I'm wondering about Genesis

  • Thread starter Thread starter theCardinalbird
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m still here. Thank you all for your answers. What’s this new form of Arianism?
Moderrn Catholic Dictionary
MODERN ARIANISM. Organized bodies or movements, since the Reformation, that professedly subscribe to the Arian denial that Christ is the natural Son of God. This modern Arianism is a logical though not always linear development from the ancient stock. Under the more familiar names of Unitarians, Anti-trinitarians and Socinians, those who profess this creed believe in the Fatherhood of God, the society of the human race, the example of Jesus as a model of ethical perfection, and salvation of humankind through an evolutionary process inherent in all things.

Also in the Arian tradition are the rationalists when they deal with the person of Christ. Their system postulates the absolute rights of natural reason as the only source of religious truth. Consequently they deny the divinity of Christ, except in Arius’ sense of “the most intimate to God,” and for the same reason as Arius (256-336), because the Trinity and Incarnation are mysteries of faith to be accepted on the authority of God.
Socinians
  • The Church of God Seventh Day, Salem Conference
  • Christadelphians
  • Church of God General Conference
  • Church of the Blessed Hope
 
I just want to add these to illuminate Joe1:
Evolution is a scientific theory, however, the dogma of faith is that God created ex nihilo. Science does not know about such non material causes
Since it is just a theory, there is nothing to reconcile to. Evolution theory is still far from validation. it is not a natural law such as Law of Thermodynamics.
Traditionally, the authorship of Genesis is ascribed to Moses, the Lawgiver. However somebody else may have assembled what he said this into writing.
Eulogies and last additions obviously can not be written by Moses himself. But as long as that someone is authorized by Moses to put his thoughts in writing is considered as from Moses himself. Even in today’s world as long as a message is from the office of the CEO, the message is considered as from him although he may not have written it himself but by an approved source, typically the secretary or in ancient times an amanuensis. It is not uncommon to ask someone to add last sentences after they are gone. Moses knew when he is going and he made those preparations in Deu 31. Obviously Deu 34 can not be written by him.
Yes God created dinosaurs, but that does not say when the dinosaur was created before or after man.
Gen 1:21 and Gen 1:24 all came before Man. i.e. sea monsters and beasts. In fact after creation of Man, God rested.
 
I just want to add these to illuminate Joe1:
40.png
Vico:
Evolution is a scientific theory, however, the dogma of faith is that God created ex nihilo. Science does not know about such non material causes
Since it is just a theory, there is nothing to reconcile to. Evolution theory is still far from validation. it is not a natural law such as Law of Thermodynamics.
Traditionally, the authorship of Genesis is ascribed to Moses, the Lawgiver. However somebody else may have assembled what he said this into writing.
Eulogies and last additions obviously can not be written by Moses himself. But as long as that someone is authorized by Moses to put his thoughts in writing is considered as from Moses himself. Even in today’s world as long as a message is from the office of the CEO, the message is considered as from him although he may not have written it himself but by an approved source, typically the secretary or in ancient times an amanuensis. It is not uncommon to ask someone to add last sentences after they are gone. Moses knew when he is going and he made those preparations in Deu 31. Obviously Deu 34 can not be written by him.
Yes God created dinosaurs, but that does not say when the dinosaur was created before or after man.
Gen 1:21 and Gen 1:24 all came before Man. i.e. sea monsters and beasts. In fact after creation of Man, God rested.
Some living things change over the generations, an adaptation that produces a new variety, such as the Italian wall lizard.
 
Some living things change over the generations, an adaptation that produces a new variety, such as the Italian wall lizard.
Obviously God intend his Creation to continue to function e.g. adapting to environment pressures or breeders after he is done with the major works.
 
How do we reconcile Genesis (creation story) with science?

Who wrote Genesis?

Did God create Dinosaurs? If so why isn’t it in Genesis?
Joe I am not going to wade through the answers.

God is the author of creation and also sustains that creation. Therefore God sustained all that has ever existed and will ever exist, including dinosaurs.

Catholics should be reading the Old Testament
  1. In a historic- critical way- it is written in Ancient Near East and Greco-roman cultural lenses.
    We see Abraham as the first historical figure. We read Noah and the first Covenant between God and all creatures , through Noah. The second Covenants between God and us is given to historical Abraham, the Third covenant to Moses in the Ten Commandments . Jesus then gives us the new Covenant.
What’s a Covenant? Very important to sort this out, as there are main messages God wants us to know about Covenants between Him and us, in the Old Testament

We read how God wants us to know He created life, ordered His everything, and Sustains life in Genesis.
We know, through Dei verbum that there are inconsistencies and things in the Old Testament, things we would question, like slaughter and war. We know God is speaking to us through these books though.
  1. The Old Testament is a sacred text of God’s word in human language, what God wanted us to know for salvation history.
  2. We read the Old Testament as Christocentric. It is written, every word, authored in what God wants us to know for salvation history, to prepare the peoples for the appearance of Jesus and the new covenant between God and His Chosen, in the Paschal Mysteries.
  3. We read the Old Testament as books of wisdom, of daily life, hymn books, prayer books, psalms of struggle and reaffirming whatever happens, God is with us.
There is much more I could write.

But

People go all creation and forget , its not just creation, it’s sustaining and ordering that creation. Even now, till the end.
 
Last edited:
40.png
Vico:
Some living things change over the generations, an adaptation that produces a new variety, such as the Italian wall lizard.
Obviously God intend his Creation to continue to function e.g. adapting to environment pressures or breeders after he is done with the major works.
Yes, that is why one can say that God created dinosaurs, but without certainty of the time that the dinosaur was created relative to man.
 
40.png
ericc:
No idea. The Bible is not intended to be a geography book.
But doesn’t Genesis say that every living creature was blotted out by the flood?
Genesis 6
20 The waters swelled fifteen cubits higher than the submerged mountains. 21 All creatures that moved on earth perished: birds, tame animals, wild animals, and all that teemed on the earth, as well as all humankind. 22 Everything on dry land with the breath of life in its nostrils died. 23 The Lord wiped out every being on earth: human beings and animals, the crawling things and the birds of the air; all were wiped out from the earth. Only Noah and those with him in the ark were left.

24 And when the waters had swelled on the earth for one hundred and fifty days,
National Geographic has an article on this topic and the theory, which has some evidence, that the melting glaciers from the last ice age raised the water level in the Mediterranean and flooded the Black Sea area through the Bosporus. There is evidence of a former shoreline 400 feet below the current level of the Black Sea and a flood about 5,000 B.C., said Robert Ballard, underwater archaeologist, in 2012. He thinks he found evidence of a massive flood that submerged a vast geographical area, not claiming it to be Noah’s Flood.
 
Last edited:
National Geographic has an article on this topic and the theory, which has some evidence, that the melting glaciers from the last ice age raised the water level in the Mediterranean and flooded the Black Sea area through the Bosporus.
So the flood was regional and not global?
 
40.png
Vico:
National Geographic has an article on this topic and the theory, which has some evidence, that the melting glaciers from the last ice age raised the water level in the Mediterranean and flooded the Black Sea area through the Bosporus.
So the flood was regional and not global?
Local per the article. If all the glaciers melted the sea levels would rise by 70 meters (230 feet) worldwide.
 
Local per the article.
This is where some will see the contradiction, since the Genesis account says that all living creatures on earth were killed by the flood (except for those on the Ark). Also, even if the flood were global, I am not sure about fish, sea mammals and insects being wiped out?
 
40.png
Vico:
Local per the article.
This is where some will see the contradiction, since the Genesis account says that all living creatures on earth were killed by the flood (except for those on the Ark). Also, even if the flood were global, I am not sure about fish, sea mammals and insects being wiped out?
Yes, per the Hebrew word eh’-rets used in Genesis 6 for earth means (Strong’s Concordance):
(1) land, earth
(1a) earth
(1a1) whole earth (as opposed to a part)
(1a2) earth (as opposed to heaven)
(1a3) earth (inhabitants)
(1b) land
(1b1) country, territory
(1b2) district, region
(1b3) tribal territory
(1b4) piece of ground
(1b5) land of Canaan, Israel
(1b6) inhabitants of land
(1b7) Sheol, land without return, (under) world
(1b8) city (-state)
1c) ground, surface of the earth
(1c1) ground
(1c2) soil
(1d) (in phrases)
(1d1) people of the land
(1d2) space or distance of country (in measurements of distance)
(1d3) level or plain country
(1d4) land of the living
(1d5) end(s) of the earth
1e) (almost wholly late in usage)
(1e1) lands, countries
(1e1a) often in contrast to Canaan
 
Last edited:
Noah is awesome. As is the first Covenant God gave us, through Noah.
 
None of the sea creatures would have survived the flood. The oceans would become fresh water

Unless God wanted them to survive
 
Last edited:
There are about 8.7 million spices worldwide. Between 1-2 million of them are animal. I don’t think that with the current technology we can build a ship which can accommodate 1-2 million animals.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top