E
Erethorn
Guest
The trilemma is** not ** meant as logical proof that Jesus was God, but as an argument against the idea that he was simply a wise man.I’m not following you here.
I don’t see a problem in a perfectly sane man lying that he was anything, as long as he would have something to gain from it. After all, we see that all day around us.I’m not proving Lewis’ conclusion wrong, I’m faulting his logic. I’m just saying there are other options besides the three he forces us to choose from. Lewis posits that liar is one of the three options, but surely if someone was lying by saying he was God, it would indicate psychological problems. So we can throw out the derogatory term* lunatic*, and liar and replace them both with deluded, mistaken, psychotic, schizophrenic, etc.
So Lewis is in fact giving us a true false dichotomy, either Jesus had some type of pathological disorder, or he was God. Doesn’t leave us much wiggle room does it?
After all, isn’t that the definition and distinction between a lie and some delusion - the fact that you “know it ain’t so” ? You don’t have to be a psychotic to tell a child that you’re Santa Clause, while wearing the red costume at Christmas Eve, right ?
No. the more outlandish the claim, the more probable that the person uttering it is either crazy, simply lying, or he might just be saying the truth.So the more outlandish the claim, the higher probability that it’s true?
And the less probable that the person uttering it remains a “wise teacher”, if the claim isn’t true, which is, again, the point of Lewis’ whole argument.