If The Inquisition Had never Happened

  • Thread starter Thread starter Starwynd
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Starwynd

Guest
Yes I do know it was never officially sanctioned by the church, and this thread is not about the usual blame game for it.

I often wonder what would’ve happened if the Inquisition had never happened. There is a fair amount of hostility towards Christianity for it by unbelievers and is often one of the things they cite when criticizing Christianity. The things I wonder about is would there still be this hostility if things like the Inquisition had never happened? How different would the world be if it had never happened? Would we also have a lot more technology and science developed because of it?
 
When you say it was never officially sanctioned by the church, what do you mean by “the church?” It was a Christian Inquisition. The argument gets made that its victims were then handed over to secular institutions. But all these secular institutions were still Christian institutions. Whether it was official or not is moot. Whether we define “the church” one way or another is moot.

Clearly we would be more advanced technologically and scientifically. But this is true in other historical cases, most notably the Ionian Greek experiment of millennia ago. It also failed because of humanity’s penchant for mysticism and superstition and control of power.

The Inquisition was a squandering of resources, same as WWII. In all those cases where we devoted more time to destroying one another than cooperating with one another we gave up something more valuable, culturally speaking.
 
Yes I do know it was never officially sanctioned by the church, and this thread is not about the usual blame game for it.

I often wonder what would’ve happened if the Inquisition had never happened. There is a fair amount of hostility towards Christianity for it by unbelievers and is often one of the things they cite when criticizing Christianity. The things I wonder about is would there still be this hostility if things like the Inquisition had never happened? How different would the world be if it had never happened? Would we also have a lot more technology and science developed because of it?
The Inquisition is a stick that unbelievers use to hit Catholics over the head. Like the Crusades, the accusers know about it, much less they are telling. Each of course is an example of what happens when political, social, and economic issues get all mixed up with religion. Each, of course, was “caused” by the conflict between Christendom and Islam. For some reason unbelievers somehow hold the Muslims blameless. My guess is that they have chosen to be ignorant
of the great military power of first the Arabs and then the Turks, each of whom came close to overrunning all of Europe. The Spanish Inquisition is the end result of the long Reconquista, which saw Christians kings reclaim Hispania from the “Moors” resulting in Christian kingdoms with large minorities of Jews and Muslims, whom they then largely converted to Christianity. But so incomplete were these conversiuons that the “Old Christians” did not trust the “New Christians,” and used the inquisition to “filter out” the supposedly insincere converts. This at the same time that the last Muslim state in Hispania was being reconquered. All sorts of injustices ensued for more than 20 years. Thereafter, the Inquisition devolved into an agency that “certified” the purity of landowning families, an ironic process by which many moorish and Jewish families were able to prove their racial “purity” by crossing the right palms with gold.
 
Yes I do know it was never officially sanctioned by the church, and this thread is not about the usual blame game for it.

I often wonder what would’ve happened if the Inquisition had never happened.
probably nothing, it wasnt even a blip on the modern scale of atrocities.

less than one person a month died on average, for the millions of people that were subject to the inquisition. similar rate to our modern death penalty.

though there are good arguments to be made that its scope and importance were puffed up by protestants in order to lend themselves some legitimacy as martyrs.
There is a fair amount of hostility towards Christianity for it by unbelievers and is often one of the things they cite when criticizing Christianity. The things I wonder about is would there still be this hostility if things like the Inquisition had never happened?
of course people would find other things to criticize while ignoring the tens of millions of deaths attributable to the secular, atheistic governments of just this last century.

in the light of those atrocities, people criticizing Christians for the inquisition is self serving twaddle

meant only to further their claims, not express actual outrage, otherwise they should be much more outraged at the deaths caused by secular governments, but they arent, thats how i know it is self serving twaddle
How different would the world be if it had never happened?
like i said above it wasnt even a blip in the radar in comparison to modern times
Would we also have a lot more technology and science developed because of it?
that statement seems to assume that it was anti technology or science, it wasn’t regardless of the tall tales that were told, other than direct assaults on te cosmological sense of the times, the inquisition couldnt have cared less.

in other words, only people who denied a specific precept of the churches cosmology had a problem

so mathematicians, chemists, etc. werent affected, and any who were could simply keep quiet.

even if they were though would that be bad?

we arent created to be scientists, as helpful as science is in manipulating the physical world, it cannot lead to knowing, or loving G-d, it gives no salvation, it simply makes our time here more comfortable.

in fact insofar as it leads to the avoidance of redemptive suffering, science can be an impediment to our purpose as children of G-d, to be Holy as He is Holy
 
Yes I do know it was never officially sanctioned by the church, and this thread is not about the usual blame game for it.

I often wonder what would’ve happened if the Inquisition had never happened. There is a fair amount of hostility towards Christianity for it by unbelievers and is often one of the things they cite when criticizing Christianity. The things I wonder about is would there still be this hostility if things like the Inquisition had never happened? How different would the world be if it had never happened? Would we also have a lot more technology and science developed because of it?
Well, I suppose because most Christians ignore the fact that it happened and cite Islamic atrocities basically saying, “Our religion is so much more God-like than theirs”. Most modern Catholics ignore the fact that the church does have a way with persecution: Galileo, Luther, Copernicus, etc.

So, no, we would not have a lot more technology, because it doesn’t change the fact that Galileo was sentenced under the Spanish Inquisition to recant his scientific proofs of a heliocentric system, and to go under house arrest for the rest of his life.🙂
 
None of that is what the initial post was about. I just was wondering how different things would be in the modern age if the Inquisition would never happen.
 
None of that is what the initial post was about. I just was wondering how different things would be in the modern age if the Inquisition would never happen.
Well from a different standpoint, I suppose it was necessary for such an atrocity such as the Inquisition to occur in order for us to realize its atrocious nature, and so we wouldn’t do it again in the future…

In that case the inquisition was a necessary evil in order for the development of a good such as tolerance to be realized.

so it is irrelevant if it didn’t happen. something similar would of happened somewhere else in Europe that would teach tolerance
 
that statement seems to assume that it was anti technology or science, it wasn’t regardless of the tall tales that were told, other than direct assaults on te cosmological sense of the times, the inquisition couldnt have cared less.

in other words, only people who denied a specific precept of the churches cosmology had a problem

so mathematicians, chemists, etc. werent affected, and any who were could simply keep quiet.
Remember, at that time, Galileo was going againt the science of those times, not just the Church. Althogh modern secular scientists would have you believe otherwise. 😉
The Church disputed Galileo’s work because at that time, Galileo challenged all the scientists.
 
Remember, at that time, Galileo was going againt the science of those times, not just the Church. Althogh modern secular scientists would have you believe otherwise. 😉
The Church disputed Galileo’s work because at that time, Galileo challenged all the scientists.
Yeah, one against many. Kinda like Jesus.
 
…it doesn’t change the fact that Galileo was sentenced under the Spanish Inquisition to recant his scientific proofs of a heliocentric system, and to go under house arrest for the rest of his life.
Interesting series of words on which to pin the label “fact”.

– Mark L. Chance.
 
Remember, at that time, Galileo was going againt the science of those times, not just the Church. Althogh modern secular scientists would have you believe otherwise. 😉
The Church disputed Galileo’s work because at that time, Galileo challenged all the scientists.
Actually, that’s not entirely true. The Catholic Church actually permitted Galileo to carry on his research for quite some time before they condemned him. The issue the church had was NOT with his conclusions, but his self-determination that they were not in conflict with the Bible (which happened to come precisely during the Reformation, when the church was very sensitive about issues of self-interpretation). It also didn’t help that Galileo wrote his conclusions in the form of a dialogue that portrayed the pope as being less than smart.
 
There is actually a great deal of misinformation out there regarding the Inquisition. The English hated the Spanish, and particularly due to their Protestant bias, they developed the “Black Legend” which GREATLY distorted the facts. Consider the following:
-Compared to other courts of the day, the Inquisition (Roman or Spanish) was really quite humane
-Modern scholarship has found that only 1-2% of those tried were executed…a mere few thousand souls over a few centuries (yes a few thousand souls is nothing to scoff at…but the death toll does not constitute a massacre by any stretch of the imagination)
-The Spanish Inquisition rooted out heresy sparing Spain the devastation of the religious wars that tore apart other realms, like the Holy Roman Empire. The death toll from religious wars (between Catholics and Protestants) was far higher than that of the Inquisition…
-Heresy was considered both a grave sin against God and treason against the state…the entire social fabric was based upon the common faith all the nation of Christendom shared…heresy led to social unrest. From the Church’s perspective, heretics damned many poor souls by leading them into error…something had to be done.
 
There is actually a great deal of misinformation out there regarding the Inquisition. The English hated the Spanish, and particularly due to their Protestant bias, they developed the “Black Legend” which GREATLY distorted the facts. Consider the following:
-Compared to other courts of the day, the Inquisition (Roman or Spanish) was really quite humane
-Modern scholarship has found that only 1-2% of those tried were executed…a mere few thousand souls over a few centuries (yes a few thousand souls is nothing to scoff at…but the death toll does not constitute a massacre by any stretch of the imagination)
-The Spanish Inquisition rooted out heresy sparing Spain the devastation of the religious wars that tore apart other realms, like the Holy Roman Empire. The death toll from religious wars (between Catholics and Protestants) was far higher than that of the Inquisition…
-Heresy was considered both a grave sin against God and treason against the state…the entire social fabric was based upon the common faith all the nation of Christendom shared…heresy led to social unrest. From the Church’s perspective, heretics damned many poor souls by leading them into error…something had to be done.
very well put, a reasoned and cogent defense:)
 
None of that is what the initial post was about. I just was wondering how different things would be in the modern age if the Inquisition would never happen.
I think it’s almost impossible to tell.

Yes, unbelievers do throw the inquisition out at the believer, and it is unfortunate that chrisitians in general don’t simply say “yes, certain elements of the church got it wrong”. The church has got it wrong on many occasions since it is a human institution, but people put so much faith in the institution, without that faith in the “church” I suspect most wouldn’t believe in God. Accepting Catholic critisizm is hard . So be it.

I don’t personally blame, the “religion” christianity on the people who follow it, but it’s took a long time to get to that place.

And if you think non-believers would suddenly change their tune on religion, if it never happened, then no they wouldn’t. There are many “possible” things that could have happened, and didn’t. That’s not why people don’t believe, it’s just why they feel justified(and in some way’s rightly so) in rejecting a particular denomination and church, especially when people follow that church make excuses rather than deal with some of it’s history.

Would we be more “advanced” as a society if the inquisition didn’t happen? Again…I cannot say. I think religion has had it’s place, and without it…even with the flaws within each doctrine and group that follows it…I think the world has been better off with it in many ways.

But…It’s very hard to look at inquisitions, the amount of females alone that died through the spanish inquisition is dreadful.

But…as to your question, I don’t know. Why…do you ask it?
 
twf;4519818-:
Heresy was considered both a grave sin against God and treason against the state…the entire social fabric was based upon the common faith all the nation of Christendom shared…heresy led to social unrest. From the Church’s perspective, heretics damned many poor souls by leading them into error…something had to be done.
This is what is such an issue with concepts like an inquisition.

One institution, deciding that certain people were “damning” souls or leading to error…and strong manning them into changing their stance.

One institution, deciding how humanity should behave and deciding for humanity what will be considered their reality and truth. ONE institution. They removed and ostrasized people from their community, and in certain cases, torturing or even killing them.

Even if it isn’t as bad as documented, you must see this as a problem?

Funnily enough, we have a system today that does this. It’s called the US justice system. Kills people…in the name of justice. We haven’t come so far after all maybe.
 
But…as to your question, I don’t know. Why…do you ask it?
I just like speculating alternate histories, the what may have bee if this different decision had been taken, is all.
 
There is actually a great deal of misinformation out there regarding the Inquisition. The English hated the Spanish, and particularly due to their Protestant bias, they developed the “Black Legend” which GREATLY distorted the facts. Consider the following:
-Compared to other courts of the day, the Inquisition (Roman or Spanish) was really quite humane

How is burning a living & conscious person alive “humane” ? Such behaviour is evil. It degrades the Church & corrupts Christian ethics, if such things are to be defended as not evil. If they are not evil, there is no moral objection to burning Catholics today. But if these things are evil, comparisons with the acts of others are no defence at all - the sins of others do not make us sinless.​

-Modern scholarship has found that only 1-2% of those tried were executed…a mere few thousand souls over a few centuries (yes a few thousand souls is nothing to scoff at…but the death toll does not constitute a massacre by any stretch of the imagination)
-The Spanish Inquisition rooted out heresy sparing Spain the devastation of the religious wars that tore apart other realms, like the Holy Roman Empire. The death toll from religious wars (between Catholics and Protestants) was far higher than that of the Inquisition…

That does not make its activities any less unChristian - a murderer is still a murderer if he kills just one person; not being a serial murderer does not make him any less a murderer.​

-Heresy was considered both a grave sin against God and treason against the state…the entire social fabric was based upon the common faith all the nation of Christendom shared…heresy led to social unrest. From the Church’s perspective, heretics damned many poor souls by leading them into error…something had to be done.

From the Reich’s perspective, the Jews were doing immense harm to the German Volk. The argument justifies Hitler, if it justifies the Church. As you say, something had to be done - enter the Nuremberg Laws, Kristallnacht, the building of concentration camps, the Wannsee Conference, & the Final Solution. The argument used to defend the Inquisition justifies the Chinese repression of Christian parasites and fifth-columnists & other enemies of the People’s Republic as well; because it is an appeal to “reasons of state” - which may not be moral (let alone Christian) at all. The Church is supposed to be a Christian body - not a totalitarian tyranny. But that is what that argument has defended. 😦​

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top