H
Hastrman
Guest
OK, pagans, this “An ye harm none, do as thou wilt” nonsense has got to stop. First off, it’s bad grammar: “ye” is plural, “thou” is singular.
Second, it’s not pagan. It’s a modification of a quote from the medieval poet Rabelais, who was so intensely Catholic he lived in a constant pattern of profligacy and repentance. Not a pagan bone in his body.
Third, you obviously get it from Aleister Crowley’s Book of the Law, where he quotes the Rabelais line: “‘Do as thou wilt’ shall be the whole of the law.”
Fourth, it’s *really *not pagan. “Do as thou wilt”, harm or no harm, is the attitude of an individualist. No pagans were individualists. A man who did not live for his clan was considered not only worthless, but a dangerous lunatic, like a lone wolf or an old lion. The Irish word for “man without a clan” actually means “headless man”, because such a person lived with no sense of responsibility or obligations, but simply ran wild like a chicken with its head cut off.
But please, explain why I and Cicero and Aristotle and the Mabinogion and Irish mythology and the Rg Veda are wrong, and the Barnes and Noble New Age section is right.
Second, it’s not pagan. It’s a modification of a quote from the medieval poet Rabelais, who was so intensely Catholic he lived in a constant pattern of profligacy and repentance. Not a pagan bone in his body.
Third, you obviously get it from Aleister Crowley’s Book of the Law, where he quotes the Rabelais line: “‘Do as thou wilt’ shall be the whole of the law.”
Fourth, it’s *really *not pagan. “Do as thou wilt”, harm or no harm, is the attitude of an individualist. No pagans were individualists. A man who did not live for his clan was considered not only worthless, but a dangerous lunatic, like a lone wolf or an old lion. The Irish word for “man without a clan” actually means “headless man”, because such a person lived with no sense of responsibility or obligations, but simply ran wild like a chicken with its head cut off.
But please, explain why I and Cicero and Aristotle and the Mabinogion and Irish mythology and the Rg Veda are wrong, and the Barnes and Noble New Age section is right.