I'm having a hard time believing the Incarnation

  • Thread starter Thread starter coolduude
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

coolduude

Guest
Hi,

So far as I can tell Jesus is God, the evidence says He is, but I’m still debating. I can’t totally convince myself that He really was God; for all I know he was a great miracle worker (akin to Moses and other OT Prophets who worked miracles). I do know, and I’m 100% sure here, that Jesus was the Messiah. No doubt about that.

Also, to me, the Incarnation just seems so… contrary or contradictory to God- the infinite becoming finite and, most human of all, dying!. The infinte one dying. It seems so contradictory.

But I suppose I should take the leap of faith and believe in Jesus because all the evidence is there. I must sound like a first century Jew wrestling with the Incarnation 😛 but for God to become human is so out there… It’s befuddling! :confused:

Don’t get me wrong though, I am trying to understand it and believe it with full faith, but right now I’m just not at that point 😦 Oh how I wish I was…

Can anyone offer some advice on how to deal with this? Maybe how I can understand the Incarnation better? Anything at all will help.

I’ll close by saying:
Jesus, I trust in You!

Thank you,
coolduude:cool:
 
Also, to me, the Incarnation just seems so… contrary or contradictory to God- the infinite becoming finite and, most human of all, dying!. The infinte one dying. It seems so contradictory.
If you want my explanation for the infinite becoming finite, think about this, the number Pi has an infinite number of decimal places (it’s a non terminating, non recurring decimal, it goes on forever with no pattern), yet it is in a finite space between the two natural number 3 & 4, so the infinite is in the finite space of 1.

if you have a Mathmatical mind you’ll get the explanation, if not, it’s abit harder lol

But God himself dying was a fulfillment of the OT prophecies, and was the ultimate sacrifice, Jesus was the pinultimate lamb if you would, to forgive ALL sins, instead of the sacrificing of Lambs that was happening in the temples, God himself incarnate placed himself as the sacrifice for our sins, that is a loving God, that is OUR God (:

God Bless you
 
God had to incarnate a real flesh and blood human to undo the effects of Original Sin. Since a man originally committed original sin only a son of man could atone for it. But only God was perfect and innocent enough to act as both a perfect Priest and a perfect Sacrifice that would atone for original sin once and for all. Since Jesus is fully the Son of Man and the Son of God he could atone for it and act as both Priest and Offering.

I’m not sure if this explanation makes it easier to believe, but at a certain point we must accept this on Faith.

I accept this since the entire Old Testament points to this sacrifice and the coming of Jesus as Messiah and God. (for just one example re-read about the near sacrifice of Isaac in Genesis 22).

Gen 22:8 And Abraham said: God will provide himself a victim for an holocaust, my son. So they went on together.

No other figure in history, religious or not, has been predicted ahead of time.
 
Jesus said He is God. So if you believe all the other supernatural things He did, why not believe that statement too?

C.S. Lewis used the bit about “Lord, liar, or lunatic…”
 
Jesus said He is God. So if you believe all the other supernatural things He did, why not believe that statement too?

C.S. Lewis used the bit about “Lord, liar, or lunatic…”
Because I think (this is a counterargument I use when I debate myself) tha Jesus could have been a miracle worker. Why couldn’t He have been?
 
But if He was a miracle worker, and those miracles came from God, then He was definitely in God’s favor and worthy to be trusted.

So when He said that He was God, that can be trusted. I know it doesn’t answer the metaphysical doubt, but it is a way of looking at the logic – a guy like that can’t be lying or else everything else He did is not possible either.
 
But if He was a miracle worker, and those miracles came from God, then He was definitely in God’s favor and worthy to be trusted.

So when He said that He was God, that can be trusted. I know it doesn’t answer the metaphysical doubt, but it is a way of looking at the logic – a guy like that can’t be lying or else everything else He did is not possible either.
That is true. I’ll explore it furthur. Thank you! 👍

@Skeptic92:

lol I’m not a math person but I somewhat see what you’re saying 😛 :o
 
Faith is a gift from God, not something you need to muster all by yourself. It’s certainly something you can ask God for. How could God refuse such a prayer?

You seem to be doubting whether you can trust Scripture and Catholic tradition on the person of Jesus Christ. In fact, either it’s complete rubbish, or Jesus is the God of the universe. It’s no good trying to make sense of it, or dreaming about what Jesus else might really have been. You are on the edge of the precipice, at the end of the reason trail. Either you turn back and hope for the best on your own out in that broken world, or else you trust that Jesus will not let you fall and step forward. There are lots of others who’ve gone before you to show that Jesus will not abandon you. That may help you screw up your courage, but it can’t stop it from being unnerving. But Jesus will not abandon you. The world, yes, but not God.
 
At one time I doubted the Incarnation because it just seemed too extraordinary that God would become a human being and die… but this shows that He is Love. Just as we are taught 🙂 He is not distant… He is love itself. That’s why He chose to do this.
 
You could try reading St. Athanasius’ “On the Incarnation.” It’s . . . um . . . on the Incarnation.

Also, I’m having trouble figuring out why Jesus being a contradiction is a stumbling block to a fuller faith. The physical properties of a cross can shed some light on this. It points both up and down. It points both left and right. It was an instrument of death, but God turned it into His instrument of life for all. Like the poisonous snakes of Moses’ time and God’s healing miracles from a bronze snake-head on a stick, “The sign of our suffering has become the sign of our salvation.” - St. Paul. God intended the contradiction.

If you listen closely to the priest during Mass, you may hear him mumble a difficult truth: God humbled Himself to share in our humanity that we might share in His divinity. In the end, just believe it.
 
Jesus was truly human and truly divine. To my way of thinking, Jesus was never finite. His time here on earth was finite. But, Jesus is infinite.

John 1:1 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. 2 He was in the beginning with God.:

John 6:38* "… because I came down from heaven… "*

Luke 24:
30
And it happened that, while he was with them at table, he took bread, said the blessing, broke it, and gave it to them.
31
With that their eyes were opened and they recognized him, but he vanished from their sight.


I don’t mean to insult your intelligence. You know all of this. If you believe in the resurrection and the ascension, and accept John 1, the only conclusion is that Jesus as the second person of the Trinity is infinite.

Reread the Bread of Life Discourse in John 6. We have the hope of eternal life because He still lives.

John 6:40 For this is the will of my Father, that everyone who sees the Son and believes in him may have eternal life, and* I *shall raise him (on) the last day."
 
Jesus is like Moses and Elijah and Elisha and all the other prophets and miracle-workers of the Old Testament because those men prefigured Jesus. Elisha, for example, raised the dead and multiplied loaves of bread. Sound familiar? Jesus is the fulfillment of the prophets.
 
Jesus is like Moses and Elijah and Elisha and all the other prophets and miracle-workers of the Old Testament because those men prefigured Jesus. Elisha, for example, raised the dead and multiplied loaves of bread. Sound familiar? Jesus is the fulfillment of the prophets.
Fullfillment? It sounds like the same thing to me. 😦 maybe I just don’t fully comprehend the OT and it’s relation to the NT.
 
Fullfillment? It sounds like the same thing to me. 😦 maybe I just don’t fully comprehend the OT and it’s relation to the NT.
You may want to read Scott Hahn. A Father Who Keeps His Promises is an overview of salvation history and explains the story of God expanding His family through covenants–a man with Adam, a family with Noah, a tribe with Abraham, a nation with Moses, a kingdom with David, and the world-wide Catholic Church with the new representative of humanity, the Second Adam, Jesus Christ (this is why the Incarnation is so important!).

The entire Old Testament is the story of God preparing His people for the coming of Jesus and the final and redemptive covenant, the New Covenant, between Himself and the world. There’s a quote in the Catechism to the effect: the Old Testament is the New concealed, and the New Testament is the Old revealed. We read the OT with Christ in mind, and we read the NT with the signs of the OT in mind.
 
Jesus is like Moses and Elijah and Elisha and all the other prophets and miracle-workers of the Old Testament because those men prefigured Jesus. Elisha, for example, raised the dead and multiplied loaves of bread. Sound familiar? Jesus is the fulfillment of the prophets.
👍

and Moses and Elijah appeared at the Transfiguration, showing that the law and the prophets testify to Jesus being the Lord.
 
Hi,

So far as I can tell Jesus is God, the evidence says He is, but I’m still debating. I can’t totally convince myself that He really was God; for all I know he was a great miracle worker (akin to Moses and other OT Prophets who worked miracles). I do know, and I’m 100% sure here, that Jesus was the Messiah. No doubt about that.

Also, to me, the Incarnation just seems so… contrary or contradictory to God- the infinite becoming finite and, most human of all, dying!. The infinte one dying. It seems so contradictory.

But I suppose I should take the leap of faith and believe in Jesus because all the evidence is there. I must sound like a first century Jew wrestling with the Incarnation 😛 but for God to become human is so out there… It’s befuddling! :confused:

Don’t get me wrong though, I am trying to understand it and believe it with full faith, but right now I’m just not at that point 😦 Oh how I wish I was…

Can anyone offer some advice on how to deal with this? Maybe how I can understand the Incarnation better? Anything at all will help.

I’ll close by saying:
Jesus, I trust in You!

Thank you,
coolduude:cool:
A leap of faith is good.

It will not negate your intellect but it will suspend the reasoning on a mystery of faith. That’s what we do when we analyze, scrutinize, reason, dissect and re-dissect a mystery -
we make the leap of faith because Jesus is truth.

Hypostatic union is what’s at work here. In the second person of the Holy Trinity there are two natures - perfectly human and perfectly divine. One not interfering with the other nor overcoming the other.

Jesus is God’s Love and mercy and reconcilling victim to Himself. The nature of sin is of such lethal and horrible consequence that only a divine being could destroy it’s deadly influence…Jesus Christ, true God and true man.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top