If you are catholic now; was your conversion long and hard?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rv_Cain_Spencer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Rv_Cain_Spencer

Guest
What denomination were you and how and why did you convert to catholicism? Tell me if it was difficult.
 
I had many years between starting RCIA and confirming 😉 I had too many questions, doubts, concerns, and frankly: perhaps a good deal of not wanting to give up my secular lifestyle.
 
I had many years between starting RCIA and confirming 😉 I had too many questions, doubts, concerns, and frankly: perhaps a good deal of not wanting to give up my secular lifestyle.
So were you protestant?
 
What denomination were you and how and why did you convert to catholicism? Tell me if it was difficult.
Hi.

My story’s a little unusual because I converted from nothing at all.

I strongly suspect that those who are agnostic or atheist have a better time in understanding the Catholic faith. I firmly believed that God existed all my life but did not subscribe to any particular faith at that time, but show Him more as the “watchmaker” diety.

The reason why agnostics and atheists have a better go at it? They aren’t burdened by past non-Catholic teachings that often were inherently contradictory with Catholicism.

For me, it was harder to wrap my head around Christ as God until I began to see Him as an historical person and not a fairy tale. The Scriptures did for me in part; the history of the Church took me the rest of the way.

So, for me, it wasn’t very hard.
 
I was raised Catholic but left the Church gradually from about age 18 - 25 and spent much time in sort of a “limbo”. I looked at Protestantism and some eastern systems but I could find nothing else that really felt “more right”, and so sort of cobbled together my own “theology” based on the idea that Christ was right but that there was a lot of error mixed in to everyone’s mix.

My conversion back was also gradual, first a yearning for the eucharist and, believe it or not, the discipline of the Church that I found I missed. Unfortunately my life was in such a mess that I was unable to return to the sacraments and I still had theological issues to deal with. Only after much prayer, and the help of my Godfather, did God show me how to return. That was at age 52. My wife also returned to the church ans sacraments with me which is wonderful because she has alzheimers and that was perhaps the last really “cognizant” thing she was able to do.

If your interested in particular details let me know and I will share.

Peace
James
 
I was raised Catholic but left the Church gradually from about age 18 - 25 and spent much time in sort of a “limbo”. I looked at Protestantism and some eastern systems but I could find nothing else that really felt “more right”, and so sort of cobbled together my own “theology” based on the idea that Christ was right but that there was a lot of error mixed in to everyone’s mix.

My conversion back was also gradual, first a yearning for the eucharist and, believe it or not, the discipline of the Church that I found I missed. Unfortunately my life was in such a mess that I was unable to return to the sacraments and I still had theological issues to deal with. Only after much prayer, and the help of my Godfather, did God show me how to return. That was at age 52. My wife also returned to the church ans sacraments with me which is wonderful because she has alzheimers and that was perhaps the last really “cognizant” thing she was able to do.

If your interested in particular details let me know and I will share.

Peace
James
What a mind boggle. It took you so long, but now you are back. Welcome home.

Tell more.
Hi.

My story’s a little unusual because I converted from nothing at all.

I strongly suspect that those who are agnostic or atheist have a better time in understanding the Catholic faith. I firmly believed that God existed all my life but did not subscribe to any particular faith at that time, but show Him more as the “watchmaker” diety.

The reason why agnostics and atheists have a better go at it? They aren’t burdened by past non-Catholic teachings that often were inherently contradictory with Catholicism.

For me, it was harder to wrap my head around Christ as God until I began to see Him as an historical person and not a fairy tale. The Scriptures did for me in part; the history of the Church took me the rest of the way.

So, for me, it wasn’t very hard.
Yes, Jesus being the “I am” is very difficult at first isn’t it?
 
I was a secular Jew, which basically means my background / heritage is Jewish but I was raised agnostic. I felt a strong calling to the Church last year and have just converted a few months ago. It was all very quick and almost miraculous from my point of view! I was supposed to be baptized at the Easter Vigil this year but because I fell very ill in September (and might have died), the priest baptized me ahead of time and I also received Holy Communion and Reconciliation later on in 2009. I’m still going to be confirmed at the Easter Vigil. Rather than repeat it here, my conversion story is in this thread (very long!):

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=332683

I’m very interested to hear other people’s stories, thanks for starting this thread!
 
I am presuming you are a cradle Catholic? Or do you have your own story to tell?

My priest calls me an ‘ecumenical’!!

Truth be told, though we will never know, if I were still living where I grew up, I might have been satisfied to continue attending the UCC Church. But, I grew up in a Union church - Ev. Lutheran/UCC. Both hymnals were in the pews, so essentially we were Lutheran and UCC on alternating Sundays. Our Sunday schools were combined, too, so, the line between the two is very fuzzy for me. Our services were very similar to the NO Mass, and we believed in the Real Presence of Christ in Communion (and, yes, I understand the difference, so, please let’s not get side-tracked by this statement!), and in Faith and works - both very important in my conversion. I still remember the Sunday the altar was pulled forward and the pastor now faced the congregation! Our Union church split not because of discord, but, because both congregations became too large for the church building. They continue to have joint services - Lent, Advent, Thanksgiving. That is when I really learned I was UCC, though, and that’s how I was baptized and confirmed, and where my son was eventually baptized. I was their choir director and organist for 9 years.

I went to Penn State, where I sang in their chapel choir on campus - an ecumenical service, so, no communion. There was no UCC church in town, but, I could walk to the Lutheran Church so I could receive communion. I attended 2 services nearly every Sunday when I was in college.

Fast forward - I got married, then, my mother died, family issues, and for other reasons, my husband, son and I decided it was time to move away. Where we moved, there was no UCC Church, but there was a Lutheran church - with the same name as the Lutheran church I grew up in. So, that seemed to be where I was meant to be, and that is where my son was confirmed. There eventually were theological differences that became apparent. I learned that this was a M.S. Lutheran Church. The pastor preached against Faith and works, and communion seemed more symbolic in nature. Both Lutheran denominations celebrated well the liturgical seasons - also very important in my conversion. Things got to a point where I knew it was time to leave that church, and for the first time in my life, I was without a church home. I sang in the choir there, played for chapel services - Christian school, and filled in for the organist.

We had a Baptist youth pastor across the street from us. My son would go to youth group with him, and we went to their Baptist church as well as to other local Protestant churches. I knew I didn’t belong in any of them, but, a Methodist church advertised for a church pianist, so I thought that was an answer to my prayers. I had to audition - TWICE! - and got the position. In my 6 years there, we were never invited to become members, but, there were theological differences there, too - especially communion, and Faith and works - that I couldn’t reconcile, so, I knew I didn’t belong there, either.

Less than a week before Christmas, 2005, I got a call from a woman at the local Catholic church that they had just learned that their organist decided to go away and was not playing for Christmas Eve Mass, and could I play!? She was friends with the Methodist church secretary and they had already determined that the times were such that I could play both places! That is the first time I had ever been inside an American Catholic church!

Playing for that Mass was an experience - I had people putting unfamiliar music in front of me telling me what to play and when - oh, my!!!Wouldn’t know the priest if I fell over him!!

That was supposed to be once and done, so I didn’t give it any more thought. Same year, end of June, I get another phone call. They got a new priest. The organist wasn’t happy with the change, so she quit, effective immediately. Could I play until the found someone full-time? Their Mass - 8 AM, Methodist service, right down the street - 10AM. Can’t imagine a church without music, so I said I would. Needless to say, they never found anyone else. I got more familiar with the order of worship. The more I heard, the more the theology sounded right. I began asking questions - pity the priest!! The lady who called me in the first place - who eventually became my sponsor (seemed only right!) - and the priest invited me to come to RCIA. (I had my own personal struggle with that, and came and left, and went back). I was received into the Church Easter Vigil 2007. Now I am part of our RCIA team. Actually, I am presenting a lesson on Holy Week tonight.

It has been quite a journey, but, I know I am truly Home. My son had issues with Baptist theology, yet will still participate in some activities with our Baptist neighbors. He continues to attend the Methodist church where I had played. He attends Mass with me sometimes, but says he will never be Catholic. Five years or so ago, I probably would have said the same thing. He asks me many questions, and we have some very interesting theological discussions. I am content that he is a good Christian. He must make his own choice just as I did.
 
I was a secular Jew, which basically means my background / heritage is Jewish but I was raised agnostic. I felt a strong calling to the Church last year and have just converted a few months ago. It was all very quick and almost miraculous from my point of view! I was supposed to be baptized at the Easter Vigil this year but because I fell very ill in September (and might have died), the priest baptized me ahead of time and I also received Holy Communion and Reconciliation later on in 2009. I’m still going to be confirmed at the Easter Vigil. Rather than repeat it here, my conversion story is in this thread (very long!):

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=332683

I’m very interested to hear other people’s stories, thanks for starting this thread!
That’s very amazing, I love it when someone comes to Catholicism rapidly.
 
I am presuming you are a cradle Catholic? Or do you have your own story to tell?

My priest calls me an ‘ecumenical’!!

Truth be told, though we will never know, if I were still living where I grew up, I might have been satisfied to continue attending the UCC Church. But, I grew up in a Union church - Ev. Lutheran/UCC. Both hymnals were in the pews, so essentially we were Lutheran and UCC on alternating Sundays. Our Sunday schools were combined, too, so, the line between the two is very fuzzy for me. Our services were very similar to the NO Mass, and we believed in the Real Presence of Christ in Communion (and, yes, I understand the difference, so, please let’s not get side-tracked by this statement!), and in Faith and works - both very important in my conversion. I still remember the Sunday the altar was pulled forward and the pastor now faced the congregation! Our Union church split not because of discord, but, because both congregations became too large for the church building. They continue to have joint services - Lent, Advent, Thanksgiving. That is when I really learned I was UCC, though, and that’s how I was baptized and confirmed, and where my son was eventually baptized. I was their choir director and organist for 9 years.

I went to Penn State, where I sang in their chapel choir on campus - an ecumenical service, so, no communion. There was no UCC church in town, but, I could walk to the Lutheran Church so I could receive communion. I attended 2 services nearly every Sunday when I was in college.

Fast forward - I got married, then, my mother died, family issues, and for other reasons, my husband, son and I decided it was time to move away. Where we moved, there was no UCC Church, but there was a Lutheran church - with the same name as the Lutheran church I grew up in. So, that seemed to be where I was meant to be, and that is where my son was confirmed. There eventually were theological differences that became apparent. I learned that this was a M.S. Lutheran Church. The pastor preached against Faith and works, and communion seemed more symbolic in nature. Both Lutheran denominations celebrated well the liturgical seasons - also very important in my conversion. Things got to a point where I knew it was time to leave that church, and for the first time in my life, I was without a church home. I sang in the choir there, played for chapel services - Christian school, and filled in for the organist.

We had a Baptist youth pastor across the street from us. My son would go to youth group with him, and we went to their Baptist church as well as to other local Protestant churches. I knew I didn’t belong in any of them, but, a Methodist church advertised for a church pianist, so I thought that was an answer to my prayers. I had to audition - TWICE! - and got the position. In my 6 years there, we were never invited to become members, but, there were theological differences there, too - especially communion, and Faith and works - that I couldn’t reconcile, so, I knew I didn’t belong there, either.

Less than a week before Christmas, 2005, I got a call from a woman at the local Catholic church that they had just learned that their organist decided to go away and was not playing for Christmas Eve Mass, and could I play!? She was friends with the Methodist church secretary and they had already determined that the times were such that I could play both places! That is the first time I had ever been inside an American Catholic church!

Playing for that Mass was an experience - I had people putting unfamiliar music in front of me telling me what to play and when - oh, my!!!Wouldn’t know the priest if I fell over him!!

That was supposed to be once and done, so I didn’t give it any more thought. Same year, end of June, I get another phone call. They got a new priest. The organist wasn’t happy with the change, so she quit, effective immediately. Could I play until the found someone full-time? Their Mass - 8 AM, Methodist service, right down the street - 10AM. Can’t imagine a church without music, so I said I would. Needless to say, they never found anyone else. I got more familiar with the order of worship. The more I heard, the more the theology sounded right. I began asking questions - pity the priest!! The lady who called me in the first place - who eventually became my sponsor (seemed only right!) - and the priest invited me to come to RCIA. (I had my own personal struggle with that, and came and left, and went back). I was received into the Church Easter Vigil 2007. Now I am part of our RCIA team. Actually, I am presenting a lesson on Holy Week tonight.

It has been quite a journey, but, I know I am truly Home. My son had issues with Baptist theology, yet will still participate in some activities with our Baptist neighbors. He continues to attend the Methodist church where I had played. He attends Mass with me sometimes, but says he will never be Catholic. Five years or so ago, I probably would have said the same thing. He asks me many questions, and we have some very interesting theological discussions. I am content that he is a good Christian. He must make his own choice just as I did.
What a story! I am actually a ex protestant (methodist to be precise).
 
Originally Posted by JRKH
I was raised Catholic but left the Church gradually from about age 18 - 25 and spent much time in sort of a “limbo”. I looked at Protestantism and some eastern systems but I could find nothing else that really felt “more right”, and so sort of cobbled together my own “theology” based on the idea that Christ was right but that there was a lot of error mixed in to everyone’s mix.
What would you like to know?

Peace
James
 
I am presuming you are a cradle Catholic? Or do you have your own story to tell?

My priest calls me an ‘ecumenical’!!

Truth be told, though we will never know, if I were still living where I grew up, I might have been satisfied to continue attending the UCC Church. But, I grew up in a Union church - Ev. Lutheran/UCC. Both hymnals were in the pews, so essentially we were Lutheran and UCC on alternating Sundays. Our Sunday schools were combined, too, so, the line between the two is very fuzzy for me. Our services were very similar to the NO Mass, and we believed in the Real Presence of Christ in Communion (and, yes, I understand the difference, so, please let’s not get side-tracked by this statement!), and in Faith and works - both very important in my conversion. I still remember the Sunday the altar was pulled forward and the pastor now faced the congregation! Our Union church split not because of discord, but, because both congregations became too large for the church building. They continue to have joint services - Lent, Advent, Thanksgiving. That is when I really learned I was UCC, though, and that’s how I was baptized and confirmed, and where my son was eventually baptized. I was their choir director and organist for 9 years.

I went to Penn State, where I sang in their chapel choir on campus - an ecumenical service, so, no communion. There was no UCC church in town, but, I could walk to the Lutheran Church so I could receive communion. I attended 2 services nearly every Sunday when I was in college.

Fast forward - I got married, then, my mother died, family issues, and for other reasons, my husband, son and I decided it was time to move away. Where we moved, there was no UCC Church, but there was a Lutheran church - with the same name as the Lutheran church I grew up in. So, that seemed to be where I was meant to be, and that is where my son was confirmed. There eventually were theological differences that became apparent. I learned that this was a M.S. Lutheran Church. The pastor preached against Faith and works, and communion seemed more symbolic in nature. Both Lutheran denominations celebrated well the liturgical seasons - also very important in my conversion. Things got to a point where I knew it was time to leave that church, and for the first time in my life, I was without a church home. I sang in the choir there, played for chapel services - Christian school, and filled in for the organist.

We had a Baptist youth pastor across the street from us. My son would go to youth group with him, and we went to their Baptist church as well as to other local Protestant churches. I knew I didn’t belong in any of them, but, a Methodist church advertised for a church pianist, so I thought that was an answer to my prayers. I had to audition - TWICE! - and got the position. In my 6 years there, we were never invited to become members, but, there were theological differences there, too - especially communion, and Faith and works - that I couldn’t reconcile, so, I knew I didn’t belong there, either.

Less than a week before Christmas, 2005, I got a call from a woman at the local Catholic church that they had just learned that their organist decided to go away and was not playing for Christmas Eve Mass, and could I play!? She was friends with the Methodist church secretary and they had already determined that the times were such that I could play both places! That is the first time I had ever been inside an American Catholic church!

Playing for that Mass was an experience - I had people putting unfamiliar music in front of me telling me what to play and when - oh, my!!!Wouldn’t know the priest if I fell over him!!

That was supposed to be once and done, so I didn’t give it any more thought. Same year, end of June, I get another phone call. They got a new priest. The organist wasn’t happy with the change, so she quit, effective immediately. Could I play until the found someone full-time? Their Mass - 8 AM, Methodist service, right down the street - 10AM. Can’t imagine a church without music, so I said I would. Needless to say, they never found anyone else. I got more familiar with the order of worship. The more I heard, the more the theology sounded right. I began asking questions - pity the priest!! The lady who called me in the first place - who eventually became my sponsor (seemed only right!) - and the priest invited me to come to RCIA. (I had my own personal struggle with that, and came and left, and went back). I was received into the Church Easter Vigil 2007. Now I am part of our RCIA team. Actually, I am presenting a lesson on Holy Week tonight.

It has been quite a journey, but, I know I am truly Home. My son had issues with Baptist theology, yet will still participate in some activities with our Baptist neighbors. He continues to attend the Methodist church where I had played. He attends Mass with me sometimes, but says he will never be Catholic. Five years or so ago, I probably would have said the same thing. He asks me many questions, and we have some very interesting theological discussions. I am content that he is a good Christian. He must make his own choice just as I did.
What a story! I am actually an ex protestant (methodist to be precise) but we wont go there!
 
What would you like to know?

Peace
James
Even when I studied and believed catholicism to be true, I still didn’t bother to actually do anything about it. What got you up and motivated?
 
Even when I studied and believed catholicism to be true, I still didn’t bother to actually do anything about it. What got you up and motivated?
Boy - That’s a question.

I guess it was really the fact that my Wife was diagnosed with Alzhemer’s that got me thinking more about things spiritual.
I prayed hard about that and received an actual “voice” in my head telling me not to worry. It said, and I’m not kidding, “She’s mine, I’ll take care of her”. That put me back on track for sure. But since I had a marriage issue (divorced and remarried) I could not immediately return. In fact I felt I would not be able to return until after my wife passed away.
Then a while later I received a letter from my Godfather who I hadn’t really seen in some time, and who knew nothing about my recent experiences, advising me to go ahead and apply for an annulment. This cause me no samll amount of concern because I did not really know if I had valid grounds. So I went ahead and sent for the questionaire from the dioces and I prayed hard and long on this. Then I had my second experience.
Early one morning, I was lying in bed beside my wife who was sound asleep. I was contemplating on the questions on the questionaire when she lifted the blankets with one hand, made a perfect sign of the cross with her other hand, and then laid the blankets back down. She did not wake up.
After that I found that the answers to the questions came more easily and I was able to begin to heal over that entire first marriage experience. Something that I had not been able to do completely before.
I was able to receive my annulment in about 6 months (a really quick response) and we immediately got our marriage convalidated, went to confession and returned to communiopn. That was in August of 2007.

Shortly thereafter I was looking for good information to answer my many faith questions and found CAF. From there I have rediscovered so much and now I dont’ seem to be able to “get enough”. Especially since I’ve discovered the “mystics” of the Church for that is the type of spirtuality I am drawn to.

Peace
James
 
What a story! I am actually an ex protestant (methodist to be precise)** but we wont go there**!
I notice that you added that, so, I won’t ask for anything you don’t feel comfortable divulging, but, I will ask 3 questions. How long have you been Catholic? Was your conversion fairly easy and comfortable, or a struggle? What was the greatest obstacle to your becoming Catholic? …if you don’t mind my asking.
 
What denomination were you and how and why did you convert to catholicism? Tell me if it was difficult.
I was a secular /cultural Jew but had some exposure to Judaism growing up via Hebrew school. Those lessons in Hebrew school connected me with God at an early age, and I will say that connection had an impact on me when I converted to Roman Catholicism. The two most memorable things I learned was that God is in everyone and everything and that God loves me. I realize that I spent my life hungering for God but was too proud to admit it.

My conversion to Catholicism was gradual over a period of 23 years. My first husband was Roman Catholic (but not observant), and that’s where I got my initial exposure to christianity, albeit at funerals and weddings only. I was agnostic throughout our 19 year marriage. I went through a difficult divorce from him (what divorce isn’t difficult?) six years ago and at that time became extremely anxious, lost 22 pounds from not eating, could hardly function, and was generally a spiritual mess. I began to take a good look at myself and my situation/ misery. I needed to change.

I starting reading the New Testament and slowly began to grow interested in Christianity. I didn’t understand everything I was reading, but I felt something. I went to a few Masses and I also attended some protestant services. At a Methodist service they were having communion and when I did not go up to receive, the pastor asked me (after the service and within earshot of everyone around us) why I didn’t go up–and I replied that I did not feel worthy or ready to receive communion. I sensed that communion was special–but that Church did not treat it as such. At that moment I knew that the Catholic Church is the true church, and I went full force toward the Church from that time on. I hooked up with a priest at our small rural parish, attended RCIA 1:1 with him, and converted at Easter vigil 3 years ago.

Since that time I have remarried in the Church to a Catholic. I am so thankful that Jesus saved my life–without Him I would never have made it to where I am today.
 
I notice that you added that, so, I won’t ask for anything you don’t feel comfortable divulging, but, I will ask 3 questions. …if you don’t mind my asking.
Sigh…
How long have you been Catholic?
Too long.
Was your conversion fairly easy and comfortable?
No.
What was the greatest obstacle to your becoming Catholic?
Eucharist. After having looked up about the fulfilment of passover, to some depth.
 
Boy - That’s a question.

I guess it was really the fact that my Wife was diagnosed with Alzhemer’s that got me thinking more about things spiritual.
I prayed hard about that and received an actual “voice” in my head telling me not to worry. It said, and I’m not kidding, “She’s mine, I’ll take care of her”. That put me back on track for sure. But since I had a marriage issue (divorced and remarried) I could not immediately return. In fact I felt I would not be able to return until after my wife passed away.
Then a while later I received a letter from my Godfather who I hadn’t really seen in some time, and who knew nothing about my recent experiences, advising me to go ahead and apply for an annulment. This cause me no samll amount of concern because I did not really know if I had valid grounds. So I went ahead and sent for the questionaire from the dioces and I prayed hard and long on this. Then I had my second experience.
Early one morning, I was lying in bed beside my wife who was sound asleep. I was contemplating on the questions on the questionaire when she lifted the blankets with one hand, made a perfect sign of the cross with her other hand, and then laid the blankets back down. She did not wake up.
After that I found that the answers to the questions came more easily and I was able to begin to heal over that entire first marriage experience. Something that I had not been able to do completely before.
I was able to receive my annulment in about 6 months (a really quick response) and we immediately got our marriage convalidated, went to confession and returned to communiopn. That was in August of 2007.

Shortly thereafter I was looking for good information to answer my many faith questions and found CAF. From there I have rediscovered so much and now I dont’ seem to be able to “get enough”. Especially since I’ve discovered the “mystics” of the Church for that is the type of spirtuality I am drawn to.

Peace
James
James, this is quite something!
 
I was raised as “nothing” by parents who had only their treasured mutual dislike for the Catholic church in common. All my extended family were Catholic except for me, my mother and my brother. I grew up yearning for Jesus and went to Mass with my relatives as often as I could get away with. I would beg my cousins and Catholic friends to say the rosary with me.

When I was in middle school around 1970, I asked my mother if I could become Catholic but she refused. When I insisted that I at least be Baptized, she agreed to let me be Baptized as an Episcopalian. After a painful rift in the local Episcopal church, I pretty much gave up on organized Christian religion and turned to Hinduism, since I had already been meditating for a few years at this point.

As much as being a Hindu suited me, I also attended Mass as often as I could, with relatives for weddings and Baptisms and also on my own. I never gave up my desire to become a Catholic, but it just seemed pointless after so many years.

Then in the 1990’s when my devotion to Hinduism was growing stronger, I felt more pulled toward the Catholic church and started going to Mass several times a week. After my husband and I moved to the midwest, I stopped going to daily Mass but missed seeing Our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. At this time I discovered adoration and began to make weekly Holy Hours (and often several times a week). From that point forward, it just blossomed into the decision to begin RCIA.

I can’t say it was difficult, but it was quite an interesting 50-year-long journey! And whew - it’s sure good to be home at last.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top