If Protestants dont go to Heaven, why are there so many NDE's with Protestants?

  • Thread starter Thread starter yogosans14
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Vat II states that the Protestants “have some communion” with us, so they too can go to heaven.

A NDE, if true, is a gift of God to the person. That’s all we know.
 
Pope Francis suggested that good atheists may go to heaven!
Perhaps. It is only God who determines who goes to heaven or not. None of us here on earth can tell Him what to do. So if God judges that an atheist goes to heaven, so be it!

This is why we pray for everyone, including our enemies. We don’t know who will be in heaven. Certainly anyone can be there. But Pope Francis isn’t saying that as a guarantee, he’s not giving out guarantees, he’s giving out hope for all. And hope is a virtue of Christianity.
 
There is no evidence that NDE are anything more than the brain responding to a physical shut-down. If many of the experiences are similar, it could well be because we are all human.

I recall reading somewhere that the “experiences” are culture based. So a Hindu would “see” something that relates to his religion.

While NDE are “real” in the sense that people experience them, there is no way to prove if they are objectively true.
This. I used to have OOB experiences and face-to-face talks with God almost every night when I was on certain medications. I put a LOT of stock in those dreams - they were very real - until “God” started contradicting himself.
 
I have never heard Catholics claim that Protestants do not go to Heaven. Some may have been told that in the past, but it was never Church teaching.
ICXC NIKA
I have some pre-Vatican 2 books and then as now the requirements for salvation of a non-Catholic are very narrow, and not necessarily common.
 
This. I used to have OOB experiences and face-to-face talks with God almost every night when I was on certain medications. I put a LOT of stock in those dreams - they were very real - until “God” started contradicting himself.
What’s does OOB stand for? I’ve had some trouble myself separating the mystic from the merely psychological.
 
This. 👍 and apply it to protestants who think this way about Catholics.

Jon
It is absurd for anyone to believe such nonsense. I know of some very loving Protestants who practice their faith very well.
 
Of course, protestants can go to heaven… Not news for this Catholic.
 
No one watches the Simpsons then? 😉
You know the episode, Bart becomes a faithful catholic, converts Homer, and later on Marge is granted a vision of the Protestants in their level of heaven, and the Catholics on their heaven.
So the Protestant faithful DO go to heaven, it’s just that wearing their Sunday best outfits and playing croquet on the lawn, they look a bit boring…
Meanwhile we Catholics go to our heaven, and it’s all Irish and Italian music, dancing, and drunken bar fights. 🙂

Please forgive me, I couldn’t resist.

Pray for peace.
The bolded is an unfair statement. I am a Polish Catholic so where is the polka music? 😃
 
The Athanasian creed clearly holds that those who do not subscribe to the doctrine of the Holy Trinity cannot be saved:
“Whosoever will be saved, before all things it is necessary that he hold the catholic faith. Which faith except every one do keep whole and undefiled; without doubt he shall perish everlastingly.”

It’s black and white. Believe and be saved.
 
I believe that Protestants go to Heaven. YOU MAY HAVE HEARD THE OLD JOKE ABOUT A CATHOLIC WHO DIED AND WENT TO HEAVEN AND THEN WAS SHOWN AROUND BY ST PETER. Upon coming to a large room he was instructed to be silent because the room contained Catholics and St Peter did not want to disturb them because they thought that they were the only ones there.
To find out more please visit www.catholicprayergroup.net
 
Where did you get Protestants don’t go to Heaven?
I just figured out what NDE meant! I’m such a non-techie! Who the heck has Near Death Experiences these days? Unless you’re as old as me and I haven’t had any yet thank goodness!
 
I just figured out what NDE meant! I’m such a non-techie! Who the heck has Near Death Experiences these days? Unless you’re as old as me and I haven’t had any yet thank goodness!
NDE can result from any situation where human body goes “near death.” You don’t need to be old, any more than that is required to die.

ICXC NIKA.
 
Pope Francis said even atheists are redeemed and “good atheists will meet us there…”.The pope didn’t mention anywhere that good atheists are saved nor will go to heaven!Please read very carefully all what he wrote in context.
Since we’re not supposed to include private revelation, then I don’t know how much the following will hold water, but I’ve often said before that the night he died, my father appeared in my room. He started with an apology for 20 years of deliberate cruelty, we argued and conversed, and at the end he gave this terrifying scream and disappeared.

I think he’s in Hell, going by the scream. The fear and terror was so contagious that I started to scream, but then he just disappeared. This wasn’t an NDE incidentally - he was dead, full stop. In fact at one stage I blurted out, “What is this? A dream or something?”. He looked a bit bemused, and replied, “It’s not a dream. I died tonight.”

At another point he exclaimed “It wasn’t easy for me either, you know, and I didn’t have a chance to see anything like this!”

Most of the time he was looking over my head with one of two expressions - the first was one of awe. The second was when he would put his face behind his hands as though he couldn’t bear to watch what he was seeing. I think in the first instance he was seeing God or the heavenly court, and he was awed. In the second I think he was seeing episodes of his own behaviour that appalled him seen in the light of the Divine Presence. He couldn’t stand it.

What gets me about all these Protestant (and other) NDE’s (and don’t get me wrong - I think they occur) is that there is not one word about facing a judgement. You get this Angela what’s her name in South America somewhere who alleges JPII is in hell, along with a host of others, but not once does she mention being judged herself. Apparently she’s as pure as the driven snow.

And I think the reality is that the judgement is pretty tough, even if we’ve been redeemed. We still have to go through it.

I’ll say it again, not once do these NDE’s mention facing a rigorous judgement, or being awed by the Judging Panel, or being appalled by their own behaviour at times.

Personally I don’t think that NDE’s get that far. So we don’t know the final outcome.

And for reasons of my own I don’t think Protestants get into heaven. That’s based on something my old Protestant pastor said, and he was pretty clued up. I don’t think God tolerates the continued division of His Church by men, when He set it up at such great cost by the crucifixion of His own Son by men.

I think they go to Purgatory, even the very heavenly end of Purgatory, but they’ll have to wait for the church to formally reunify before they go the final step.

The words my old pastor used were “I sometimes wonder if Protestants get into heaven… I don’t think God accepts the division of His Church like we do…” I challenged him on that and replied, “If you think that, then why are you still a Protestant?”. He thought for a minute and said, “They (the Catholic Church) have done a lot of damage at times” (no argument there). So we left it at that.

But sometime after he died, he appeared briefly to me and simply said, “We’re not in heaven. We’re all in Purgatory. Oh, we not suffering any pain, so you don’t have to worry about that! In fact, it’s pretty good around here (and here he appeared rather impressed).” But then he continued, “But we’re not in heaven.”

Then he disappeared again.

Now that’s been part of my personal experience, and of course it’s just as subjective and suspect as someone else’s NDE. But due to that and other things, that’s why I don’t think Protestants get into heaven.

And not once in NDE’s do they mention a rigorous judgement, so complete that Christ promised we would answer for “every useless word”. So unless all these Protestants are holier than the saints, one would think they would have something to say about this aspect of their NDE’s if they get so far as the Pearly Gates.
 
Your assuming their experiences are legitimate. Every time I hear these sorts of stories heaven is depicted as it if were this stereotypical heaven that you find in Pop culture, that right there is highly suspect because the concept of heaven being this place with clouds, a gate and saint Peter at the door is a product of the 20th century and its ignorance in confusing Christianity for some dualistic system.

Heaven rather to me would be quite incomprehensible so even if you were to have been there you would not be able to describe it.
 
No one watches the Simpsons then? 😉
You know the episode, Bart becomes a faithful catholic, converts Homer, and later on Marge is granted a vision of the Protestants in their level of heaven, and the Catholics on their heaven.
So the Protestant faithful DO go to heaven, it’s just that wearing their Sunday best outfits and playing croquet on the lawn, they look a bit boring…
Meanwhile we Catholics go to our heaven, and it’s all Irish and Italian music, dancing, and drunken bar fights. 🙂

Please forgive me, I couldn’t resist.

Pray for peace.
:rotfl:
 
I believe that Protestants go to Heaven. YOU MAY HAVE HEARD THE OLD JOKE ABOUT A CATHOLIC WHO DIED AND WENT TO HEAVEN AND THEN WAS SHOWN AROUND BY ST PETER. Upon coming to a large room he was instructed to be silent because the room contained Catholics and St Peter did not want to disturb them because they thought that they were the only ones there.
To find out more please visit www.catholicprayergroup.net
I love that one;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top