Redhen, I don’t have time to sift through all the articles you linked, but I thought I’d read and respond to this one.
His most famous claim is his false trichotomy; Lord, Liar, or Lunatic.
atheism.about.com/od/cslewisnarnia/a/jesustrilemma.htm
Most of the article is spent merely repeating again and again that C.S. Lewis is using a false trilemma. It’s only at the end of the article that an actual argument comes out. Here’s the argument from the end of the article.
aboutatheism:
In this case, there are other possibilities which Lewis does not effectively eliminate. For example, perhaps Jesus was simply mistaken
It would be extremely hard for a sane man to become convinced that he’s God. Especially when you’re talking about God in the Hebrew context, for they believed in one God who is eternal, omniscient, omnipresent and omnipotent, and the Early Christians continued to believe that. Jesus also is recorded in the Gospels as arguing that He is free from sin, a necessity for deity in the Hebrew context. He also says that He saw Abraham, and He remembers seeing Satan’s fall from Heaven. Those are the kinds of things you’d have to know if you were deity according to Yahweh standards. The Gospels are full of records of miracles showing how Jesus has power over all things, for God would be omnipotent. The atheism article is ignoring the Hebrew understanding of deity when it says He could have been “simply mistaken.”
aboutatheism:
or that we don’t have an accurate record of what he truly said
I think that’s the best argument someone could make when trying to dodge the Lewis trilemma. But it doesn’t work either, for there’s very solid reason to believe we have what Jesus really said and did. I suggest reading “The Case for Christ” by Lee Strobel, a book in which he interviews many experts in archaeology, history and the various forms of evidence pertaining to early Christianity. There is certainly far stronger evidence for the accuracy of the Gospels than there is for the accuracy of any other ancient text, as the scholars in the book demonstrate. The author makes a strong case.
aboutatheism:
— if, indeed, he even existed.
Now this aside moves from reason into deep ignorance. The evidence for Jesus’ existence is extremely strong, from Early Christian sources like the apostles and Early Church Fathers, from Jewish sources like the Talmud, and from Roman sources like Tacitus and Josephus. A great many elements of the Gospels’ accounts can be shown from non-Christian early corroborative sources alone, without using early Christian writings at all. From Roman and Jewish records alone one can know that a man named Jesus lived at the time the Gospels record Him living in Palestine, that huge crowds flocked to listen to His messages, that many of His early followers believed He was the Messiah, was God and performed many miracles, and that He was crucified and His followers believed He rose from the dead. All that is in the early Phariseean and Roman sources.
aboutatheism:
Lewis’ argument is in fact unacceptable in the context of first century Palestine, where Jews were actively awaiting a messiah to rescue them. It’s implausible that they would have greeted incorrect claims of messianic status with labels like “liar” or “lunatic.” Instead, they would have moved on to await another claimant.
I don’t know of any reason to believe this at all. There is no evidence provided and it sounds ridiculous. Of course there would be a sense of betrayal if a Messiah claimant proved to be false. They would feel he was a liar. Many scholars point to this as the cause of Judas’ betrayal, arguing that most Jews of the time believed in a militaristic Messiah who would save them from the Romans, and when it was clear Jesus wouldn’t do this, Judas may have felt betrayed and angry. I think this particular argument in aboutatheism is one of the most absurd and baseless of all its baseless claims.
But even if this unsupported statement were true, it would be a red herring, for most Messiah figures from the time wouldn’t have claimed to be God. C.S. Lewis’ trilemma is about Jesus’ claim to be GOD, not His claim to be the Messiah. One might not have to be a lunatic to think one was Messiah, but one would have to be a lunatic to think of oneself as God according to Hebrew definitions.