I'm a confused atheist

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pi314
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m not following you here.
The trilemma is** not ** meant as logical proof that Jesus was God, but as an argument against the idea that he was simply a wise man.
I’m not proving Lewis’ conclusion wrong, I’m faulting his logic. I’m just saying there are other options besides the three he forces us to choose from. Lewis posits that liar is one of the three options, but surely if someone was lying by saying he was God, it would indicate psychological problems. So we can throw out the derogatory term* lunatic*, and liar and replace them both with deluded, mistaken, psychotic, schizophrenic, etc.

So Lewis is in fact giving us a true false dichotomy, either Jesus had some type of pathological disorder, or he was God. Doesn’t leave us much wiggle room does it?
I don’t see a problem in a perfectly sane man lying that he was anything, as long as he would have something to gain from it. After all, we see that all day around us.

After all, isn’t that the definition and distinction between a lie and some delusion - the fact that you “know it ain’t so” ? You don’t have to be a psychotic to tell a child that you’re Santa Clause, while wearing the red costume at Christmas Eve, right ?
So the more outlandish the claim, the higher probability that it’s true?
No. the more outlandish the claim, the more probable that the person uttering it is either crazy, simply lying, or he might just be saying the truth.

And the less probable that the person uttering it remains a “wise teacher”, if the claim isn’t true, which is, again, the point of Lewis’ whole argument.
 
I got so caught up in debate, I almost missed this!
A Happy New Year to everyone !

During the holidays I finished reading Chesterton’s “Orthodoxy” and now I m halfway through “Mere Christianity”, both of which I find excellent books.

I also kept praying and going to Mass. Yesterday, after Mass, I finally managed (after getting cold feet on two previous occasions ) to gather enough courage to address the priest about joining the Church. He mentioned attending some classes - the local equivalent of RCIA I believe. I also have to fill in a written request and present it to the parish priest tomorrow. Since I’m baptized in the Eastern Orthodox Church I won’t need that sacrament again. He was quite nice, but nonetheless I felt extremely nervous, to the point where I was almost physically shacking and I felt lost for words. And that is NOT in my nature - I’ve been earning my living by speaking for the last 13 years, first as a teacher, then as a soft skills trainer and finally as a lawyer… and yesterday I felt like a dumb pupil in front of a stern teacher. Thank God I managed to go through with it…

In any case, if all goes well, I’m hoping to be admitted into the Church this Easter.
Yay! 😃
 
First off, this might be in the wrong forum. I’m guessing. :\

So, I’m an atheist, have been for years. Suddenly the whole atheism thing isn’t feeling right. I feel like I’m missing something, but I can’t put my finger on what (I got into a good school, I love my job, I have wonderful friends). But it’s not something I can talk about to much of anyone. All my friends are atheists. All the professors I’m close to (and usually talk to) are atheists too. Anyone I talked to, if they know me, would think I’m a crazy hypocrite.
I guess what’s bugging me is this interest in God, and Catholicism specifically, having been an atheist for so long. I don’t like it when I don’t have a logical explanation for something. I don’t have an explanation for this. And it’s not like it’s been one day, it’s been almost a year of feeling like this. Seriously, I woke up one morning last December and thought “I should be a nun”. Which is ridiculous of course since I’m an atheist, and that’s like the extreme end of religion. But I can’t get that line of thinking out of my head.
I looked into becoming a Catholic, but then I always stop short, because everyone I know would think I’m a nutty hypocrite to change my mind like that.
I don’t even know what I’m talking about really. Just wanted to get it out… I’m just all confused. I kind of want to just go back to being confident and happy in my non-belief. It was easier.
Start reading the Bible… and the teachings of the Catholic Church… in fact start going to church! Since you feel this interest , perhaps it would be wise to start learning about the Catholic Faith… about Christianity in general.

A good starting point >>> I would recommend C.S. Lewis’ Mere Christanity (since you like logical explanations…)

My prayers are with you!

In Christ,
Zachary
 
There are almost no real atheists, because almost everyone who denies God does believe that they themselves are a kind of god, with free will. They don’t really accept the logical conclusion of a complete absence of any god-like entity: that the pure randomness and cause-and-effect of the physical world totally determine all that they do, say, speak, think, and feel … that they are in effect a naturally-evolved robot.

For most people, the question is really, “Am I God (or one of many gods)?” not, “Is there a God?”
 
Sorry, but you have to do more than just say “surely this is true.” People do lie without having psychological problems.
I wasn’t talking about lying in general, I meant the specific example of someone lying about being a deity.
But perhaps you are saying, you don’t think Jesus was a liar. Ok. But you don’t think he was telling the truth, and you don’t think he was crazy.
Then would you care to actually state what you DO think Jesus was?
I don’t know if Jesus was a liar or not. Lying would imply intent. I have no way of knowing if Jesus intended to lie. I can’t read minds, let alone someone who died 2,000 years ago.

Do I think he was crazy? Again, that’s a loaded term like lunatic or mad. I have no way of knowing if Jesus had psychological disorders tending to delusions. In the NT texts, Jesus shows joy, sadness, anger, love, all normal human emotions.

When you ask “what you DO think Jesus was?”, I assume you mean "do you believe Jesus was the supreme and only deity, as described by NT scripture and early church fathers letters (tradition). I don’t know. It’s possible, but so are the truth claims of other religions.
 
Avalokitesvara is not God, he is a bodhisattva, a being that has reached enlightenment but chooses continual reincarnation in order to compassionately help others, so it is a totally different issue.
Right, bodhisattvas are spiritual beings, that many people pray to for intercession, some people call them gods. Hindus believe in many gods, some of which were also human like Krishna. Christians only believe in one, now we’re just quibbling about numbers.
Besides, the Dalai Lama was brought up to believe this about himself from the time he was a child, it’s not something he himself came up with out of the blue.
Right, but Jesus was raised from birth steeped in a 1st century Judaic tradition.
 
Right, bodhisattvas are spiritual beings, that many people pray to for intercession, some people call them gods. Hindus believe in many gods, some of which were also human like Krishna. Christians only believe in one, now we’re just quibbling about numbers.
The Christian equivalent of a bodhisattva is not God, but a saint. Sanctity is the ideal, and devout Catholics wish to become saints. In Mahayana Buddhism (of which Tibetan Buddhism is one kind) the ideal is a bodhisattva, and devout Buddhists try to become bodhisattvas. There are particular bodhisattvas to whom practitioners pray, asking for help to become a bodhisattva themselves, and Avalokitesvara is one such bodhisattva. Buddhist teaching says he started out as a human being and eventually reached enlightenment. It is not polytheism, it is more like the concept of the Communion of Saints in Catholicism.
Right, but Jesus was raised from birth steeped in a 1st century Judaic tradition.
Exactly. Judaic tradition says there is ONE GOD. No one can see Him, and no one is even allowed to make images of Him. To say “I am the Son of God” and “the Father and I are one” would be considered blasphemy (as, indeed, it was thought to be in Jesus’ case by the Pharisees) and would seem truly mad. Whereas in Tibetan Buddhism, a normal part of the religion is that the Dalai Lama is in the reincarnation of Avalokitesvara and the concepts are completely different.
 
The trilemma is** not ** meant as logical proof that Jesus was God, but as an argument against the idea that he was simply a wise man.
Ok, gotcha. But the implication is, as Lewis stresses, is that if Jesus is not who he says he is, then he’s either a rotten liar or suffering from a severe mental disorder. When you apply Lewis’ false trichotomy to other people who claimed to be a deity, or divine or some kind of spiritual being, then it paints them all in a bad light. He’s saying that the worship of some Taoist, Buddhist, Hindu deities is wrong because these people were afflicted with a mental disorder (a sociopath would cover the* liar* option).
No. the more outlandish the claim, the more probable that the person uttering it is either crazy, simply lying, or he might just be saying the truth.
But if you consider someone who makes claims that he is a deity, multiple times, afflicted with a psychological disorder, then you really are left with two options, either he speaks the truth, or he speaks falsely (for whatever reasons). This is a self-evident claim. What other option is there? This is not new knowledge.
And the less probable that the person uttering it remains a “wise teacher”, if the claim isn’t true, which is, again, the point of Lewis’ whole argument.
Right, and those other “wise teachers” of other religions who were later deified are sociopaths and pathological liars. Nice.
 
Exactly. Judaic tradition says there is ONE GOD. No one can see Him, and no one is even allowed to make images of Him. To say “I am the Son of God” and “the Father and I are one” would be considered blasphemy (as, indeed, it was thought to be in Jesus’ case by the Pharisees) and would seem truly mad. Whereas in Tibetan Buddhism, a normal part of the religion is that the Dalai Lama is in the reincarnation of Avalokitesvara and the concepts are completely different.
The Lord Buddha was raised in a Hindu tradition yet broke away, blasphemously proclaiming that there was no enduring soul (atman). He must have been truly mad.
 
Redhen, different religions are different. There is no comparison between Siddhartha deviating from some traditional Hindu beliefs (and Hinduism already has a great plurality of beliefs) to teach what would become Buddhism, or between the Dalai Lama being believed to be a reincarnated bodhisattva, and Jesus claiming to be the Son of God. Note that many Hindus, while remaining Hindu and not converting to Buddhism, consider the Buddha to be an incarnation of Vishnu, whereas Jews do not consider Jesus to be the Son of God (unless they are Jewish Christians) or even a prophet. That is because Hinduism and Judaism start out with totally different premises. There is no parallel.

I come from a family of agnostics. One thing I really wish is that agnostics would actually put some effort into learning about different religions and understanding them, and that they would at least search for the truth with open hearts. But there is no point in debating anything with someone whose heart is closed.
 
Ok, gotcha. But the implication is, as Lewis stresses, is that if Jesus is not who he says he is, then he’s either a rotten liar or suffering from a severe mental disorder. When you apply Lewis’ false trichotomy to other people who claimed to be a deity, or divine or some kind of spiritual being, then it paints them all in a bad light. He’s saying that the worship of some Taoist, Buddhist, Hindu deities is wrong because these people were afflicted with a mental disorder (a sociopath would cover the* liar* option).
First off, the trichotomy is not inherently false, or, at least, your proclaiming it does not make it so.

Second, the trichotomy applies, in Lewis’ description, to Jesus alone, because of some very specific conditions. The Taoist, Buddhist and Hindu deities were not historical people who claimed to be gods, in a manner that would be so blasfemous (if the claim wasn’t true) so as to go against every perceived notion of their people’s religion. They were simply deities, not “some people”.

Or else you are transferring the trichotomy from the deity to the believer, and it’s simply not about the believer. It’s about the deity, but not about just any ordinary deity, but a very special kind - the man claiming to be deity.
Right, and those other “wise teachers” of other religions who were later deified are sociopaths and pathological liars. Nice.
There is a HUGE difference between being “deified later” and “deifying yourself”. The vast majority of religious teachers that I would call wise never claimed to be gods.
The Lord Buddha was raised in a Hindu tradition yet broke away, blasphemously proclaiming that there was no enduring soul (atman). He must have been truly mad.
Again, you miss the point. The Lewis trilemma does not apply in this case, simply because, in a way, Buddha did proclaim himself to be nothing more than a wise man, since his way was open for any man. Anyone can become a Buddha - Buddha said so. No one can become God - Jesus said so.

redhen, for the last time - because I think the arguments are starting to repeat themselves and the debate is pretty much over - the point of Lewis was to prove, or suggest - take your pick - that a certain view of Jesus is not compatible with the teachings of Jesus Himself - and that is the view of Jesus as a wise man, but not a God. Like Lewis puts it - “He didn’t leave that option open to us”. But Lewis’ intention was not to make a liar or a madman out of any other religious teacher.
 
Sure, the analogy is not perfect, I’m just using it as an example of someone with radical new teachings, some would say wise. Just because these types of claims are wildly different from the Brahmans or Sadducees, doesn’t mean they’re more probable.
I come from a family of agnostics. One thing I really wish is that agnostics would actually put some effort into learning about different religions and understanding them, and that they would at least search for the truth with open hearts. But there is no point in debating anything with someone whose heart is closed.
That’s quite right. That is the reasonable method of inquiry. Please continue debating.
 
Sure, the analogy is not perfect, I’m just using it as an example of someone with radical new teachings, some would say wise. Just because these types of claims are wildly different from the Brahmans or Sadducees, doesn’t mean they’re more probable.
The analogy is far from perfect, because we’re talking about different things.

There must be a separation made between the “teachings” and the “claims”.

Had Jesus brought only the teachings - “be good, love one another, love God, teach the nations and so forth, because these are the teachings of God”, then yes, we might say he was a wise man, perhaps a prophet, perhaps just a smart guy with good ideas who knew how to disguise them in religious garb so that the dumb religious people would accept them.

The problem is not in Jesus’ teachings, but in His claims. The claim that he was God was not a moral teaching. It was a fact he proclaimed out loud, in a day and age when saying such a thing was liable to get you killed faster than… well, you name it.

And now I foresee a debate about whether my distinction between “teaching” and “claim” is a valid one 🙂 But it’s late in my part of the world, so I’ll be unable to post anymore, not until tomorrow.

Until then, good night and God bless.

Edit - one last thing. I visited the wiki page en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_who_have_been_considered_deities

for the purposes of our discussion and in light of Lewis’ argument, I think the only relevant category is that of Self-deification.

Now, take a look in that list, including Jim Jones, Kim Il Sung, Claude Vorilhon, Matayoshi Jesus, Jehovah Wanyonyi and others… Then read Lewis’ argument again, and tell me if it doesn’t start to ring true…
 
redhen, for the last time - because I think the arguments are starting to repeat themselves and the debate is pretty much over - the point of Lewis was to prove, or suggest - take your pick - that a certain view of Jesus is not compatible with the teachings of Jesus Himself - and that is the view of Jesus as a wise man, but not a God. Like Lewis puts it - “He didn’t leave that option open to us”. But Lewis’ intention was not to make a liar or a madman out of any other religious teacher.
Ok, granted. My analogies may be weak. Yes, of course, Muslims who hold that Jesus is just a prophet or wise man are ignoring NT texts that describe Jesus pardoning sins and making divine pronouncements.
 
Muslims are not ignoring them, they are disputing their truth. Lewis’ argument takes the fact that Jesus did claim Godhood as a premise. But I’m sure you already knew that.

And now I really need to go to sleep 🙂
 
Muslims are not ignoring them, they are disputing their truth. Lewis’ argument takes the fact that Jesus did claim Godhood as a premise. But I’m sure you already knew that.

And now I really need to go to sleep 🙂
I’m off to my first class of the new semester. I just wanted to congratulate you for your diligence. It’s too bad many cradle Catholics don’t have the knowledge to defend their faith as well as converts such as yourself. 👍
 
I’m a science major, I’m supposed to think logically and not believe what can’t be observed. But I’m finding it harder to not see God in science, as backwards as that sounds.
Actually I think all scientists who see the marvels they do and can’t see God are the ones who are backwards. :confused: Have you SEEN the stars, have you SEEN a tree, have you SEEN any part of your own body? God is so obvious to me that I still don’t have an adequate response to “how do you know God exists?” All I could say is “isn’t it obvious!?” 😛

Merry Christmas by the way (since you post was around that time). I hope all is well and that you’re still going to Mass. 😃

Seems like an argument broke out while you’ve been gone but I hope you’ll come around again.

If you have any further questions, rants or updates please let us know! Don’t be shy, that’s what we’re here for. 🙂
 
First off, this might be in the wrong forum. I’m guessing. :\

So, I’m an atheist, have been for years. Suddenly the whole atheism thing isn’t feeling right. I feel like I’m missing something, but I can’t put my finger on what (I got into a good school, I love my job, I have wonderful friends). But it’s not something I can talk about to much of anyone. All my friends are atheists. All the professors I’m close to (and usually talk to) are atheists too. Anyone I talked to, if they know me, would think I’m a crazy hypocrite.
I guess what’s bugging me is this interest in God, and Catholicism specifically, having been an atheist for so long. I don’t like it when I don’t have a logical explanation for something. I don’t have an explanation for this. And it’s not like it’s been one day, it’s been almost a year of feeling like this. Seriously, I woke up one morning last December and thought “I should be a nun”. Which is ridiculous of course since I’m an atheist, and that’s like the extreme end of religion. But I can’t get that line of thinking out of my head.
I looked into becoming a Catholic, but then I always stop short, ***because everyone I know would think I’m a nutty hypocrite to change my mind like that. ***I don’t even know what I’m talking about really. Just wanted to get it out… I’m just all confused. I kind of want to just go back to being confident and happy in my non-belief. It was easier.
The Lord is calling you, don’t hang up. He IS your best friend whom you haven’t spoken to in years, give him a call. 🙂

and…
  1. Be true to yourself, even very secular people say this over and over again. I mean, it is like the moral in EVERY story, cmon how obvious is this?😃
  2. This is kinda obvious to, life aint easy, life has challenges. This is something you can’t forget eaither, your at the point where you can’t go back, but are too afrad to go forward.
    Take the first step man. It’s obvious because you said it yourself it was “EASY” again, how many stories/movies have the theme of hard work, merit, and effort? Really you could figure these two out! 🙂
Good luck buddy

MAY THE LORD OUR GOD BLESS YOU! 🙂
 
Your post reminds me of one of G. K. Chesterton’s quotes: “The center of every man’s existence is a dream. Death, disease, insanity, are merely material accidents, like a toothache or a twisted ankle. That these brutal forces always besiege and often capture the citadel does not prove that they are the citadel.”

Do not make the mistake of thinking that these questions you are posing are a mere accident - you wouldn’t be asking them if there was no reason to - right?

I would strongly suggest that you read his book, Orthodoxy.

Do not let others dictate what you believe. Seek out the truth - not the regurgitated myths of those who proclaim to know it all.

Peace +
And if you would like ot pick and choose through some Orthodoxy topics, try here;

payingattentiontothesky.com/fr-richard-neuhaus-on-gk-chesterton/reading-selections-from-orthodoxy/

Same treatment for The Everlasting Man here:

payingattentiontothesky.com/fr-richard-neuhaus-on-gk-chesterton/reading-selections-from-the-everlasting-man/

A teaser:

Christian Dogma: Answers To Questions
Some dogma, we are told, was credible in the twelfth century, but is not credible in the twentieth. You might as well say that a certain philosophy can be believed on Mondays, but cannot be believed on Tuesdays. . What a man can believe depends upon his philosophy, not upon the clock or the century.

If a man believes in unalterable natural law, he cannot believe in any miracle in any age. If a man believes in a will behind law, he can believe in any miracle in any age. Suppose, for the sake of argument, we are concerned with a case of thaumaturgy [working of miracles or magic feats] healing. A materialist of the twelfth century could not believe it any more than a materialist of the twentieth century. But a Christian Scientist of the twentieth century can believe it as much as a Christian of the twelfth century.

It is simply a matter of a man’s theory of things. Therefore in dealing with any historical answer, the point is not whether it was given in our time, but whether it was given in answer to our question. And the more I thought about when and how Christianity had come into the world, the more I felt that it had actually come to answer this question."

It’s a great way to review the two books and to find a quote that originally moved you. I was a confused new age something once and G.K. put me on the road to Catholicism.

dj
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top