but does not concelebate as well as a cleric who is master of ceremonies presents a somewhat different situation. Hence, those individuals would not distribute the Sacrament but attend to those roles. In those situations, there are normally more than a sufficient number of other clerics for Communion though.
 
what Brendan said
also the priest serving as MC is in choir dress, not vested, and does not concelebrate (usually),

The priest does not have to take any active role, he can sit in the pews and assist as does a layperson, but he may NOT then recite the words of consecration or any of the other prayers reserved for the priest. Visiting priests not assigned to parishes need a place to say Mass, and the pastor may give them this opportunity, and may assist as described in OP, or stay in the pews (although he may help distribute communion as an ordinary minister) or simply stay home and rest.
 
What if a priest is on vacation somewhere away from his home diocese? Can he not just attend Mass as a “regular” person unknown to anyone else?

Just curious.
yes, but in the pews, with the laity, and may NOT recite prayers reserved for the priest.
 
It sounds as if everything was in perfect order.

A priest should attend Mass as if he is a layperson. If he chooses not to concelebrate, he is to ‘sit in choir’, which means that he dresses in a cassock and surplice and sits in or near the sanctuary. ( Watch a Papal or Episcopal Mass, there will usually be priest assisting the Pope or Bishop who is dressed in a cassock and surplice, this person is not a celebrant, but rather ‘in choir’)

A priest (or Deacon) in choir is still a member of Holy Orders, and as such, is permitted to both read the Gospel and\or preach the homily, and he was correct to place his stole on to do so.

Also, as a cleric in Holy Orders he has an obligation to assist in the distribution of Holy Communion.

So far, all is in order.
This is exactly what happened at the final Mass to close my mother’s old parish. The Bishop and the pastor of the church concelebrated. The other priests who were there sat in the first rows of pews. They distributed Communion, but did not concelebrate.
 
Cool, thanks for the responses. I definitely didn’t think anything was wrong with what happened, I just had never seen it before, so I was curious. Thanks. 🙂
 
Related question: what obligation, if any, does a priest have to say mass on a regular basis? I know at one time there was a requirement to do so daily - without the option for concelebration, this reportedly led to priests at side altars in the larger churches celebrating masses solo while the scheduled mass was underway in the main part of the church.
 
Today, there was a visiting priest celebrating Mass and our parish priest was there too. Except, our parish priest did not participate in celebrating the Mass, rather he took place as if he were an altar server. With the exception that he preached the homily (at which time he wore a stole, at all other times he had taken it off). Neither did he receive holy communion. But he did distribute the Precious Blood? (He wore his stole at this point as well.) I’m not sure the reasoning behind all of this. The only thing I can think of is that he had already celebrated Mass early in the morning at our missionary parish.
Is it possible that your parish priest had a mass earlier or later in the day, like a funeral or another daily mass? Priests are only allowed to take one stipend per day, yet are permitted to celebrate 2 masses per day if there is a pastoral need. This is in accord with Canon Law. When a visiting priest drops by and would like to say mass, he would be the beneficiary of the second stipend and the Parish Priest could still participate by proclaiming the gospel, preaching and helping with the distribution of Holy Communion. It really should be a concelebration situation for the Parish Priest, rather than a stole on, then off, MC type of a role.

Here are some answers from the GIRM about priests, masses, frequencies and recommendations.

A priest should not ordinarily sit in the pews like/as if a layperson because by doing so, he is not exercising the role that is consistent with his state in life. [The Mass] It is therefore of the greatest importance that the celebration of the Mass—that is, the Lord’s Supper—be so arranged that the sacred ministers and the faithful taking part in it, according to the proper state of each, may derive from it more abundantly, those fruits for the sake of which Christ the Lord instituted the Eucharistic Sacrifice of his Body and Blood and
entrusted it to the Church, his beloved Bride, as the memorial of his Passion and Resurrection.

Concelebration, which appropriately expresses the unity of the priesthood, of the Sacrifice, and also of the whole People of God, is prescribed by the rite itself for the Ordination
of a Bishop and of priests, at the blessing of an abbot, and at the Chrism Mass. Unless the good of the Christian faithful requires or suggests otherwise, concelebration is also recommended at
a. The Evening Mass of the Lord’s Supper;
b. The Mass during Councils, meetings of Bishops, and synods;
c. The conventual Mass and the principal Mass in churches and oratories; (religious orders)
d. Masses at any kind of meeting of priests, either secular or religious.
An individual priest is, however, permitted to celebrate the Eucharist individually, though not at the same time as a concelebration is taking place in the same church or oratory. On Holy Thursday, however, and for Mass of the Easter Vigil, it is not permitted to celebrate individually.
Visiting priests should be gladly welcomed to eucharistic concelebration, as long as their priestly standing is ascertained.
Where there is a large number of priests, concelebration may take place even several times on the same day, wherever necessity or pastoral benefit suggest it. Nevertheless, it must be held at different times or in distinct sacred places.
Lastly, It is for the Bishop, in accordance with the norm of law, to regulate the discipline for concelebration in all churches and oratories of his diocese.

A priest on Vacation should make the necessary arrangements to celebrate mass privately or at a nearby parish or may concelebrate at a regularly scheduled mass if he makes the appropriate arrangements.
The Eucharistic Celebration always retains its efficacy and dignity because it is the action of Christ and the Church, in which the priest fulfills his own principal office and always acts for the people’s salvation. It is therefore recommended that the priest celebrate the Eucharistic Sacrifice even daily, if possible
 
I would love it if puzzleannie could cite where she got her information about priests sitting in the pews. As far as I know, if a priest is at a Mass, then according to the GIRM, if they are not to concelebrate, then they are to be seated in the sanctuary in choir dress as stated previously in this thread. The only time that I know of priests being able to sit in the pews are when there is not enough room to accomodate them, such as at a priest’s funeral. I was an altar server at this Funeral Mass. The Bishop presided and only the certain Deacons, the MC, and concelebrating priests were in the sanctuary. We had over 150 other priests in the pews, actually in chasubles.

Anyway, considering all, I believe that only at the Bishop’s say may a priest not be in the sanctuary. They don’t have to concelebrate, but they must be in choir dress and in the sanctuary and help distribute Holy Communion.

Andrew
 
I would love it if puzzleannie could cite where she got her information about priests sitting in the pews. As far as I know, if a priest is at a Mass, then according to the GIRM, if they are not to concelebrate, then they are to be seated in the sanctuary in choir dress as stated previously in this thread. The only time that I know of priests being able to sit in the pews are when there is not enough room to accomodate them, such as at a priest’s funeral. I was an altar server at this Funeral Mass. The Bishop presided and only the certain Deacons, the MC, and concelebrating priests were in the sanctuary. We had over 150 other priests in the pews, actually in chasubles.

Anyway, considering all, I believe that only at the Bishop’s say may a priest not be in the sanctuary. They don’t have to concelebrate, but they must be in choir dress and in the sanctuary and help distribute Holy Communion.

Andrew
At our Cathedral, the sanctuary is not big enough to fit all of the diocesan priests when they concelebrate the Chrism Mass. They can’t all sit up there during the readings and the homily. So, they are in their albs and stoles in the front pews. However, when it comes time for the Liturgy of the Eucharist, the MC leads them up to the sanctuary where they join the Bishop and concelebrate. The only ones whom I have seen vested in surplice, cassock and stole are the priest/MCs who are assisting the bishop. And, they all help out with Holy Communion and the Precious Blood.
 
Related question: what obligation, if any, does a priest have to say mass on a regular basis? I know at one time there was a requirement to do so daily - without the option for concelebration, this reportedly led to priests at side altars in the larger churches celebrating masses solo while the scheduled mass was underway in the main part of the church.
They don’t HAVE to celebrate daily but it’s strongly recommended.

Can. 904 Remembering always that in the mystery of the eucharistic sacrifice the work of redemption is exercised continually, priests are to celebrate frequently; indeed, daily celebration is recommended earnestly since, even if the faithful cannot be present, it is the act of Christ and the Church in which priests fulfill their principal function.
 
I would love it if puzzleannie could cite where she got her information about priests sitting in the pews. As far as I know, if a priest is at a Mass, then according to the GIRM, if they are not to concelebrate, then they are to be seated in the sanctuary in choir dress as stated previously in this thread.
At the closing Mass of my former parish, there was not enough room in the sanctuary for all the priests who were there. The pastor of the church concelebrated with the bishop. The rest of the priests sat in the pews and only came forward to distribute Communion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top