hmm… it seems that a lot of it comes back to Scripture, whether we want it to or not. Especially, it seems, when the Saints are involved…
As Catholics, we believe that “everything in the Bible is true”, not “everything that is true is in the Bible”. Hence our argument against Sola Scriptura. Let us for the moment ignore Scriptural references, as this can only make things worse and make us go round in circles, for the devil can cite Scripture for his purpose.
I would like to first address the concern of the Saints. A dogmatic (right term?) problem to be sure, because nowhere in Scripture, to my knowledge, does it state we should honour those in Heaven, if indeed, we know that they are. However, I think it stems from a misinterpretation of ‘Communion of Saints’. That is, the part of the Catholic faith that has saints. It seems to have been interpreted as ‘praying to the saints’, whereas it is instead ‘praying with the saints’. Just as on Earth, we pray in groups, and come together at Mass, the Saints are there with us too, guiding us in our prayer and praying with us. Indeed, prayer is never a solitary exercise, it is a dialogue, with God and also the saints, praying with us to God, and interceding for us on our behalf.
What do I mean by Saint? I mean it in the original sense, that is, not one whom the Church has designated as ‘holy and in heaven’, but simply one who is ‘blessed’. That includes us, and as such when it comes to the Communion of Saints, it means that as a community, both on Earth and in Heaven (and Purgatory as well…), we are all praying together, to God, and God answers back.
It is like asking a friend for help. Usually, under such restrictions, people may ask ‘why did you get your friend to help you? Don’t you know you have your father to do that for you?’
I answer, ‘Yes, but I still love my friend, and we have helped each other. It will please my father to know we are working together, for the gift he brings back is for him, from both of us.’
That is what I mean by intercession, and communion of saints. They are there to help, to be part of the community, and also serve as role models, a friend to look up to, and to help us by following their example. Of course, for those saints in heaven, in order to communicate with them, we do need to pray to them as well, just as with my friend, I may need to call him through a phone, or some other communications.
For example, to help us with our battle against evil, we may pray to St. Michael, who is the chief warrior of heaven. It doesn’t mean that we cannot do it ourselves, it means that we want all the help we can get, and through this community, this sacred brotherhood, we are drawn closer together to God, from the love that we feel towards each other, because I say, the gift is for Him.
It is not Scripture, our faith, our catechism, is based on common sense. We live in a community of love. Therefore, we help each other out. We pray for one another, in some cases, to one another. But above all, remember that God is love, and to love is to love God. For it is the greatest of all virtues, and the one thing that allowed us to live.