I'm a confused atheist

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pi314
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Funny you tied Mere Christianity together with Collins’
I’ve read both, several times, I found them both disappointing. Collins’ scientific credentials as director of the Human Genome project caught my attention, and the cover of the book with the double helix of DNA, and the title “The Language of God”. When I read it though I realized that his conversion did not come about through his scientific research, it was totally subjective.

Mere Christianity has been touted for a long time as an apologetic masterpiece, but it’s not convincing either. His most famous claim is his false trichotomy; Lord, Liar, or Lunatic.
atheism.about.com/od/cslewisnarnia/a/jesustrilemma.htm

His arguments from morality and desire are also weak.
atheism.about.com/od/cslewisnarnia/a/argumentmorals.htm
atheism.about.com/od/cslewisnarnia/a/desireargument.htm

Lewis is an excellent writer though, so by all means read it. I would also recommend The Screwtape Letters. Lewis has a vivid imagination, evidenced as well by the Narnia series.

Anyone who wants to investigate the truth claims of Christianity must be reasonable about it. By that I mean being open, and not excluding any contrary observations. So if I might be permitted, here’s some other books you might want to check out;

amazon.com/Gods-Problem-Answer-Important-Question-Why/dp/0061173975
amazon.com/Misquoting-Jesus-Story-Behind-Changed/dp/0060859512/ref=pd_bxgy_b_img_c
amazon.com/Putting-Away-Childish-Things-Ranke-Heinemann/dp/006066861X
amazon.com/Putting-Away-Childish-Things-Ranke-Heinemann/dp/006066861X
amazon.com/Breaking-Spell-Religion-Natural-Phenomenon/dp/067003472X
amazon.com/Primates-Philosophers-Morality-Evolved-Princeton/dp/0691124477
 
I think that prayer works better than anything in leading people to the truth 🙂

an argument can be twisted in any number of ways and made to sound convincing. When I was looking into Catholicism, I had to decide between Catholicism and Orthodoxy. I read about both, and both made really good points and supported them with historical facts, etc. But they were saying opposite things. It’s similar with Christianity and atheism… sure, there might be books about atheism that make a good case for it. But that doesn’t mean it’s the truth, it just means the author has a talent for writing and organizing information.

In every single conversion, there comes a point when a person just ‘knows’ that God is real and this goes deeper than any argument. It’s not just an emotion or anything like that. It’s just faith. 🙂
 
Redhen, I don’t have time to sift through all the articles you linked, but I thought I’d read and respond to this one.
His most famous claim is his false trichotomy; Lord, Liar, or Lunatic.
atheism.about.com/od/cslewisnarnia/a/jesustrilemma.htm
Most of the article is spent merely repeating again and again that C.S. Lewis is using a false trilemma. It’s only at the end of the article that an actual argument comes out. Here’s the argument from the end of the article.
aboutatheism:
In this case, there are other possibilities which Lewis does not effectively eliminate. For example, perhaps Jesus was simply mistaken
It would be extremely hard for a sane man to become convinced that he’s God. Especially when you’re talking about God in the Hebrew context, for they believed in one God who is eternal, omniscient, omnipresent and omnipotent, and the Early Christians continued to believe that. Jesus also is recorded in the Gospels as arguing that He is free from sin, a necessity for deity in the Hebrew context. He also says that He saw Abraham, and He remembers seeing Satan’s fall from Heaven. Those are the kinds of things you’d have to know if you were deity according to Yahweh standards. The Gospels are full of records of miracles showing how Jesus has power over all things, for God would be omnipotent. The atheism article is ignoring the Hebrew understanding of deity when it says He could have been “simply mistaken.”
aboutatheism:
or that we don’t have an accurate record of what he truly said
I think that’s the best argument someone could make when trying to dodge the Lewis trilemma. But it doesn’t work either, for there’s very solid reason to believe we have what Jesus really said and did. I suggest reading “The Case for Christ” by Lee Strobel, a book in which he interviews many experts in archaeology, history and the various forms of evidence pertaining to early Christianity. There is certainly far stronger evidence for the accuracy of the Gospels than there is for the accuracy of any other ancient text, as the scholars in the book demonstrate. The author makes a strong case.
aboutatheism:
— if, indeed, he even existed.
Now this aside moves from reason into deep ignorance. The evidence for Jesus’ existence is extremely strong, from Early Christian sources like the apostles and Early Church Fathers, from Jewish sources like the Talmud, and from Roman sources like Tacitus and Josephus. A great many elements of the Gospels’ accounts can be shown from non-Christian early corroborative sources alone, without using early Christian writings at all. From Roman and Jewish records alone one can know that a man named Jesus lived at the time the Gospels record Him living in Palestine, that huge crowds flocked to listen to His messages, that many of His early followers believed He was the Messiah, was God and performed many miracles, and that He was crucified and His followers believed He rose from the dead. All that is in the early Phariseean and Roman sources.
aboutatheism:
Lewis’ argument is in fact unacceptable in the context of first century Palestine, where Jews were actively awaiting a messiah to rescue them. It’s implausible that they would have greeted incorrect claims of messianic status with labels like “liar” or “lunatic.” Instead, they would have moved on to await another claimant.
I don’t know of any reason to believe this at all. There is no evidence provided and it sounds ridiculous. Of course there would be a sense of betrayal if a Messiah claimant proved to be false. They would feel he was a liar. Many scholars point to this as the cause of Judas’ betrayal, arguing that most Jews of the time believed in a militaristic Messiah who would save them from the Romans, and when it was clear Jesus wouldn’t do this, Judas may have felt betrayed and angry. I think this particular argument in aboutatheism is one of the most absurd and baseless of all its baseless claims.

But even if this unsupported statement were true, it would be a red herring, for most Messiah figures from the time wouldn’t have claimed to be God. C.S. Lewis’ trilemma is about Jesus’ claim to be GOD, not His claim to be the Messiah. One might not have to be a lunatic to think one was Messiah, but one would have to be a lunatic to think of oneself as God according to Hebrew definitions.
 
aboutatheism:
It isn’t even necessary to go into much detail about alternative possibilities in order to dismiss Lewis’ argument because the options of “liar” and “lunatic” are themselves not refuted by Lewis. It’s clear that Lewis doesn’t regard them as credible, but he doesn’t give good reasons for anyone else to agree — he’s trying to persuade psychologically, not intellectually. There’s no good reason to insist that Jesus isn’t similar to other religious leaders like Joseph Smith, David Koresh, Marshall Applewhite, Jim Jones, and Claude Vorilhon. Are they liars? Lunatics? A bit of both?
Jim Jones was pretty nuts, and there is strong evidence that Joseph Smith was a liar. I haven’t read about the others and so can’t speak to their personalities. But these men didn’t claim to be God either, only prophets and the like.

If the author of the article wants to argue that Jesus was a liar or a lunatic, I’ll let him, though. C.S. Lewis set up a trilemma with three options. The author to the article you cited finds the “liar” or “lunatic” options more likely than the “lord” option. A great many people would disagree. Those are the people C.S. Lewis is presenting this trilemma to. It isn’t meant to be a fool-proof argument proving Christianity. Though it is a good one.
aboutatheism:
Of course, Lewis’ primary goal is to argue against the liberal theological view of Jesus as a great human teacher, but there is nothing contradictory about someone being a great teacher while also being (or becoming) insane or also lying. No one is perfect and Lewis makes an error in assuming from the outset that Jesus’ teaching aren’t worth following unless he is perfect. In effect, then, his infamous false trilemma is based upon the premise of this false dilemma.
C.S. Lewis isn’t saying Jesus’ teachings aren’t worth following if He isn’t God. That wasn’t part of his argument, which was centered on the identity and character of Jesus.
 
Actually, the main point of the Lord, Liar, Lunatic argument was to get people to stop having the complacent attitude of “He was a great teacher, like all the other great religious teachers.” I know a lot of people with this attitude and held it for a while myself. Lewis is saying, “Look, he can’t just be a great teacher, he’s either God or he’s a madman or he’s lying.” You are free to choose one of the latter two options if you wish.
 
Anyone who wants to investigate the truth claims of Christianity must be reasonable about it. By that I mean being open, and not excluding any contrary observations.
And by “reasonable” I presume you mean adopting a scientific mindset that precludes the supernatural.

It is worth repeating that the biblical materials for a concept of God do not organize themselves. They do not automatically arrange themselves into a satisfactory form. They achieve that form only when the human mind, seeking to understand its own faith, begins to work on them and to set them out in more intelligible ways.

To organize the biblical materials, we soon find that we need to draw on such philosophical categories as good and evil, freedom and necessity, person and nature, mind and will, essence and existence, being and knowing. Of course, the application of these notions to God is an attempt to speak of what lies beyond the world within terms drawn from this world, and so is only justified if we always add a postscript to that effect. Warning: This Paper Contains Metaphysical Arguments or something like that so that our atheist friends can keep their superior scientific minds free from contamination.,

The problem with the science only view of the world is that it bans what is truly necessary to the discussion. Perhaps Einstein had it right"

Science without religion is lame. Religion without science is blind.
The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existing. One cannot help but be in awe when he contemplates the mysteries of eternity, of life, of the marvelous structure of reality. It is enough if one tries merely to comprehend a little of this mystery every day. Never lose a holy curiosity.
Albert Einstein

More here:

payingattentiontothesky.com/2009/09/09/approaches-to-god%e2%80%99s-existence/

dj
 
A Happy New Year to everyone !

During the holidays I finished reading Chesterton’s “Orthodoxy” and now I m halfway through “Mere Christianity”, both of which I find excellent books.

I also kept praying and going to Mass. Yesterday, after Mass, I finally managed (after getting cold feet on two previous occasions ) to gather enough courage to address the priest about joining the Church. He mentioned attending some classes - the local equivalent of RCIA I believe. I also have to fill in a written request and present it to the parish priest tomorrow. Since I’m baptized in the Eastern Orthodox Church I won’t need that sacrament again. He was quite nice, but nonetheless I felt extremely nervous, to the point where I was almost physically shacking and I felt lost for words. And that is NOT in my nature - I’ve been earning my living by speaking for the last 13 years, first as a teacher, then as a soft skills trainer and finally as a lawyer… and yesterday I felt like a dumb pupil in front of a stern teacher. Thank God I managed to go through with it…

In any case, if all goes well, I’m hoping to be admitted into the Church this Easter.
 
Three cheers and a hearty and loud “Amen” for Erethorn!!! Everyone continue to pray for a joyful and inspirational journey.
 
A Happy New Year to everyone !

During the holidays I finished reading Chesterton’s “Orthodoxy” and now I m halfway through “Mere Christianity”, both of which I find excellent books.

I also kept praying and going to Mass. Yesterday, after Mass, I finally managed (after getting cold feet on two previous occasions ) to gather enough courage to address the priest about joining the Church. He mentioned attending some classes - the local equivalent of RCIA I believe. I also have to fill in a written request and present it to the parish priest tomorrow. Since I’m baptized in the Eastern Orthodox Church I won’t need that sacrament again. He was quite nice, but nonetheless I felt extremely nervous, to the point where I was almost physically shacking and I felt lost for words. And that is NOT in my nature - I’ve been earning my living by speaking for the last 13 years, first as a teacher, then as a soft skills trainer and finally as a lawyer… and yesterday I felt like a dumb pupil in front of a stern teacher. Thank God I managed to go through with it…

In any case, if all goes well, I’m hoping to be admitted into the Church this Easter.
This is wonderful news Erethorn. I will certainly be praying for you. I am so happy you have made the most important decision of your life and afterlife. Christ’s Peace to you.
 
I think that’s the best argument someone could make when trying to dodge the Lewis trilemma. But it doesn’t work either, for there’s very solid reason to believe we have what Jesus really said and did. I suggest reading “The Case for Christ” by Lee Strobel, a book in which he interviews many experts in archaeology, history and the various forms of evidence pertaining to early Christianity. There is certainly far stronger evidence for the accuracy of the Gospels than there is for the accuracy of any other ancient text, as the scholars in the book demonstrate. The author makes a strong case.
I’ve read “The Case for Christ”. Strobel, being a lawyer, goes at it as he would in prosecuting a legal case. Historiography has different evidence requirements though. Also, Strobel does not interview anyone who holds contrary positions.
Now this aside moves from reason into deep ignorance. The evidence for Jesus’ existence is extremely strong, from Early Christian sources like the apostles and Early Church Fathers…
I’m not debating historical criticism. That’s another topic.
But even if this unsupported statement were true, it would be a red herring, for most Messiah figures from the time wouldn’t have claimed to be God. C.S. Lewis’ trilemma is about Jesus’ claim to be GOD, not His claim to be the Messiah. One might not have to be a lunatic to think one was Messiah, but one would have to be a lunatic to think of oneself as God according to Hebrew definitions.
Psychology does not use the words lunatic or mad which are just derogatory terms; the same with the word insane, which is a legal definition. I submit that there are some psychological disorders that could induce such delusions but still leave the subject fully able to function.

All I’m saying is that we should not be forced to arbitrarily decide between a false choice such as liar, lunatic or Messiah, with no other possibilities allowed.
 
And by “reasonable” I presume you mean adopting a scientific mindset that precludes the supernatural.
No, by reasonable I mean inquiring into something with no preconceived notions, bias, or ideology. So, I do not exclude miracles out of hand.
 
All I’m saying is that we should not be forced to arbitrarily decide between a false choice such as liar, lunatic or Messiah, with no other possibilities allowed.
I think the main point of the argument is not to choose between the three given options, but to exclude the “great teacher” option, and in that respect it works.
I submit that there are some psychological disorders that could induce such delusions but still leave the subject fully able to function.
The question is whether such a disorder would allow the subject to function as a valid source moral authority.
 
I think the main point of the argument is not to choose between the three given options, but to exclude the “great teacher” option, and in that respect it works.
It’s still a false dichotomy fallacy. I could use it with many examples, i.e. Either Mohammad was a liar, lunatic or Prophet of God who was given revelations by the angel Gabriel. Take your pick of the three, no other options are allowed. See the problem?
The question is whether such a disorder would allow the subject to function as a valid source moral authority.
That’s another ball of wax altogether. There are several threads in the philosophy forum on objective moral values. Many people simply deny any objective morality, and live their lives according the Golden rule, which is not exclusive to Christianity.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Golden_Rule_(ethics
 
It’s still a false dichotomy fallacy. I could use it with many examples, i.e. Either Mohammad was a liar, lunatic or Prophet of God who was given revelations by the angel Gabriel. Take your pick of the three, no other options are allowed. See the problem?
Sorry, I don’t 🙂
Because, like I’ve said, the point is not to exclude all other options, just one other option. And in proving Lewis wrong, you should bring good arguments for that specific option, that a first century Jewish preacher openly (and erroneously) proclaiming himself to be God could/should be viewed as a trustworthy moral authority.
 
redhen, to try to put the thing in the right context:

If a fellow should appear today, claiming to be the reincarnation of the Virgin Mary, Jesus Christ and Luke Skywalker at the same time, what moral authority do you believe he would hold ? What would the chances be that he was “a wise teacher”, with a message worthy to endure through the ages, despite the enormity of his claims ?

And the example I’ve given, however preposterous, does not do it justice, because claiming to be God in first century Judaea would be way more “out there”, unless, of course, it was the truth…
 
Sorry, I don’t 🙂
Because, like I’ve said, the point is not to exclude all other options, just one other option.
I’m not following you here.
And in proving Lewis wrong, you should bring good arguments for that specific option, that a first century Jewish preacher openly (and erroneously) proclaiming himself to be God could/should be viewed as a trustworthy moral authority.
I’m not proving Lewis’ conclusion wrong, I’m faulting his logic. I’m just saying there are other options besides the three he forces us to choose from. Lewis posits that liar is one of the three options, but surely if someone was lying by saying he was God, it would indicate psychological problems. So we can throw out the derogatory term* lunatic*, and liar and replace them both with deluded, mistaken, psychotic, schizophrenic, etc.

So Lewis is in fact giving us a true false dichotomy, either Jesus had some type of pathological disorder, or he was God. Doesn’t leave us much wiggle room does it?
 
It’s still a false dichotomy fallacy. I could use it with many examples, i.e. Either Mohammad was a liar, lunatic or Prophet of God who was given revelations by the angel Gabriel. Take your pick of the three, no other options are allowed. See the problem?
No I don’t. First of all, it would be easier to deceive oneself into thinking that one was a prophet, than into thinking that one was God. However, my opinion in any case is that Mohammad was probably a liar.
 
redhen, to try to put the thing in the right context:

If a fellow should appear today, claiming to be the reincarnation of the Virgin Mary, Jesus Christ and Luke Skywalker at the same time, what moral authority do you believe he would hold ? What would the chances be that he was “a wise teacher”, with a message worthy to endure through the ages, despite the enormity of his claims ?
I don’t believe in objective moral values. Morality exhibited by homo sapiens seems to be an evolutionary development of cultural norms, the beginnings of which we can also see in non-human apes.
And the example I’ve given, however preposterous, does not do it justice, because claiming to be God in first century Judaea would be way more “out there”, unless, of course, it was the truth…
So the more outlandish the claim, the higher probability that it’s true?

There have been many people throughout history who sincerely believed they were divine.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_who_have_been_considered_deities

Either the Dalai Lama is a liar, lunatic or reincarnation of Avalokiteśvara. Lewis has to take his pick of the three options.
 
I’m not proving Lewis’ conclusion wrong, I’m faulting his logic. I’m just saying there are other options besides the three he forces us to choose from. Lewis posits that liar is one of the three options, but surely if someone was lying by saying he was God, it would indicate psychological problems.
Sorry, but you have to do more than just say “surely this is true.” People do lie without having psychological problems. But perhaps you are saying, you don’t think Jesus was a liar. Ok. But you don’t think he was telling the truth, and you don’t think he was crazy.

Then would you care to actually state what you DO think Jesus was?
 
Either the Dalai Lama is a liar, lunatic or reincarnation of Avalokiteśvara. Lewis has to take his pick of the three options.
Avalokitesvara is not God, he is a bodhisattva, a being that has reached enlightenment but chooses continual reincarnation in order to compassionately help others, so it is a totally different issue. Besides, the Dalai Lama was brought up to believe this about himself from the time he was a child, it’s not something he himself came up with out of the blue.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top